
Making Bad Nanny: how we uncovered the truth behind 'Carrie Jade'
Below, Bad Nanny director Alan Bradley introduces a wild true tale you really couldn't make up...
I first came across Samantha Cooke's story in a small article in the Irish Independent. The headline alone stopped me in my tracks - a woman accused of faking a terminal illness to defraud people. It felt too outrageous to be true. But the more I read, the more astonishing the story became. This wasn't a one-off con; it was a sprawling, years-long web of deception stretching across Ireland and the UK. The scale of it was staggering. It read like a thriller - except it was all real.
What struck me early on was how many people had been affected. Through some online digging, I found Lynn, one of Samantha's victims based in Dublin. She introduced me to an extraordinary group - a loose collective of Samantha's victims, many of them mothers, who had connected online and become a kind of informal investigation unit. Through WhatsApp chats and TikTok threads, they had spent years piecing together Samantha's movements, aliases, and scams. They had quietly become the keepers of the truth, determined to stop others from falling into the same trap.
Beyond the twists and turns of the story, what stayed with me most was what it revealed about us as a society.
Despite their efforts, they felt largely ignored and dismissed, by authorities, and by the media. I knew instantly this was a story that deserved more attention. Not because it was lurid, but because of what it revealed about the cracks in our systems, and the resilience of ordinary people who refused to be silenced.
At the time we began filming, Samantha had vanished. Given the coverage her story had already received, I assumed she had left Ireland. But then, in February 2024, we discovered she had in fact been living under a new identity as a nanny in Celbridge. With that came another wave of revelations, more victims, more lies, more lives upended. With every layer we uncovered, another seemed to emerge.
Structuring the documentary was one of the biggest creative challenges. Samantha operated under multiple aliases over a decade, spinning a different persona each time -a nanny/ au pair, a psychologist, a terminally ill author, a play therapist. Her backstories often contradicted one another and determining the actual truth required some real focus! We had to find a clear, coherent way through the chaos so that viewers could follow along. Central to this was giving the narrative back to those she deceived. I wanted them to tell the story in their own words, not just as victims, but as the people who ultimately exposed her.
Many contributors were understandably nervous. Some still feared Samantha, others were deeply affected by their experiences. Creating a space where they felt safe and supported to share their story was paramount. It was a long process, but one I felt was essential to doing justice to their voices.
As we were filming, RTÉ's The Real Carrie Jade podcast began releasing episodes weekly, sparking a new wave of public interest in the case. It was surreal to watch people react in real-time to a story we were still actively investigating. I'm hugely grateful to producers of the podcast Liam O'Brien and Ronan Kelly, who generously shared new tips and leads as they came in from listeners. In many ways, making the documentary evolved into a live investigation, one that kept unfolding until the very end.
But beyond the twists and turns of the story, what stayed with me most was what it revealed about us as a society. Samantha found her opportunities by targeting the gaps, families of children with additional needs struggling to access support, parents desperate for childcare, the disabled community. She presented herself as a psychologist, a role not protected by law in Ireland. In doing so, she exploited the very people already navigating the most difficult circumstances.
Ireland is, at its best, a place built on trust and community. But that very trust can leave us exposed when someone with bad intentions gains a foothold. Samantha's story is not just one of deceit, it's a lens on the vulnerabilities within our systems, and how easily someone can exploit them.
And yet, this project didn't leave me cynical. Far from it. The people affected by Samantha, those who appear in the series, are some of the most resilient, thoughtful, and generous individuals I've met. They didn't come forward out of revenge. They simply wanted others to be protected. As Lorraine says in Episode 2, "I still trust people. You'll only ever meet one Samantha Cookes."
Making this series reminded me that even in the face of deception, kindness and solidarity endure. And that sometimes, the most powerful stories aren't just about what happened, but about the people who refused to stay silent.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Irish Independent
a day ago
- Irish Independent
Gardaí launch probe into ‘mindless, racist violence' after alleged attack in Dublin
The incident took place in at Parkhill Lawns in the Kilnamanagh area of Tallaght at around 6pm on Saturday evening. Gardaí are appealing to people not post or reshare social media content including footage related to the incident. The assault on the Indian man by a group on Saturday has been condemned as 'mindless, racist violence'. The man is believed to have only entered the country a number of weeks ago. The man was taken to Tallaght University Hospital for treatment after the attack on Saturday evening. Fine Gael councillor, Baby Pereppadan for Tallaght South, met with the man on Monday and said he is in 'shock'. He told the Irish Independent: "He couldn't speak much because of the shock he was in, he only arrived in Ireland three weeks ago. He is not taking any visitors at the moment. "I am calling for more Garda presence in the area. Small incidents like these are happening frequently in Tallaght. "People need to understand that many Indian people moving to Ireland are here on work permits, to study and work in the healthcare sector or in IT and so on, providing critical skills.' Sinn Féin TD for Dublin South-West, Seán Crowe, has said that violent and racist attack on Parkhill Road in Tallaght on Saturday must be the last. 'The attack on Parkhill Road, Tallaght on Saturday was vile and utterly unacceptable on so many levels. 'Anyone who thinks this sort of mindless, racist violence makes their community safer is lying and fooling no one. Some residents are increasingly nervous to leave their homes due to this type of behaviour, regardless of whether they are new arrivals to our community or have lived here all their lives. 'I condemn this attack entirely and call on anyone with any information relating to this incident to reach out to the garda authorities. This is not the first such attack in our area, but it has to be the last,' he added. In a statement Gardaí said: "Gardaí in Tallaght were alerted to an incident at Parkhill Road, Tallaght, Dublin 24 on the evening of Saturday 19th July, 2025 at approximately 6pm. 'Gardaí attended the scene and a male, aged in his 40s was taken to Tallaght University Hospital with injuries.'


Irish Independent
2 days ago
- Irish Independent
Vicious assault on Indian man in Dublin condemned as ‘mindless, racist violence'
The man was taken to Tallaght University Hospital for treatment after the attack on Saturday evening and gardaí have commenced an investigation into the incident. Fine Gael councillor, Baby Pereppadan for Tallaght South, met with the man on Monday and said he is in 'shock'. He told the Irish Independent: "He couldn't speak much because of the shock he was in, he only arrived in Ireland three weeks ago. He is not taking any visitors at the moment. "I am calling for more Garda presence in the area. Small incidents like these are happening frequently in Tallaght. "People need to understand that many Indian people moving to Ireland are here on work permits, to study and work in the healthcare sector or in IT and so on, providing critical skills.' Sinn Féin TD for Dublin South-West, Seán Crowe, has said that violent and racist attack on Parkhill Road in Tallaght on Saturday must be the last. 'The attack on Parkhill Road, Tallaght on Saturday was vile and utterly unacceptable on so many levels. 'Anyone who thinks this sort of mindless, racist violence makes their community safer is lying and fooling no one. Some residents are increasingly nervous to leave their homes due to this type of behaviour, regardless of whether they are new arrivals to our community or have lived here all their lives. 'I condemn this attack entirely and call on anyone with any information relating to this incident to reach out to the garda authorities. This is not the first such attack in our area, but it has to be the last,' he added. In a statement Gardaí said: "Gardaí in Tallaght were alerted to an incident at Parkhill Road, Tallaght, Dublin 24 on the evening of Saturday 19th July, 2025 at approximately 6pm. 'Gardaí attended the scene and a male, aged in his 40s was taken to Tallaght University Hospital with injuries.'


Irish Daily Mirror
3 days ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Gardaí taking no further investigation into original Bishop Eamonn Casey file
Gardaí are taking no further action into the original investigation file on disgraced Bishop Eamonn Casey. The review was conducted by the Garda National Protective Services Bureau (GNPSB) at the request of Garda Commissioner Drew Harris. A garda spokesperson said: 'This review has been completed and no further investigative actions have been identified." The request came after an RTÉ documentary titled Bishop Casey's Buried Secrets examined the Catholic Church's handling of abuse allegations made against Casey. Multiple allegations of child sex abuse were made against the Bishop, including from his niece Patricia Donovan. She claimed that he first raped her at five years old and the abuse continued for years. Ms Donovan told the documentary: 'The horror of being raped by him when I was five, the violence. And it just carried on in that vein. He had no fear of being caught. 'He thought he could do what he liked, when he liked, how he liked… He was almost, like, incensed that I would dare fight against him, that I would dare try and hurt him, I would dare try and stop him… It didn't make any difference.' The former CEO of The National Board for Safeguarding Children in the Catholic Church in Ireland, Ian Elliott, described Bishop Casey as 'a sexual predator'. He told RTÉ: 'It should have been stopped… those that have been distressed and hurt should be helped and supported by the Church. That is a major priority.' Patricia Donovan (Image: RTÉ) Child sexual abuse allegations against Casey were reported to gardaí, but he was never charged. He vehemently denied all of these allegations when he was alive. The former Bishop of Galway died in 2017 and was buried in the crypt of Galway Cathedral. However, on Friday the diocese of Galway confirmed that his remains were removed and they are now with his family. In a statement, Galway Disocesan Office thanked everyone 'for their understanding of the situation, for their patience and for their respect as this process was undertaken and brought to a conclusion". It added: 'Significant consensus emerged around the unique role of a Cathedral as a place of unity rather than division, healing rather than hurt and peace rather than disquiet.' Casey resigned from his post as Bishop of Galway and Kilmacduagh in 1992 after it was revealed that he had an affair with American woman Annie Murphy, which resulted in the birth of their son. The Vatican later confirmed that he was formally removed from public ministry in 2007 following 'allegations', which included complaints of child sexual abuse. However, this wasn't made publicly aware when he was alive and was only revealed during RTÉ's documentary last year. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.