Dáil told government has ‘betrayed' students amid calls for clarification on college fees
The student contribution fee has been temporarily reduced for the past three years as part of cost-of-living packages accompanying the budget.
The fees had been €3,000 before being temporarily reduced to €2,000 euros.
But last week, Higher Education Minister James Lawless said that a
cost-of-living package will not form part of Budget 2026, meaning the temporary drop in the student contribution fee would 'reset' and revert back to €3,000 per academic year.
'All of us in any walk of life have to play the hands we're dealt,' Lawless told RTÉ on Sunday.
Higher Education Minister James Lawless
Alamy Stock Photo
Alamy Stock Photo
He added: 'If I don't have a cost-of-living package. I can't do those kind of measures that were done last year.'
Opposition politicians have been criticising the mooted increase and have repeatedly asked the Government to give clarity to parents ahead of the upcoming academic year.
'Bombshell'
Speaking in the Dáil today during Leaders' Questions, Social Democrats TD Jennifer Whitmore said Lawless had 'dropped a bombshell' and called on the government to 'level with parents and students'.
She added that Lawless's comments on 'playing the hands we're dealt' were 'utterly galling' and 'incredibly tone-deaf'.
Whitmore also said that Lawless had 'actively stacked the deck' against students and families and 'essentially told them to suck it up'.
She added that people 'believed promises in the Programme for Government to reduce student fees' and they have been 'betrayed'.
'They don't have this money down the back of a sofa. They'll have to scrimp and save and sacrifice to cover this increase, do you not understand that Minister?' Whitmore asked Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe, who was taking Leaders' Questions.
File image of Jennifer Whitmore
Alamy Stock Photo
Alamy Stock Photo
Donohoe however hit out at Whitmore for saying the government had 'stacked the deck' against students.
He added that supports are available and that over 140,000 students benefit from Free-Fees and that 60,000 students benefit from lower forms of student contribution fees.
'All of that is in place because of our desire to ensure supports are in place to help,' said Donohoe.
He added that as the government works to move towards a 'normal budget', the government will also look at how progress can be made on the affordability and access to higher and further education.
Donohoe also remarked that the student contribution fee would be 'outlined' in October's budget.
Advertisement
However, Whitmore said Donohoe was 'clearly not listening to what parents and students are saying'.
'They believed you when you said your government would continue to reduce student fees, it really couldn't be any simpler,' said Whitmore.
'Will parents be paying €2,000 in September, or €3,000?'
Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe
Alamy Stock Photo
Alamy Stock Photo
Donohoe said he was providing a 'clear and honest answer' and that the government 'has to make decisions as part of our budget process so we can ensure that the changes that we make are affordable, sustainable, and can be built upon in the years ahead'.
He added: 'We'll be in a position to give a clear answer to that when our budgetary work is done.'
Government 'all over the place'
Earlier, Donohoe had been pressed on the issue by Sinn Féin's Matt Carthy, who said the government was 'all over the place'.
Carthy said he had 'one simple question, when students get their bill in September will they be paying €2,000 or €3,000?'
However, Donohoe began by remarking that the question provided an opportunity to 'outline what the government is already doing'.
He said half of students are supported through the SUSI grant (Student Universal Support Ireland) and that the threshold has been increased by 15% to ensure more students can avail of it.
He added that the grant is now also available to students in part-time or hybrid education.
Donohoe said the budgets put in place measures for students that 'we know is affordable and that we can build upon in the years ahead'.
He added that there is a need to 'look at other measures' following the temporary reduction in student contribution fees.
'Your question may have been brief but the answer to it is longer, outlining the supports and the difference that we already make and we want to build upon,' said Donohoe.
Sinn Féin's Matt Carthy
Alamy Stock Photo
Alamy Stock Photo
However, Carthy said a line of minister have been 'unable to answer a simple question'.
'They don't want to hear what politicians are planning to do in the future, I'll ask you one more time, are fees going to be €2,000 or will they be higher?
'Come down from your ivory tower and answer that question.'
Donohoe replied that 'it is exactly because this issue of life-defining for so any that the government already has supports in place that you will never acknowledge'.
He added that the government is 'interested in solutions rather than soundbites' and that the answer is 'the same as the answer that has been given at any other points in recent years'.
'It's an issue that has to be decided budget-by-budget and this government wants to help in a permanent way and we will outline our answer to that serious question, as we will with many others, when the budget is complete.'
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
9 hours ago
- The Journal
Taoiseach hints childcare focus in Budget will be on increasing places rather than cutting costs
TAOISEACH MICHEÁL MARTIN has stressed the need to create more childcare places across the country quickly. Asked by reporters in Japan, where the Taoiseach is this week for a trade mission, if there will be reductions to the cost of childcare in this year's Budget, the Taoiseach was coy in his response. Cutting the cost of childcare to €200 per month per child was a core election promise by both Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael. It is now a pledge in the Programme for Government to deliver the reduction over the lifetime of this government. 'I think we want to continue to make progress on childcare, but we have a whole range of issues now that we have to make progress on,' the Taoiseach said, adding that there will be negotiations leading into this year's Budget in October. 'We can't do everything at once, so we will endeavor to prioritise and continue the progress we've made in recent years. We've made very good progress in childcare, but we need more places, so the access issue and the number of places is also important, as well as affordability.' Advertisement Martin made the point that recent research has pointed to the need to improve the number of available childcare places. 'That speaks to the growth of population and the pressures on childcare and health services, and education,' he said. He added that the government will be prioritising the transformation of Ireland's infrastructure in the Budget. Asked if the government will be prioritising increasing childcare places over reducing costs this year, the Taoiseach said this will be a decision for Minister for Children Norma Foley, who will approach government with her priorities ahead of October's Budget. 'All Programme for Government commitments will be followed through. So that's the basic point,' he said. With reporting from Christina Finn in Japan Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
The Journal
10 hours ago
- The Journal
Taoiseach lays wreath at Hiroshima memorial, says the world is more dangerous now than in 1945
TAOISEACH MICHEÁL MARTIN laid a wreath at the Memorial Cenotaph for the Atomic Bomb Victims in Hiroshima today. This year marks the 80th anniversary of the atomic bombings at the end of World War II. On the morning of 6 August 1945, most of Hiroshima was destroyed when the US dropped its first atomic bomb directly over the city. Around 70,000 people died instantly and by the year's end a total of 140,000 people had died due to radiation poisoning and other after effects of the bomb. Around 5,000 people per year get added to that list having passed away generally due to radiation related cancers. World War Two destruction after the atomic bomb was dropped on Hiroshima 1945 Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo Speaking with reporters after his meeting with Mayor of Hiroshima Kazumi Matsui, the Taoiseach expressed Ireland's strong and long-standing commitment to disarmament and denuclearisation. World is in a 'dangerous place' When asked if he thinks the world is a more dangerous place now that it was in 1945, the Taoiseach replied: 'I think it is. It is in a very dangerous place. I think it speaks to at one level, the incredible engineering ingenuity of humankind, and at another level, the stupidity of humankind, on a very basic level that the world is advancing at an extraordinary rate. 'We are on the cusp of the AI revolution, which would be as profound as the industrial revolution, if not more. This is what people say. And yet mankind keeps on developing the means to destroy itself,' he said. The Taoiseach spoke about being at a recent AI summit in Paris whereby one of the presentations was about the application of AI to warfare, which he said 'would really be on a different level altogether in terms of destruction that could be wreaked on humankind'. 'So it is very problematic and I think very worrying, in terms of where we are today,' he added. Advertisement Hiroshima victims Visiting the Hiroshima Peace Memorial Park, which is located at the centre of Hiroshima, the mayor told the Taoiseach about the thousands of names that are recorded at the memorial. The Journal / YouTube He said survivors do not want the 'cycle of hatred' against those that perpetrated the attack on the people of Japan to continue. He said the message from Hiroshima is that 'we should not repeat the evil'. 'We must break the cycle,' the Taoiseach agreed. While visiting today the Taoiseach also rang the Peace Bell and visited the the Hiroshima Peace Memorial, commonly called the A-Bomb Dome, which stands just 160 metres from the hypocentre of the explosion. Aimée-Linh McCartney Aimée-Linh McCartney Speaking about the importance of today's visit, Martin said Ireland and Japan are like-minded, peace-loving countries, stating that there has been a breakdown in the international rules-based system, which the Taoiseach said needs to be restored. Trump's comments on Hiroshima Previous to meeting the Taoiseach today, the mayor of Hiroshima found himself responding to comments from US President Donald Trump. The US president told reporters the US attack on Iran's three nuclear facilities recently were 'essentially the same thing' as the attacks on Japan 80 years ago. 'I wish that President Trump would visit the bombed area to see the reality of the atomic bombing and feel the spirit of Hiroshima, and then make statements,' the mayor said in response this week. A Japanese reporter asked the Taoiseach today what he made of Trump's comments. Martin said that two events were not comparable, in his view. As a student of history, Martin said one has to be careful when looking at contemporary events and applying them to past. 'It doesn't always work,' he said. The Taoiseach told the reported that he doesn't believe that Trump likes war, stating that in his view, the US president's fundamental instinct is to oppose war. Martin said he believes Trump wants peace but said 'sometime it can be very complex to get to peace'. 'But if Iran, for example, was ever to secure a nuclear weapon, then the prospect of proliferation for the nuclear weapons within the Middle East, for example, would grow very significantly, and that's why there's been huge emphasis on preventing Iran from getting a nuclear bomb,' Martin said today. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Independent
11 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Government committed to €200 childcare fee, but increase in places must happen
A big feature of the election, which also made it into the Programme for Government, was the promise to reduce childcare fees to €200 per child per month. Last month, Children's Minister Norma Foley announced that fees for parents paying the highest rates in the country are to see those fees capped from September. This meant that fees would be brought closer to the average weekly fee of €197 for full day care, when the National Childcare Scheme subsidy is included. However, the figure is a long way off the commitment from government - but Taoiseach Micheál Martin said commitments in the Programme for Government would be followed through. 'The minister will come to us with her priorities, and obviously it's a Programme for Government commitment, so all Programme for Government commitments, will be followed through. So that's the basic point,' the Taoiseach said. 'But we also cannot lose sight of the need, as well as affordability, we have to move also in terms of additionality, in terms of places, and that people can get places,' he added. Mr Martin added that research showed more childcare places were needed quickly. 'We've made very good progress in childcare, but we need more places, so the access issue and the number of places is also important as well as affordability,' Mr Martin said. 'Some of the research at the moment is pointing towards the need to improve the number of places fairly quickly. In respect of child care, again, that speaks to the growth of population and the pressures on child care and health services and education. So there will be a focus on childcare, and that will continue,' he added. Asked if measures to begin the process of moving towards the €200 per month promise need to happen to show the Government is committed to reduction, Mr Martin said progress made in recent years needed to continue. However, he added that 'we can't do everything at once'. 'We have a whole range of issues now that we have to make progress on. There will be negotiations leading into the budget. We can't do everything at once, so we will endeavour to prioritise and continue the progress we've made in recent years,' he added. Last year, it was reported that a row had broken out in Government over the increase to social welfare payments with former Social Protection Minister Heather Humphreys wanting increases for some on welfare payments, including pensioners, but not for jobseekers. Speaking in Hiroshima on his final day of his four-day visit to Japan, Mr Martin said the row was a 'false row' and that the proposal was never put to Fianna Fáil. Asked if he thought job seekers were less deserving of an increase in the budget than others on welfare, he said he does not agree with the characterisation of people on welfare. He added that priorities would have to be made in the budget and would like to see measures on child poverty come from the Department of Social Protection. 'I don't like drawing distinctions, and I've never been into the characterisation of people on welfare. I've never been into that politics,' Mr Martin said. 'We do have to make priorities. In terms of how we allocate, my view is that we have, over the last two years, committed to doing something significant on child poverty, to turn the dial around on child poverty, and that's where I would like to see a targeted set of measures emanating from the Department of Social Protection,' he added.
