Dying teen transferred, family told to arrange return of his body
They were further distressed by being told they needed to organise his body's repatriation to his hometown.
A complaint about the 19-year-old's care was referred to Health and Disability Commissioner by the coroner.
The young man – who died in 2015 – had undergone an operation in January that year related to his type 2 neurofibromatosis – a genetic condition that causes benign tumours to develop on nerves, particularly those in the skull and spine.
There were complications due to a post-operative infection and meningitis, which was treated successfully at a secondary hospital.
ADVERTISEMENT
The man – who was referred to in the commissioner's report as Mr B – continued to suffer from fluid building up around the brain and required regular release of cerebrospinal fluid through lumbar puncture.
He was admitted to hospital with ongoing headaches and vomiting in April.
A decision was made to hold off on further lumbar punctures due to concerns it could cause a hernia and to transfer him to another hospital via an air retrieval team.
The transfer was delayed due due to staffing issues and a lack of an available air ambulance.
Deputy commissioner Dr Vanessa Caldwell said Mr B was neurologically stable at the time and his transfer was scheduled for the next day.
However, while waiting he collapsed and his heart stopped.
He was then urgently transferred to another hospital, but his condition deteriorated and at the second hospital he was declared brain dead.
ADVERTISEMENT
Mr B's family told the commissioner they did not understand why he was not transferred by road when the air retrieval team was not available, and they did not understand why he was transferred to another hospital when his prognosis was poor.
The transfer meant they did not have a chance to say goodbye to him before his death.
The family also said they were asked if they would donate his organs only minutes after being told he was brain dead, which left them little time to consider their options.
They were also told by a social worker it was up to them to organise transport of his body back to where they lived, even though he qualified for travel assistance.
Health NZ apologised for the distress caused by the discussion related to organ donation and the miscommunication regarding transporting Mr B's body.
Dr Caldwell said the care provided to the man was at an appropriate standard and decisions, such as the air transfer, were made appropriately based on the information available to the team at the time.
Incorrect and minimal information was provided to the family once the man died and this had been particularly distressing for them, she said.
ADVERTISEMENT
She also had concerns about the communication between the air retrieval team and the teams treating Mr B.
Health New Zealand breached the patient's right to information under the Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers' Rights, the commissioner said.
A number of changes had been made since the young man's death, including the establishment of Health NZ, Dr Caldwell said.
The morning's headlines in 90 seconds, including wintry blast on the way, Gloriavale leader in court, and Liam Lawson picks up points. (Source: Breakfast)
"I am also mindful that providing recommendations at this stage for errors that happened some time ago is likely to have limited practical benefit."
She recommended Health NZ Southern and Health NZ Waitaha Canterbury provided a formal written apology for the breaches identified in the report within three weeks.
rnz.co.nz
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
5 hours ago
- RNZ News
What you need to know about Wednesday's nurses strike
Nurses held an 8-hour strike last December. A new strike is planned for 24 hours on Wednesday. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone Nurses are going on strike on Wednesday. About 36,000 nurses, midwives and health care assistants will be off the job from 9am Wednesday to 9am Thursday. Last-ditch negotiations on Monday failed to reach an agreement . There will be pickets and marches throughout the country. Nurses are concerned about staffing levels and safety . The latest pay offer was also dismissed as a "massive backward step" . Health NZ is offering a 3 percent pay rise over 27 months, plus two lump sum payments of $325. NZNO's counter-offer seeks a 5 percent pay rise over two years, along with $2000 flat rate increases for senior positions. The union also seeks to restore a Tikanga Māori allowance. "The average salary for both senior and registered nurses, including overtime, PDRP allowance, and penal rates, is $125,662, Health NZ said . "Members also need a wage offer that enables them to meet the rising cost of living without them and their whānau going backwards financially for the important mahi they do," said Paul Goulter, chief executive of the New Zealand Nurses Organisation. "We believe the offer we have made to the union is a fair one given our current financial constraints," Health NZ said. In a statement, Health New Zealand said "we are disappointed that the New Zealand Nurses Organisation (NZNO) is taking strike action when there is a fair offer on the table." "We are concerned about the impact strike action will have on patients who are waiting for planned care." Goulter said the latest offer from Health New Zealand ignores worries about safe staffing . "Patients are at risk because of short staffing. Nurses, midwives and health care assistants are stretched too thin and can't give patients the care they need. This is heartbreaking for our exhausted members who became health care workers because they want to help people." A safe staffing agreement was dropped from negotiations with Health New Zealand. Figures obtained by NZNO from Health New Zealand show surgical hospital wards were short-staffed more than half of all day shifts last year. Health New Zealand said in their statement it also seeks to keep nurses and patients safe. "While we are aware of NZNO's commentary in recent weeks we would like to reassure New Zealanders that Health NZ is completely committed to safe staffing. "For us safe staffing in a busy hospital environment includes the skills mix of the staff, the way care is provided, strong clinical judgement, flexibility and thoughtful decision making from our experienced leaders on the frontline. We take responsibility for operational and patient safety decisions seriously as we are accountable for the safety of patients who access our services." Paul Goulter, chief executive of the New Zealand Nurses Organisation. Photo: RNZ / Nate McKinnon Goulter said the key issue was making sure there was enough staff to "ensure patient safety", which was "foremost in the minds of our members" during negotiations. "While, obviously, there's a wage element, we're trying to do our best to ensure we get staffing that's appropriate to meet what patients need and we seem to have come up short on that," he told RNZ recently. Negotiations began last October, but the union said bargaining had stalled over "big ticket items" centred on public safety. Nurses also walked off the job in strike in December for eight hours. "We are striking because patient safety is at risk every day due to chronic understaffing and under-resourcing," Wellington nurse Hilary Gardner said. "We simply don't have enough nurses to provide the level of care our patients need and deserve. It's not safe, and it's not fair - for patients, their whānau, or the staff trying to care for them. We've raised concerns time and time again, but nothing changes - so now we're taking action to stand up for safer care." Acute and emergency services will still be provided, including maternity care, intensive care, ambulance services and emergency departments. Patients already in hospital will still receive ongoing care. "... The public can be reassured that we have an agreement with NZNO for life preserving services support throughout the strike and our hospitals and emergency departments will remain open," Health NZ Chief Executive Dr Dale Bramley said. "To maintain patient safety, most clinics will be closed. However, if you have a hospital appointment, please come to your appointment unless we have contacted you directly to reschedule." However, most appointments for the strike days will be rescheduled. "It is estimated that 4300 planned procedures and specialist appointments would have to be postponed should the 24-hour strike action on 30 and 31 July go ahead," Dr Bramley said. Aged residential care, St John Ambulance, GPs and hospice services are not affected by the strike and will carry on as normal. Anyone unsure about whether they need emergency department care should contact their GP or call Healthline 0800 611 116 for free advice. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone The union does not rule out further action if their concerns aren't met, Goulter said. "Our members have indicated this strike is just the beginning and they are in it for the long haul." "Our members don't take this action lightly. They are striking because they are exasperated with being short-staffed and their patients being put at risk because Te Whatu Ora refuses to resource safe staffing levels and instead staffs to an arbitrary budget set by the government. "The public know that when there aren't enough nurses, patients wait longer to get the care they need. Critical observations and treatments may be delayed, errors are more likely and health outcomes worsen. A lack of nurses has reduced numbers of elective surgeries for years and contributed to longer waiting times and the current backlog. "Any member of the public who has been to a hospital recently knows the reality for patients and the nurses, midwives, health care assistants and kaimahi hauora who care for them." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Scoop
12 hours ago
- Scoop
Common-Sense Change Clears Way For Counsellors
Minister for Mental Health Mental Health Minister Matt Doocey says the completion of a revised accreditation process has removed an unnecessary workforce barrier preventing more than 330 experienced counsellors from working in publicly funded mental health services. Health New Zealand, in partnership with the New Zealand Association of Counsellors (NZAC), has finalised a strengthened accreditation pathway for counsellors. 'This is a common-sense step that unlocks existing workforce capacity at a time of high demand,' Mr Doocey says. 'I've been clear from day one, workforce shortages are one of the key barriers to delivering timely mental health support for New Zealanders in their time of need. 'This is a practical and common-sense decision that ensures we're making full use of the experienced counsellors already working in our communities.' Previously, counsellors were excluded from publicly funded roles due to a lack of formal regulation. In response, Health NZ, alongside the largest counselling membership and accredited professional body, NZAC, worked on one recognised and robust accreditation pathway. 'With more than 330 counsellors now eligible through this expanded pathway, the move is expected to bolster primary mental health workforce initiatives. 'Driving down mental health and addiction vacancies and making better use of underutilised workforces like peer support specialists and counsellors is common sense. 'We are starting to turn the corner with reducing wait times and increasing the workforce. We have more mental health nurses, psychologists, support workers and addiction counsellors working on the ground, and overall vacancy rates are starting to ease. 'While many challenges remain, this is yet another step this Government is taking to turn the corner on the longstanding mental health workforce vacancies. 'When someone is making the brave step of reaching out to get support, workforce should never be a barrier.'
RNZ News
12 hours ago
- RNZ News
Dargaville Hospital loses its only full-time doctor
Dargaville Hospital has lost its last full-time doctor. Photo: RNZ / Peter de Graaf Dargaville Hospital has lost its last full-time doctor, the latest setback in a staffing crisis affecting many rural hospitals around the country. Health New Zealand said the doctor's departure is unfortunate, but it has enough staff to keep the hospital running on the current roster, and there won't be any change to staffing levels in place since late last year. The 12-bed Northland hospital came close to shutting down last October when it could no longer find enough doctors to fill the 24-hour roster. The inpatient ward now runs without a doctor most nights. Instead, overnight care is provided by nurses backed up by a telehealth service, in which a doctor at another location offers advice via phone or video call when needed. Hopes of returning to 24-hour medical cover slipped further out of reach at the end of June with the loss of the hospital's only remaining full-time doctor. Rural medicine specialist Josh Griffiths, a member of the ASMS doctors' union, said the hospital now had two-and-a-half full-time-equivalent (FTE) doctors, when four were needed. "We were already not in a great place, staffing wise. When she was here, we were down to about two thirds of our job-sized FTEs. With her gone, that takes us down to about half." Dr Griffiths said the doctor's departure was a blow because she was committed to Dargaville - she had even bought a home in the town - and had specifically sought a position in rural Northland when she was recruited from the US about three years ago. Dr Griffiths said the remaining doctors were doing extra day shifts to fill the roster, but that was balanced by fewer night shifts now the hospital no longer had a doctor on duty 24 hours. They had, however, hoped to return to 24-hour cover at some point. "This just takes us a step further away from reinstating full services, which is really disheartening," he said. Dargaville Hospital serves about 27,000 people living in the town (pictured) and surrounding Kaipara District. Photo: Peter de Graaf/RNZ Mike Shepherd, acting deputy chief executive for Health NZ's northern region, said Kaipara residents continued to receive the same level of service from Dargaville Hospital as they had since November. "We have received the resignation of one of our doctors and clearly that's unfortunate, but we continue to have enough doctors to staff the roster without impacting the service for patients," he said. "We're continuing to actively recruit to further staff, as you'd expect, and we don't anticipate any change to service to the community." Shepherd said Health NZ had yet to decide whether to try to reinstate 24-hour cover. "We're having that conversation... Our priority at the moment is to continue to provide what we are providing. We think we're providing a good service during the day, and a safe service overnight using the range of treatment and staff that we have." Shepherd said the number of calls nurses were making to Emergency Consult, the hospital's telehealth provider, had decreased as they became more skilled at managing issues in the ward overnight. Meanwhile, Dr Griffiths said he had mixed views on telehealth. He believed it was safe and essential, because it was filling a gap that could have otherwise forced the hospital to close. "But it doesn't always work out great for patients. We now transfer anyone unstable to Whangārei but that means a massive increase in the use of ambulance transfers, which is a problem for St John who are also struggling with staffing in rural areas. It's also problematic for patients who want to be cared for close to home." Dr Griffiths said it also put extra strain on Whangārei Hospital, because patients that could have been treated in Dargaville were now sent there. Another problem was that patients who were not particularly ill could not be sent home because they could not be fully assessed overnight. "So they're either transferred to Whangārei or kept in Dargaville overnight where they can be monitored, and the next day the doctor has an increase in workload because stuff's been deferred from overnight... So, it's safe, but it's clearly sub-optimal, and a lot of patients tell me that they're dissatisfied because they can't really be dealt with by telehealth, they're just deferred or transferred." Dr Griffiths said he was "really proud" of the way Dargaville's nurses had stepped up. "It's resulted in a lot of upskilling, and nurse management has taken a proactive stance by trying to get people through courses to educate them more on managing emergencies in a way they wouldn't have had to previously, because the doctor would have taken the lead," he said. "Some of them have taken to it really well. Others are not really happy because it's different to what they signed up for. I'm also worried about our senior nurses, because they're compensating for the lack of doctor cover by being on call for critical issues 24/7, and sharing that amongst themselves." Dr Griffiths acknowledged that recruiting doctors was difficult worldwide, not just in Dargaville. "But I do think there are specific things that could be done better, which we've pushed for, and we've had a really lacklustre response." In particular, he said Health NZ should increase the rural recruitment and retention bonus paid to doctors who took up jobs in hard-to-staff places like Dargaville. As for the improved after-hours medical service promised in May by Health Minister Simeon Brown, Dr Griffiths said it was a positive move, but he was surprised no one at the hospital had heard about it before the announcement. He hoped officials would talk to locals and find out what was needed, rather than impose a top-down solution. Brown told RNZ the $164 million programme to expand and strengthen after-hours healthcare across the country would be rolled out during 2026 and 2027. He said Health NZ was currently considering the model and specific timing for the service. Within Northland, better after-hours access would be provided in Dargaville, Hokianga, Kaikohe, Kaitaia, Kawakawa, Mangawhai and Waipapa. Health NZ was also working on improved access to daytime urgent care in Dargaville, he said. Brown said he also expected Health NZ to continue recruiting clinical staff for Dargaville Hospital. "I have received assurances that Health NZ are doing so, and that existing services for patients will be maintained while this is underway," he said. Dargaville Hospital serves a population of about 27,000 people. The nearest secondary-level hospital is at Whangārei, about an hour's drive away on State Highway 14. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
