Erasmus to rethinks Springbok selections after unconvincing win over Italy
Image: Timothy Bernard Independent Media
The Springboks' lacklustre performance in the first Test against Italy will have repercussions, with coach Rassie Erasmus stating that he will revisit his planned selection for this week's second Test in Gqeberha.
The Boks went into the Pretoria season-opener with high expectations after a promising warm-up against the Barbarians, but their 42-24 win was flawed. The Italians had left a core of stars at home, yet troubled the Boks in the line-outs and breakdowns, and were arguably the better side in the second half.
Last week, Erasmus said he had internally informed the players which of them would feature at the Nelson Mandela Bay Stadium on Saturday. But after several disappointing individual performances, the coach says he will revisit those plans.
'I guess it's a positive that we scored six tries, but we're frustrated,' the coach said.
'The buck stops with us coaches because we obviously did not prepare the guys well enough. I didn't see this performance coming. It is fixable, but it's definitely frustrating.'
'Internally, we've announced the 13 or 14 players that will definitely get a run next week, and that we'd build the bench or starting line-up around those guys,' he added.
'We won't discard those players, but some of them might move to the bench. Some of the real standout players who featured today might start again.
'The make-up of the team may change to handle the physicality that Italy threw at us. You'd think a team that made 120 tackles in the first half would break in the second half, but they did the opposite.
'Italy are a fit and passionate side and we have to make sure that the team we put out for the second Test is not just one that can go 50 or 60 minutes — it must be a team that can go 80 minutes.'
The Boks started the game strongly and it seemed a question of time before the Italians would collapse. At half-time, the Boks would have spoken about opening the taps and putting the visitors away by a big margin. That appeared to be on the cards when they scored their fifth try early in the second half, only for Italy to rally and score three tries of their own.
'It was a very frustrating game,' said Erasmus.
'We knew they were stronger than the public perception, and they manned up in every department of the game. When we were 28-3 up and we scored a try that was disallowed for obstruction, I thought we might have them — but then we lost momentum.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
2 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Springboks seek referee feedback after breakdown mess at Loftus
Frustrated members of the Springbok management team have asked referee Hollie Davidson and her team for clarity ahead of the decisive Test against Italy in Gqeberha on Saturday. Rassie Erasmus used the word 'frustrated' several times in the aftermath of the Springboks' 42-24 win against a weakened Italy at Loftus Versfeld last Saturday. The Bok coach lamented South Africa's lack of intensity in the second half, and went as far as to suggest that there would be consequences ahead of the next team announcement. In the same breath, Erasmus questioned the legality of Italy's breakdown approach and intimated that the officials were too lenient on the visitors. Both teams have since transferred to Gqeberha for the decisive Test of the series. While it's a new city subject to different weather and playing conditions, the Boks are determined to receive answers on some of the recent breakdown calls. These answers will have some bearing on the next game, as the same teams will feature and the same group of officials will be on duty at the Nelson Mandela Bay Stadium – although Andrew Brace will referee the match, with Hollie Davidson joining assistant referee Matthew Carley on the touchline. Feedback On Monday, the Boks made another strong statement on the matter when they sent laws and discipline adviser Jaco Peyper to the first media conference of the week. The former Test referee went out of his way to acknowledge the officials, before asking for clarity and consistency in their application of the laws. 'We think that Hollie and the rest of the team here in South Africa are good referees, and they're the type of referees who will give you feedback when you ask for feedback,' Peyper said. 'Regarding the weekend's game [at Loftus], there are one or two questions that we've raised. 'We respect the refs, we know that they go through their game reviews, and we are sure they will give us some honest feedback. 'That will put us all into a better position going into the next game.' The breakdowns were a mess in the latter stages of the first Test, with stray boots and hands edging the ball back towards the defensive side on numerous occasions. One could ask why a vastly experienced Bok team wasn't more street smart, or why they didn't exploit the refereeing interpretations to their benefit. Those who watched the game, of course, would have noted how the contest lacked rhythm and energy in the second half. Pressed for specifics, Peyper conceded that the management of the breakdown was the point of query. 'In rugby, when you carry dominant or when you tackle dominant, the little bit of grace sits with you. 'We have to make sure that we show the referee a picture that is easier to referee, and that we don't allow for too much interpretation or management. 'We need to know how we can adjust, and we need feedback – but it's a positive process, this is not bagging anyone. 'It's not about us being unhappy, it's a question of learning. We've got to make sure that we adjust to the referees. 'World Rugby sends out best practises [before the start of tournaments and international windows], and we need to know that we understand those correctly, and that we are training our players accordingly.' Some officials give a competing player a warning in order to keep the game flowing. Others are quick to penalise a player who is deliberately slowing the ball down at the ruck. Harsher As the interaction with Peyper progressed, it became clear that the Boks want the officials to be harsher on breakdown offenders in the coming match. 'It comes down to whether the ref sees an infringement, whether they ask the player to stop doing that, or whether the referee referees the infringement,' said Peyper. With regard to other areas of play, the Bok coaches and players admit that they were well below par at Loftus. Peyper went to bat for the officials as well as the opposition when it was suggested that Italians may have impeded in the lead-up to their maul-try in the second half. The Italy maul was set from some 20 metres out, yet the Boks – who pride themselves on this facet of play – failed to stop it. 'I don't think it's a law thing,' Peyper confirmed, 'It was just a really good maul by Italy that was poorly defended by us. 'That part of the game is part of our soul, so that was a big negative for us.' Bok prop Thomas du Toit – who was omitted from the lineup last week but looks set to play a role in the second Test – was equally honest about the team's shortcomings. 'We set high standards for ourselves in a match,' Du Toit said. 'When we review a game [as the Boks did on Monday morning], we compare ourselves to how we were the week before, and ask ourselves whether we were better. '[With regard to the last game] we have to look at ourselves in the mirror and say that we weren't. We've also got to acknowledge that Italy were very good.' The Bok team to play Italy will be announced at 3.15pm on Tuesday. DM
IOL News
10 hours ago
- IOL News
Peyper: Springboks seeking clarity over breakdown as second Italy test looms
Springbok laws advisor Jaco Peyper says the team have sought clarity from World Rugby over breakdown interpretations ahead of the second Test against Italy, while backing veteran fullback Willie le Roux to mark a special milestone if selected. Photo: Backpagepix Image: Backapagepix Springbok laws and discipline advisor Jaco Peyper says the Boks have approached World Rugby's refereeing department for clarity on 'one or two things' ahead of Saturday's second Test against Italy — particularly around the breakdown, where the team was outplayed in the series opener. Peyper, the vastly experienced former referee who joined the Springbok setup in early 2024, was clear that the approach was part of a normal feedback process — not a complaint. 'First of all, the refereeing team here, led by Holly Davidson and company, have a great ethic,' said Peyper. 'They are people you can give feedback to, and they give it back. World Rugby encourages this. 'We had a few questions after last week's game, and they will give us honest feedback. Italy had a clear plan and executed it well, but we need to understand whether we need to adjust — and if we have to, we will.' Asked whether the onus lies with South Africa, Italy, or the referee to adjust, Peyper pointed to the importance of dominance in key areas. 'In rugby, when you carry dominantly and tackle dominantly, then the bit of grey sits with you. So the first thing we need to do is be dominant. 'But we also need to fix a few things and ensure we are showing the referee a picture that is easy to officiate — and not one that relies on too much interpretational management. 'It's a positive process. We're not bagging anyone. We learn from each other to create a better product.' Peyper, who officiated in 14 Rugby World Cup matches before taking up his new role, explained that the Springbok camp had taken a measured approach following the disappointing result. 'First, we must understand the performance. Was the plan good enough from the coaches? Did the players execute well enough? Then you assess the performance gap and how to fix it. 'We did that on Monday. We are facing a passionate and well-coached Italian team. We need to be up for the game and work hard this week to meet our own standards. 'We are a proud team, and that's why we were frustrated. There were too many individual errors, and when those stack up, they ruin continuity.' Peyper also praised veteran fullback Willie le Roux, who is poised to become only the eighth player in Springbok history to reach 100 Test caps, should he be selected in the match-day squad this weekend. 'I've worked with Willie since he was young. He sees things on the field that others don't. It's frustrating to see the criticism he receives at times. As a team, we're proud of him, and if he plays, we hope to make the occasion a special one.'
The Herald
11 hours ago
- The Herald
Beware when Italy put foot to pedal, says Du Toit
If an energetic Italian side get their tails up and put their foot to the pedal on the attack, the Springboks must remain structured to hold them at bay, prop Thomas du Toit said. After the Boks beat a spirited Azzurri 42-24 at Loftus Versfeld at the weekend, the scene is set for a fascinating rematch at the Nelson Mandela Bay Stadium in Gqeberha on Saturday (kickoff 5.10pm). At halftime, the Boks looked to be cruising to a big win when they opened up a 28-3 lead before the never-say-die Italians produced a spirited second-half comeback. Though Italy are ranked 10th in the world, the Boks are expecting another tough battle against the proud Italians. 'Obviously, we could have been much better last week, and there were certain aspects of the game in which we had to look ourselves in the eye and say we were not good enough,' Du Toit said. 'But we know what we need to do this week against a very passionate Italian side, as we all saw last week. 'Italy are a young team full of energy and very well coached. 'You can see they don't really want to mess around in their half and they want to put foot to the pedal in the opposition's half. 'It is about sustaining discipline and not allowing them entries into your 22. 'When Italy get their tails up and want to attack and have a bit of flair, it is about staying in your systems and trying to nullify that. 'You can always see big passion from the Italian players and they are very proud to play for their country 'We have seen that through the years and it never changes. 'I wouldn't say it was a wake-up call as such [the first Test], we just set very high standards for ourselves, both in preparing for a match and in the match itself, as well as in training. 'Italy seem to be more structured than in the past and they are performing well and gelling as a unit.' Du Toit said the Boks set high standards whenever they prepared for a Test match. 'At training, we all try to lift one another so we can get better,' he said. 'When we review a game, we do so in the sense of were we better than the week before. 'Then we have to look ourselves in the mirror.' Du Toit said emotions needed to be taken out of post-match game reviews after Test matches. 'There is a reality you need to face when you review a game,' he said. 'After a game, everyone might be emotional, and they won't necessarily see the whole picture. 'Our coaches do an unbelievably good job at reviewing the game properly, so when we meet on a Monday, we have a real view of what happened. 'Your perception after a game is not necessarily accurate.' Du Toit said he was comfortable playing loosehead or tighthead prop and viewed this ability as an important asset. 'I am very grateful that back at my club at Bath in England, coach Johan van Graan has given me opportunities to play both sides of the scrum and I feel very comfortable with that,' he said. 'It is just a week of preparation and then you have it. It is like riding a bike and you get back to that natural feeling. 'I don't mind it and feel like it is another arrow in my quiver I can take out whenever the coaches or team need it and I am grateful that I can play that part. 'When you get taken out of your comfort zone, you either sink or swim. 'When I went to Bath, that definitely put me out of my comfort zone, but in a very positive way. 'There was this realisation that you had to lift your game to compete with the best and the Premiership is a very good competition and tough.' The Herald
