logo
Let kids be kids or should teens be heard? Our writers divided on voting age debate as electoral overhaul splits opinion

Let kids be kids or should teens be heard? Our writers divided on voting age debate as electoral overhaul splits opinion

The Irish Sun2 days ago
LAST week Britain moved to lower the voting age to 16 in all UK elections.
It was a major overhaul of the country's democratic system that immediately split opinion over whether they should or would cast ballots.
5
Globally, most countries have a voting age of 18
Credit: Getty Images - Getty
5
Changes have been proposed to boost participation and trust in the electoral system
Credit: Getty Images - Getty
The proposed changes were designed to boost participation and trust in the electoral system, which suffered its lowest turnout at the
But in last year's European Parliament elections,
So should
In The Irish Sun today, reporter JODIE McCORMACK and Political Correspondent ADAM HIGGINS argue both sides.
FOR - JODIE MCCORMACK
5
Jodie McCormack says being young 'does not equate to being uninterested in politics'
Credit: Collect
IN 2016 Ireland held a General Election and in 2018 the Referendum on the regulation of termination of pregnancy took place.
I voted in neither, despite the direct impacts both would have on my future as a young woman in Ireland.
Had the voting age been lowered to 16 at the time, I would have been first in line at the polls.
With the
While cynics may argue 16 and 17-year-olds are too young to form a valid political opinion, we already trust them to pay tax through part-time
Simon Harris 'does not expect' poll on Irish unity in this decade
Many will move away from home to start college, work or apprenticeships and rent their first property having never voted in this country.
Politics and society was introduced as a Leaving Cert subject in 2016, with the first exam sat in 2018. In 2022 Norma Foley, then Minister for Education confirmed 2,261 pupils sat the subject in 2019, 3,476 in 2020 and 4,084 in 2021.
Steadily increasing numbers which could be further increased if all senior cycle students had the opportunity to vote, not just the handful of 18-year-olds in 6th year.
The interest is there from Ireland's young people and now is the time for that interest to be heard.
Jodie McCormack
This also gives
Being young does not equate to being uninterested in politics.
The Central Statistics Office report a voter turnout of 50 per cent in the 2022 General Election in the 18-25 age category.
In 2024,
Both didn't have a vote just a handful of years before that.
The evidence is clear, the interest is there from Ireland's young people and now is the time for that interest to be heard.
AGAINST - ADAM HIGGINS
5
Adam Higgins says he 'can't imagine many 16-year-olds are even interested in voting'
Credit: Crispin Rodwell - The Sun Dublin
CAN we not let kids be kids anymore?
Why are we rushing to ask teenagers to start making important decisions about who should run the country when they barely know who they are as a person yet?
At 16, kids should mainly be worried about their
I don't think it is fair to put it on 16-year-olds to help decide what direction the country should go in.
GROUPS TARGETED
In the run up to elections, politicians and their PR machines specifically target different groups in a bid to win votes.
In the past it was solely through clever slogans, policy proposals and quotes in media interviews and at press events.
However, increasingly politicians are using
Do we really want our teenagers' social media pages bombarded with messages from political parties of all hues warning them about all the things that are wrong in the country and how they are the only ones that can fix it?
Surely there's an easier way to increase voter turnout than lowering the voting age?
Adam Higgins
This is a time when we are constantly reading about rising levels of anxiety and mental health issues in our young people.
Social media is often blamed as one of the main reasons for this – do we really want to throw politics into that mix?
I think it is important to get more people into politics and try increase engagement with the system.
But surely there's an easier way to increase voter turnout than lowering the voting age?
WHO BENEFITS?
What about automatic voter registration for every citizen over the age of 18?
I think we also have to consider who would benefit from this change.
I can't imagine many 16-year-olds are even interested in voting.
How many of you reading this now were engaged in politics when you were 16?
Some teens are really passionate about it already and they would probably make great TDs, let alone voters.
But for the majority of teens, they will probably just listen to their parents and vote for whomever they vote for.
Let's leave our teenagers with two more years of life experience before we ask them to form an opinion about the future of the country.
5
Should Ireland allow people to vote from the age of 16?
Credit: Getty Images - Getty
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Michael O'Leary criticised for 'drive-by commentary' on Dublin metro
Michael O'Leary criticised for 'drive-by commentary' on Dublin metro

Irish Daily Mirror

time28 minutes ago

  • Irish Daily Mirror

Michael O'Leary criticised for 'drive-by commentary' on Dublin metro

Ryanair chief executive Michael O'Leary has been criticised for his "insulting" comments on a metro for Dublin, which he called a "waste" of taxpayer money. The 18.8km rail line, most of which will be underground, is to run from north of Swords to Charlemont in the south of Dublin city centre. Various metro projects for the capital have been proposed in recent decades but none have proceeded to build stage. On Tuesday, the Government announced that the MetroLink project would get a €2 billion boost in funding as part of the national development plan, in what Taoiseach Micheal Martin said was "a very definitive commitment to the metro". While Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe indicated the latest estimated cost for the MetroLink was €11 billion, Mr O'Leary claimed it would cost €20 billion, "so about a billion a kilometre". Micheal Martin and Paschal Donohoe (Image: PA Archive/PA Images) "Dublin Airport doesn't need it, Dublin Airport passengers won't use it – they're already well-served by buses," he told RTE Radio on Wednesday, while claiming that less than a third of the airport's passengers use buses. He said that while the tube in London runs from Heathrow and through "all of London", the Metro will only serve a section of Dublin city's residents – around 100,000 people, he claimed. "Here's the madness of this. This thing is going to start at Stephen's Green in the morning. If you want to get to our first wave of departures, which leave at about 6.30 in the morning, you need to be at the airport at 5.30am. "Are you seriously going to drive into the centre of Stephen's Green, where there's no car parking, to get this metro to get to Dublin Airport for 5.30 in the morning? No, you're not. "Let me give you the alternative scenario: for €100 million, this year we could buy 400 buses, and 400 buses would provide exactly the same capacity as this metro from Dublin Airport, in through Ballymun, in through Drumcondra, on bus lanes that already exist." He claimed the plan had not been properly costed and hit out at the Government's handling of public finances. "This Government wasted €330,000 on a bike shed, imagine what they do with an 18-kilometre underground train from an airport?" He also criticised comments by Mr Martin, who said the Irish capital will not be sustainable without a metro. "Does he not understand that the buses actually will all be electrified by the end of this decade, which will actually be greener than light rail?" Labour TD Duncan Smith said Mr O'Leary's criticisms of public infrastructure were as sure "as night follows day". A Ryanair plane comes in to land at Dublin Airport during Storm Isha (Image: Collins Photos) "Dubliners are stuck in daily gridlock. MetroLink is their best chance at affordable, reliable transport that serves communities, not corporate profits. "As a consistent advocate for MetroLink in Swords, I find it insulting to hear this kind of drive-by commentary from someone who clearly doesn't rely on public transport to get to work. "Dublin deserves better than a transport plan from a billionaire whose only experience with buses is when he is pretending to be one." When asked about his endorsement of Enterprise Minister Peter Burke and junior minister Robert Troy during the general election campaign, Mr O'Leary claimed "they're not in government" and criticised Mr Martin again. "I endorsed Peter Burke, who actually topped the poll despite the criticism. I also endorsed Robert Troy – and they're not the government." Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.

Michael O'Leary criticised for ‘insulting' comments on Dublin metro
Michael O'Leary criticised for ‘insulting' comments on Dublin metro

Sunday World

time33 minutes ago

  • Sunday World

Michael O'Leary criticised for ‘insulting' comments on Dublin metro

Various metro projects for the capital have been proposed in recent decades but none have proceeded to build stage Michael O'Leary said the plan had not been properly costed (Brian Lawless/PA) Ryanair chief executive Michael O'Leary has been criticised for his "insulting" comments on a metro for Dublin, which he called a "waste" of taxpayer money. The 18.8km rail line, most of which will be underground, is to run from north of Swords to Charlemont in the south of Dublin city centre. Various metro projects for the capital have been proposed in recent decades but none have proceeded to build stage. On Tuesday, the Government announced that the MetroLink project would get a €2bn boost in funding as part of the national development plan, in what Taoiseach Micheal Martin said was "a very definitive commitment to the metro". While Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe indicated the latest estimated cost for the MetroLink was 11 billion euro, Mr O'Leary claimed it would cost 20 billion euro, "so about a billion a kilometre". "Dublin Airport doesn't need it, Dublin Airport passengers won't use it - they're already well-served by buses," he told RTÉ Radio on Wednesday, while claiming that less than a third of the airport's passengers use buses. He said that while the tube in London runs from Heathrow and through "all of London", the Metro will only serve a section of Dublin city's residents - around 100,000 people, he claimed. "Here's the madness of this. This thing is going to start at Stephen's Green in the morning. If you want to get to our first wave of departures, which leave at about 6.30 in the morning, you need to be at the airport at 5.30am. "Are you seriously going to drive into the centre of Stephen's Green, where there's no car parking, to get this metro to get to Dublin Airport for 5.30 in the morning? No, you're not. "Let me give you the alternative scenario: for €100m, this year we could buy 400 buses, and 400 buses would provide exactly the same capacity as this metro from Dublin Airport, in through Ballymun, in through Drumcondra, on bus lanes that already exist." He claimed the plan had not been properly costed and hit out at the Government's handling of public finances. "This Government wasted €330,000 on a bike shed, imagine what they do with an 18-kilometre underground train from an airport?" He also criticised comments by Mr Martin, who said the Irish capital will not be sustainable without a metro. "Does he not understand that the buses actually will all be electrified by the end of this decade, which will actually be greener than light rail?" Labour TD Duncan Smith said Mr O'Leary's criticisms of public infrastructure were as sure "as night follows day". "Dubliners are stuck in daily gridlock. MetroLink is their best chance at affordable, reliable transport that serves communities, not corporate profits. "As a consistent advocate for MetroLink in Swords, I find it insulting to hear this kind of drive-by commentary from someone who clearly doesn't rely on public transport to get to work. "Dublin deserves better than a transport plan from a billionaire whose only experience with buses is when he is pretending to be one." When asked about his endorsement of Enterprise Minister Peter Burke and junior minister Robert Troy during the general election campaign, Mr O'Leary claimed "they're not in government" and criticised Mr Martin again. "I endorsed Peter Burke, who actually topped the poll despite the criticism. I also endorsed Robert Troy - and they're not the government." Michael O'Leary said the plan had not been properly costed (Brian Lawless/PA) News in 90 Seconds - July 23rd

Michael O'Leary criticised for ‘insulting' comments on Dublin metro
Michael O'Leary criticised for ‘insulting' comments on Dublin metro

Irish Independent

timean hour ago

  • Irish Independent

Michael O'Leary criticised for ‘insulting' comments on Dublin metro

The 18.8km rail line, most of which will be underground, is to run from north of Swords to Charlemont in the south of Dublin city centre. Various metro projects for the capital have been proposed in recent decades but none have proceeded to build stage. On Tuesday, the Government announced that the MetroLink project would get a €2bn boost in funding as part of the national development plan, in what Taoiseach Micheal Martin said was "a very definitive commitment to the metro". While Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe indicated the latest estimated cost for the MetroLink was 11 billion euro, Mr O'Leary claimed it would cost 20 billion euro, "so about a billion a kilometre". "Dublin Airport doesn't need it, Dublin Airport passengers won't use it - they're already well-served by buses," he told RTÉ Radio on Wednesday, while claiming that less than a third of the airport's passengers use buses. He said that while the tube in London runs from Heathrow and through "all of London", the Metro will only serve a section of Dublin city's residents - around 100,000 people, he claimed. "Here's the madness of this. This thing is going to start at Stephen's Green in the morning. If you want to get to our first wave of departures, which leave at about 6.30 in the morning, you need to be at the airport at 5.30am. "Are you seriously going to drive into the centre of Stephen's Green, where there's no car parking, to get this metro to get to Dublin Airport for 5.30 in the morning? No, you're not. "Let me give you the alternative scenario: for €100m, this year we could buy 400 buses, and 400 buses would provide exactly the same capacity as this metro from Dublin Airport, in through Ballymun, in through Drumcondra, on bus lanes that already exist." He claimed the plan had not been properly costed and hit out at the Government's handling of public finances. "This Government wasted €330,000 on a bike shed, imagine what they do with an 18-kilometre underground train from an airport?" He also criticised comments by Mr Martin, who said the Irish capital will not be sustainable without a metro. "Does he not understand that the buses actually will all be electrified by the end of this decade, which will actually be greener than light rail?" Labour TD Duncan Smith said Mr O'Leary's criticisms of public infrastructure were as sure "as night follows day". "Dubliners are stuck in daily gridlock. MetroLink is their best chance at affordable, reliable transport that serves communities, not corporate profits. "As a consistent advocate for MetroLink in Swords, I find it insulting to hear this kind of drive-by commentary from someone who clearly doesn't rely on public transport to get to work. "Dublin deserves better than a transport plan from a billionaire whose only experience with buses is when he is pretending to be one." When asked about his endorsement of Enterprise Minister Peter Burke and junior minister Robert Troy during the general election campaign, Mr O'Leary claimed "they're not in government" and criticised Mr Martin again. "I endorsed Peter Burke, who actually topped the poll despite the criticism. I also endorsed Robert Troy - and they're not the government."

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store