An Bord Pleanála overturns decision to grant planning permission for apartments in Kerry town
ABP refused planning permission for the demolition of a house and garage and the construction of six two-bed apartments and one three-bed apartment at Poulnamuck on the Muckross Road on Wednesday, May 7.
The development, proposed by Vincent Casey, would also have included the construction of a new site entrance, parking and ancillary services and areas.
The development was granted conditional planning permission by Kerry County Council in December. This decision was appealed to ABP by Mary Guerin, owner of the neighbouring Killarney View House.
An architect acting on behalf of Ms Guerin stated that 'we completely disagree with the provisional decision by Kerry Co Co granting permission'.
They said the overall footprint, scale and height of the proposed development would dwarf the immediate neighbouring residences, including Killarney View House.
It was also argued that the proposed development is 8.44m higher than the average existing ridge levels of neighbouring properties and this could lead to breach of privacy issues.
'My client currently runs the property as a guest house and has successfully done so for many years. The proposed development has a vast negative impact over my client's property and her current guesthouse business,' the architect acting for Ms Guerin stated.
'We believe that the proposed development will result in a decrease in guest numbers thus affecting their business future.'
ABP decided to overturn Kerry County Council's grant of planning for the development despite receiving a recommendation that the decision should be upheld, subject to conditions, following an inspection in February.
ADVERTISEMENT
The body cited two reasons for its decision to refuse permission.
It considered the separation distances between the proposed development and the neighbouring property insufficient to protect the amenities of Killarney View House, which has both tourist accommodation and private residence.
The board said the limited separation distances provided between a number of windows to habitable rooms in the proposed development and its northern site boundary would adversely impact upon the guesthouse by way of overlooking and loss of privacy.
ABP also noted that there were alternative design solutions to protect the residential amenity of the neighbouring guesthouse, such as the separation distances provided between the proposed apartments and the dwelling on the associated landholding to the south.
Furthermore, the board considered there was inadequate information on file to carry out an Appropriate Assessment Screening, a survey of the potential adverse effects of the proposed development (in combination with other plans or projects) on Special Areas of Conservation and Special Protection Areas.
This was because the application did not include a Screening Report.
'… the Board cannot be satisfied that the proposed development individually, or in combination with other plans or projects would not be likely to have a significant effect on European site Killarney National Park, Macgillycuddy's Reeks and Caragh River Catchment Special Area of Conservation in view of the site's Conservation Objectives,' the board stated.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
6 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
€36,000 prize up for grabs for Beef Bull of the Future Championships
A new €36,000 prize fund to reward top pedigree bulls across all beef breeds will be awarded at this year's Iverk Show. ABP Ireland will continue its 13-year history of supporting the Iverk Show, which was first held in 1826, making it Ireland's oldest agricultural event, drawing over 25,000 visitors annually. The show will return to Piltown, Kilkenny, on August 23. This year marks a significant evolution in the show's cattle programme with the expansion to all beef breeds, under the Beef Bull of the Future Championships, a new initiative from ABP that aims to recognise and reward excellence in pedigree beef breeding across all breeds. Under a new format, the show will continue to offer an extended range of Bull Calf Championships and will incorporate five new championships to the three existing Angus Bull Calf Championships. The new championships are two new Hereford Bull Calf Championships, a Limousine Bull Calf Championship, and two new Bull Calf Championships to accommodate all other beef breeds. Diversity in sector The final category, Supreme Bull Calf Championship, will be contested by the champion and reserve champion of each of the eight championships. With the €36,000 prize pot up for grabs, the decision to open the competition to all breeds reflects the diversity of the Irish beef sector and the essential role each breed plays in a profitable and sustainable production system. ABP agri-sustainability manager Stephen Connolly said: "We are proud to support the Iverk Show again this year. By including all breeds in this year's Beef Bull of the Future Championships, it signals our recognition of each breed's strengths in Irish beef production. Breeding is central to improving carcass quality, and this show is a fantastic platform to highlight that All bulls entered in this year's show must meet the minimum genetic merit criteria for carcass weight and conformation within the Terminal Index or Dairy Beef Index. All bulls will be judged on their visual characteristics and breed traits to ensure the best bulls are crowned winners on the day. The championships are supported by Certified Irish Angus and Irish Hereford Prime, who will be represented at the show. ABP suppliers will also benefit from a €500 voucher towards the purchase of the top prize winners in selected angus and hereford classes, offering a real opportunity to invest in superior genetics.
Irish Examiner
2 days ago
- Irish Examiner
Killarney to get new shuttle buses to ease traffic gridlock
Killarney is to get a new shuttle bus service in a bid to ease chronic gridlock in the popular tourist town. The shuttle service — three buses operating seven days a week — will become operational 'imminently", according to Kerry County Council director of roads services Frank Hartnett. The buses will start at 6am and continue to pick up and drop off passengers until 11pm, running to the most popular locations in the area. The service is part of a new transport programme for Killarney and is being funded by the National Transport Authority. A management structure, overseen by the Local Link Service, is already in place. 'They are finalising routes and travel plans. It is imminent,' Mr Hartnett said. A meeting of Kerry County Council's Killarney Municipal District heard that traffic in the town is worsening, particularly during peak commuter hours. Local councillor Marie Moloney appealed for the shuttle service to be made available to school students while her fellow councillor Brendan Cronin bemoaned the introduction of cycle lanes, which he said left little space for dedicated bus lanes. Mr Cronin said: Every bit of space we have is constantly going to cycle lanes. The opportunity is gone for dedicated bus lanes. Locations for park-and-ride services are being identified so people can leave cars on the outskirts of the town to ease congestion on the main arteries into Killarney. The shuttle bus routes will be 'flexible' and involve corner-to-corner drop offs, the council has said. 'Killarney's biggest challenge' The meeting heard that people are deliberately avoiding Killarney because of the chronic traffic congestion which is negatively impacting business. The local chamber of commerce said traffic chaos is now the biggest single issue for the town. The N22 Farranfore to Killarney Road Project is overdue by more than 20 years. Many people believe the project is the ultimate solution to relieve congestion. The 27km road project was unveiled in 2003 but shelved after the economic downturn because of lack of funding. Now estimated to cost in excess of €200m, the project is again going through planning and design procedures. Proposed inner relief roads for the town would bring up to 5,000 cars out of the centre of Killarney, the council meeting heard. :: This article was funded by the Local Democracy Scheme. Read More Kerry council to roll out pilot scheme to detect deer on roads in bid to prevent accidents
Irish Independent
3 days ago
- Irish Independent
Volunteer efforts set to be honoured at upcoming Tralee Tidy Towns awards
An awards ceremony, supported by co-sponsors Cara Credit Union, Garvey's Supervalu Tralee, The Rose Hotel and Kerry County Council, will take place at the Rose Hotel in October to honour the efforts of Tralee residents, businesses, and public buildings in enhancing the town's appearance. The event will highlight the contributions of individuals and communities maintaining their homes, gardens, estates, and green areas. This year, several award categories will be available for residential estates: Large, Medium, and Small Estates, along with an Estate Biodiversity Award and an Estate Feature Area Award. Garden-related awards will include Large and Small Gardens, a Garden Biodiversity Award, a Plant Bed/Container/Flower Basket Award, a Favourite Plant Award, and a Favourite Spot in My Garden Award. Businesses and public buildings can also apply in one of six categories: Best Hotel, Shop, Bar/Public House, Café/Restaurant, Service Station, and Public Buildings. Tralee Tidy Towns Chair, Brendan O'Brien, had the following to say at the launch: 'Tralee is looking well and there's a lot of work going into the town – we want to recognise this and increase the growing sense of pride in Tralee. This awards event is a great way to do that. As a means of including more people in the awards event this year, we have categories like 'favourite spot in the garden' and a great idea by the organising committee is a 'favourite plant' award – so those who don't own a garden but are growing plants can be recognised.' 'We have to say a huge thank you to our sponsors for supporting this event, what we hope will be an even better event in 2025 – to Cara Credit Union, Garvey's Supervalu Tralee, The Rose Hotel and Kerry County Council, we just could not put this event on without this support. "We're launching this event this week and I'm asking the estates, the gardens and the businesses to enter and it might inspire that extra bit of effort or draw more volunteers in to the overall Tidy Towns effort in Tralee. We know this will build community and help Tralee progress in the Tidy Towns competition but ultimately it will help to make Tralee a better place to live in, work in and visit,' he continued. To take part, entrants should send their name, contact details, and chosen category to tidytownstralee@ or send a private message to the Tralee Tidy Towns Facebook page. Application forms will be available via email, on social media, and in hard copy from the Kerry County Council Tralee Municipal District Office on Princes Quay. The closing date for entries is July 18. The awards ceremony will be held in October at the Rose Hotel.
