Scots trial fears over filming of court cases for true-crime documentaries
Real-life- crime documentaries which allow cameras into Scots courts have been among BBC Scotland's biggest hits despite fears they could disrupt criminal trials.
The Murder Trial and Murder Case series feature in the Top 10 most requested titles of 2025 on the broadcaster's iPlayer with over three million views.
The latest viewing figures come after the broadcaster last week announced Murder Case is set to return later this year with a new three-part series focussing on two cases.
Two 60-minute episodes will concentrate on the murder of Tony Parsons – The Vanishing Cyclist – who was killed by a drunk driver on the A82 near Bridge of Orchy and secretly buried in a shallow grave.
Sandy McKellar and twin Robert hid Tony's body on a remote estate in the Highlands where it remained undiscovered for three years until Sandy confided in his new girlfriend Caroline Muirhead about the killing and took her to the burial site.
She was able to pinpoint the remote location to the police by dropping a soft drink can on the ground.
However, two years ago we revealed Muirhead fled court over the pressure of appearing in the documentary.
She was arrested after failing to turn up to court for the twins' trial.
At the time, she said the demands to take part in the BBC-commissioned programme on the case led her to have a mental breakdown.
Scottish Tory leader Russell Findlay wrote to the BBC to raise concerns with its production company Firecrest Films.
He said: 'Ms Muirhead has said she was subjected to inappropriate pressure to nagree for her testimony to be broadcast.
'She further claims that she felt unable to testify due to this pressure and that this, in turn, may have caused the Crown Office to strike a plea deal with the two men accused of murder, instead of putting them on trial, resulting in a downgrading of the charges, which they admitted to.'
The real-life crime format has attracted huge audiences.
A spokeswoman said: ' Crime documentaries continue to be really popular with audiences in Scotland and across the UK, consistently performing well on BBC iPlayer.
'The Murder Trial and Murder Case series feature in the Top 10 'most requested' titles of 2025 on BBC iPlayer with a combined audience of nearly three million streaming requests.
'This year, the top three 'most viewed' BBC crime documentaries have been Murder Trial: Girl in the River, Murder Trial: Body in the Warehouse and Murder Case: The Hunt for Mary McLaughlin's Killer.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
15 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Tributes pour in for Scots mum who died after being found seriously injured as man arrested
Police have arrested a 20-year-old man in connection with the alleged incident. Tragic Tributes pour in for Scots mum who died after being found seriously injured as man arrested Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) TRIBUTES have been paid to mum and PhD graduate who died in an alleged attack in Dundee. Dr Fortune Gomo, 39, was found seriously injured on Saturday afternoon and was treated at the scene but later died. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 The mum, 39, worked for Scottish Water, after graduating with a PhD in Geography and Environmental Science from Dundee University. Credit: Facebook 2 Fortune Gomo died following an alleged attack in Dundee on Saturday Credit: Facebook Police have arrested a 20-year-old man in connection with the alleged incident. Fortune worked for Scottish Water, after graduating with a PhD in Geography and Environmental Science from Dundee University. A spokesman said: 'This has been a truly shocking event in our city and for our university community. 'It will be particularly distressing for those who knew and worked with Fortune throughout her time as a PhD student and postdoctoral research assistant in Geography, and for all of those in our close-knit community of African colleagues and students. 'Our thoughts are with her family and friends at this tragic time.' A large crowd gathered on South Road on Saturday night and a protest was held in the city centre on Sunday. Police attended and said the march went ahead 'without incident'. A 61-year-old woman, who has lived in the area for more than 50 years, said she was 'devastated' to hear about the woman's passing. She said: 'The first we really knew about it was the police taping the street off - I thought someone had been hit by a car. 'I came home around 11pm and could see there was still an extensive police presence. It was upsetting to see what was going. Inside Israel's frontline rescue crew… from pulling families out of rubble to dodging Iranian missiles 'I woke up around 2am and looked out and saw things being placed into evidence bags. 'It's devastating to hear the woman died.' A Police Scotland spokesman said: 'A 20-year-old man has been arrested after officers were called to the report that a woman in her 30s had been seriously injured in South Road around 4.25pm. 'She was treated by paramedics, however she was pronounced dead at the scene. 'Her family is aware and is being supported by specialist officers.' Detective Superintendent Peter Sharp - who is leading the inquiry - said: 'My thoughts are with the woman's family at this time and there is no doubt this was a distressing incident for those who witnessed and attended the incident. 'Extensive enquiries are ongoing and I am satisfied that the incident has been contained and there is no wider risk to the public.'
Scottish Sun
15 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
BBC legend Sue Barker broke golden rule at Wimbledon and was caught out by music icon
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) SUE BARKER broke a golden rule at Wimbledon. And she was caught out by a music icon. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 5 Sue Barker was called out by singer Katherine Jenkins for wearing heels on Centre Court Credit: AFP 5 The Centre Court roof was unveiled in 2009 Credit: AFP Barker, 69, is a legend at the All England Club, competing in 12 Wimbledon Championships as a player. The former French Open winner then spent three decades hosting the BBC's broadcast coverage of the iconic tournament. But there was one incident that saw her breach the strict All England Club protocol. Barker revealed in her book Wimbledon, A Personal History that she made the blunder during the opening ceremony of the Centre Court retractable roof in 2009. READ MORE ON WIMBLEDON NOT 'DON RIGHT Huge Wimbledon controversy as new technology FAILS and Kartal rival fumes The former BBC anchor conducted proceedings - with some of tennis' greats in attendance. But she was called out by Katherine Jenkins for her faux pas. Welsh singer Jenkins stunned the crowd with an emotional rendition of Amazing Grace as the roof moved across and then followed it up by singing Bryan Adams' (Everything I Do) I Do It for You. Then she called Barker out for her mistake - after spotting the former British No1 wearing heels on Wimbledon's hallowed Centre Court turf. CASINO SPECIAL - BEST CASINO BONUSES FROM £10 DEPOSITS Jenkins approached Barker and said: "But I was told I couldn't wear heels." Barker wrote in her memoir: "She was wearing a pink lace strapless dress and lovely sparkly little flip-flops. 'You took the game away from me' - Major Wimbledon controversy as new technology FAILS and Kartal rival fumes at umpire "So the first part of our interview was me trying to pretend that I wasn't really in heels. "You know, because obviously the rules are that you're not allowed to wear heels on the Centre Court grass. It was hugely embarrassing." Incredibly, a decade-and-a-half later, Jenkins reminded Barker of her blunder - in front of tennis great Billie Jean King. Barker added: "Without so much as a hello, Katherine pointed me out to her husband like she was identifying a criminal in a police line-up. "She blurted out, 'SHE broke the rules on Centre Court.' "That was 2009 – nearly 15 years ago – and her first association on seeing me again was to recall my illegal high heels. 5 Wimbledon 2025 LIVE - follow all the latest scores and updates from a thrilling fortnight at SW19 "But we had a lovely chat, another really special time just relaxing with someone rather than the fleeting catch-ups I had when I was relentlessly working." Barker hung up her microphone and retired from the BBC hosting gig in emotional scenes in 2022. She returned in 2024 for Andy Murray's farewell ceremony. And then for this year's Championships, Barker fronted an advert for Emirates as she checked the height of the nets, the length of the grass, the colour of the flowers, the cleanliness of the staircase and the bounce of the balls on the courts - before finishing off the clip with a spot of afternoon tea at the All England Club. The former Question of Sport host has largely remained out of the public eye since her BBC departure. And that meant she turned down the chance to front Sky Sports' tennis coverage of the ATP and WTA Tours. 5 Barker returned to Wimbledon last year for Andy Murray's farewell send-off Credit: Getty
The Sun
30 minutes ago
- The Sun
BBC legend Sue Barker broke golden rule at Wimbledon and was caught out by music icon
SUE BARKER broke a golden rule at Wimbledon. And she was caught out by a music icon. 5 Barker, 69, is a legend at the All England Club, competing in 12 Wimbledon Championships as a player. The former French Open winner then spent three decades hosting the BBC's broadcast coverage of the iconic tournament. But there was one incident that saw her breach the strict All England Club protocol. Barker revealed in her book Wimbledon, A Personal History that she made the blunder during the opening ceremony of the Centre Court retractable roof in 2009. The former BBC anchor conducted proceedings - with some of tennis' greats in attendance. But she was called out by Katherine Jenkins for her faux pas. Welsh singer Jenkins stunned the crowd with an emotional rendition of Amazing Grace as the roof moved across and then followed it up by singing Bryan Adams' (Everything I Do) I Do It for You. Then she called Barker out for her mistake - after spotting the former British No1 wearing heels on Wimbledon's hallowed Centre Court turf. Jenkins approached Barker and said: "But I was told I couldn't wear heels." Barker wrote in her memoir: "She was wearing a pink lace strapless dress and lovely sparkly little flip-flops. 'You took the game away from me' - Major Wimbledon controversy as new technology FAILS and Kartal rival fumes at umpire "So the first part of our interview was me trying to pretend that I wasn't really in heels. "You know, because obviously the rules are that you're not allowed to wear heels on the Centre Court grass. It was hugely embarrassing." Incredibly, a decade-and-a-half later, Jenkins reminded Barker of her blunder - in front of tennis great Billie Jean King. Barker added: "Without so much as a hello, Katherine pointed me out to her husband like she was identifying a criminal in a police line-up. "She blurted out, 'SHE broke the rules on Centre Court.' "That was 2009 – nearly 15 years ago – and her first association on seeing me again was to recall my illegal high heels. 5 Wimbledon 2025 LIVE - follow all the latest scores and updates from a thrilling fortnight at SW19 "But we had a lovely chat, another really special time just relaxing with someone rather than the fleeting catch-ups I had when I was relentlessly working." Barker hung up her microphone and retired from the BBC hosting gig in emotional scenes in 2022. She returned in 2024 for Andy Murray's farewell ceremony. And then for this year's Championships, Barker fronted an advert for Emirates as she checked the height of the nets, the length of the grass, the colour of the flowers, the cleanliness of the staircase and the bounce of the balls on the courts - before finishing off the clip with a spot of afternoon tea at the All England Club. The former Question of Sport host has largely remained out of the public eye since her BBC departure. And that meant she turned down the chance to front Sky Sports' tennis coverage of the ATP and WTA Tours. 5
