Dozens of children may have undergone unnecessary hip surgeries, says new report
Dozens of children who underwent hip surgeries at Cappagh and Temple Street did not meet an international expert's full criteria for hip surgery, a damning new report has found.
In nearly 80% of cases at Cappagh Orthopaedic Hospital and 60% of cases at Temple Street, lower decision-making thresholds were used to decide whether surgeries should be conducted. It is likely that hundreds of children may have been operated on at a lower threshold, as it is understood that it is likely this standard was applied going back "many years".
CHI and National Orthopaedic Hospital at Cappagh (NOHC) commissioned an audit after a whistleblower raised concerns about the thresholds used to decide whether to perform surgery for children with Developmental Hip Dysplasia (DHD) at Temple Street and Cappagh. This surgery relates to the failure of the full formation of the hip socket in children. It can be identified through screening and is followed up with other investigations such as X-rays and ultrasound.
CHI commissioned UK-based Consultant Paediatric Orthopaedic Surgeon Mr Simon Thomas to review a random sample of surgery cases carried out on children aged between one and seven between 2021 and 2023 across Temple Street, Crumlin, and Cappagh hospitals. In total, Mr Thomas reviewed 147 random and anonymous cases across the three hospitals.
The report found that there were significantly different thresholds for recommending pelvic osteotomy procedures between Crumlin, Temple Street and The National Orthopaedic Hospital in Cappagh. At CHI Crumlin, the threshold for performing hip surgeries on children was fully in line with the criteria used by the international expert who wrote the report. However, Mr Thomas raised concerns about the threshold for surgery in many cases in Temple Street and Cappagh Hospital.
What was called "novel picking" was used. In this context, an existing but less invasive procedure was completed, but questions were raised about the threshold for surgery. Mr Thomas sampled 51 cases out of a total of 114 surgeries done at Cappagh. Of 70 pelvic osteotomies, just 15 met the audit criteria (21%).
At Temple Street, 49 cases were audited out of 127 that took place in the hospital between 2021 and 2023. Out of 85 pelvic osteotomies, 34 met the audit criteria (40%). At Crumlin, 47 cases of 101 were audited. Of 63 pelvic osteotomies, 62 met the audit criteria
This means that 79% of surgeries at Cappagh and 60% of surgeries at Temple Street did not reach the criteria required for surgery set out by Mr Thomas. The audit also identified one case from the review sample where a child experienced complications due to the surgical approach recommended to them.
Mr Thomas said in many of the Crumlin and Cappagh cases sampled, there was no record of closed or open hip reduction after delayed diagnosis, no record of either hip ever having been dislocated and "often no history of treatment soon after birth by splint or brace for hip instability". All 497 cases that have undergone pelvic osteotomy at Cappagh and Temple Street between 2021 and 2023 now require ongoing follow-up to skeletal maturity.
Around 1,800 children and young adults who have had this surgery at CHI at Temple Street and Cappagh since 2010 will now be reviewed. These families will be recalled and should undergo an independent clinical review and radiological assessment, the report stated.
This group of patients will be contacted directly to explain what this means and the next steps for them. An external independent panel of surgeons with expertise in DDH surgery is currently being established to review all patients who underwent surgery for DDH in CHI at Temple Street from 2010 and Cappagh from 2021 to establish whether the criteria for surgery aligned with acceptable parameters as determined by the expert panel. Families will be involved throughout this process.
Bernard Gloster, CEO of the HSE, said that the variance in surgical practice between Cappagh and Temple Street was concerning. He said: "The proportion of pelvic osteotomies taking place at CHI at Temple Street and NOHC, despite not reaching the international criteria used in the audit, was so high that the audit report says further inquiry is mandated.
"Focus on follow-up and putting in place a mechanism to ensure this kind of variation can't recur is central to our next steps, and we will be working with everyone to ensure that this can't happen again." CHI and Cappagh Hospital have established a dedicated contact number which will be supported by clinical staff and will support patients and families who are seeking further information about their care and the next steps.
The phone line is open Monday to Friday 8am to 8pm, and Saturday and Sunday 9am to 5pm. The number is Freephone 1800 807 050, or 00 353 1 240 8706 from outside Ireland. Health Minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill said she has 'moved immediately to strengthen governance and oversight structures at CHI and NOHC'.
She said: "In responding to this Report, I am thinking first and foremost of the impact a surgery has on a child. I am also deeply aware of the worry that parents will face today and this is something that is sitting with me all the time.
"My immediate priority is to ensure that there is clinical follow-up and care for patients who have undergone pelvic osteotomy surgery. This follow-up will be in accordance with best practice and the recommendations of the Report."
Join our Dublin Live breaking news service on WhatsApp. Click this link to receive your daily dose of Dublin Live content. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.
For all the latest news from Dublin and surrounding areas visit our homepage.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Extra.ie
41 minutes ago
- Extra.ie
Who is Deirdre Heenan? The professor tipped for FF Áras bid
The race for who will be Fianna Fáil's presidential candidate remains open but party members believe that Derry-based academic Deirdre Heenan is ticking a lot of the right boxes. It is reported that Deirdre is An Taoiseach and Fianna Fáil leader Micháel Martin's preferred choice of candidate due to her political likeness to Mary McAleese. has taken an in-depth look at the Ulster University professor and the background that has led her to potentially run for Áras an Uachtaráin. Deirdre Heenan with President Michael D Higgins in 2018. Pic: Sasko Lazarov/Photocall Ireland Born in Annaclone, Co Down, Deirdre was educated at Banbridge Academy and Ulster University. Now, she lives in Derry with her husband and three sons. Deirdre is a former Pro-Vice-Chancellor of Ulster University and a former Provost of its Coleraine and Magee campuses. She is a member of the Institute for Research in Social Sciences and has published widely on healthcare, education policy, social care and devolution. In 2001, Deirdre was the recipient of a Distinguished Teaching Award and this was followed by a prestigious National Teaching Fellowship by the Higher Education Academy in 2006. Professor Deirdre Heenan with former US president Bill Clinton At the University of Ulster in 2010. Pic: Paul Faith –Two years later, she secured an ESRC fellowship and spent nine months as policy adviser in the Office of the First Minister and Deputy First Minister. In 2011, she was appointed by the health minister to join a five strong panel of experts to oversee a radical review of Health and Social Care in Northern Ireland and the following year, she was appointed to the Council of State by President Michael D Higgins. Professor Deirdre Heehan posing for a selfie with former British Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn during a visit to Lifford Bridge in 2018. Pic: Liam McBurney – Pool/Getty Images Deirdre is described by Ulster University as a 'distinguished researcher, author and broadcaster'. Many Fianna Fáil sources told that they first came across the 58-year-old when she spoke at a party event in UCD to commemorate the 25th anniversary of the Good Friday Agreement. They said: 'I wasn't surprised to hear her name as she ticks a lot of Mary McAleese boxes. She was very impressive when she spoke at the Good Friday event and would fit the mould of what Micheál (Martin) would want. 'She was very impressive, and really challenging about the Good Friday Agreement. She spoke about how too many people sit back and applaud the GFA, when, in her view, it is not yet complete, and that we can't afford to rest on our laurels.'
Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
Dublin children's hospital ‘misplaces' child's record in ‘serious data-protection breach'
A Dublin children's hospital has had a 'serious data-protection breach' after a patient's healthcare record was 'misplaced', a memo sent to staff said. It comes in the same week as an unannounced inspection by the Data Protection Commission (DPC) following concerns about the accessibility of patient charts in a shared office at Children's Health Ireland (CHI) Tallaght . On Friday, Sarah Hartnett, data-protection officer at CHI , sent a memo to all staff members entitled 'misplaced healthcare records'. 'A healthcare record has recently been reported misplaced at CHI. Despite a thorough search process, the original record has not been recovered,' the memo said. READ MORE 'In accordance with our statutory obligations, this incident has been reported to the Data Protection Commission'. According to Ms Hartnett, this is a 'serious data-protection breach and a reminder of the critical importance of following all healthcare record procedures'. 'Staff must strictly comply with the HSE standards for healthcare records management and CHI data-protection policies'. Separately, the DPC carried out an unannounced inspection at CHI Tallaght last week on foot of a complaint. The inspection took place in a shared office for non-consultant hospital doctors (NCHDs) on the first floor of the hospital. It is understood the door to the shared office, containing hundreds of patient charts, was propped open – making it accessible to people walking by. When closed properly, the door is locked with a keypad. Dr Turlough Bolger, a consultant in emergency medicine, sent an email to staff at the hospital on Thursday morning, the day after the inspection. 'The report will be received in the coming weeks but they expressed concern regarding the number of charts in the room yesterday (approx 320 charts) and the amount of loose pages with patient details,' his email states. 'I expect that the recommendations will be wide-ranging and damaging to CHI at Tallaght.' Dr Bolger said he appreciates the 'hard work' made by staff to reduce the number of outstanding discharge charts in recent weeks, which has seen a 'significant reduction' from 900 to 600 charts. 'I have said repeatedly that there needs to be a sustainable approach to this issue. Ultimately, as the accountable officer in CHI at Tallaght, I am responsible for the overall situation regarding medical records.' Dr Bolger said as the accountable officer, he 'cannot rely on blitzes to clear backlogs as routine'. In order to clear the current backlog, Dr Bolger said he had requested that four NCHDs be allocated to discharges daily. He added that there was a need for 'an emphasis on the use of the confidential shredding bin for most of the loose pages'. A spokesman for the DPC confirmed a team carried out an inspection at CHI Tallaght last week. 'Enquiries relating to this inspection are ongoing at present,' the spokesman said. 'We are not in a position to provide any further comment at this time.' In relation to the unannounced inspection, a spokeswoman for CHI said a data breach 'has not been confirmed at this time' and the inspection related to a 'potential data breach'. 'Immediate measures have been taken to reduce any potential risk, including reinforcing physical safeguards and engaging directly with staff,' the spokeswoman said. 'Additional actions will follow, as appropriate, in line with our internal procedures and any recommendations issued by the DPC as part of its broader oversight.' The spokeswoman added that CHI is transitioning to a 'fully digital health records system and, once complete, this will significantly reduce reliance on paper charts'. CHI has faced significant public and political scrutiny in recent months, particularly in relation to the governance and oversight of its paediatric orthopaedic services.
Irish Times
3 days ago
- Irish Times
Ireland far behind other countries for IVF genetic testing, doctors and advocates say
Eight healthy babies were recently conceived via in vitro fertilisation (IVF) in the UK using DNA from three people to avoid inheriting serious genetic mutations, but it could be many years before these procedures are permitted under law in Ireland. The remarkable scientific development was years in the making. The procedure is carried out in cases where the mother is known to have a genetic mutation in her mitochondrial DNA – the power house of the cell that makes up human tissue. The mother's egg is artificially fertilised by the father's sperm, and the genetic material from this embryo is extracted and transferred to a donor's egg, one which doesn't have mitochondrial mutation. The vast majority of the DNA is that of the mother and father, with the donor only providing less than a tenth of a per cent to the embryo's genetic code. It nonetheless has the potential to provide hope for families around the world. Graphic: Newcastle University/Newcastle Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust/PA Wire Dr Jane Farrar, from Trinity College 's genetics department, explains that mutations in the mitochondria are rare, yet manifest themselves in serious health issues from birth. Babies born with these mutations often suffer brain, heart and muscle failure from a young age as well as developmental delays. Dr Farrar says there is a range of mitochondrial disease with a spectrum of symptoms, all of which are severe. Leber Hereditary Optic Neuropathy (LHON) can lead to quite sudden, sometimes total loss of vision in both eyes. Dr Farrar says this is an onset disease and often takes place in young adulthood. On the other hand, Leigh Syndrome is a disorder characterised by progressive and gradual loss of muscle use and brain function. This is evident from infancy and early childhood, she says. The eight healthy babies in the UK were born after about 20 years of genetic and medical research, and in 2015 a change in law allowed for this procedure to be carried out. In spite of the Church of England and other religious leaders questioning its ethics, the UK parliament passed it by a two-thirds majority. IVF clinics in Ireland are not permitted under law to carry out this procedure. The Department of Health calls it 'a relatively new and highly complex form of assisted human reproduction technology'. A department spokesperson said the Health (Assisted Human Reproduction) Act 2024 'establishes a regulatory framework for fertility clinics and assisted human reproduction (AHR) treatments, aiming to ensure consistency, oversight and ethical standards in practice and research'. The National Infertility Support and Information Group (NISIG) said 'while work is under way to establish a regulatory authority for Assisted Human Reproduction (AHR) treatment in Ireland as part of this legislation, research like this in the UK highlights just how far behind Ireland still is in comparison to other countries'. They said it is imperative the government's regulatory framework includes an authority that 'enables the use of pre-implantation genetic testing (PGT) of embryos; posthumous assisted human reproduction; and embryo and stem cell research'. Dr John Waterstone, a graduate of Trinity College's genetics department as well as its medical school, is the founder and director of Waterstone Clinic, one of Ireland's largest IVF providers. While he acknowledges the 'very experimental' nature of the procedure, he says 'it is pretty remarkable that they've managed to do it. It's an incredible achievement for them'. He says that for some 'it's ethically questionable' to facilitate genetic modification of embryos but adds that this is for 'couples who have found themselves in tragic situations. Really traumatic, horrendous experiences of parents' children dying in infancy after being born with rare genetic mutations'. Waterstone Clinic does provide pre-implantation genetic testing on embryos to discover if parents are unknowingly passing down genetic mutations that could cause serious health conditions in their children. However, Dr Waterstone says that the kind of procedure that took place in the UK is unlikely to come to Ireland anytime soon. 'I don't really think in the foreseeable future that anyone in Ireland who's diagnosed with mitochondrial disease will receive that treatment here. It's more viable to go to the UK,' he says. Given the rarity of these mutations, 'one in 5,000 individuals might have mitochondrial diseases', he says and the necessity for this treatment is not widespread.
