Waitangi Tribunal pushes pause on seabed mine claim
Photo:
Te Korimako o Taranaki
The Waitangi Tribunal has rejected the application to halt a fast-track bid to mine the seabed off Pātea - but has left the door open if the process turns out to be unfair.
Trans-Tasman Resources (TTR) has applied through the new Fast-Track Approvals Act (FTAA) to mine for iron, titanium and vanadium in the South Taranaki Bight.
Multiple South Taranaki hapū and iwi sought a Tribunal injunction to block processing of the fast-track application, and an urgent hearing into alleged Crown Treaty breaches.
But Tribunal deputy chair Judge Sarah Reeves agreed with the Crown that the fast-track needed a chance to be proven fair.
The Crown argued a panel had not even been appointed - and that iwi will contribute to that selection and get a say once the decision-making panel is working.
The Waitangi Tribunal grants urgent hearings in exceptional circumstances: applicants must be suffering - or likely to suffer - significant and irreversible prejudice from current or pending Crown actions.
"I do not agree that the risk of significant and irreversible prejudice has crystallised, and the application is premature," said Judge Reeves.
"The application does not yet meet the high threshold required to divert the resources and disrupt the Tribunal's inquiry programme that would result by granting an urgent inquiry," she ruled.
"However, leave is reserved for the applicants to renew their application if circumstances change."
Claimants said they had already suffered prejudice from their decade-long fight against TTR's mining application, right through to defeating the company in the Supreme Court.
Mana whenua said government bias made the fast-track process unjust.
Judge Reeves said the claimants believe "the Crown's vocal support of the [seabed mining] project and the FTAA appears to make meaningful engagement with the applicants or delay of the project to pursue alternative remedies 'highly unlikely'".
On Friday in New Plymouth Shane Jones - the minister of oceans and fisheries, and of resources - called opponents a [www.teaonews.co.nz/2025/07/21/minister-proud-of-potshots-in-seabed-mine-culture-war "belligerent, well-organised, rowdy] bunch of activists."
He had previously dismissed mana whenua objectors as "pixie-like hapūs" - which many felt was an insult that still rankles in South Taranaki.
Taranaki mana whenua claimants to the Tribunal are:
Trans-Tasman Resources boss Alan Eggers says the seabed mine would bring jobs and riches without harming the environment.
Photo:
Te Korimako o Taranaki
Other parties include Climate Justice Taranaki, Ngāruahine's school Te Kura o Ngāruahinerangi and from outside the region Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Porou ki Hauraki who also face an FTAA application.
For the fast-track bid to be rejected the mine's negative impacts must significantly outweigh national and regional benefits - meaning environmental and cultural damage must be deemed greater than the money the mine makes for Taranaki and New Zealand.
Last Thursday the organisers of the fast-track decision process ordered TTR to [www.thepost.co.nz/nz-news/360761435/mining-company-directed-provide-updated-info-after-panel-convenors-concerns show where it had updated its evidence] since losing in the courts.
"Almost all of the technical appendices are dated 2015 and were obviously prepared to support the 2016 application. Only a handful of those reports were updated in 2023 or 2024," noted panel convener Jennifer Caldwell.
"The Cultural Values Assessment report, prepared by an independent consultant in 2017, was not updated despite what must have been new information as to the Māori concerns."
A month earlier panel conveners ordered the Environmental Protection Authority to dig into the proposed seabed mine's [www.nzherald.co.nz/whanganui-chronicle/news/agencies-probe-proposed-south-taranaki-seabed-mine-on-environment-and-money/IOTD7N4O75BSZDX5UOZP7GKEVY/ environmental and economic impacts].
Every day of operation for at least 20 years the mining ship would discharge 180,000 tonnes of unwanted seabed sediment, a recognised pollutant, into the abundant waters of the Pātea Shoals.
TTR claims region benefits of:
A report for the miners predicted annual national gains of:
LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ on Air.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
19 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Education Ministry says new curriculums are much clearer
The Education Ministry said the new curriculums were much clearer about what needed to be taught each year. Photo: 123RF The Education Ministry says its staff have a clear understanding of what the term 'knowledge-rich' means. A ministry document from March warned its work on the new school curriculum was suffering because it did not have a clear definition of the term, which was central to the entire project. But the ministry's acting curriculum centre hautu (leader) Pauline Cleaver told RNZ's Midday Report it was not a problem. "It's fully understood by our team and our PLD [professional learning and development], alongside the curriculum that we've already produced is working really well and our response from teachers about the English curriculum for Year 1 to 8 and the maths is going really well. People are really seeing what a knowledge-rich curriculum looks like," she said. Cleaver said the already-published curriculums were examples of knowledge-rich. "It's really well structured, it's got clear content. The things that we want young people to know and the things that we want them to know how to do, they're sequenced in a year-by-year way so that the knowledge builds over time and they get a nice coherent learning pathway. That the learning is managed and taught in nice structured ways, such as you see through our structured literacy programmes and their teachers have real clarity on what needs to be taught and what students should be learning at any particular point on the pathway." She said the new curriculums were much clearer about what needed to be taught each year. But Principals Federation president Leanne Otene told RNZ the curriculum changes were chaotic and imploding. She said the government was changing too much, too fast and the training for teachers and principals was insufficient. "We've had multiple announcements, and they're disconnected initiatives and they are creating chaos," she said. Otene said primary schools were teaching new English and maths curriculums without sufficient training and without assessment tools to test children's achievement against the new curriculums. She said the key ideas underpinning the curriculum change, science of learning and knowledge rich were "mentioned everywhere, defined nowhere" PPTA vice-president Kieran Gainsford said at a recent meeting of subject association leaders, many were worried that the government had not provided a clear explanation of what it meant by terms like "science of learning" and "knowledge-rich curriculum". "It leaves schools and teachers in almost a hopeless position. If we're supposed to implement a new curriculum, we want to do a good job. We want to do the best for the young people in front of us. But if we're given such unclear guidance, that leaves us in a very difficult position to be able to do that," he said. Meanwhile, Cleaver told RNZ the ministry was using AI to help with background work on the curriculum. "We have used AI to help us synthesise a range of research, what other countries are doing, how we're comparing with the content we're choosing to make sure we're doing the best job possible. It's not a replacement for our writers. It's information that our writers can use to be more effective at making sure we get this right," she said. "It's not writing the curriculum now. We have real teachers, real educators writing the content." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Midday Report Essentials for Tuesday 22nd July 2025
money education 6 minutes ago In today's episode, the Prime Minister has described the war in Gaza as an absolute catastrophe; A collection of money donated by New Zealanders for families in Gaza is being withheld by Paypal for no reason; The government's curriculum changes have been described by one school union as chaotic and imploding; The winner of season two of the 'Drag Race Down Under' television show has her sights set on a new sparkle - but at a great sacrifice.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Govt's curriculum changes come under fire
education policy 25 minutes ago The government's curriculum changes have been described by one school union as chaotic and imploding. Ministry of Education's Acting Hautu, or leader, of its Curriculum Centre Pauline Cleaver spoke to Charlotte Cook.
