Ed Miliband 'abandons zonal electricity pricing' plan that would have charged people in southern England more for power than Scots
The Energy and Net Zero Secretary had been examining the idea of 'zonal pricing', which would reflect what it costs to produce and supply energy in each region, rather than what is currently a single countrywide price.
It would have meant people living near wind farms or other clean power projects - most common in upland rural areas - paying less for electricity than those living in other parts of Britain.
Supporters of a move to zonal pricing, such as Octopus Energy boss Greg Jackson, claim it could bring down bills overall, saving households billions of pounds on their energy bills.
It could also be used to entice energy-hungry tech firms away from the South towards Scotland and the North
But critics had warned it could create a 'postcode lottery' for homeowners and lead to a fragmented system.
The Guardian reported that Mr Miliband had decided not to go ahead with the scheme - first suggested by the Conservatives - after receiving warnings that it could put off investors and make it harder to build wind farms.
'The government has been weighing this up carefully and concluded that the benefits of delivering the clean power mission at pace, particularly given the expected impact of imminent grid upgrades; the need to deliver on the coming renewables auctions; and the significant risk premium being attributed to the UK by international investors, would outweigh the purported benefits of zonal pricing – which at any rate would take beyond the next election to implement,' a source told the paper.
However, Mr Miliband was criticised by campaigners who argued that not going ahead would raise bills for everyone in the long run.
Sam Richards, chief executive of the Britain Remade campaign, tweeted: 'If reports are true this will lock *everyone* - not just Scotland - into higher bills for years as we will spend billions switching off wind farms when it's windy (rather than allowing them to sell power dirt cheap locally). A mistake.'
Mr Jackson's company commissioned research that found Britons could save between £55-74billion by 2050 on electricity bills if the Government adopts zonal pricing.
It is also claimed zonal pricing is a more efficient system and could address regional inequalities in the UK by boosting investment in areas where there is cheaper energy.
Tech giants are putting pressure on ministers to encourage an AI data centre boom in remote areas of Britian by offering some of the cheapest electricity prices in Europe.
But opponents said zonal pricing would merely create a 'postcode lottery' for energy bills, with those in the south facing sharply increased costs.
In April Ecotricity founder Dale Vince said: 'Tens of millions could end up paying more for their energy than they do now. It makes no sense when Labour's mission is about cutting bills for all rather than a few.
'Zonal pricing is being presented as a solution but it's madness. Fragmenting our energy market into 12 different regions would create complexity, delays and unfairness.'
Today he tweeted: 'Zonal is toast.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
24 minutes ago
- The National
Threat of industrial action averted as council workers agree pay deal
Unite the union announced on Thursday that 77% of its members backed the deal offered by local authority body Cosla, while GMB said 66% voted in favour. The deal will see a 4% increase in pay this year and 3.5% next year, with both unions joining Unison – which accepted the proposal earlier this week – in backing it. READ MORE: 'Trading people like cargo': UK-France 'one in, one out' deal sparks fury With union members backing the proposal, the chance of strike action among non-teaching council staff has been averted this year. Sharon Graham, the general secretary of Unite, said: 'The deal negotiated by Unite will boost pay packets and provide stability for our members. 'Unite is once again delivering better jobs, pay and conditions for our Scottish council members.' (Image: PA) Keir Greenaway, the GMB union's senior organiser for public services, said the offer 'does not do enough' for the lowest paid staff despite the vote to back it. 'We argued and will continue to argue for pay offers to be a flat increase to the hourly rate of every council worker,' he said. 'A percentage increase means the highest-paid council staff will receive thousands of pounds more each year while frontline workers get pennies more each hour. 'This offer does not do enough for them and it does not do enough to reach a minimum wage of £15 an hour which ministers continue to insist is their ambition.'
The Herald Scotland
25 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
UK retains national electricity price, scrapping zonal plan
Under that system, areas with abundant renewable generation — such as Scotland — would have benefited from lower prices, while consumers in southern England, where more energy is consumed than produced, would likely have paid more. READ MORE Supporters of zonal pricing, including Octopus Energy chief executive Greg Jackson, said it could save billions of pounds a year by improving grid efficiency. However, the proposal faced widespread opposition from other energy firms, unions and some charities. Miliband said: 'Building clean power at pace and scale is the only way to get Britain off the rollercoaster of fossil fuel markets and protect families and businesses for good. 'As we embark on this new era of clean electricity, a reformed system of national pricing is the best way to deliver an electricity system that is fairer, more affordable, and more secure — at less risk to vital investment in clean energy than other alternatives.' The Scottish Government said Miliband must now set out how he plans to deliver lower energy bills, as promised in Labour's manifesto. Net Zero and Energy Secretary Gillian Martin said: 'The UK Government promised to cut bills — instead, they have increased. 'They need to set out immediately how they will sort out the high energy bills faced by the people of Scotland. In an energy-rich country like Scotland, people should not be struggling to pay their bills. 'They promised that bills would fall by £300, but bills are higher than they were this time last year. 'The UK Government have set out what they will not do; they now need to set out what they will do to bring bills down. 'Given the significance of Scotland's renewables sector, the Scottish Government must be fully involved in decisions on reforming the national energy market in a way that brings down bills and delivers a level playing field for renewables in Scotland.' Gillian Martin said the UK Government needed to spell out how it would bring down bills (Image: PA) British Gas owner Centrica welcomed the decision, with chief executive Chris O'Shea calling it a 'common sense decision' and arguing that the 'theoretical benefits never stacked up against the real-world risks' of zonal pricing. Energy firm SSE also backed the move, describing it as 'much-needed policy clarity'. Chief executive designate Martin Pibworth said: 'Zonal pricing would have added risk at a time when the UK needed to accelerate its clean power transition, making energy bills more expensive.' The Government said the decision was part of a wider reform package that will see ministers take more control over planning the energy system and the location of clean energy infrastructure. At the centre of this is the Strategic Spatial Energy Plan, commissioned by the UK, Scottish and Welsh governments last year, which will 'set out how to best spread new energy projects across land and sea in Great Britain up to 2050'. The Government says the plan will speed up development, reduce grid connection delays and help cut costs. READ MORE Scottish Secretary Ian Murray said the reforms were 'great news' for Scottish jobs. 'We have listened to Scottish industry and made a positive decision to reform our energy market, ensuring consumers feel the benefit of our clean energy mission,' he said. 'Bills are already falling in Scotland and we'll bring them down for good by getting off the rollercoaster of foreign gas, and winning the race to clean power. 'This decision will safeguard the investment required to win that race and secure thousands of good Scottish jobs for decades to come. 'This package of measures will create a predictable climate for Scottish industry and ensure the whole of Scotland benefits from our clean energy future.'
The Independent
29 minutes ago
- The Independent
Clean energy delays to hit household bills
The National Energy System Operator (Neso) has warned that delays to critical clean energy projects could cost UK consumers approximately £4.2 billion in 2030. These delays primarily concern three vital grid projects in East Anglia and the southeast, which are essential for connecting offshore wind farms. Neso's assessment indicates that without these projects, the UK's clean power objective for 2030 will not be achieved, leading to significant constraint costs. The government may need to compensate offshore wind farm developers for switching off turbines due to grid limitations, with these costs potentially passed on to households. Separately, the government has announced it is dropping plans for energy pricing zones, opting to maintain a single national wholesale price for electricity.
