Couple withdraw personal injury claims worth up to €120,000 over alleged fall on Dublin Airport escalator
DAA
over an incident on an escalator at
Dublin Airport
have withdrawn their separate €60,000 personal injury claims.
The decision came after a
Circuit Civil Court
judge said an application by their counsel for a five minute break for talks was 'a good idea'.
Housewife Bernie Browne (66) and retired Peter Browne (71), of Spafield Crescent, Cashel,
Co Tipperary
, had claimed they were injured because of the alleged faulty operation of the escalator in Terminal One.
Judge Jonathan Dunphy on Friday heard the couple had just returned from a holiday in Lanzarote in September 2021 and were ascending on an escalator when Ms Browne fell backwards, toppling her husband as he attempted to stop her.
READ MORE
They had to be helped up by a security guard who pressed the escalator's emergency stop button.
The couple's counsel told the court they were withdrawing their claims following talks with barrister Adrianne Fields, who had earlier cross-examined Ms Browne and a forensic engineer. They both alleged the escalator handrail stopped moving briefly while the steps continued moving upwards.
Ms Fields, who appeared with David Martin of Gore and Grimes Solicitors for DAA, highlighted that Ms Browne was carrying her passport and another document in her left hand, which she had been using to hold the moving handrail with a pinch-like finger grip.
Counsel noted that seconds-long CCTV footage of the incident showed Ms Browne was struggling to steady her wheelie suitcase with her right hand on the steps of the escalator from the time she stepped on until the moment she fell.
Ms Browne said she suffered injuries to her left leg and was treated by her GP, who she visited with her husband for the purpose of obtaining a medical report for her solicitor.
She told Ms Fields her husband had not received medical treatment from the doctor.
The case was interrupted for talks during the evidence of Ms Browne and her engineer. Mr Browne's case was withdrawn, along with his wife's, before he was called to give any evidence on his or her behalf. Both cases were struck out, as were any existing earlier legal costs issues.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Teenager charged with arson of house shows no remorse, court hears
A 14-year-old boy showed no remorse for allegedly taking part in a firebomb attack that destroyed an innocent family's home in Dublin and killed their pet husky trapped in the blaze, a court heard. The teenager, charged with arson of the house on Landen Road, Ballyfermot, which was left gutted on May 21st, was denied bail on Saturday. He was remanded to the Oberstown Children Detention Campus after appearing before Judge Maire Conneely at Dublin District Court. The boy, who cannot be named because he is a juvenile with the right to anonymity, made no reply when charged in advance of his court appearance after he was deemed unsuitable for inclusion in the Garda Youth Diversion Programme. READ MORE Objecting to bail due to the seriousness of the case, Garda Alan McGinty recounted that at 2.28am, gardaí responded to a report of a domestic fire at the home. They learned that one resident was asleep in the livingroom, but he woke to the sound of glass smashing and found the room was on fire. The man's wife, son and their dog were in the property at the time. The family got out but the pet husky 'was still trapped inside and died in the fire'. The court heard the innocent family's home was 'totally' destroyed in the attack, after which a witness overheard a male yell 'wrong house'. Evidence was given that two males in balaclavas arrived at the house on an electric bicycle, and the defendant was allegedly the driver, while his passenger carried and threw the burning petrol can. Images of the scene were handed over to the court, which also heard there was CCTV footage, but the judge held it was unnecessary to view the video. She noted allegations that a jerrycan of petrol was bought at a service station three hours before the incident before being brought to and hidden in bushes at a building in the Dolphin's Barn area. It was alleged that shortly before 2:30am, two males arrived in a taxi, put on balaclavas and travelled to Landen Road on an electric bicycle. Garda McGinty alleged that they could be tracked on CCTV and, after the arson, they returned to the Dolphin's Barn area and handed the electric bicycle back to another person. It was alleged that the boy and another male went away in a taxi and the vehicle's dashcam footage has been retrieved, leading to his identification. The jacket he allegedly wore in the taxi was found during a search of his home. Garda McGinty stated that during the interview, the teenager, who has no prior criminal convictions, showed no remorse. The boy, supported in court by his mother and other family members, sat silently at the side of the courtroom and has not yet indicated a plea. The judge noted that no bail terms would alleviate the concerns of the investigation team. A decision has yet to be made on his trial venue but defence barrister Kevin McCrave submitted it was likely the case would go to the Circuit Court, which has greater sentencing powers. He submitted that refusal of bail would mean he could be held for a year before his trial and disrupt his education. He urged the judge to note that the teenager would abide by a myriad of strict conditions available to the court. Referencing the Children's Act, he cited the law, which sets out that detention should be a last resort. He stressed the teen had the presumption of innocence, no prior convictions, history of drug abuse or failing to appear in court and there was no witness intimidation evidence. Judge Conneely held, however, that the garda had established a case for refusing bail and remanded the boy in custody to appear at the Children's Court on Wednesday.
Sunday World
6 hours ago
- Sunday World
Sacked car wash worker stabbed his ex-employer while attempting to break into his home
George Toma (47) pleads guilty to stabbing Mircea Maties and and his nephew Darius Maties in Co. Roscommon. A sacked car wash worker stabbed his former employer and his nephew after attempting to enter their home through an upstairs window, Roscommon Circuit Court has heard. George Toma of no fixed abode pleaded guilty to trespassing with a knife, burglary, production of an article capable of inflicting serious injury, and assault causing harm to Mircea Maties and Darius Maties. The court heard that Toma was having financial issues in his native Romania when he was hired by Mircea Maties to work at his car wash business in Brackernagh, Ballinasloe, Co Galway. He was initially housed in an apartment with another employee and began working at Crystal Clean Car Wash. He received a €1,000 loan to help his financial situation, which he paid back in €100 deductions from his weekly wages. On December 10, 2024, Mercia Maties terminated Toma's employment after becoming suspicious that Toma was stealing from the business while he was away. Mr Maties said that the number of cars being washed did not correspond with the records kept on the premises and that the CCTV had been turned off. Later that day at 7.20pm Toma broke the lock and gained access to the premises and slept the night there. Toma charged his phone overnight before leaving at 7am the following morning with a knife he took from the premises. Roscommon Courthouse Today's News in 90 Seconds - July 5th On December 15, Toma gained access to 9 Gleann Ard, Ballaghaderreen - a property maintained and managed by Mr Mercia Maties for a Dublin-based company - and took a two-metre ladder from the premises. At approximately 4am that morning, the 47-year-old used the ladder to climb up to an upstairs window of Mercia Maties' home at 7 Gleann Ard, Ballaghaderreen. Darius Maties, a nephew of Mercia Maties, woke to the sound of Toma attempting to pry open the window. Mercia Maties, his wife and seven-year-old daughter were also in the house at the time. Recognising Toma, Darius Maties screamed and told his uncle that Toma was outside his bedroom window. Mercia Maties went downstairs and retrieved a baseball bat as Toma attempted to enter through the window. Upon seeing Toma, Mercia Maties shouted at Toma, who fell off the ladder and landed on the ground in front of the patio window. Mercia Maties went downstairs and saw Toma moaning on the ground and went to check on him. Toma then drove a knife at Mercia Maties, stabbing him in the chest through his t-shirt. He told his nephew to get back into the house before Toma attempted to enter the house via the patio door. Toma managed to get part of his body inside the patio door and began swinging the knife. Darius Maties was stabbed in the shoulder during the exchange before they forced Toma out of the room. Toma then left the scene. Merica Maties' wife called the emergency services and both men were conveyed to hospital via ambulance. Merica Maties required stitches for his wounds while Darius Maties was left with a minor scar at the top of his arm. They were released from hospital the following day. When cautioned before being arrested at Pound Street, Ballaghaderreen, at approximately 8pm that evening, Toma said: 'Problem with boss, no money for me.' He was conveyed to Castlerea Garda Station where he was interviewed twice. He cooperated fully with gardaí. During his interview, Toma claimed he had gone to the house to retrieve €10 of stolen jewellery and cash he claimed he was owed by Mercia Maties. He maintained that Mercia Maties had exploited him during his employment and that he stabbed him accidentally on the night he attempted to enter his house. Toma later pleaded guilty to all charges on June 18, 2025. He has no previous convictions and had been living in Ireland for approximately six months at the time of his offences. The court heard that Toma has a wife and child living in Romania and had been sending money to them while employed by Mercia Maties. In a victim impact statement read to the court, Mercia Maties said he lived in constant fear that his attacker would return to the house since the event. A separate victim impact statement from his wife heard that she had been diagnosed with post traumatic stressed disorder since the incident. Darius Maties said he had experienced persistent fear anxiety and difficulty sleeping since the incident. He has been prescribed diazepam to treat his stress and has experienced memory lapses and had difficulty concentrating. Defending barrister Mr Rob Lowe, BL, said his client was the father of an eight-year-old child with a good work ethic and said he intended to return to Romania. Judge Kenneth Connolly remanded Toma in custody to appear before Longford District Court on July 30 for sentencing.
Irish Times
8 hours ago
- Irish Times
Businessman sent masked spy to watch ex through her window, court hears
A Dublin businessman flouted a protection order by sending a masked man to spy on his ex-partner through her window at night and e-mailing her work, saying 'I've nothing to lose', a court heard. The man in his late 20s, who cannot be identified for legal reasons, was charged with breaching the Domestic Violence Act order and refused bail by Judge Maire Conneely on Saturday. Voicing concerns about possible witness interference, a local garda told Dublin District Court that the woman had secured a protection order at the start of May but continued to live with the accused for several weeks. She recently moved out, however, and was staying at another house in a different part of the city. READ MORE It was alleged her ex-partner sent an email to her work on Friday, booked an appointment with her and one message quoted in court read: 'I have nothing to lose, watch what I do today.' The garda testified that in the early hours of Saturday, a masked man on a bike was sent by the accused to her new home and there was CCTV evidence. The woman also alleged the person outside had been shouting: 'Where are you? Where are you?' She said she stood behind her curtains but heard the man speaking on his phone, telling someone 'he could see her inside'. Visibly upset, the woman told Judge Conneely that she could see the 'fully covered' man at her window talking about her and referring to her with a version of her name only used by her ex-partner. She broke down and wept as she spoke out, claiming her ex became nasty when he abused alcohol and drugs, which had resulted in her seeking the protection order. The woman alleged that the man blocked her from re-entering their former shared home when she needed to retrieve her work uniform. Cross-examined, defence counsel Kevin McCrave put it to her that she kicked or damaged the door and that his client had offered to leave her uniform outside, which she did not accept. She also alleged she had to move her car because of a threat to damage it, saying, 'I am in genuine fear'. Mr McCrave stressed that his client maintained he was innocent and would abide by strict conditions, including not going near his former partner's new address and refraining from contacting her. Judge Conneely said the accused has the presumption of innocence, but held that the garda had established grounds as she denied bail. The accused did not testify during the proceedings and spoke only to consult his barrister. The man, who awaits a full hearing of the charge, was remanded in custody to appear again next week. After the judge made her decision, the accused raised concerns, via his counsel, about his work and the lack of someone to care for and feed his pets before he was escorted from the court.
