Jane Street to challenge India ban, says it engaged in basic arbitrage
Jane Street said it was 'beyond disappointed' by what it called 'extremely inflammatory' accusations from the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) and is working on a formal response, according to an internal email sent to employees over the weekend that was seen by Reuters.
The email did not elaborate on the potential action that Jane Street might take.
SEBI on Friday barred the firm from buying and selling securities in the Indian market and seized $567 million of its funds.
'The order clearly lays out SEBI's prima facie case and addresses all relevant areas and questions,' SEBI said in an official comment to Reuters.
At this stage, we have nothing to add to what is already contained, explained, and reasoned in that order, SEBI added.
SEBI in its order had alleged that Jane Street bought large quantities of constituents in India's Bank Nifty index in the cash and futures markets to artificially support the index in morning trade, while simultaneously building large short positions in index options which were exercised or allowed to expire later in the day.
India bars Jane Street from its securities market, citing manipulation of stock indexes
The regulator, which tracked Jane Street's trading patterns for more than two years, has also widened its investigation to include other indexes and exchanges, a source has said.
Over the past three years, India's derivatives market has had explosive growth as retail investors swarmed in and is now the world's largest. But that has also led to losses for many ordinary investors, which has become a concern for regulators.
In its email, Jane Street said arbitrage trades were 'a core and commonplace mechanism of financial markets that keeps the prices of related instruments in line.'
SEBI's order that this activity is 'prima facie manipulative' disregards the role of liquidity providers and arbitrageurs in markets, Jane Street added.
SEBI did not respond to Reuters' requests for comment.
The proprietary trading firm also took issue with SEBI's claims that it had failed to respond adequately to the regulator's concerns, saying the firm's executives had met with regulators and exchange officials multiple times.
'Once again, we left this process feeling that we had reached an understanding of the concerns and reflected them in modifications to our trading behaviour.'
'Since February, we have made ongoing efforts to communicate with SEBI and have been consistently rebuffed,' the email said.
India accounted for roughly 60% of global equity derivative trading volume in May, according to the Futures Industry Association.
Data out on Monday showed that equity derivative losses for India's retail traders widened by 41% to 1.06 trillion Indian rupees ($12.4 billion) in the financial year that ended in March.
SEBI Chairman Tuhin Kanta Pandey also said on Monday that the regulator was enhancing its surveillance to scrutinize manipulation in derivatives trading, but added that there may not be many more cases like Jane Street.
Other overseas proprietary trading firms that are active in India include Citadel Securities, IMC Trading, Millennium and Optiver.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
an hour ago
- Express Tribune
State Dept starts firing over 1,350 workers
A general view of the US state Department building in Washington, DC, US, July 11, REUTERS The State Department began firing more than 1,350 US-based employees on Friday as the administration of President Donald Trump presses ahead with an unprecedented overhaul of its diplomatic corps, a move critics say will undermine US ability to defend and promote US interests abroad. The layoffs, which affect 1,107 civil service and 246 foreign service officers based in the United States, come at a time when Washington is grappling with multiple crisis on the world stage: Russia's war in Ukraine, the almost two year-long Gaza conflict, and the Middle East on edge due to high tension between Israel and Iran. "The Department is streamlining domestic operations to focus on diplomatic priorities," an internal State Department notice that was sent to the workforce said. "Headcount reductions have been carefully tailored to affect non-core functions, duplicative or redundant offices, and offices where considerable efficiencies may be found," it added.
Express Tribune
2 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Bodies of nine slain passengers sent home
Mourners in Multan carry the coffin of a victim of the latest terrorist carnage in Balochistan to graveyard. PHOTO: ONLINE Listen to article The bodies of nine passengers martyred in a terrorist attack in the Sardhaka area overnight were sent to their hometowns in Punjab for burial on Friday, as the provincial government expanded the scope of law-enforcement agencies (LEAs) to launch decisive actions against the perpetrators. Those slaughtered in the late-night terrorist attack belonged to the Lahore, Gujrat, Khanewal, Gujranwala, Lodhran, Dera Ghazi Khan, Muzaffargarh, and Attock districts. They included two brothers Jabbar and Usman from Dunyapur. Balochistan government spokesperson Shahid Rind said that Fitna al Hindustan, a term used for Indian-backed terrorist organisations in Balochistan, had carried out attacks at three different places. The terrorist attack occurred near the boundary between the Zhob and Loralai districts. The bodies were brought to Zhob, where they were received by Deputy Commissioner Usman Khalid and Border Military Police Commandant Asad Khan Chandia. The victims, who were travelling from Quetta to Lahore, were identified as Muhammad Irfan, Dera Ghazi Khan; Sabir Hussain, Gujranwala; Muhammad Asif, Chowk Qureshi; Ghulam Saeed, Khanewal; Muhammad Junaid, Lahore; Muhammad Bilal, Attock; Bilawal, Gujrat and Jabbar and Usman, Dunyapur. The funeral prayers for brothers Jabbar Toor and Usman Toor were held at Government Boys High School, Dunyapur in the Lodhran district. Relatives said that the victims were traveling to attend the funeral of their father. Meanwhile, Balochistan Chief Minister Sarfraz Bugti ordered the law-enforcement agencies to launch an immediate and decisive action against those involved in the Sardhaka massacre, authorising them to act beyond the "usual limits of the levies and police jurisdictions, if required". The chief minister chaired a security meeting in the provincial capital to review the law and order situation in the province, and received a briefing from the Balochistan inspector general of police on the Sardhaka incident and the updates on the ongoing investigation and security operations in the area. "The pursuit of these terrorists will continue until they are brought to justice. There will be no compromise on enforcing the law in Balochistan," the chief minister said, adding that security forces have been authorised to act beyond the usual limits of levies and police jurisdictions. 'Barbaric act' President Asif Ali Zardari described the killing of passengers as a "barbaric act" and said that it was part of Fitna al-Hindustan's broader conspiracy to destabilise Pakistan. He reaffirmed the state's commitment to purge the country of Fitna al-Hindustan and their facilitators at all costs. Similarly, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif condemned Sardhaka massacre, terming it "blatant terrorism". He asserted that the perpetrators would be dealt with through full state force. "The blood of innocent people will be avenged," he said, blaming India for supporting such acts against unarmed civilians. Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi denounced the killings as "cowardly barbarism" by "Indian?sponsored terrorists and their local facilitators", vowing nationwide pursuit and punishment of the perpetrators. He reaffirmed the state's commitment to thwart all plots against national peace and integrity. (WITH INPUT FROM APP)
Express Tribune
8 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Another terror act
Listen to article One more gruesome killing incident in Balochistan goes on to confirm that authorities are at a fail in cracking down on the terror nexus. Nine passengers on two Punjab-bound buses were pulled out after being screened on lingual basis and then executed on the highway linking Musakhail-Makhtar and Khajuri. This wanton killing sends the wrong signals in a province that is already teetering under lawlessness and socio-economic deprivation. The outlawed BLA, an Indian proxy, has claimed responsibility for the crime, and the government rightly believes in exterminating such foreign-sponsored outfits. However, the fact is that there is something amiss in taking on such unscrupulous elements, and there is nothing much to do other than remorse after every such tragedy. A coherent political-cum-military strategy to overcome such fissures is indispensable. This butchery on the Zhob-Loralai junction invites some introspection. It attests that non-state actors or their cahoots are scot-free, and have a set mindset to bleed. Secondly, the repeated targeting of a particular ethnic community is probably meant for sending down the message that national cohesion is up for a toss. The government's sole reliance on the kinetic strategy, disregarding the political option completely, has kept the province on tenterhooks, endangering not only the lives of its inhabitants but also the prospects of broader development of the province and the region. The HRCP, and the likes, are right in pressing for a negotiated solution to the imbroglio that is unending and taking a toll in the form of pushing the entire country over the brink as communal cross-currents are being flared through such killings. The grievances of people in the absence of political space and true representation are genuine, and cannot be brushed aside by alienating them. Besides employing the kinetic-political method that also features an unconditional dialogue offer to all the dissidents, there is need to launch an aggressive diplomatic campaign to apprise the regional countries of foreign meddling, and bring them round to collectively work to rid the region of the menace of terrorism.
