Asking Eric: Sister-in-law warned me not to get serious with him
I still like hanging out with him. Should I tell him what she said? Or just keep it to myself and just keep my guard up?
– Dating Dilemma
Dear Dating: A lot depends on whether you have a pre-existing relationship with the sister-in-law. If she's just coming to you out of the blue and giving you dire warnings, it doesn't mean she's wrong, necessarily, but there's no reason for you to trust her. How do you know she has your best interests in mind?
So, keep your guard up but also talk about it with the man you've been dating. Maybe he has more insight, maybe he'll have a response that gives you a different view of him, maybe she's completely right. If you're getting to know someone in a romantic context and their relative is talking trash about them, it's very helpful to ask them why that might be.
Lastly, think about what you want from this relationship, what you're expecting and what you want to give to it. As you gain more information – good, bad, neutral – it's important to weigh it against your own needs and expectations. Maybe he's fine for you for now; maybe you'll discover you want something more. Staying clear-eyed can help you avoid getting hurt.
Dear Eric: My wife and daughter have not gotten along well since my daughter hit middle school (she's now about to turn 18). Part of the problem is that they are very much alike. Both of them have OCD, but they don't obsess over the same things, which often leaves them at odds. They are both in therapy, and both therapists have recommended family counseling, but my daughter has refused.
I was driving with my daughter yesterday and out of nowhere, she told me what her problem with her mother is: 'The only things I know about her are her favorite foods and that she has to control everything. You're an open book, Dad: warts and all. Mom won't share anything about herself that is even slightly embarrassing, or that makes her seem human.'
When I asked her if she had shared this with her mother, she replied that it was too late for that now.
For the most part, what my daughter said was true. My wife was a bit of a 'wild child.' The OCD didn't present until she was older. Now, she is very much closed off about her past. She says it's to protect my daughter from making the same mistakes. My question is, do I share what my daughter said with my wife? Telling this to my wife would hurt her deeply. I know they love each other, but when my daughter goes off to college, I feel that they will just drift apart.
– Stuck Dad
Dear Dad: I really feel for your wife – she's in a 'cursed if you do, cursed if you don't' position. For many parents, it can be particularly heartbreaking when the things you do with the best intentions, end up being the exact things that create a problem in your relationship with your child.
I think your daughter is being a bit unfair to your wife. Maybe it's a by-product of where she is developmentally; maybe it's simply that aspects of her personality and your wife's are like oil and water. However, you're in a unique position to help her see where she's being short-sighted. The statement that she made to you is exactly the kind of thing that a therapist can help your family navigate. Talk with her about what she shared and gently remind her that what she's lamenting is a treatable problem. See if she'll agree to a set number of sessions with a counselor, say three to start. She may believe that it's too late to address this rift, but as she grows and matures, she will likely grow to regret not trying.
You should also tell your daughter that you're planning to share some of what she shared with your wife. And then, figure out what of that feedback is actionable and have a conversation with your wife about it. I doubt it's prudent, at this point, to tell her everything. However, if she can hear this feedback as an invitation to vulnerability, and an indication of your daughter's curiosity, it can set them on a healthier track.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Washington Post
3 days ago
- Washington Post
Asking Eric: How do I tell my friend her dog is not welcome in my pool?
Dear Eric: Can you offer any advice about a good friend who lets her dog jump in my pool? I have an inground vinyl liner pool so one concern is the dog could damage the liner with its nails or teeth. And my friend does not have the funds to replace the liner if it were damaged, nor would she probably offer.
Chicago Tribune
3 days ago
- Chicago Tribune
Asking Eric: Jealousy between sister-in-laws
Dear Eric: I'm close friends with one of my sisters-in-law but not the other, Betty. Betty and I used to be close until jealousy came between us. She was jealous that her brother and I were the first to get married, have kids and reach other milestones. She is also very sensitive, so I've felt like I need to walk on eggshells, especially after she confided to my husband that she thinks I complain too much. In short, I don't feel like I can share my joys or my struggles with her. I am cordial toward her, but I do not make an effort beyond being polite and kind. I've been going through an intense period of stress and burnout for almost two years. A few months ago, I had a mental breakdown. Since then, Betty has made several attempts at rekindling our former friendship. I haven't reciprocated. Mentally and emotionally, I am still very burned out and I don't have the emotional energy to restore a complicated friendship. Based on previous patterns of behavior, I know that it's just a matter of time before my husband is told either by Betty or their parents that she's hurt that I'm not reciprocating. I know I will be asked why and feel pressured to make more of an effort. How do I set a boundary and explain that I'm not interested in restoring this relationship right now, without further complicating the situation? – Not Ready to Make Nice Dear Not Ready: Being proactive will really help you and Betty here. Reach out to Betty first and tell her that you've noticed (and perhaps appreciate) her desire to rekindle a friendship and you want to acknowledge that. Then let her know that you're still in a tough place and that you just don't have a lot of capacity. This is a little more 'it's not you, it's me' than I'd like, but what seems most important is that you right-size Betty's expectations before this becomes a family issue. Acknowledging her efforts keeps her feelings from getting hurt, and being honest about what you can and can't offer right now saves you from having to reject her outright. It also gives her useful information that will, ideally, help her be a better friend. Hopefully, she's self-aware enough to be able to hear what you're asking for. Sometimes the most loving thing a person can do is give us space and the most loving thing we can do is ask for it. Dear Eric: Regarding your response to 'What to Say', who didn't know how to address a friend's Ozempic weight loss: A couple of years ago, I lost about 60 pounds by sticking to a very strict diet (something I will never do again, it was that unpleasant and detrimental to my quality of life). I was astounded when nobody appeared to notice. Well, at least they didn't say that they noticed. So, after all that I suffered for that result, I was actually kind of hurt. A 'You look great' comment would have been much more than enough, and much better than nothing at all. Now, after gaining all that weight back due to not being able to continually and severely restrict my diet, I am using semaglutide. If and when it is as successful, I hope that somebody notices and mentions it in one way or the other. I don't know too many people who would be offended by a 'You look great' comment. – Looking Great Dear Great: The issue isn't so much offense, per se, so much as making a statement that isn't received as a compliment. While some might receive such a comment in the spirit given, others might not want friends or strangers commenting on their bodies, or they might have complicated feelings about their journeys, or they might have lost weight unwillingly, as through illness. I gave the advice I did not to have everyone walking around on eggshells, but to remind folks that we don't always know what's going on in people's lives or minds. This is also true in your case – you wanted a compliment, and you didn't receive one and those around you didn't sense that. Sometimes, I find that a desire to be complimented is wrapped up in a desire to be more authentic with those around us. Do you, perhaps, have an opportunity to share your pride at your accomplishment with a friend or loved one? Or even share the good parts and the frustrating aspects of the journey you're on? It's not bragging to say, 'I'm doing this thing for me and I'm really happy with it.' And doing so extends an invitation for others to celebrate with you in the way that you want to be celebrated.
Chicago Tribune
4 days ago
- Chicago Tribune
Asking Eric: My daughter's husband isn't good enough for her
Dear Eric: My kiddo is hardworking, makes friends everywhere and is working on her third advanced degree. She is also working full time and volunteers at a shelter and her professional organization. She owns her house. My problem is her husband. He is not good enough for her. He has also been working on an advanced degree that took him five years to complete as he was 'too anxious' to present his research findings. He does nothing around the house except cook (she has to clean up) and play video games on a very expensive set-up. He was in another state for a while for research and it took my kiddo and I an entire day to clean his office. The floor was covered with fast-food wrappers and trash. We found 15 pairs of sneakers. His field is sports-related but he does nothing physical as he has 'old injuries'. She tells me he is a lot like me and that makes me furious. She says it makes him sad to know I don't love him. She and I have had lots of talks about him as I have been too blunt on occasion. I told her that I would try to see him as she does but I just can't seem to get past the fact he is lazy and entitled. I think it would be best if he and I sat down and talked but I am afraid he will go back to her with bad information. Please help me work through this. – Worried Mom Dear Mom: Listen to what she's actually telling you: she loves her husband, she loves you and your critiques are creating an issue where there isn't one. Your laundry list of complaints about her husband are complaints, not hers. Yes, he has some growing to do. But I struggle to see what's so egregious that your daughter should, what, get a divorce? We can express opinions to loved ones, respectfully and when asked for, but – absent conditions of neglect, abuse or illegal behavior – let people do what they want to do with their love lives. I don't see anything that indicates your daughter is asking you for help out of this situation. In fact, it sounds like she's having talks with you because your bluntness has become a problem. So, it's not a good idea for you to sit down and talk with him. It doesn't sound like you want to build a relationship with this person. It sounds like you want to excoriate him. Instead, start by respecting the choice that your daughter made and respecting the fact that you don't know everything about what's going on inside of this marriage. Dear Eric: My husband and I have been married for 47 years. He walks very fast and refuses to slow down to walk with me. He says I should keep up with him (even though it is hard for me to do so). He always just strides ahead. He even accuses me of slowing down on purpose. I believe a polite, loving husband should walk beside his wife. He is clearly neither. Who is right? – Walker Dear Walker: Does he expect you to magically lengthen your legs? Go sprinting through airports like an Olympian? Levitate? This strikes me as rude and short-sighted (no pun intended). It's also a bit on the nose as a metaphor. People move at different speeds in relationships. The goal is not to force one or the other to radically change, but to find a cadence at which you can travel together comfortably. Dear Eric: I am writing after reading the letter about how to handle beautiful greeting cards you don't want to just throw away ('Greeting Cards'). I'd love to suggest an option that, for me, is heartwarming. When I feel the love expressed, I turn the card over and on the back write a little note. Example: 'Dear ___, you sent me this card on my 80th birthday and it touched my heart. Thank you. (personal note follows). Love Forever.' Then I place the card in a folder to be distributed to the sender when I pass away. I have an individual folder for each family member. It's my hope that they'll feel the love returned even after I am gone. – Feeling the Love Dear Love: Oh wow! The foresight and creativity of this solution took my breath away. I simply adore this! You've created a sort of ouroboros of love, looping back on itself forever. Others suggested that children's hospitals, senior centers and schools may have donation programs set up for repurposing old cards. And – important! – I used the term 'throw out' in my original answer. Let me clarify: if you're throwing the cards out, throw them in the recycling bin.
