logo
Siddaramaiah, Biocon founder spar over vaccine safety amid rise in Hassan deaths

Siddaramaiah, Biocon founder spar over vaccine safety amid rise in Hassan deaths

India Today14 hours ago
A public exchange between Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah and Biocon founder Kiran Mazumdar Shaw has brought national attention to the state's investigation into a series of sudden deaths in Hassan district. The debate between the two public figures is centred on whether Covid-19 vaccines might be linked to the rise in heart-related fatalities.In her latest post on July 4, the Biocon founder while agreeing with the Chief Minister's position on seeking scientific clarity reiterated that vaccines developed in India were approved through due process. advertisement'My response was that due process was followed as prescribed by WHO for safety and efficacy for EUA. Losing lives in a sudden manner is always tragic and I am glad an investigation is being conducted in Hassan district,' she wrote on X.
This came in response to Siddaramaiah's post on July 3 on the social media platform, where he clarified that asking questions about vaccine safety was a governance responsibility, not misinformation. 'When parents lose their young children or families lose breadwinners without warning, seeking clarity is not misinformation; it is an act of governance rooted in empathy.' Citing multiple peer-reviewed studies, he added that some Covid-19 vaccines had been linked to rare cardiac events, and that global regulators, including the World Health Organisation (WHO), had acknowledged the emergency rollouts involved 'calculated risks'.Siddaramaiah defended his earlier remarks on July 1 suggesting that 'hasty' vaccine approvals could not be ruled out as a factor in the increase in heart attacks. 'It cannot be denied that the hasty approval and distribution of the Covid-19 vaccine to the public could also be a reason for these deaths, as several studies worldwide have recently indicated,' he had said.Mazumdar Shaw had earlier countered that Indian vaccines were approved under the Emergency Use Authorisation framework, adhering to international safety and efficacy norms. 'To suggest that these vaccines were 'hastily' approved is factually incorrect and contributes to public misinformation,' she wrote on July 3. 'These vaccines have saved millions of lives and, like all vaccines, may cause side effects in a very small number of individuals.'In response, Siddaramaiah stated, 'Haste is not a sin when saving lives, but acknowledging potential unintended consequences is wisdom.' The Chief Minister's comments followed reports that more than 20 people had died of heart attacks in Hassan district in the past month. In response, the state government has formed a high-level expert committee under Dr Ravindranath, Director of the Jayadeva Institute of Cardiovascular Sciences and Research, to investigate the deaths and submit a report within ten days.advertisementThis is the same panel that was tasked in February 2025 with studying the cause of sudden deaths among young people in Karnataka and whether there could be any link to Covid-19 vaccination. Siddaramaiah said the panel would continue evaluating cardiac cases and deliver its findings, based on which the government would take further action.'We too value the lives of children, youth, and innocent people who have their entire lives ahead of them, and we share the concerns of their families,' he said. He also condemned the BJP for allegedly politicising the deaths. 'Before BJP criticise us on this matter, they should ask their conscience,' he said.- Ends
IN THIS STORY#Karnataka
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

‘No trade deal under pressure of deadline': Piyush Goyal
‘No trade deal under pressure of deadline': Piyush Goyal

Economic Times

time15 minutes ago

  • Economic Times

‘No trade deal under pressure of deadline': Piyush Goyal

Reuters India's trade minister Piyush Goyal Days ahead of the US' July 9 deadline for reciprocal tariffs, commerce and industry minister Piyush Goyal on Friday said India does not enter into trade agreements based on deadlines but on mutual benefits and national interest. 'FTAs (free trade agreements) are possible only when both sides get benefits. It should be a win-win agreement. India never negotiates trade deals based on deadlines. Our focus is always on fairness and the country's benefit,' Goyal told media persons on the sidelines of an event, a day after Indian trade negotiators returned from an eight-day visit to the US to close a trade pact before July 9. The minister ruled out him visiting the US in the near term. The Indian negotiating team returned from Washington after hectic parleys with their US counterparts. 'India Always Ready to Do Deals' 'India's national interest should always be supreme… keeping that in mind, if a good deal happens then India is always ready to do deals with developed countries,' Goyal said. 'Jab deal achchhi ban jaaye, puri tarah se pakk jaaye tab usko sweekar karenge (When a good deal is done and ready, then we will accept it),' he emphasised. Asked whether he was hopeful of a trade deal with the US, Goyal said, 'I have told you many times that India negotiates FTAs on its own terms'. He added that trade discussions are on with the European Union and different countries—New Zealand, Oman, US, Chile and Peru. US President Donald Trump on Thursday said that his administration would send letters to individual countries which don't have a deal with the US, specifying the tariffs they would now have to pay to export to America. In April, Trump had announced reciprocal tariffs for most of the trading partners based on their trade surpluses with the US, including a 26% levy on India. The Indian government wants the entire 26% levy to be rolled back and is negotiating with the Trump administration. However, the US' demand for market access across sectors, including sensitive agriculture and dairy products, and insistence on genetically modified crops, have been some sticky areas. On the issue of the two sides inking multiple deals on issues as and when they get agreed, an official said that all possibilities are on the table.

Kusum-C scheme: Target to generate 2,400MW solar power for farmers, says George
Kusum-C scheme: Target to generate 2,400MW solar power for farmers, says George

Time of India

time15 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Kusum-C scheme: Target to generate 2,400MW solar power for farmers, says George

Hassan: Under the Kusum-C scheme, which aims to solarise agricultural feeders and provide daytime electricity supply to farmers' pumpsets, 200MW of electricity is being produced. In the coming months, 545MW of electricity will be generated, stated energy minister KJ George. Speaking to reporters after the energy department's progress review meeting of Hassan district, held on Friday at the Zilla Panchayat hall in the city, George said, "Under the Kusum-C scheme, construction of solar units with a capacity of around 200MW is completed. In the next few months, solar units with a capacity of 545MW will be commissioned at 93 locations. This will help provide an adequate daytime electricity supply to farmers. " "The state govt has set a target of generating 2,400MW of solar electricity through feeder solarisation of agricultural pumpsets under the Kusum-C scheme. Recently, chief minister Siddaramaiah inaugurated a solar power unit established under the Kusum-C scheme in Gauribidanur. The feeder solarisation work is progressing at a rapid pace," the energy minister added. Under the Kusum-C scheme, generating 1MW of electricity requires 4 acres of land. If govt land is available, CM Siddaramaiah has directed that it be allocated free of cost. However, private power producers must pay Rs 25,000 per acre, which will be deposited with the district commissioner and used to improve govt schools and anganwadis in villages where the substations are located, the minister elaborated. "If private land is used, developers awarded the power generation contracts will lease the land and pay landowners a minimum of Rs 25,000 per acre," George said. Of the 4 lakh unauthorised irrigation pumpsets in the state, 3 lakh are already regularised. For pumpsets within 500m of power feeders, transformers will be installed by the department. Those beyond 500m will receive solar pumpsets under the Kusum-B scheme, he said. Earlier, during a progress review meeting, the district MLAs raised issues concerning the energy department in their constituencies. In response, George instructed the CESC MD to take swift action and reiterated that officials should proactively consult elected representatives and follow through on their suggestions. MP Shreyas Patel, MLA and Housing Board chairman KM Shivalingegowda, MLAs K Manju, Swaroop Prakash, CN Balakrishna, HK Suresh, and S Manjunath, KPTCL MD Pankaj Kumar Pandey, DC S Latha Kumari, and ZP CEO BR Poornima were present.

Eat butter in peace, or be toast in war
Eat butter in peace, or be toast in war

Time of India

time19 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Eat butter in peace, or be toast in war

Ukraine is not a rich country. The average Ukrainian earns the equivalent of $15,885 - PPP terms - in a year, which is 75% more than the average Indian but slightly less than the average Iranian. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now To catch up with neighbours like Romania ($40,304) and Poland ($43,625), Ukraine must spend more on development, but last year it spent a third of its GDP fighting Russia. Where India with a $4tn economy had a $75bn defence budget in 2024, Ukraine spent $65bn on defence from its meagre and stagnant $180bn GDP. Guns Vs Butter That's the guns/butter trade-off of war. You can have more of one only at the cost of the other. As Eisenhower said: "Every gun that is made, every warship launched, every rocket fired signifies, in the final sense, a theft from those who hunger and are not fed..." It was 1953 and, perhaps, Eisenhower remembered how 3mn Indians had starved to death in the Bengal famine a decade earlier. Historians say the calamity wasn't caused by drought but the misplaced priorities of Churchill's wartime cabinet. True, there was a shortage of grain in Bengal in 1943, but London made it worse by continuing to export rice from the province for British troops. The price of grain skyrocketed, and when Indian officials sought an emergency supply of wheat, London declined. Saving Empire became more important than saving people. People suffer It doesn't matter who imposes war on whom - whether Russia invades Ukraine or Afghanistan erupts in civil war - non-combatants pay a high price. A UN Women research paper shows how the Afghan govt spent 37% of its budget on defence and policing in 2019, as against 6% on health. In Mali, another war-torn country, defence expenditure in 2017 was five times higher than the outlay for social programmes. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Contrast that with Kiel Institute's data for G7 nations. Over a 90-year period, from 1872 to 1962, their military expenditure exceeded social programmes, dipping below 20% of their budget only once, immediately after WW-1. But today, these nations spend less than 10% of their budget on defence, as against more than 40% on social expenditure. Under pressure from Trump, Nato members have pledged to raise defence spending to 5% of GDP by 2035, but don't count on it. No winners War can spur the economy - as it's done in Russia - by increasing demand for killing machines, but data shows a dollar spent on the military produces fewer jobs than a dollar spent on infrastructure, health, education, etc. The Vietnam war may have been good for US defence contractors, but it hurt ordinary Americans by starting an inflation spiral that lasted till the 80s. Likewise, the post-9/11 American wars diverted money away from infrastructure and the social sector, and have run up an $8tn bill. So, guns or butter? Sometimes, countries - like Ukraine - don't have a choice, but when they do - like Russia - they should pick butter, and a loaf of Borodinsky.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store