Doctor who had opioid addiction is spared jail for stealing and forging prescriptions
Daniel Nevin (39) pleaded guilty at Mullingar Circuit Criminal Court to the theft of prescription pads from two hospitals, 46 counts of forgery and using false instruments between 2021 and last year.
His fiancee Rebecca Moylan (35), a qualified nurse, admitted stealing prescriptions and unlawfully using them in pharmacies.
Judge Keenan Johnson said these offences undermined the integrity of the medical prescription system and said Nevin was in the throes of an addiction but had never put a patient at risk.
READ MORE
He said the couple whose careers have been ruined and reputations tarnished had only damaged themselves, saying, 'The main victims of this are the two accused.'
Nevin achieved a PhD from Trinity College Dublin, specialising in pharmacology, and had worked in medical research in Australia before returning to Ireland to continue his studies. He qualified as a medical doctor in 2018.
When the addiction started in 2019 he tried to tackle the problem, but relapsed around the period of offending.
Judge Johnson said Nevin was a 'high achiever', but had removed himself from working onwards as a clinician and moved into a tutoring role at Midlands Regional General Hospital.
The judge was also mindful of the pressures placed on medical professionals working 24-hour shifts in busy environments.
He said the couple did not reach the threshold for a custodial sentence and said they had paid a huge price.
Judge Johnson said they could be spared convictions and would receive the benefit of the Probation of Offenders Act if Nevin and his fiancee donated €15,000 and €5,000 respectively to the Merchant Quay drug treatment project as a form of restorative justice.
Among Nevin's charges were thefts of prescriptions from University Hospital Galway between July 2021 and July 2023 and from the Midlands Regional General Hospital in Mullingar from July 10th, 2023, until February 18th last year.
The remaining charges he admitted included three counts of using false prescriptions in pharmacies in Kells, Co Meath, at Kilbeggan, Co Westmeath, and in Tullamore, Co Offaly.
Moylan admitted theft of prescription pads from St James's Hospital in Dublin from September 1st, 2023, until November that year and using prescriptions forged by her partner in several pharmacies.
The couple, of Greenpark Meadows, Mullingar, Co. Westmeath, used a fictitious patient's name on most of the prescriptions to get OxyContin, a highly addictive opioid-based medicine.
Their offending was exposed when a pharmacist in Mullingar became suspicious in May last year, the court heard.
He contacted University Hospital Galway and discovered they had no record of the prescription or the named patient.
In court, Nevin agreed with his barrister, Colm Smyth SC, that the 'stress and strain of the job precipitated and aggravated' Nevin's addiction. The doctor initially managed to buy opioids online before he sought help to tackle the problem.
He said after a substantial period of sobriety, he had a relapse, resulting in a prolonged absence from work and 'I took myself out of the clinician domain'. He said he switched to a teaching role in the hospital, saying he was passionate about education.
Nevin said the consequences had been devastating. He expressed remorse and said he was attending addiction counselling.
The court heard how Moylan, while studying to be a nurse, had cared for her terminally ill mother.
Dara Foynes SC, defending, said Moylan acted out of the highest level of compassion and concern for her partner and was trying to manage a situation that was out of control, resulting in self-inflicted harm and a fall from grace.
The court heard Moylan has resigned from her job, agreed not to work as a nurse again, while Nevin awaited a decision on the future of his medical career.
Their court case was adjourned until Friday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Community ‘numb' following death of 12-year-old girl in Co Tipperary swimming accident
A local community is 'numb' following the death of a 12-year-old girl after a swimming incident in Co Tipperary on Friday afternoon. The girl, who has been named locally as Freya Tobin, was swimming at a spot along the Suir Blueway in the village of Newcastle, which is located close the border with Co Waterford The former sixth class student at the Social Mhuire Caisleán Nua National School had been swimming with a number of others when she got into difficulty at about 4.20pm. A friend raised the alarm and number of local boys dived into the water to help. The spot where the girls were swimming is known to have strong currents. READ MORE Gardaí, National Ambulance Service personnel and firefighters from Clonmel Fire Station's swift water rescue team attended the scene. Freya was transferred to Cork University Hospital by the Irish Coast Guard Air and Sea Rescue 117 helicopter after being recovered from the water at about 4.45pm. In a statement, gardaí said that they and emergency services attended an incident where 'a female child got into difficulty in the water at river Suir, Newcastle, Co Tipperary at approximately 4.20pm today.' The statement said: 'She was airlifted by Rescue 117 to Cork University Hospital in a serious condition. She has since passed away.' A file will be prepared for the Coroner's Court. 'Sometimes no words seem adequate when a tragedy like what happened in our parish in Newcastle today occurs,' said local priest Fr Michael Toomey. He said 'no words can give comfort at this time' and that his thoughts and prayers are with the girl's family who have 'suffered a terrible loss in this awful tragedy'. A prayer service will be held at Our Lady of the Assumption in Newcastle at 12pm. 'As we all come together to support one another in our grief and to offer prayers for her family, please, look out for one another in these days, and don't be afraid to look for help and support in the coming days,' Fr Toomey said. Scoil Mhuire Caisleán Nua has organised support for all students and parents. Independent TD Mattie McGrath, who is from the local area, said that 'everyone in the village is numb after what has happened. 'It's a very close knit community. Our thoughts are with the young girl's family, her mother and younger brother whom I know well.' Mr McGrath thanked all the emergency services and 'so many locals who did their best' to help save Freya and who are now 'rallying around her family.'
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Trafficked women can spend their life recovering from mental trauma, says campaigner
Women trafficked for sexual exploitation can spend their lives trying to deal with the mental trauma of what they have endured, a campaigner against sexual violence has revealed. Barbara Condon, the chief executive of Ruhama, said that human trafficking for sex has been described as 'the worst example of what one human being can do to another human being.' Speaking at the official launch of Ruhama's Cork-Kerry support service, Ms Condon revealed that the service, which has been operational since April 2024, has helped support some 80 women who were the victims of sexual exploitation in the southwest. She explained that Ruhama, which supports women impacted by prostitution and human trafficking, works with 'a hidden cohort of women, often ignored, overlooked and marginalised, trafficked women who are highly transient with no addresses, no bank accounts who are subjected to sexual violence in every town and city across Ireland.' She said that human trafficking and sexual exploitation brings with it complex trauma, not just physical but also mental with many victims developing post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) which can often lead to addiction, homelessness and further exploitation. 'But the biggest thing probably that the women face is the stigma and the discrimination and the shame,' she said. 'Nobody should be stigmatised because they've been sexually assaulted or sexually violated – recovery from sexual violence and sexual exploitation is lifelong because of what they've endured.' Ms Condon said that there was 'a huge silence around sexual exploitation' which made it difficult for people to speak about it, but Ruhama helped through talking and listening to the victims of such exploitation, but society needs to step up more to address the problem and the stigma. 'And the shame, the shame is what keeps women stuck long after they've exited and the shame really comes from most of depraved and degrading acts that nobody in this room can actually imagine unless they've been through and it really is unbelievable.' Ms Condon said that one the findings of a new study commissioned by Ruhama entitled Room for Recovery – Housing Hope After Exploitation was that accommodation was an essential part of the set of assistance measures necessary for victims of trafficking if they are to recover. 'Both the National Action Plan on Trafficking and the Third National Strategy for Domestic Sexual and Gender Based Violence are crystal clear on the crucial importance of gender-specific specialist accommodation for victims of human trafficking for sexual exploitation,' she said. 'The continued accommodation of these victims-survivors with their particular vulnerabilities among the general asylum reception and the general International Protection Accommodation Service is inhumane and untenable.' One survivor of human trafficking and sexual exploitation, who wished to remain anonymous, said that the new Cork-Kerry service will offer not just support and safety but also compassion and hope for those who have endured great trauma from what they have been through. 'I carried enormous shame especially after discovering there was footage of my abuse – videos taken without consent, passed around like I was an object- that kind of violation leaves scars deeper than words,' she said. 'It makes you question if you are even human any more – I wanted to disappear – the new Ruhama Cork-Kerry service will be a place where trauma is named, shame is lifted and women come home to themselves.' Taoiseach Michéal Martin paid tribute to Ruhama for the work that the organisation is doing and he said the opening of the Cork-Kerry service was a vital step towards providing vital support and to 'some of the most vulnerable women in appalling circumstances' so they can rebuild their lives. 'The services delivered by Ruhama in this sector and on the frontline with victims are essential as we move forward with the Government's National Action Plan on Trafficking and our zero tolerance strategy for tackling domestic, sexual and gender-based violence,' he said.
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
Redress for school abuse survivors would be biggest in State's history, sparking fears among officials
A redress scheme for survivors of sexual abuse in schools would be at a 'far greater scale' than any other scheme in the history of the State, and could have 'far-reaching implications'. A group of civil servants across five senior Government departments warned they could not support a call for such a redress scheme without 'concrete data' about how high demand and what 'potential costs' would be. It is possible that a commission of investigation would have to start its work before a redress scheme is set up, with the early stages of the inquiry being used as a way to measure demand for redress. There are concerns among senior sources about the impact the redress scheme would have on budgets for present-day needs. The Government will now consider if the insurance policies of schools found liable for abuse can be used to 'offset' the costs of payments to a possible 40,000 survivors or more. READ MORE This week Ministers agreed to set up a commission of investigation into historic abuse in schools. Minister for Education Helen McEntee said 'further' investigation and analysis was required before an anticipated redress scheme for abuse survivors could be announced. [ Q&A: Will survivors of historical abuse in schools be compensated? And who will be liable? Opens in new window ] The commission of investigation and proposed redress scheme were among the recommendations of a scoping inquiry published last year, which detailed 2,395 allegations of sexual abuse at 308 schools run by religious congregations, involving 884 alleged abusers. An inter-departmental group report (IDG) including officials from the Departments of the Taoiseach, Education, Justice, Children, and Public Expenditure and Reform wrote a report examining the main recommendations of the scoping inquiry. The group of civil servants felt that setting up a redress scheme for survivors of sexual abuse in schools was 'as complex' as setting up a commission of investigation. Analysis by the Department of Public Expenditure warned against 'the significant risks' of a 'rushed' redress scheme, 'including the assumption of risk by the State when liability should more appropriately be borne by third parties'. The report said that recent case law on the liability for the actions of school employees found that 'the State does not have such liability'. IDG said such a redress scheme requires 'serious and careful consideration' and that it could have 'far-reaching implications'. [ The Irish Times view on the inquiry into the handling of child abuse in schools: a mammoth task Opens in new window ] The IDG report noted that based on information from the Central Statistics Office (CSO), there are more than 41,300 people aged 35 or over in Ireland that have been affected by sexual abuse in schools, with the added note that sexual abuse tends to be 'under-reported'. 'In the event that a comparable number of people applied to any future redress scheme, the impact would be considerable and certainly on a far greater scale than any such scheme implemented to date in Ireland,' it said. It said: 'Concrete data regarding the potential scale of historical sexual abuse in day and boarding schools in Ireland is unavailable and in the absence of such information, the IDG is not in a position to advise on an appropriate response to [the recommendation for a redress scheme] at this time.' Officials will now carry out further work on the practical issues of a redress scheme. [ Highest number of abuse allegations in 16 years received by Catholic Church's safeguarding body Opens in new window ] International examples of redress schemes that succeeded in getting third parties found liable for abuse to pay for redress will also be examined, including a scheme in Australia that succeeded in getting religious organisations to pay for redress by threatening to withdraw charitable status or state funding. Survivors had stressed to the scoping inquiry the need for the future Commission of Investigation to be carried out quickly, with Ms McEntee this week setting a five-year timeline for the inquiry. The IDG has proposed letting the commission sit in parallel 'divisions' to save time. This would be the first time in the history of the State that an inquiry has been carried out in such a way, and it would be likely to require additional legislation passed by the Oireachtas.
