‘Manipulative': Expert slams states on sluggish shark net stance
Shark nets across NSW beaches are taken in annually from mid-autumn to mid-spring, however the NSW government is conducting a review to determine shark mitigation measures for the 2025-26 summer, including support from local councils on the continued use of shark nets.
Speaking to NewsWire, The University of Sydney associate professor and shark behaviour expert Christopher Pepin-Neff said he believed two simple premises lay at the heart of the issue; firstly, that shark nets catch fish (Sutherland Shire council reported a 13 times differential between non-target animals caught in nets compared with the targeted eight species of sharks), and secondly, that in getting caught, those fish struggle and die and attract sharks.
'Shark nets attract sharks,' he said. 'There is no way that science exists everywhere in the ocean except on netted beaches in NSW or Queensland.
'That the vibrations that struggling fish make attract sharks everywhere in the ocean except when they get caught in a net at a netted beach in Australia.
'If science still applies, then we have to conclude that shark nets attract sharks to local beaches.'
The decision to use shark nets is left to the state government, and during the 2024-25 season, 51 beaches between Newcastle and Wollongong used shark nets.
Professor Pepin-Neff said his principal objection to shark nets was that 'they are used by politicians when it is convenient for them to protect themselves by providing a false sense of security to the public'.
'Politicians know that the public has an idea that shark nets work and they are manipulating that public perception for their own benefit,' he said.
'It's a disgrace that in 2025, politicians have not come clean about the fact that shark nets and a lot of beach safety measures are mythical.
'For me, this is not an environmental issue; it is an issue of integrity in the policy process and respect for local constituents across Australia.'
The office of NSW Agriculture Minister Tara Moriarty declined to respond to NewsWire's request for comment; however Professor Pepin-Neff, received a letter from the Department of Primary Industries (DPIE) saying 'in 2024/25 the DPIE consulted the 25 coastal councils about their preferences for shark mitigation at beaches within their local government area'.
'The NSW government is currently considering the feedback from the councils as well as the evidence from the technologies used over the 2024/25 summer period to help inform the upcoming season,' the DPIE continued.
The Sutherland Shire in Sydney was one of the last councils in NSW to oppose the use of shark nets on its beaches. When the state government surveyed local councils in late 2024, councillors were presented with options and evidence for the various shark mitigation technologies.
Sutherland Shire councillor Kal Glaznig voted against the use of shark nets and speaking to NewsWire said 'just based on the evidence that was presented it was pretty clear that they're not the most effective tools to keep people safe'.
'I feel like it's a big education piece for beachgoers. The thing around shark nets and why there's a bit of hesitancy to take them out is this perceived safety, which from what I saw scientifically, there's no argument for,' he said.
'People in our community aren't getting in the ocean or not getting in the ocean because they feel like they're being saved with nets.'
Mr Glaznig said he couldn't speak for everyone, but during the council deliberation he didn't have a single constituent reaching out to say 'keep the nets in' but was instead inundated with community members who spent large amounts of time in the ocean saying they didn't believe the nets should be in.
'A lot of the evidence for me is around the fact that these nets have been here since 1937,' Mr Glaznig said. 'And I feel like if we just relied on existing measures for everything in life from nearly 100 years ago, we would be so backwards and behind.
'The ocean is such an unknown and you're never going to be able to control the elements, but you can definitely use better technologies and fuller solutions.' 

'My take for the state government is for them to hopefully listen to what the councils who are on the ground with the community are saying because ultimately we are more accessible than state ministers in getting the response and the feel from the community.
'And our community in the Sutherland shire is telling us that they don't want shark nets and the experts that presented made it super clear that shark nets were not the most effective way to keep people safe.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
5 minutes ago
- ABC News
Australia urged to act on deep sea mining after moratorium fails
Global environmentalists are warning of long term damage to the earth's oceans after governments, including Australia, failed to agree to a moratorium on deep sea mining at a major meeting in Jamaica last week. The 30th session of the International Seabed Authority wrapped up on Friday with no deal, despite 37 countries voting for a moratorium or a 'cautionary pause'". But the ISA did agree to launch an official investigation into the actions of deep sea mining contractors which have applied for permits via the United States, after Donald Trump signed an executive order to open international waters, including the Pacific, to deep sea mining, not waiting for global agreement on the rules and safeguards. Guest: Helen Rosenbaum, Research Coordinator for the Deep Sea Mining Campaign
News.com.au
35 minutes ago
- News.com.au
ASX jumps in Monday trading after Trump announces more tariff deals
Australia's sharemarket snapped a brief two day losing streak on Monday after US President Donald Trump announced his latest trade deal and the major banks bounced back from their recent falls. The benchmark ASX 200 index closed up 30.8 points or 0.36 per cent at 8697.7 after hitting an intraday high of 8704.9, while the broader All Ordinaries finished in the green up 29.20 points or 0.33 per cent to 8,963.50. The Australian dollar slipped from a nine-month high on Friday buying 65.51 US cents at the time of writing. On an overall positive day, eight of the 11 sectors finished in the green, led by the telecommunications sector, the big four banks and healthcare stocks. Shares in Telstra gained 0.81 per cent to $4.95, REA Group jumped 1.34 per cent to $236.09 and CAR group added 1.72 per cent to $37.89. Market heavyweight CBA gained 1.17 per cent to $174.90 offsetting half the falls in recent days, while NAB gained 0.67 per cent to $37.76, Westpac added 0.54 per cent to $33.21 and ANZ group closed 0.30 per cent higher at $30.31. Healthcare darling CSL gained 1 per cent to $270.59, Sigma Healthcare added 1.41 per cent to $2.88 and ResMed finished 0.97 per cent higher to $41.70. The markets jumped after US President Donald Trump announced a deal with the EU to end four months of negotiations between the two economic powerhouses. Following the discussions, the EU will face a 15 per cent tariff from the US, which is down from the 25 per cent the President announced in April. European Commission chief Ursula von de Leyen described it as 'a big deal, a huge deal, bringing: stability and predictability' to the two trading partners. IG market analyst Tony Sycamore said global markets around the world jumped on these trade deals. 'In terms of the trade deals with Japan and Europe, the tariff rate that will be implemented came in lower than initially threatened and the market is looking very positively on it,' Mr Sycamore said. Uranium shares were one of the rare misses during Monday's trading, dragged down by news out of Boss Energy which flagged challenges out of its Honeymoon uranium project. Boss Energy shares plummeted 43.97 per cent to $1.90, Deep Yellow fell 8.34 per cent to $1.65 and Paladin Energy dropped 4.43 per cent to $6.91. 'That is the uranium sector in a nutshell,' he said. 'It is one where you have to be prepared for extraordinary volatility. 'This was a disappointing performance day and a disappointing report by Boss Energy.' In company news, Helloworld Travel shares soared 14.14 per cent to $1.69 after the business upgraded its guidance to somewhere between $58-$62m. Stealth Group's shares also soared 11.02 per cent to $0.70 after announcing a 50 per cent jump in pre-orders on the back of the soon to be released iPhone 17. Bubs Australia shares jumped 2.94 per cent to $0.18 after the infant formula maker announced Joe Cootes as its new chief executive, effective immediately.
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
NSW premier resists calls for pro-Palestinian 'March for Humanity' on Sydney Harbour Bridge
The NSW premier has opposed calls for a mass pro-Palestinian march across Sydney Harbour Bridge, saying he "cannot allow Sydney to descend into chaos". Palestine Action Group Sydney proposed the march for Sunday, August 3, to address the "extraordinary situation" in Gaza. It said it chose the bridge as "Australia's most iconic symbol" to send a "powerful message to the world". "Thousands of aid trucks remain stranded at crossings outside Gaza, as Israel starves the Palestinian population," a spokesperson said. More than 100 humanitarian agencies have warned the strip was facing mass starvation due to Israeli restrictions on essentials and aid. Palestinian health authorities said 133 people had died from starvation in the last week, including 87 children. Rallies in support of the Palestinian people have drawn thousands across the country since the Hamas terrorist attacks on Israel on October 7, 2023. Israel has denied its actions have caused a starvation crisis, and instead blames Hamas for creating the situation. Premier Chris Minns said the NSW government could not "support the protest of this scale and nature" on the bridge on a week's notice. "The bridge is one of the most critical pieces of infrastructure in our city — used every day by thousands of people," he said. "Unplanned disruption risks not only significant inconvenience, but real public safety concerns. "We cannot allow Sydney to descend into chaos." Palestine Action Group Sydney said there was "nothing chaotic about people marching for peace, to stop mass starvation". "If the premier says we need more time to plan such an event, then would he agree to support the 'March for Humanity' a week later? "We call on NSW authorities to work with us to plan this event and stand on the right side of history." A spokesperson for the group added it had lodged a form with police for its intentions with the "March for Humanity". NSW Police said it was aware of the proposed planned assembly and was "consulting relevant stakeholders". Mr Minns added that the force "were in discussions with organisers about other routes they can take" and were "working to ensure community safety is upheld". Opposition Leader Mark Speakman acknowledged the situation was tragic but said the bridge "belongs to everyone". "I can understand people have sincere and passionate views about what is happening in the Middle East, which whichever way you look at it, it is a tragedy," Mr Speakman said. "The failure to release hostages is a tragedy, the initial terrorist attack is a tragedy … and what is happening to innocent people in Gaza is a tragedy." But Mr Speakman said there were "plenty" of alternative ways to protest and "other venues where the protesters can march". "Absolutely they should not be taking over the harbour bridge," he said. NSW Greens MP Sue Higginson said on Monday the party endorsed the march and that it was "time for action".
