‘Manipulative': Expert slams states on sluggish shark net stance
Shark nets across NSW beaches are taken in annually from mid-autumn to mid-spring, however the NSW government is conducting a review to determine shark mitigation measures for the 2025-26 summer, including support from local councils on the continued use of shark nets.
Speaking to NewsWire, The University of Sydney associate professor and shark behaviour expert Christopher Pepin-Neff said he believed two simple premises lay at the heart of the issue; firstly, that shark nets catch fish (Sutherland Shire council reported a 13 times differential between non-target animals caught in nets compared with the targeted eight species of sharks), and secondly, that in getting caught, those fish struggle and die and attract sharks.
'Shark nets attract sharks,' he said. 'There is no way that science exists everywhere in the ocean except on netted beaches in NSW or Queensland.
'That the vibrations that struggling fish make attract sharks everywhere in the ocean except when they get caught in a net at a netted beach in Australia.
'If science still applies, then we have to conclude that shark nets attract sharks to local beaches.'
The decision to use shark nets is left to the state government, and during the 2024-25 season, 51 beaches between Newcastle and Wollongong used shark nets.
Professor Pepin-Neff said his principal objection to shark nets was that 'they are used by politicians when it is convenient for them to protect themselves by providing a false sense of security to the public'.
'Politicians know that the public has an idea that shark nets work and they are manipulating that public perception for their own benefit,' he said.
'It's a disgrace that in 2025, politicians have not come clean about the fact that shark nets and a lot of beach safety measures are mythical.
'For me, this is not an environmental issue; it is an issue of integrity in the policy process and respect for local constituents across Australia.'
The office of NSW Agriculture Minister Tara Moriarty declined to respond to NewsWire's request for comment; however Professor Pepin-Neff, received a letter from the Department of Primary Industries (DPIE) saying 'in 2024/25 the DPIE consulted the 25 coastal councils about their preferences for shark mitigation at beaches within their local government area'.
'The NSW government is currently considering the feedback from the councils as well as the evidence from the technologies used over the 2024/25 summer period to help inform the upcoming season,' the DPIE continued.
The Sutherland Shire in Sydney was one of the last councils in NSW to oppose the use of shark nets on its beaches. When the state government surveyed local councils in late 2024, councillors were presented with options and evidence for the various shark mitigation technologies.
Sutherland Shire councillor Kal Glaznig voted against the use of shark nets and speaking to NewsWire said 'just based on the evidence that was presented it was pretty clear that they're not the most effective tools to keep people safe'.
'I feel like it's a big education piece for beachgoers. The thing around shark nets and why there's a bit of hesitancy to take them out is this perceived safety, which from what I saw scientifically, there's no argument for,' he said.
'People in our community aren't getting in the ocean or not getting in the ocean because they feel like they're being saved with nets.'
Mr Glaznig said he couldn't speak for everyone, but during the council deliberation he didn't have a single constituent reaching out to say 'keep the nets in' but was instead inundated with community members who spent large amounts of time in the ocean saying they didn't believe the nets should be in.
'A lot of the evidence for me is around the fact that these nets have been here since 1937,' Mr Glaznig said. 'And I feel like if we just relied on existing measures for everything in life from nearly 100 years ago, we would be so backwards and behind.
'The ocean is such an unknown and you're never going to be able to control the elements, but you can definitely use better technologies and fuller solutions.' 

'My take for the state government is for them to hopefully listen to what the councils who are on the ground with the community are saying because ultimately we are more accessible than state ministers in getting the response and the feel from the community.
'And our community in the Sutherland shire is telling us that they don't want shark nets and the experts that presented made it super clear that shark nets were not the most effective way to keep people safe.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Australian
3 hours ago
- The Australian
Dickson MP Ali France honours late 19yo son Henry
The disabled, single mum who ended Peter Dutton's 24-year run in politics has shared the emotional, private battle behind her uphill campaign to unseat the former opposition leader at her third attempt. Giving her inaugural speech in parliament, Ali France said that while the 2025 federal campaign was 'obviously my best,' she remained heartbroken over the death of her 19-year-old son Henry, who lost his battle to leukaemia in February 2024. 'The 2025 campaign was obviously my best, and that is quite a bizarre thing because behind the curtain I was grieving and desperately wanting to hold my son Henry,' she told parliament. The 52-year-old became a Labor legend after she defeated Mr Dutton in the outer Brisbane seat of Dickson, a seat he had held since 2001. While the electorate was one of the country's most marginal at 1.7 per cent, Ms France achieved a 7.7 per cent swing. Former politician Ali France credited her election win to her 19-year-old son Henry, who died from leukaemia in 2024. Source: X Ali France MP delivered her inaugural speech in the House of Representatives at Parliament House on Tuesday. Picture: NewsWire / Martin Ollman Ms France, a former journalist and staffer to former Queensland premier Steven Miles, credited Henry, who she said was 'in another place, hopefully looking on with a big, wide smile,' as being 'instrumental' to her unexpected election win. She also shared a private moment in the days before his death, when Henry was able to return home from hospital 'for a couple of nights'. 'He asked to sleep in my bed, next to his mum, like he did for years when he was little,' she said, her voice occasionally breaking. 'I watched him breathe all night, in awe of him, his courage and his ability to smile every day despite unbelievable pain and the never-ending hospital stays and treatment. 'I am so grateful for those hours.' She said her son told her she would win the seat of Dickson. 'He told me many times, that this election was my time. He was convinced I would win and said a number of times, 'don't make me the excuse for you not doing important things,' she said. 'His words, his courage, were with me every day of the campaign. Henry was instrumental in getting me to this place.' Ali France, with the Prime Minister, was the first of the new MPs elected at the May 3 election to give their inaugural speech. Picture: NewsWire / Martin Ollman Ali France hugs the Prime Minister after giving her first speech to parliament on Tuesday. Picture: NewsWire / Martin Ollman Ms France also spoke about the 2011 car accident which resulted in the amputation of her leg. The incident occurred in the after a car crashed into her, and pinned her against another vehicle. At the time, Ms France was taking her youngest son Zac to a doctor's appointment, however she managed to push the child out of the car's path. She referred to the incident as the 'day I was supposed to die,' and thanked her trauma surgeon Martin Wullschleger, the bystanders and staff at the Royal Brisbane Hospital for saving her life. 'Martin's split-second decision to amputate my leg with a makeshift tourniquet saved me and ensured my kids had their mum,' she said. 'We kept in touch, Martin is in the gallery.' Ms France said that while she was told she was 'unlikely to ever work again,' she owed her recovery to a 'refugee (orthopaedic) surgeon from Iraq', Professor Munjed Al Muderis, who successfully completed a 'groundbreaking and risky' osseointegration surgery, which at the time had only been completed 25 times. Supporters of Ali France, including her son Zac and father Peter Lawlor (fourth and fifth from the left) were in the gallery for her inaugural speech. Picture: NewsWire / Martin Ollman Fellow Labor MPs applaud Ali France after her speech. Picture: NewsWire / Martin Ollman 'I've now been walking for 11 years – with a little help from my wheelchair,' she said. 'Munjed is in the gallery. And I am so grateful you stepped outside the boundaries of what was thought to be medically possible at the time. 'I literally would not be standing here today without you.' The Brisbane MP also paid a special tribute to Anthony Albanese and her former boss Mr Miles, and referred to them as her 'greatest political believers'. Notably the Prime Minister visited the seat of Dickson twice during the federal campaign, and began his election run in what was originally regarded as an unwinnable seat. 'When you're running for a third time, there will always be those who question if you're the right candidate,' she said. 'The Prime Minister and Steven have always been in my corner. 'Their support has meant I've continued to climb the mountain and succeed, when many others said I should step away.' The woman who beat Greens leader gives speech The woman who defeated another party leader at the election, Sarah Witty, has also given her first speech – highlighting the policy area that was key to the Greens. Sarah Witty, who upset Greens leader Adam Bandt to win back the seat of Melbourne for Labor after 15 years, has highlighted housing affordability as policy of concern. 'Most of Melbourne's high-density suburbs sit right here in the seat of Melbourne, and that places us at the very heart of the housing crisis,' said Ms Witty told parliament. Sarah Witty also made her first speech in the House of Representatives on Tuesday. Picture: NewsWire / Martin Ollman 'The crisis didn't happen overnight. It is a result of underinvestment from previous governments and blocking of good housing policies that has slowed progress and kept supply dangerously low. 'You must confront this crisis now with honesty and urgency and courage.' 'Safe, secure housing is not a luxury, it's a human right. Today, it's harder than ever to get into the housing market.' Meanwhile, another new Labor MP, Gabriel Ng, who won the seat of Menzies from rising Liberal star Keith Wolahan, citied Pauline Hanson as an inspiration for him to enter public life. Senator Hanson used her first speech in 1996 to warn that Australia was in danger of 'being swamped by Asians'. 'For the first time, I felt there were some in the population, maybe a sizeable number, who considered me less Australian because of my race,' Mr Ng, who is of Chinese-Singaporean descent, said in his first speech. 'I raise Miss Hanson's … speech not to elicit sympathy, but to remind all of us in this house, if we needed any reminding, that what we do in this place matters. 'Not only in the legislation we pass, but in the words we speak. 'We have one of the most powerful platforms in the nation, and I urge all of us in this parliament to turn away from opportunistic division and embrace and tell the story of modern Australia as it is.' Read related topics: Peter Dutton Jessica Wang NewsWire Federal Politics Reporter Jessica Wang is a federal politics reporter for NewsWire based in the Canberra Press Gallery. She previously covered NSW state politics for the Wire and has also worked at and Mamamia covering breaking news, entertainment, and lifestyle. @imjesswang_ Jessica Wang
West Australian
3 hours ago
- West Australian
UK shows off military might as Carrier Strike Group arrives in Darwin
The UK's Carrier Strike Group has arrived in Darwin as it undergoes an eight-month deployment to showcase its commitment to the security of the Indo-Pacific. Ahead of the fleet's arrival Britain's new High Commissioner Dame Sarah MacIntosh talked up the UK-Australia partnership as an 'anchor relationship in a dangerous world'. The prosperity and stability of the Euro-Atlantic and Indo-Pacific regions were 'indivisible,' she said. 'We are in an era of radical uncertainty, to be navigated with agility, speed and clarity.' Operation Highmast, led by Royal Navy flagship HMS Prince of Wales, embarked on its mission to the Pacific and Australia in late April as a signal of the British Government's intent to maintain a presence in the Indo-Pacific despite the war in Ukraine on Europe's doorstep. The international Task Group is made up of five core ships, 24 F-35 fighter jets, and 17 helicopters, centred around the UK's flagship aircraft carrier HMS Prince of Wales. Its deployment follows a British Government commitment to hike defence spending to 2.5 per cent of GDP by 2027, raising it well above Australia's projected target of 2.33 per cent by 2033. UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer went even further in June, pledging to boost Britain's overall defence and security spending to five per cent of economic output by 2035 to meet a NATO target – the highest level since the Cold War. Australia's Government has so far refused to follow its UK ally to lift its spending any higher, deferring to a defence review next year and a 'needs-based' approach despite pressure from the Trump administration to pour 3.5 per cent of GDP into defence spending. The participation of the UK's Carrier Strike Group in Australia's multinational exercise Talisman Sabre comes alongside Britain's renewed commitment to the $368 billion trilateral AUKUS program to provide nuclear-powered submarines to Australia. British AUKUS envoy Sir Stephen Lovegrove told the Australian Strategic Policy Institute earlier this month that London viewed AUKUS as a 'momentous collaboration' between three allies, playing down fears about an ongoing Pentagon review of the landmark project. More than 3,000 UK personnel are taking part in Talisman Sabre, the largest military exercise Australia has ever hosted, with the participation of 19 countries in total, including the United States. The UK contingent includes British Army and Royal Air Force units in drills to build towards 'full operational capability' of the UK's carrier strike group, said a statement from the High Commission. It said the deployment demonstrated British commitment to a free and open Indo-Pacific at a time when trade between the UK and the region accounted for 17 per cent of total UK trade in the 12 months to September 2024. ' The visit demonstrates how the UK is delivering on our Strategic Defence Review commitments to the Indo-Pacific,' said Dame Sarah MacIntosh. 'It's about turning policy into action, together with our allies and partners here in Australia.'
SBS Australia
5 hours ago
- SBS Australia
Ali France, who unseated Peter Dutton, delivers emotional first speech to parliament
Newly-elected Labor MPs Ali France and Sarah Witty delivered their first speeches to the House of Representatives on Tuesday night. Ali France, the MP who unseated Peter Dutton at the May election, paid tribute to her late son in an emotional maiden speech. France stunned political pundits when she beat Dutton, making him the first federal opposition leader to lose his own seat. 'He was convinced I would win' France spoke of the painful loss of her 19-year-old son Henry, who died from leukaemia in February 2024 after an 18-month battle. She said her late son was the driving force of her campaign. "He told me many times, that this election was my time," she said in the speech. "He was convinced I would win and said a number of times, 'don't make me the excuse for you not doing important things'. "His words, his courage, were with me every day of the campaign. Henry was instrumental in getting me to this place." France told the House of Representatives her journey to becoming an MP was not "a lifelong dream. Rather, it was hundreds of little steps." The single mother of two recalled the day she and her other son were hit by a car in 2011, in which she lost her leg, as a day she "was supposed to die". She was taking her youngest son Zac, then four years old, to an appointment at a Brisbane shopping centre when an out-of-control car came veering towards them. Her left leg was crushed from her thigh down as she was pinned against another vehicle. Martin Wullschleger, the trauma surgeon whose split-second decision to amputate saved France's life, was in the gallery to hear her maiden speech. Six surgeries in four years, PTSD and severe pain left France at the lowest point in her life. The refugee and surgeon also watched on from the gallery. 'People only saw disability' France described being pretty angry by the time she joined Labor in 2016. "Landing a job was incredibly difficult for me. People only saw disability," she said. She said her "epic journey" to sitting in federal parliament was not part of any grand plan, but rather the result of hundreds of little steps. France contested the seat of Dickson twice before defeating Dutton in the 2025 election. 'Our moment to fix the system' Experienced foster carer Sarah Witty beat former Greens leader Adam Bandt in the May election, and took the seat of Melbourne back to Labor for the first time in 15 years. It was one of the biggest upsets of the election and while she never expected to win, from her first day on the campaign trail, her appetite for change was clear. In her maiden speech, Witty thanked former Greens leader Adam Bandt, whom she unseated in the electorate of Melbourne. Labor member for Melbourne Sarah Witty delivered her first speech in the House of Representatives at Parliament House in Canberra on Tuesday. Source: AAP / Mick Tsikas The Richmond local also paid tribute to the city she now represents. "We are the home of the eight-hour working day and the union movement. The Victorian Trades Hall, the oldest continuously operating trades hall in the world, stands proudly in my electorate." Witty said Medicare, childcare and housing are at the top of her priorities for her constituents. "Homelessness is the harshest symptom of this failure," she said. "Safe houses are all that's needed… Without that foundation, everything else — health, work, education becomes so much harder. This is our moment to fix the system." She told the chamber that representing Melbourne is "not just an honour. It's a calling". "I bring with me the voices of renters demanding Justice, of people demanding climate action, of communities demanding to be heard, not managed." Witty and France were the first people elected at the May poll to give their maiden speech in the 48th parliament, with other first-term MPs to deliver their remarks in coming days. With additional reporting by the Australian Associated Press.
