
Competition watchdog finalizes anti-greenwashing guidelines for businesses
The Competition Bureau said on Thursday that it is unable to make changes to the legislation, which has been the subject of heated debate. The guidelines are designed to help businesses ensure compliance, it said.
Companies, especially in natural resource industries, have complained the provisions prevent them from publishing anything about their environmental records and plans by putting them at risk of stiff penalties under the Competition Act.
The guidelines follow two rounds of public consultation about the new provisions in the act, which came into force almost a year ago with the passage of Bill C-59.
Is Ottawa's anti-greenwashing law helping or hurting Canadian companies?
Companies are at legal risk for making environmental assertions that do not stand up to scrutiny. Corporate communications over such things as emission reduction plans and net-zero ambitions must be backed up by international standards. Individuals and companies could face sizable fines if found liable.
Later this month, private parties will be able to make their own complaints to the federal Competition Tribunal in what is known as private right of action.
The bureau said its guidelines, which closely follow a draft version, do not prescribe whether companies can make environmental claims.
'Companies are free to make any environmental claims they wish, as long as they are not false or misleading, and have been adequately and properly tested or substantiated where required,' it said in a statement.
The finalized guidelines point out that provincial securities commissions, not the bureau, are responsible for securities regulation, and that disclosure requirements involving environmental factors are evolving. The agency said it will not review corporate filings made to regulators.
The catch, said Beth Riley, a competition lawyer with McMillan LLP, is that some material risks come under scrutiny in a private action if disclosure is reused, for example, on a corporate website or other public forum to promote a business interest or product not connected with the sale of securities.
'The sense of accountability for disclosure is a good thing, but I think the legislation, these new greenwashing provisions, are a bit unwieldly,' Ms. Riley said. 'When you capture them with the private right of action that's been granted at the same time, without transition or any case law on the new greenwashing provisions, the bureau is no longer the watchdog, or the gatekeeper, of how to engage in claims.'
Some large organizations have scrubbed their websites of environmental materials they had previously trumpeted.
In recent weeks, the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board abandoned its net-zero carbon emission target, citing 'recent legal developments in Canada' that have changed how such commitments are interpreted, including requiring adoption of standardized metrics and interim emission-reduction targets.
Its announcement came after Royal Bank of Canada dropped sustainable finance targets from its public communications, citing Bill C-59 provisions as one reason for the move.
Some business groups as well as the Alberta government criticize the legislation as overreach, though supporters say corporate decisions to expunge materials show it is working.
Still, environmental groups said they were disappointed the guidelines do not include more detail and practical advice for companies, as is the case in other countries.
'The recent changes to the act already appear to be weeding out greenwashing, but the federal government must continue to enact legislation and policy that mandate transparency and accountability from Canada's biggest polluters – as well as the financial institutions that enable them,' Matt Hulse, lawyer for the group Ecojustice, said in a statement.
Deciding which standards are used to back up assertions are a top concern. The bureau said it will recognize methodologies deemed credible in two or more countries that result in 'adequate and proper substantiation.' Many of them will be based in science.
Ms. Riley's colleague, Radha Curpen, McMillan's group head, sustainability and ESG, said several methodologies are widely recognized in areas such as tallying emissions and setting targets, including Greenhouse Gas Protocol, the International Organization for Standardization's life-cycle assessment and the Science Based Targets Initiative.
The key for companies when publishing environmental materials is to make sure they are subject to internal controls and governance, and determine who in the organization needs to sign off, Ms. Curpen said. 'Lots of people have already started this, but they need to align disclosures with risk management frameworks and all that. And be prepared for what could be a private right of action,' she said.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

CBC
33 minutes ago
- CBC
True sovereignty
Amidst all the buzz about the future of the Canadian Arctic, some Nunavummiut believe there's one voice missing — the young generation of Inuit who call this land home. Your browser does not support the video tag. Pause By Samuel Wat Jul. 27, 2025 Gazing at the land and water surrounding Apex Beach, Iqaluit's Manu Kunuk reflects on how his home in the Arctic has become a focal point for geopolitical tensions. There's a lot of uncertainty around the world right now, but if there's one thing he's sure about, that's the need for Inuit — and especially youth — to be at the heart of Arctic policy. 'We're the future of the land — we're going to be the next leaders,' he said. Like many Nunavummiut, Kunuk is still trying to learn about the true meaning of Arctic sovereignty, but he believes it starts with protecting the land and the people living on it. From a colonial perspective, sovereignty in Canada's North is often tied to military exercises, major infrastructure projects and defence spending — actions the government takes to show its control of the vast region. Less commonly explored is how Nunavut's communities and the people who live there are already at the heart of Arctic sovereignty. Nolan Qamanirq, from Arctic Bay, doesn't believe there is a word in Inuktitut that truly describes sovereignty, and it's hard to talk about land ownership because his ancestors didn't believe in that. 'The way the term is used today, especially in Ottawa and in places in Iqaluit, it really feels hollow. It's about military presence, mining approvals, transportation corridors. It's really not about what Inuit and communities prioritize,' he said. images expandAlassua Hanson set out on a Students on Ice expedition in the Arctic in 2016. This is one of several avenues she believes helps empower youth to become future leaders. The way the Canadian government is currently trying to reaffirm its borders in the Arctic makes Iqaluit's Alassua Hanson think back to the country's colonial history. 'I find the federal government does control Arctic sovereignty, in a way, because they did try to claim Nunavut before with the missionaries. And Inuit in general were trying to stay on their own land,' she said. These days, Hanson sees an increasing number of meetings, forums and summits about Arctic sovereignty. She believes some of those discussions should also happen inside the classroom and in youth groups. 'I think a lot of youth should be present or should be knowledgeable about ongoing things for Arctic sovereignty. And I don't think a lot of it is taught in school at all,' she said. Giving back to the community Three of Canada's main parties made military announcements in Iqaluit as part of their election campaign blitz earlier this year, but not all of those pledges involved consultation with local leaders. Nunavut's Premier, P.J. Akeeagok said he only learned about the Conservatives' Arctic announcement the day of, and he stressed the importance of consultations. Part of the Liberal government's own announcement in March was to establish three new military hubs in the North, with Iqaluit set to be home to one of them. At the time, the Department of National Defence said the hubs will consist of airstrips, logistics facilities and equipment and are intended to support military aircraft operations and also serve as storage for equipment and spare parts. 'Sovereignty isn't proven by planting a flag or opening a port. It's proven by a community's ability to feed itself, govern itself, and pass on knowledge without interference.' Nolan Qamanirq To many Canadian leaders, Iqaluit is a strategic location for missions in the Arctic. It has a functional airport and seaport that can accommodate both the navy and air force, for example, and it is also home to one of Canada's forward operating locations, which supports temporary missions. Yet Kunuk says he often struggles to find information about Arctic sovereignty and updates to what's happening in the territory. If the Canadian government is serious about sovereignty initiatives, he would like to see more information publicly shared about security developments. 'Hopefully community consultations, maybe even more training [if there is] supposed to be a military base here,' he said. Bringing Inuit into the conversation Despite all the talk, Hanson doesn't see much of a military presence in Nunavut. And when there is, she said she often doesn't see Inuit involved. She said she knows very little about what happens up in Alert, Nunavut, for example — the location of Canada's northernmost military outpost. She knows of a few people who head up there occasionally for work, but very few of them are Inuit. When there are members of the military in town, or people visiting for some Arctic security conference, she hasn't seen those visitors engaging much with the community. 'They could be more involved. They could provide food hampers, they could do a workshop on the meeting and what they're doing here. They could be present in the community rather than holding five day long meetings or get an opportunity to hear from the locals,' she said. She adds that youth should get the opportunity to hear about the results of the work these travellers are doing in the community. Creating global citizens Empowering Canada's future leaders has been a lifelong passion for Geoff Green. He founded Students on Ice (SOI) 25 years ago, which organizes educational expeditions — combining science and traditional knowledge — for youth to learn more about the Arctic. Talking about military spending and nation-building infrastructure projects is all well and good, he said, but he wonders where the investment is for youth. 'You're building a house of cards if you're not also investing in youth … they're going to be the ones we need for an upskilled workforce, and the leadership that's needed,' he said. In his view, a big part of youth empowerment comes from investments in education, plus programs to connect with the land and other youth around the world. He said there are more opportunities for youth nowadays compared to when he first founded SOI, but it's imperative that Canada builds on that. 'So engaging with youth from other parts of the world, seeing their worldviews, their knowledge bases, and having those friendships and relationships formed [early] are critical. We need global youth addressing global issues together,' he said. 'It's an investment in experiential education, which is truly one of the most proven and most powerful forms of education.' Kunuk echoes that sentiment, having been a delegate to international forums in the past, including to the Arctic Circle Assembly in Iceland last year. 'It really opens the doors for me, especially being here in Nunavut, in an isolated community and territory,' he said. images expandFor Manu Kunuk, Arctic sovereignty means ensuring the people living in the region are healthy and well. No flag or port can replace true sovereignty Ultimately, Qamanirq believes Arctic sovereignty can only exist if Canada recognizes the true priorities of northern communities. 'Sovereignty isn't proven by planting a flag or opening a port," he said. 'It's proven by a community's ability to feed itself, govern itself, and pass on knowledge without interference.' 'I don't think we need more youth leadership programs that teach us how to behave like bureaucrats. We need more programs that teach us our rights in our language, that explain what was negotiated in the land claims and what was left out," he added. Qamanirq also calls on Canada to be more open to partnerships with other countries in the circumpolar world, who share similar interests and challenges. 'If there was a serious attitude about sovereignty in the Arctic, [Canada] would let Inuit strengthen ties across the Arctic without forcing national policy filters. These connections are older than the borders and we shouldn't have to ask permission to remember them.' About the Author Footer Links My Account Profile CBC Gem Newsletters Connect with CBC Facebook Twitter YouTube Instagram Mobile RSS Podcasts Contact CBC Submit Feedback Help Centre Audience Relations, CBC P.O. Box 500 Station A Toronto, ON Canada, M5W 1E6 Toll-free (Canada only): 1-866-306-4636 TTY/Teletype writer: 1-866-220-6045 About CBC Corporate Info Sitemap Reuse & Permission Terms of Use Privacy Jobs Our Unions Independent Producers Political Ads Registry AdChoices Services Ombudsman Public Appearances Commercial Services CBC Shop Doing Business with Us Renting Facilities Accessibility It is a priority for CBC to create a website that is accessible to all Canadians including people with visual, hearing, motor and cognitive challenges. Closed Captioning and Described Video is available for many CBC shows offered on CBC Gem. About CBC Accessibility Accessibility Feedback © 2025 CBC/Radio-Canada. All rights reserved. Visitez


CBC
41 minutes ago
- CBC
Nova Scotia Power temporarily shut off power in part of Cape Breton to carry out repairs
A power outage affecting over 3,000 customers in the Whycocomagh area of Cape Breton was expanded for two hours at noon AT on Sunday as Nova Scotia Power carried out repairs. But as of 3:30 p.m. AT Sunday the utility's outage map showed that power had been restored to all affected areas. On Saturday night, over 9,000 customers were affected by the outage, which also included Chéticamp, Inverness, Mabou and Baddeck. Sunday's planned outage included customers in the areas that previously had their power restored. In a post on X, the utility said the additional outage was being done to ensure power could be safely restored to all areas. At one point, Sunday more than 11,000 customers were without electricity. Asked what the cause of the initial outage was, a Nova Scotia Power spokesperson said the company is focused on restoring power. Bonny MacIsaac, warden for the Municipality of the County of Inverness, said the outage coincided with the busy Inverness Gathering weekend. She said some businesses had to close as a result of the outage and haven't reopened. This includes the only grocery store in the community of Inverness, said MacIsaac.


CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
$500K lotto win a ‘big blessing' for Vancouver woman
Rowena Ibusca is shown in this photo provided by the B.C. Lotto Corporation. A Vancouver woman burst into tears after receiving life-changing news in a drug store earlier this month. Rowena Ibusca won a $500,000 LottoMax jackpot in the July 11 draw, splitting the Maxmillions prize with another lucky ticket holder in Ontario, according to a statement from the B.C. Lottery Corporation. 'When I scanned, I first thought it said $500, but then I scanned it again and just started crying. The first thing I said was, 'Is this true?'' Ibusca told the BCLC. When she went home and told her daughter, the tears of joy kept on flowing. 'We were both jumping and crying,' Ibusca said, recalling the moment she shared the news. Ibusca told the BCLC she still hasn't decided what to do with the windfall but described it as a 'big blessing' and a 'big help.' The odds of winning the Maxmillions prize are 3 in 99,884,400. Ibusca bought the winning ticket at the Point Grey Pharmacy on West 10th Avenue.