logo
Wallabies want 'accountability' over controversial Lions try

Wallabies want 'accountability' over controversial Lions try

RTÉ News​5 days ago
Rugby Australia chief Phil Waugh has backed Joe Schmidt's criticism of the match officials after Saturday's Lions Test in Melbourne.
The British and Irish Lions clinched their series versus the Wallabies with a game to spare after Hugo Keenan's late try sealed a 29-26 win after an epic Test at the MCG.
That winning try was clouded by controversy though, with the score eventually being awarded after a TMO check for possible foul play by Lions flanker Jac Morgan, who had cleared out Australia's Carlo Tizzano in the build-up.
Australia head coach Schmidt made his feelings clear after the game, saying the decision to award the try didn't stack up with World Rugby's drive for better player safety.
And the former Ireland boss has been given his backing by Rugby Australia chief executive Waugh, who says they will be seeking an explanation from the game's governing body.
"Joe's comments at the press conference were 100% aligned with mine as a CEO and a former Wallaby," Waugh told the Sydney Morning Herald.
"Our position on that particular decision is consistent to what Joe outlined in his analysis of that last breakdown.
"Clearly there'll be the usual process, which is what happens after every test match, and we'll certainly be looking for a level of accountability from World Rugby over the next period of time."
The incident has dominated the Australian sports media since Saturday night, with the Sunday Telegraph's back page headline simply reading "ROBBED", before saying referee Andrea Piardi "ruined our shot at victory" with his decision to award the try.
Naturally, most northern hemisphere pundits have backed Piardi's decision, and Morgan's technique at the breakdown, with the bulk of the criticism levelled at the door of Tizzano for milking the collision.
Former England and Lions flanker James Haskell was the most vocal as he called for the Australia flanker to be carded for allegedly taking a dive.
Wallabies pair Nick Frost and Max Jorgensen spoke to the media on Monday, and used the opportunity to give their support to their team-mate.
"A lot of the forwards put ourselves in harm's way a lot of the time. It's tough on the body," Frost said.
"It's hard when you've got guys [pundits] who aren't on the field – I know they're ex-players – but when the people are on the field day in and day out and putting their body [on the line].
"Especially a guy like Carlo, who always gets over the ball. It's tough.
"It's a tough one for him. We don't really listen to outside noise, whatever the media says around that stuff. It's the first time I've heard of it.
"It's disappointing in general that this series is done for us.
"Carlo is there as a competitor like he always is, he's trying to get on ball.
"The 7 puts his hands there, he's there first and gets hit pretty hard with a full-force cleanout.
"It is what it is. We can't do anything about a decision. Joe's spoke about all of that stuff, but for us, we're trying to compete for the ball there."
Jorgensen, who scored a try in the opening Test in Brisbane, said the defeat felt like a sucker-punch after the Wallabies had been leading the game since the fifth minute.
"It really hurts, it's a tough pill to swallow," the 20-year-old said.
"I was absolutely gutted personally, I know everyone in the team was.
"To have to wait another 12 years to have the chance of getting a series win is obviously devastating."
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Ireland hooker Sheehan cited over clearout of Australia's Lynagh during Lions defeat
Ireland hooker Sheehan cited over clearout of Australia's Lynagh during Lions defeat

Irish Examiner

timean hour ago

  • Irish Examiner

Ireland hooker Sheehan cited over clearout of Australia's Lynagh during Lions defeat

Leinster and Ireland hooker Dan Sheehan could be facing disciplinary troubles after being cited for an incident during the first half of the British and Irish Lions' wet and wild tour-ending defeat to the Wallabies in Sydney on Saturday. The 26-year-old, one of the stand-out performers on Andy Farrell's successful touring side, was cited in the early hours of Sunday morning Down Under over a clear-out which left Australian out-half Tom Lynagh flattened 34 minutes into the third and final Test. Replays appeared to show Sheehan charging in slightly to the side of the ruck and his right elbow making contact with Lynagh's head. The Wallabies playmaker was taken off for a Head Injury Assessment and didn't return. Tom Lynagh flattened by elbow to the head. #AUSvBIL — Jobson Growthe (@electricBAU) August 2, 2025 The game-day officials, including TMO Marius Jonker, opted not to take any action against the No.2, despite howls of accusation from the home supporters when replays of the incident played at Accor Stadium. "British & Irish Lions player Dan Sheehan will have a citing complaint reviewed by an Independent Foul Play Review Committee (FPRC) after being cited by the independent citing commissioner Adrien Menez for an act of foul play contrary to Law 9.20 (a) (a player must not charge into a ruck or maul…) in the Australia v British & Irish Lions third test in Sydney on Saturday, 2 August," a statement from World Rugby confirmed. "In line with World Rugby's expedited off-field sanction process, Sheehan's case will be considered by the on-duty Independent Foul Play Review Committee (FPRC) comprising Wang Shao-ing (chair), Val Toma and Mike Mika on Sunday, 3 August 2025."

Lions' series win will leave Schmidt and Wallabies to ruminate over 'what ifs'
Lions' series win will leave Schmidt and Wallabies to ruminate over 'what ifs'

The 42

time2 hours ago

  • The 42

Lions' series win will leave Schmidt and Wallabies to ruminate over 'what ifs'

THE 40-MINUTE PAUSE for lightning brought with it the usual questions that fill such space in a match broadcast. 'Who will this delay suit more?' 'How will the players deal with an interruption like this? 'Does it mean anything that Australia are back on the field ahead of the resumption while the Lions are still in the changing room?' While these questions are virtually impossible to answer, it would be a fair read of the third Test that it meant more to the Wallabies than it did to the Lions, totally understandably. In retrospect, Andy Farrell may question his selection: a handful of players with a greater point to prove than the series winners might have stirred something other than a lame Lions performance. From Joe Schmidt's perspective, though, the questions will lead with 'what if'. Advertisement What if Rob Valetini had been available for the the full series? What if Will Skelton was up to full speed? What if Harry Potter had lasted for all of the second Test? What if I hadn't so readily discarded Taniela Tupou? What if we got a fair crack of the whip from the officials? The former Ireland head coach won't be happy that Dan Sheehan's clear-out on Tom Lynagh, for example, which led to the Aussie out-half's withdrawal following a HIA, went unpunished. But to zoom out from the third Test specifically and unpack the series as a whole, Schmidt has reason to be seriously proud of his players. In the sands of time, only the Lions' 2-1 win will really matter, but from the 43rd minute of the first Test onwards, Schmidt's Wallabies were arguably the better side. Indeed, their trajectory might one day soon see to it that the Lions' 2025 series victory is painted in a different complexion. Before this tour, the consensus would have been that Ireland, England, or perhaps even Scotland, could have won a summer series in Australia, not to mind a collection of the best players from those countries and Wales. Such bullishness would be rarer now. Ahead of this third Test, the Lions laid it plain that they were chasing history, a first 3-0 series sweep since a tour of Argentina 98 years ago. Easily forgotten is the motivation to avoid becoming a part of history, and the Wallabies' cause — as well as their players — simply proved stronger than those of the Lions in Sydney. Farrell will be disappointed but hardly dismayed. That his side fell short of their 3-0 target will rankle but one day in the distant future, beyond the documentaries and podcasts and after-dinner speaking, rugby fans will see that he was a series-winning head coach. More intriguing may be the 'New Zealand tour of 2029′ category on his Wikipedia page. And while the Lions' overall achievement in Australia may have been unremarkable (the tourists have won eight out of 10 total series Down Under), the feeling of futility that pervaded rugby discourse on either side of the first Test was obliterated by the spectacle that was the second meeting in Melbourne. If it gave us nothing else, the 2025 tour gave us that epic at the MSG, perhaps the greatest Test match since the World Cup quarter-finals weekend of 2023, and certainly the best Lions Test since the second game in South Africa in 2009. And surely a game like Melbourne is the point of these things, or at least it's the trade-off for the naked commercialism that fuels the Lions as a concept in the modern era. Most rugby fans still consider it a fair deal. That second Test and the summer as a whole have highlighted an undeniable truth, which is that rugby union needs a strong Australia. The sport is just more fun for the rest of us when the Wallabies are good, and when the Australian public is engaged with its national team. Should the series catapult Schmidt's side back to the top table in time for the 2027 World Cup — and that idea will be tested away to South Africa in the Rugby Championship in two weeks' time — then it was worthwhile for that alone. This series was less the Lions' Everest, more a hike up the Sugar Loaf. The view is still pretty nice from the top. And yet the Wallabies were only a stroke of fortune or two short of scaling a far mightier height. As this year's tour begins to fade out of view, another difficult question can be put to rest: yes, the Lions should absolutely tour Australia again in 2037.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store