Controversial call costs Moana Pasifika in crucial Blues match
The failure to spot that Lalomilo had been in touch should have been exactly that in the end – a failure to spot that Lalomilo had been in touch – as, once the Blues had regained possession from his infield pass, that started the clock again. The Blues' brief moment with the ball should have rendered the infringement off-limits in the decision as to whether the try had been legally scored or not.
It became a somewhat farcical scene at North Harbour, as referee Angus Gardner and his assistant Ben O'Keeffe tried to make sense of what had happened and what protocol needed to be applied.
Moana captain Ardie Savea showed just how confused and confusing the law book can be when he suggested – wrongly as it happens, because this clause has been changed – that the officials couldn't go back more than three phases to determine whether the try should stand. Ardie Savea speaks with referee Angus Gardner as the Moana try is overturned. Photo / Photosport
Moana did score a valid try two minutes later, but as always with these sliding door moments – like the Aaron Smith try the All Blacks scored in the World Cup final that was wrongly disallowed – it's impossible to know what impact it would have had on the game, had it stood.
Based on what was happening at North Harbour Stadium, though, it's fair to suggest that Moana, who had all the momentum and all the energy in the period leading into Sanerivi's non-try, could have lifted to another level again if they hadn't had to wait for almost two minutes to hear that their score was being chalked off.
The waiting, as any team on a surge can testify, sucks the energy and flow out of the contest – and to then hear that the score is not standing is deflating.
That may not seem like much, but in the heat of the moment, it can be critical – especially as the prolonged discussion among the officials gave the Blues a chance to recuperate and regather.
The bottom line is that it's impossible not to wonder whether that decision was critical in enabling the Blues to hold on to a losing bonus point they may not otherwise have gathered, and then to wonder just how critical that bonus point may be in Moana's quest to secure a place in the playoffs.
The Blues and Moana are both on 28 competition points and are fighting, alongside the Hurricanes, for two quarter-final spots.
In the course of a 14-game regular season, there will be innumerable incidents and failings that could be highlighted to explain why a team didn't make the last six. But there will always be something truly contentious and frustrating about officiating errors that are made not as a result of law interpretation and application, but as a result of not actually knowing the laws under which the game is being played.
In defence of the officials, they are faced with an overly complex and nuanced set of protocols that have been introduced this year by World Rugby and which come with different criteria for different circumstances.
If there is an act of foul play discovered in the build-up to a try, then the officials can adjudicate as far back as the last restart of play.
If there is a knock-on, forward pass or someone is in touch, they can go back to the last attacking passage of play and if there is an offside or maul obstruction, they can go back two phases (scrum, lineout, ruck or maul) of play.
It seems needlessly complex, although TMO Glenn Newman should have had these protocols in front of him to ensure the officials were being advised correctly on the law.
It's to be applauded that rugby wants lighter-touch interference from the TMO and a means to use technology without destroying the flow and integrity of the contests.
But surely it has to simplify and unify the protocol – and have one standard application of just how far back events can be analysed.
Gregor Paul is one of New Zealand's most respected rugby writers and columnists. He has won multiple awards for journalism and written several books about sport.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
8 hours ago
- NZ Herald
All Blacks v France: How weakened touring side cheats rugby out of a proper contest
Strategically, leaving so many of their frontline troops to rest and recover in the French summer may ultimately prove to not be an effective form of cheating. Not taking the opportunity to test themselves against the All Blacks in a three-test series may turn out to be an opportunity lost – a blown chance to galvanise a team that was looking frighteningly good by the end of this year's Six Nations. Ireland showed the value of going all-in, when they brought every man and his dog to New Zealand in July 2022, won the series and then embarked on a 17-test unbeaten streak that ended in the 2023 World Cup quarter-final. French coach Fabien Galthié is bringing a weakened line up into the first test. Photo / Photosport Maybe it will prove to be the masterstroke coach Fabien Galthié hopes it will be – a way to preserve the mental and physical vigour of his best, while finding the odd gold nugget buried deep within his squad here in New Zealand. Whether resting so many players this July helps or hinders France is not the point, though. This shouldn't be happening. It contravenes the goodwill agreement between the top-tier nations about the respect they show for international rugby and while the term cheating may be harsh, it is accurate. It is cheating the system of reciprocity – damaging its credibility and integrity. The deal is that international rugby is best v best, and what France have done is turn up to the All Blacks' house party with a bottle of unremarkable Côtes du Rhône when they promised to bring Saint-Émilion. They will still have the temerity to expect the All Blacks to bring something splendid from the Gimblett Gravels next time they are due in Paris. It is cheating the All Blacks out of the contest they wanted. It is cheating New Zealand Rugby out of the marketing story it needs and hampering its future ability to sell tickets. And it is cheating the fans as it's a dupe: a straight consumer case of not being sold what was advertised. The punishment for France will likely be a difficult three weeks in which they battle to contain an All Blacks team that should have too much pace, power and experience for them. It could get embarrassing – scorelines that run away on them – but obviously the French aren't overly worried about that, or they wouldn't have selected the way they have. They have come with a mindset that they have nothing to lose as they threw the series away the instant they picked the squad they did. Now they believe they only have a potential upside to think about which is the possibility of this rag tag group of good but inexperienced players finding a way to punch way above their weight. All Blacks coach Scott Robertson during the squad naming for 2025, held at the Coastal Rugby Club in Taranaki. Photo / Dean Purcell All Blacks coach Scott Robertson has sidestepped making any pronouncement on the issue, preferring instead to frame the series as what his side can gain from it rather than focusing on what they have been denied. But then what else could he say or do? This whole business is above his pay grade and he will be judged just the same as he would have had the French brought the heavy cavalry rather than the light infantry. His goals remain unchanged, but the ability to achieve them has unquestionably become significantly easier. This is now a series in which the All Blacks can get their scrummaging honed – the timing fractionally more precise and the all-important art of adapting to the referee and adjusting to his interpretations improved. It's a series in which they can lift confidence in their driving maul and their ability to defend it, and it's a series in which they can build familiarity with their attack patterns while tinkering with their midfield and back three set-ups. There will be the illusion of this being the big time – but on the field there will be a fraction more time for the All Blacks to pass and catch, a little bit of naivety to exploit at set-piece, a little bit of leeway to make the odd mistake and not be harshly punished for doing so. It all sounds great, maybe even a good thing that the All Blacks can open their season with a tough but underpowered opponent to give them a challenging but not overly intense means to feel their way into 2025. But again, whether playing France Lite is indeed a better way for the All Blacks to start their campaign, is a moot point. The French have cheated everyone. Gregor Paul is one of New Zealand's most respected rugby writers and columnists. He has won multiple awards for journalism and written several books about sport. For live commentary of this weekend's All Blacks v France test, go to GOLD SPORT or iHeartRadio.
1News
17 hours ago
- 1News
'Competition needs them' - Savea's hopes for Moana Pasifika
Moana Pasifika captain Ardie Savea has spoken publicly for the first time about his hope that the franchise continues despite funding issues which have made headlines recently. Savea was outstanding this season – his first for the Auckland-based side after moving north from the Hurricanes – and his inspirational form and leadership helped Moana Pasifika to its highest ever placing of seventh. They were in the playoffs mix until the final round and notched first ever victories over the Highlanders, Blues and Crusaders. They also beat the Hurricanes. But the franchise, supported by New Zealand Rugby, World Rugby, and Pasifika Medical Association Group, which bought the franchise last year, is not on solid ground financially and there are concerns among the rugby community – clearly also held by Savea – that it could struggle to continue. Savea, 31, training with the All Blacks ahead of Saturday's first Test against France in Dunedin, was asked today about the issues surrounding a club that had contributed to what he has described as his most enjoyable season of rugby. ADVERTISEMENT 'You saw what the team did for New Zealand and the people,' Savea said. 'It would be a huge loss if Moana wasn't in any rugby competition. Any competition needs them… we're the Lord's team, we're the people's team.' Savea, who recently announced he would serve a sabbatical in Japan next year and therefore not play Super Rugby in 2026, carried an enormous responsibility at Moana Pasifika over the past eight months or so and the workload told. 'I was tired,' he said. 'I probably didn't realise at the time but I was fatigued. But the heart was full. When the heart and spirit is full it kind of takes over your body… it was nice to take a breath and relax and come back in here and get stuck into it.' Coming back into the All Blacks environment was no hardship, however. 'It's what it demands of you… when the purpose is clear and strong you do everything you can to turn up. We've spent the last couple of days coming together as one and that's what works for me.' Ardie Savea signs autographs after Moana's final match of the season - a loss to the Hurricanes in Wellington. (Source: Photosport) One of the more contentions decisions the selectors must make this week is the make-up of the loose forwards, as well as the identity of their No.10 and the left wing/midfield mix. ADVERTISEMENT With Wallace Sititi out of the series due to an ankle injury and Luke Jacobson set to miss the first Test due to concussion protocols following the Super Rugby Pacific final, Savea, Samipeni Finau and Du'Plessi Kirifi are the only loose forwards available from the original 33-man squad. Christian Lio-Willie and Dalton Papali'i have joined the squad as injury cover and at least one will play in Dunedin. It is possible that the selectors go for Finau, Savea and Kirifi at blindside flanker, No.8 and openside flanker respectively but it's just as possible that they select Lio-Willie as a like-for-like replacement for No.8 Sititi and pick Finau and Savea as flankers. That would leave Kirifi on the bench as an impact player – a role he is likely to fill in the short to medium term. Asked about his willingness to play No.7 after playing there for Moana this year and starting his Test career there, Savea replied: 'I don't have a say do I? Just wherever Razor needs me or where I fit in best for the team… if that's 12 or 13 I'd do my best. 'The loosie roles are quite interchangeable now on the field… it's how collectively as a trio you work together and that's what I want to build as a loose trio with the All Blacks – to be able to connect well and work together." Of Kirifi, with whom he played at the Hurricanes, and Crusader Lio-Willie, Savea said: 'They've played awesome and they're in here for a reason… the All Blacks is a different level and it's on to us to get around each other and best prepare for Test level.' Robertson, who will announce his team on Thursday, may start Beauden Barrett at No.10 ahead of Damian McKenzie, with Rieko Ioane a good chance to start on the left wing, with Billy Proctor at centre.
NZ Herald
a day ago
- NZ Herald
All Blacks coach Robertson to test new talent in French series
A few new faces were given a bit of game time here and there, but it never seemed there was a concerted or committed attempt to find a third halfback and third first five-eighths, develop the options in midfield or cast the net wider than just Wallace Sititi in the hope of landing a big catch at loose forward. And nowhere was that reticence to be a little bolder, or experimental even, more sharply realised than the final test of the year, when the selectors opted to throw the kitchen sink at an Italian team that really were nowhere near the calibre Robertson was trying to suggest they were. In a commercially driven world where the All Blacks rarely get served up a gimme, this was a missed opportunity on a similar scale to those publishers who said to JK Rowling that they didn't think kids would go for her world of wizards, Quidditch and magical boarding schools Robertson spent much of the week leading into that test talking about his desire to build the depth of his squad and yet instead of taking the chance to learn a bit more about the likes of Josh Lord, Peter Lakai, Stephen Perofeta and Ruben Love, it was all the same, highly familiar names asked to go round for one more time and play a fourth test in succession. Its clear now, that having had months to review the 2024 season and reconsider what he may have done differently, Robertson is of the view he needs to accelerate his 4-4-4 project – his plan to take four years, to win a fourth World Cup with four options in each position. Or at least he needs to better align his selections with the strategy, and that for all that he has said the appropriately respectful things about the underpowered French team that has turned up in New Zealand, he knows the weakness of the visitors has handed him a not to be missed opportunity to get a few answers to a few questions. Billy Proctor could get a call up for the opening test against France. Photo / Photosport If he wants depth, he has to give players a chance to play and Project 4-4-4 can't be abstract and theoretical. It has to be a practically managed concept where throughout this year, Robertson reads when to weight his selections more heavily towards the experienced core, and when to dabble in a bit of fact-finding and experimentation. The French, as something of an unknown quantity, are likely to provide three tests in which Robertson will feel he has a hitherto ungranted degree of latitude to mix-and-match: to sprinkle some new faces into the team each week without making change on a scale that could be considered dramatic and potentially dangerous to landing the victories. In the first stage of this mission to properly ignite Project 4-4-4, it would be no surprise to see Billy Proctor start at centre in Dunedin, with Rieko Ioane on the left wing to answer the question of whether the former can deliver the sort of calm and accurate distribution and the latter the power running and sharp finishing the All Blacks' attack needs. There may also be a desire to get Timoci Tavatavanawai into action this Saturday – possibly starting him on the right wing – but more likely off the bench where he can be injected into the midfield. He's got power and an extraordinary gift for stealing turnovers, but there will be some interest in using the July tests to determine whether he has the top end pace to be effective at this higher level. In the forwards, it is apparent Robertson has been keen on the Fabian Holland for some time and that the interest has only intensified since the big lock impressed as training cover late last year and then delivered an impressive Super Rugby campaign this year. Potentially Holland could start alongside captain Scott Barrett as Tupou Vai'i clocked up a lot of Super Rugby minutes and will have a big role to play throughout the season, but regardless of which way around they take the field, the man born in the Netherlands is most likely going to make his debut in Dunedin. Injury to Tamaiti Williams has presumably elevated the uncapped Ollie Norris to a bench spot, and in the back row, both Christian Leo-Willie and Du Plessis Kirifi look set to feature because Sititi has been forced to have surgery and Luke Jacobson has been ruled out. Possible All Blacks team 1. Ethan de Groot, 2. Codie Taylor, 3. Tyrel Lomax, 4. Scott Barrett, 5. Tupou Vai'i, 6. Samipeni Finau, 7. Kirifi Du Plessis, 8. Ardie Savea 9. Cameron Roigard; 10. Beauden Barrett, 11. Rieko Ioane, 12. Jordie Barrett, 13. Billy Proctor, 14. Sevu Reece, 15. Will Jordan. 16. Samisoni Taukei'aho, 17. Ollie Norris, 18. Fletcher Newell; 19. Fabian Holland, 20. Christian Leo-Willie, 21. Cortez Ratima, 22. Damian McKenzie, 23. Timoci Tavatavanawai. Gregor Paul is one of New Zealand's most respected rugby writers and columnists. He has won multiple awards for journalism and written several books about sport. For live commentary of this weekend's All Blacks v France test, go to GOLD SPORT or iHeartRadio.
