Carney responds to Indigenous criticism of project fast-track bill, says consultation is ‘at the heart' of C-5
He made the comments Thursday after opposition parties amended the bill in committee to address some of the concerns expressed by Indigenous groups.
Bill C-5 creates two new federal laws. The Free Trade and Labour Mobility in Canada Act aims to eliminate federal barriers to interprovincial trade and that section has been relatively uncontroversial.
However, Indigenous and environmental advocates in particular have expressed strong concern with the bill's second element, The Building Canada Act, which aims to help implement a Liberal campaign pledge to fast track approvals for large infrastructure projects that are in the national interest.
The general premise of the bill is that it would allow cabinet to list specific large projects as national priorities and then exempt them from the application of various laws, or aspects of laws, in order to speed up the approval process.
Critics say the proposed changes would weaken existing requirements related to Indigenous consultation and environmental protection.
Chartrand on Bill C-5: 'We do have to have consent from Indigenous rights holders'
At a news conference Thursday, Mr. Carney was asked to respond to those concerns.
'The first thing is that at the heart of this legislation is section 35 of our Constitution. At the heart is not just respect for, but full embrace of free, prior and informed consent. It has to be seen as well, in parallel, with very major measures that this government is taking to not just support those partnerships, but also to finance equity ownership in these nation-building projects for Indigenous peoples, Indigenous groups, Indigenous rights holders,' he said.
He then added that the legislation lays out a process for consulting and working with Indigenous peoples in the process of selecting specific projects.
'Consultation, co-operation, engagement, participation is at the heart of C-5 and that is how you build a nation. And that's very much how we've designed it,' he said.
The bill was reported back to the House of Commons Thursday by the transport committee, which approved a long list of amendments.
Conservative MP and committee member Philip Lawrence said in a statement that the amendments ensure that the government can't use the legislation to circumvent a host of laws, such as the Lobbying Act, the Conflict of Interest Act and the Indian Act.
Assembly of First Nations National Chief Cindy Woodhouse Nepinak urged MPs during a committee hearing Wednesday to allow more time for the bill to be studied and to remove the Indian Act from a list of laws that could be circumvented.
What federal Bill C-5, the One Canadian Economy Act, is all about
She said in an interview Thursday morning that her organization was analyzing the amendments to the bill.
She thanked the Conservatives and the Bloc Québécois for removing the original bill's reference to the Indian Act.
She reiterated that the AFN is still very disappointed that First Nations rights holders were shut out of the legislative process. A couple of chiefs are for the bill, she said, while many are not.
'They are not having a chance to be heard,' she said.
Ms. Woodhouse Nepinak said she was concerned that the original power to circumvent the Indian Act could have been used to override First Nations rights. An AFN staff member told the transportation committee this week that they never received an explanation from the government as to why the Indian Act was referenced in the original bill.
Crown-Indigenous Relations Minister Rebecca Alty, speaking to the Senate on Tuesday, said that when moving forward with projects, some communities are subjected to 'archaic provisions' under the Indian Act. She said any exemption to advance a project would be in consultation with First Nations.
Government House Leader Steven MacKinnon said Thursday that cabinet ministers are reviewing the committee's amendments.
He later said in the House that he hopes to have the legislation adopted before Canada Day.
Friday is the last scheduled sitting day of the House of Commons before breaking for summer until mid-September.
The Senate is scheduled to sit next week and is expected to give final approval to C-5.
NDP MP Leah Gazan strongly criticized the bill in Question Period, predicting it will lead to court challenges.
'Indigenous rights holders and civil-society groups have been clear: Bill C-5 violates constitutional rights, escalates the climate crisis and endangers workers health and safety,' she said.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


CBC
14 minutes ago
- CBC
Happy Valley-Goose Bay SPCA struggling to get by this summer
Labrador's only SPCA animal shelter is once again pleading for help as it struggles to keep operations going. Bonnie Learning, a longtime volunteer with the Happy Valley-Goose Bay SPCA, said the summer months have been financially difficult in recent years. She said fundraising is getting harder for the non-profit organization. "The cost of living is going up," Learning said in an interview with CBC Radio's Labrador Morning on Monday. "There's not as much disposable income to donate or spend otherwise. "It's hard for everybody, including not-for-profits and charities," she said. Learning said the organization spends about $400,000 on its operations every year. Seventy per cent of that money goes toward full-time employees' wages and vet bills for the animals, she said. However, the former vice-president said the SPCA ensures those two expenses are covered, no matter what the financial situation is. The staff instead has to make decisions on what brand of dog food to buy, for example. The small shelter — home to cats, dogs and other small animals for adoption or fostering — holds a variety of fundraisers throughout the year, but Learning said their most helpful ones don't happen until fall. In a social media post, Learning said if the shelter doesn't get more monetary support, it will have to stop all intake of new animals by the end of October. The Happy Valley-Goose Bay SPCA hosts a monthly 50/50 fundraiser, and has several more events planned for the end of July and throughout August.


CBC
20 minutes ago
- CBC
Inclusive rite of passage + India's court backlog
The National is invited to an Indigenous-led camp in Alberta, working to inspire a renewal of rite of passage ceremonies by making them more inclusive. Plus, what's behind India's massive court backlog.


Toronto Star
36 minutes ago
- Toronto Star
Premiers entering final day of meetings with public safety, internal trade on agenda
Canada's premiers are set to meet for the third and final day of their gathering in Ontario's cottage country, with internal trade, public safety and health care on the agenda. The premiers met with Prime Minister Mark Carney in Huntsville, Ont., on Tuesday to discuss the ongoing trade war with U.S. President Donald Trump after meeting with First Nation leaders the previous day.