Why is there a public funds row over Alexander Dennis leaving Scotland
Scottish Enterprise, the agency managing government support, has stated that its most recent review found 'no risks had been identified that would preclude continued funding' to Alexander Dennis.
Who is Alexander Dennis and why does it matter to Scotland?
Alexander Dennis Limited (ADL) is a major bus and coach manufacturer headquartered with bases in Falkirk and Larbert. Formerly Scottish-owned, it was acquired by Canada's NFI Group in 2019.
ADL employs around 1,850 people in the UK, with a significant proportion based in Falkirk and Larbert.
The company is a leader in zero-emission bus technology - electric and hydrogen buses - and plays a key role in delivering Scotland's and the UK's green transport ambitions.
What are the current challenges facing Alexander Dennis?
ADL says it faces an 'uneven playing field' due to policies that favour foreign competitors, including Chinese electric bus manufacturers, whose market share recently rose from 10% to 35% in the UK market
ADL's leadership highlighted that government procurement and subsidy schemes tend to prioritise lowest cost rather than domestic manufacturing or local job creation
Additionally, UK policies under the Subsidy Control Act 2022 limit the ability to favour domestic suppliers in public funding, while Scottish rules require UK-based firms to meet Fair Work First standards, which it is claimed put ADL at a competitive disadvantage compared to international rivals who are not bound by these conditions.
READ MORE from Martin Williams:
Bus firm off to England in £90m Scots public funding row may get even more millions
Swinney got year-long warning England-bound bus firm was 'reconsidering' Scotland
FM in funding row as £90m public cash for Scots jobs given to firm going to England
Union says 1600 Scots jobs at risk if government doesn't act in 'national interest'
Scottish Zero Emission Bus Challenge Fund (ScotZEB) allocated £100m for green bus procurement. However, according to former SNP minister Michael Matheson with 523 vehicles ordered, only 162 - less than a third - were built by Scottish manufacturers like Alexander Dennis. It was estimated the rest went to overseas firms, including around half from China.
Why are jobs in Scotland at risk?
In September 2024, ADL launched a consultation on cutting 160 jobs at its Falkirk site due to funding imbalance and policy challenges
In June 2025, the company announced plans to end manufacturing altogether in Falkirk and Larbert, consolidating operations at its English site in Scarborough—putting up to 400 jobs at risk in Scotland.
(Image: Andrew Milligan/ PA) Unite and other unions warned that up to a multiplier of 1,600 jobs could be affected in the wider supply chain and support services if the closures proceed.
Why is this important to Scotland?
ADL is one of the largest manufacturing employers in central Scotland with many roles in engineering, apprenticeships, and high-skill technical jobs. The loss of production capacity would affect not only existing jobs but also local supply chains and community livelihoods
ADL positions Scotland at the forefront of zero-emission transport technology, aligning with national climate targets and global export opportunities.
It is argued that losing manufacturing in Larbert and Falkirk would diminish Scotland's ability to innovate and scale production in green mobility - a strategic disadvantage amid increasing global demand for clean public transport.
Why is the public funding of Alexander Dennis an issue?
ADL has received some £90m of taxpayer cash over the past ten years and tens of millions since a 2020 plan to axe a third of its Scottish workforce in advance of June's plan to exit to England. The firm had also admitted they had been 'forced' to offshore certain manufacturing functions to China.
The public funding is contentious because substantial taxpayer money - allocated to secure jobs and promote clean, local manufacturing in Scotland has coincided with offshore production, reduced domestic orders, and now a possible factory closure and mass redundancies. This raises questions over policy design, procurement strategy, and accountability for economic outcomes.
What does the Scottish Government say and how are they responding?
Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes described the situation as 'hugely worrying' and says the [[Scottish Government]] is actively exploring all options to preserve jobs and retain manufacturing capacity in Scotland.
The government is working with the UK Government, Transport Scotland, Scottish Enterprise, and trade unions to identify mitigation measures and potential support programs.
What solutions are being proposed?
Fairer procurement frameworks involving publicly funded support, including giving greater weight to local content and job creation.
There has been a call for the creation of a strategic industrial partnership involving government, trade unions, industry, and colleges to support retention, reskilling, and redeployment of skilled staff in transitioning industries.
Euan Stainbank MP and others have urged city-region mayors in England to place zero emission bus orders with ADL in Scotland.
Their letter proposes orders totaling 70 buses in 2025, and 320 buses in 2026, to maintain steady production and job continuity.
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer confirmed Labour support, stating they're working with mayors to secure future orders and uphold manufacturing in [[Falkirk]] and Larbert.
A joint UK-Scottish Government working group, alongside Scottish Enterprise and trade unions, is meeting weekly to explore viable ways to sustain local operations.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economist
8 minutes ago
- Economist
Cash-trapped (part 1): saving amid a property crisis
Open up the balance sheet of a typical Chinese household, and you will see plenty to worry about on both sides of the ledger. Household debt is higher than it was a decade ago, while savings are concentrated in bank deposits or bricks and mortar. This conservative approach to saving may have worked in the past—but now it's showing signs of strain amid a faltering property market, stagnant wages and growing debt distress. In a two-part series, we're asking Chinese families, young professionals and business owners about their money troubles. This week, Jiehao Chen, The Economist 's China researcher, and Simon Cox, our China economics editor, explore how the dream of security through home ownership became a nightmare.
Glasgow Times
27 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
Row breaks out over closing the exam results attainment gap
On exam results day in Scotland the Education Secretary was quizzed about a commitment to closing the gap. Jenny Gilruth was asked about an election promise to close the gap by next year. READ NEXT:Details and cost of Glasgow city councillors foreign trips revealed Gilruth mentioned making progress on literacy and numeracy in primary and secondary schools and progress on widening access to higher education. Speaking on BBC Radio, she said the Covid pandemic and the impact of austerity on poorer families have been a factor schoolshave had to deal with. Asked if the gap could be closed by next year, she said: 'I'm here today to talk to you about the exam results. ' I've spoken to some of the progress, and I'm absolutely committed to our continued work to close the attainment gap, but I am in no way shirking away from the challenge we've seen in terms of the Covid pandemic and austerity in our schools.' READ NEXT:Glasgow recovery charity performs hard hitting play about suicide and survival (Image: Andrew Milligan) Earlier, she said the poverty-related attainment gap has 'narrowed at National 5, Higher and Advanced Higher levels'. She added: 'While there is more to do, each success of every young person from the most disadvantaged areas creates a route out of poverty.' Opposition MSPs have criticised the Education Secretary and the SNP, following the remarks. Glasgow MSP, Pam Duncan-Glancy, Scottish Labour [[Education]] Spokesperson, said: 'It is damning that Jenny Gilruth cannot say whether the attainment gap will be closed by next year. 'This once again proves that any promises made by the SNP are simply not worth the paper they are written on. 'In 2015, Nicola Sturgeon said she wanted to be judged on closing the attainment gap, with the SNP promising to 'substantially eliminate' it within a decade. 'Almost a decade on and SNP ministers are refusing to own up to Scots that they have repeatedly made promises that they are unable to deliver upon." The Conservatives said the exam results for 2025 show the gap between the most and least deprived pupils obtaining A-C grades at National 5 was still 16.6%, with the gap at Higher 17.1% and Advanced Higher standing at 12.8%. Miles Briggs, education spokesperson, said: 'Nicola Sturgeon's promises in relation to the attainment gap lie in tatters. 'She wanted to eradicate it completely, yet still there is a huge gap in the results achieved by those from our most and least deprived communities. 'And John Swinney was education secretary when the [[SNP]] said it would be the defining mission of their government and promised to substantially eliminate it by 2026.'
South Wales Argus
37 minutes ago
- South Wales Argus
What happens if you die without laving a will, say experts
'Do I need a Will' searches in the UK have risen 37% in the last year, with 88K searches a month, according to Google Trends. While it's often a hard subject to broach, leaving a will, and making our wishes known for funeral plans and what we want after we die, id one of the kindest things we ca do for our loved ones. What happens if I don't have a will? If you die without a Will, the distribution of your estate (your personal possessions, money, and property) will be dealt with under the rules of intestacy (a set of legal rules that dictate who will benefit). Sally Cook at Weightmans says: 'Not many people want to contemplate writing a Will and the implications of what that means; however, it is important to protect your family and assets by doing so. "Getting your affairs in order will provide peace of mind that your wishes will be carried out, your loved ones will be appropriately provided for, and any potential family disputes are mitigated. Inheritance tax can also be planned for in advance, allowing you to pass on more to your loved ones." Martin's talking about the importance of having a will to protect your wishes, follow this link for cheap and free wills info… #MartinLewis — Martin Lewis (@MartinSLewis) February 13, 2025 The intestacy rules are rigid and may not reflect your wishes; for example, they make no provision for unmarried partners. The intestacy rules also govern who is entitled to deal with the administration of your estate. In Scotland, unmarried partners can make a claim for a share of the estate, but this is subject to the court's discretion and there are strict timescales for applying. Where there is no Will, the cost of administering the estate may be significantly higher. In Scotland, it also becomes necessary in most cases to obtain a form of insurance bond, which adds extra expense and time to the process. Donna Brennan, a specialist in Scottish succession law at Weightmans adds: 'It is also important to ensure that you take advice in the correct jurisdiction, succession laws in Scotland and the rest of the UK are quite different, so if you are domiciled in Scotland or have assets there, appropriate advice should be taken. At Weightmans, we have experts in both jurisdictions.' Will my estate automatically pass to my spouse or partner? It is not automatic that a spouse will inherit the whole of the estate under the intestacy rules. The intestacy rules are constantly subject to change, and the outcomes of dying without a Will can be surprising and often unjust. Making a Will is the only way to ensure your loved ones are provided for in accordance with your wishes as far as possible. In Scotland, a spouse/civil partner has certain prior rights on intestacy which can exhaust the estate, but only up to a certain level, which is subject to change. The intestacy rules do not make any provision for unmarried partners. The best way to ensure a cohabiting partner is provided for is to make a Will. As mentioned above, in Scotland, cohabitees can make a claim subject to strict timeframes, but the outcome is by no means guaranteed. You should review your Will regularly to ensure it continues to reflect your wishes and circumstances As your personal and/or financial circumstances change, you should consider updating your Will. Examples include: Marriage. In England, Marriage will automatically revoke any Will you had in place previously (although this is currently being reviewed by the Law Commission). That is not the case in Scotland, and even more reason why a previous Will should be updated to ensure it benefits the intended parties. A change in family circumstances, for example, having children or grandchildren. Divorce Significant changes in your financial situation It's recommended that you look over your Will every three years to assess whether there have been any changes to the law or tax allowances which could affect your Will and wider estate planning. Recommended reading: Can I include my cryptoassets in my Will? Cryptoassets will automatically form part of your estate on death if they are held in your individual name. It is not always necessary for you to specifically include a reference to your crypto assets in your Will, but care should be taken to ensure that there are sufficient powers in your Will to allow your executors to deal with these assets after your death. It is also important that you make your professional advisor aware of any cryptoassets you may own so that they can discuss with you what provision you have made for these to be accessed after you die. Ultimately, a Will ensures that your family members receive what you intend them to when you are no longer here. Seeking robust and specialist legal advice to help you write a Will is a crucial part of that process.
