Family hoping trial is final chapter in getting justice for Megan McDonald, who was murdered in March 2003
Megan's body was found on a narrow dirt path on March 15, 2003, in Wallkill, New York. The cause of death was blunt force trauma, with multiple fractures to the skull.
Holley, who had previously dated Megan, has pleaded not guilty.
He was first arrested in April 2023 — just one month after the 20-year anniversary of Megan's murder. At the time, Holley was incarcerated for an unrelated case. However, a week later, he was released from custody because his sentence had been served in that case and Orange County District Attorney David Hoovler said protocol wasn't followed in Megan's case. In an email to NBC News, Hoovler said police had arrested Holley without consulting his office and that he hadn't pursued charges against Holley because investigators hadn't gathered enough evidence.
Nearly a year later, in January 2024, Holley was indicted by an Orange County grand jury for second-degree murder.
Following that announcement, Megan's family filed a complaint against Hoovler with the judicial oversight body that investigates allegations of prosecutorial misconduct.
The complaint alleged, among other things, that Hoovler tried to stymie the investigation, and failed to disclose that, prior to becoming district attorney, he once represented a suspect in Megan's killing.
In response to NBC News' request for comment about the allegations, Hoovler replied via email that the suggestion that he or anyone in his office sought to tamper with or compromise the investigation was 'inaccurate, unfair and offensive.'
Following Holley's indictment, Hoovler recused his office from the case and asked that a special prosecutor be assigned. Attorney Julia Cornachio was appointed to the case.
Holley's trial began this week in an Orange County courthouse.
On Monday, March 10, prosecutors delivered an opening statement postulating that Holley had lied to investigators through multiple interviews over the years, including about what car he was driving and where he was the night of the murder. They stated that the injuries Megan sustained showed anger and rage on the part of her killer, suggesting a personal connection to the victim.
In its opening statement, the defense pointed to an alternate suspect -- one of Megan's ex-boyfriends. They told jurors the prosecution would present a 'parade' of witnesses, and cautioned them to weigh the quality of the evidence, not the quantity.
On Monday afternoon and Tuesday, the prosecution began its case, calling witnesses that included Megan's mother, one of the people who found Megan's body, and multiple investigators from the early stages of the investigation.
Court is not in session on Wednesdays. The trial is expected to last more than a month.
On Thursday, March 13, Andrea Canning featured Megan's story and the ongoing trial on the Dateline: True Crime Weekly podcast.
In the days leading up to this trial, Megan's family provided a statement to Dateline through their attorney, John Beatty. 'Our family will always grieve the tragic loss of our beloved Megan and we will carry the pain of losing her in such a brutal and senseless manner for the rest of our lives,' it reads. 'We want to make it clear that our focus throughout this process is in seeking justice for Megan and ensuring that the person responsible for her murder is held accountable.' They stated that they trust the legal system to provide answers and a fair trial.
'This journey has been incredibly difficult for all of us, but we are grateful for the hard work and dedication of the men and women of the New York State Police, supporting agencies and special prosecutors, who have worked tirelessly to bring us to this point,' the family's statement reads.
John Beatty provided a statement of his own on behalf of his office, saying, in part, that their hearts remain heavy with grief for the family's loss of Megan. 'I want to express our unwavering confidence in the legal process,' he wrote. 'We trust that the presiding Judge and the dedicated team of special prosecutors will present the evidence to the jury with the utmost professionalism, integrity, and fairness and we appreciate the hard work of the jurors who shall see this evidence and render a just verdict.'
Megan's family is hoping this trial will be the final chapter in their two-decades-long fight for justice. 'We look forward to this trial as the final chapter, knowing that justice for Megan will finally be served,' the family statement reads. 'We are optimistic that this case can serve as a beacon of hope for other families, especially those in older cases, still seeking justice for their loved ones.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
a day ago
- NBC News
How Trump's policies are reshaping immigration enforcement in Puerto Rico
In Barrio Obrero, a predominantly Dominican neighborhood in Puerto Rico, the chilling effect of unprecedented immigration raids in the U.S. territory has been paralyzing. With homes and businesses desolate, a truck with speakers has been cruising through the streets of the working-class neighborhood with a message. 'Suddenly, in that darkness, they heard: 'Immigrants, you have rights,'' Ariadna Godreau, a human rights lawyer in Puerto Rico, told NBC News. The legal nonprofit she leads, Ayuda Legal Puerto Rico, hired the truck, known as a ' tumba coco, ' to make people aware of their rights and announce the launch of a new hotline, the first in Puerto Rico providing legal support to immigrants, Godreau said. Over 300 families have already called the hotline and spoken with attorneys free of charge as they figure out their legal options in the face of a changing immigration landscape, Godreau said. Residents in Puerto Rico now fear that President Donald Trump's efforts to carry out mass deportations will fundamentally change how immigration policies are enforced in a U.S. territory that had long been perceived as a sanctuary for immigrants. That perception was first shattered on Jan. 27, the same week Trump took office. Immigration authorities raided Barrio Obrero and arrested more than 40 people. Witnesses told Telemundo Puerto Rico, NBC's sister station on the island, that they saw agents break down the doors of several homes and businesses. Detainees were handcuffed, placed in vans and taken away, they said. In his 40 years living in Puerto Rico, Ramón Muñoz, a Dominican immigrant, had seen authorities sporadically detain undocumented people but never ' with the aggressiveness ' displayed during that raid. Complicating matters for immigrants in Puerto Rico, those detained are transferred to the mainland U.S. — an ocean away from their families and attorneys managing their immigration cases — because there are no permanent detention centers on the island that can hold detainees for prolonged periods, according to Rebecca González-Ramos, the special agent in charge of Homeland Security Investigations in San Juan. A 'nightmare' amid racial profiling concerns Aracely Terrero, one of the at least 732 immigrants arrested by federal immigration authorities in Puerto Rico so far this year, spent a month being bounced around three different detention centers in the States before she was released last week after an immigration judge determined she should have never been detained in the first place. A local police officer in the coastal town of Cabo Rojo alerted federal immigration authorities about Terrero after the officer found her selling ice cream at the beach without business permits, Telemundo Puerto Rico reported. Terrero had a visa and was in the process of obtaining a green card when she was taken into immigration custody, her attorney Ángel Robles and Annette Martínez, the executive director of the American Civil Liberties Union in Puerto Rico, told NBC News. Local policies in Puerto Rico limit coordination between local law enforcement and federal immigration authorities, Martínez said. Yet the ACLU in Puerto Rico is seeing more cases in which local police are suspected of racially profiling Dominican immigrants with the purposes of alerting federal immigration authorities, reigniting concerns about the revival of 'discriminatory policing practices' that led to police reforms in Puerto Rico a decade ago, Martínez said. Terrero's case also spotlighted how difficult it is for families and attorneys to keep track of detainees once they are sent to the States, Martínez added. 'It was a nightmare,' Terrero told Telemundo Puerto Rico following her release. 'It was a very difficult journey because I'd never been arrested in my life. I'd never seen myself like this, with handcuffs, like a criminal.' A raid changes everything González-Ramos, the HSI special agent, said in a local radio interview last week that her office had been preparing to ramp up immigration enforcement efforts in Puerto Rico since November. She said they started 'reorganizing' resources and 'shifting priorities' after Trump's win. Yet the big raid on Jan. 27 came as a surprise to most people. Puerto Rico Gov. Jenniffer González-Colón had reassured immigrants in an interview with Telemundo Puerto Rico that same week that Trump was only ' focused on what's happening in Mexico and in the United States, on that border. ' It helped create a 'false sense of security,' Godreau said. 'These consecutive raids then begin in areas historically inhabited by the Dominican population.' As immigration authorities escalate their efforts in Puerto Rico by raiding hotels, construction sites and neighborhoods, more than 500 of the immigrants arrested so far are from the Dominican Republic. Dominicans make up the biggest share of Puerto Rico's immigrant population. Over 100,000 Dominicans are estimated to live in Puerto Rico. About a third are thought to be undocumented. Many of them are business owners or work hospitality, construction and elder care jobs, the last two being industries grappling with labor shortages, Godreau and Martínez said. González-Ramos had said her office would be detaining people illegally present in Puerto Rico, ' specifically those whose criminal records pose a threat to our communities and national security.' But only 13% of the 732 immigrants arrested this year have a criminal record, according to data from Homeland Security Investigations in San Juan. Following a subpoena from Immigration and Customs Enforcement, the administration of González-Colón, a Republican who supports Trump, recently handed over the names and addresses of 6,000 people who got driver's licenses under an immigrant-friendly law from 2013 that allowed people without legal immigration status to get them. González-Colón has said she won't challenge Trump's immigration policies so as not to risk losing federal funding. 'The governor's attitudes and expressions have been quite misleading,' Martínez said, adding that local jurisdictions frequently challenge and oppose federal policies in an effort to protect local residents. Nowhere to be detained A spokesperson for Homeland Security Investigations in San Juan told NBC News that González-Ramos was not available for an interview this week. But in her local radio interview last week, González-Ramos said immigration agents periodically carry out 'daily interventions' in an effort to find over 1,200 people who have final deportation orders 'that we must execute.' Everyone arrested in raids, regardless of whether they have final orders of deportation or not, 'must be detained, no matter what,' González-Ramos said in Spanish. 'Right now, those are the instructions.' The ACLU's Martínez said that in Puerto Rico, immigration arrests have an 'aggravating factor': Those immigrants arrested are put on a plane and sent away to detention centers in the mainland U.S. For more than a decade, the island has lacked a working immigration detention center that can permanently house detainees. As immigration arrests ramp up, 'temporary detention centers' have sprouted across Puerto Rico, according to González-Ramos. One of them is in a federal General Services Administration building in Guaynabo. Equipped with almost 20 beds, it's been nicknamed ' la neverita,' or the icebox, by immigrants who have spent time there before being transferred to the U.S. An old ICE facility in Aguadilla that shuttered in 2012 was recently reopened to temporarily hold detainees, according to Godreau and Martínez, who have heard from immigrants taken there. Before its closure over a decade ago, 'complaints were made at the time about the inhumane and inadequate conditions in which detainees in that center were held,' Martínez said in Spanish. Mayor Julio Roldán approved an ordinance Thursday to declare Aguadilla a 'sanctuary city' for immigrants in response to escalated enforcement efforts in the area. When at least two dozen detainees are at the temporary holding facilities, ICE planes come to Puerto Rico to transport them to permanent detention centers in different states, according to González-Ramos. Many of them are placed in immigration detention centers in Florida and Texas. But detainees from Puerto Rico have also been found in facilities in Louisiana and New Mexico. 'We're seeing a pattern of disappearances,' Martínez said, pointing out that in Terrero's case, it took the ACLU and her attorney weeks to find out where she was being held. The situation raises concerns over 'multiple violations of human rights and civil rights,' Martínez said, adding that the ACLU is continuing to monitor these cases and call for changes in local policies to ensure immigrants' rights are protected.
NBC News
2 days ago
- NBC News
Gun violence erupts across U.S. on Fourth of July
Gun violence seen in cities across the country during the Fourth of July holiday, even as new data shows crime dropping significantly nationwide. NBC News' Shaquille Brewster has the details.
NBC News
2 days ago
- NBC News
After deadly ambush, Idaho firefighters grapple with the loss of two colleagues
Joshua Hoston, an 18-year veteran of Idaho's Coeur d'Alene Fire Department, remembers the moment a routine wildfire call turned into a deadly ambush that killed two fellow firefighters and wounded a third. 'We dropped everything we had, hopped back in the truck, and went racing back up to the mountain,' Hoston said. What initially seemed like an ordinary report of a wildfire in the northwest Idaho city quickly devolved into chaos as first responders came under fire — an attack that has shaken the close-knit firefighting community. Hoston said he was called to Canfield Mountain on Sunday, June 29, and was assisting with retrieving a UTV, a four-wheeled vehicle used to access tight terrain, when a call crackled over the radio: shots fired. 'The way it sounded, we knew it wasn't a joke,' he said. What he and others didn't know at the time was that a man — now identified as 20-year-old Wess Roley — had allegedly set the fire intentionally to ambush responding firefighters. Hoston said a captain with the Northern Lakes Fire District quickly ordered crews to stay at a staging area, away from the gunfire. He said he felt 'helpless' not being able to rush to his colleagues to help, but acknowledged the decision likely saved more lives. 'If we all had been up there, we'd have been trapped,' he said. 'It would have been a stack of bodies.' Battalion Chiefs John Morrison and Frank J. Harwood were killed in the attack. Firefighter David Tysdal was wounded and remains hospitalized in stable condition after undergoing multiple surgeries. 'It's been the worst imaginable 56 hours,' Coeur d'Alene firefighter and captain Jeff Fletcher told NBC News. Fletcher was off duty that day and mountain biking in nearby Sandpoint when he began receiving urgent calls. He was told 'two of my best friends' had been shot. He rushed to the Coeur d'Alene fire station, then to the hospital, where he and another firefighter set up a command post. 'Just to see the smoke plume from the wildland fire really brought realities to what we were about to undertake,' he said in a phone call on Thursday. 'I think everybody initially was like, 'How can this be happening? How can it be in our community?'' Kootenai County Sheriff Bob Norris said the 'firefighters did not have a chance' after Roley allegedly opened fire. Norris said they received reports that Roley — who, according to his family, once dreamed of becoming a firefighter — fired at responders from a tree. Roley was found dead on the mountain last Sunday from a suspected self-inflicted gunshot wound, authorities said. A flint starter and shotgun were also recovered at the scene. 'The most amazing person' Fletcher said the days since the attack have been chaotic, leaving little time to process the tragedy. 'I'd say that a lot of us, we're still in the trenches,' he said. 'We're also trying to balance grieving for John and Frank and supporting Dave, and then also pulling shifts and going on calls and trying to maintain our composure.' Fletcher grew emotional recalling his 23-year friendship with Morrison, the battalion chief, and firefighter Tysdal, which began on his first day on the job. 'Dave is just the most amazing person,' he said through tears. In the winter, Tysdal runs a Christmas tree farm. 'He included everybody in anything he was doing,' Fletcher said. 'He's the most generous, nicest person I've ever met.' Officials said in an update last week that Tysdal underwent a third surgery. He was taken off a ventilator and was speaking, despite suffering severe chest and spinal trauma. Morrison embodied 'leadership on the fire ground that can never be replaced,' Fletcher said. 'In his position, when you show up to big incidents, he's basically calling the shots. There was never second-guessing what his strategy was,' he said. 'When you got back to the firehouse, he was the nicest, friendliest and funniest guy you'd ever meet.' Idaho Gov. Brad Little said he was 'heartbroken,' calling the attack a 'heinous direct assault on our brave firefighters.' Hundreds of people gathered for a procession Tuesday honoring Morrison and Harwood. A motive in the shooting remains unclear. Authorities said no manifesto has been found and they still do not know why Roley was in the area. Norris, the sheriff, said it appeared he had been living out of his car. The fire has burned about 23 acres and was 100% contained as of Friday morning, the Idaho Department of Lands said in a Facebook post. Roley's family could not be reached for comment. They released a statement Monday through their attorney, Justin P. Whittenton, saying that they 'do not understand why this happened or how this came about.' Since the attack, support for the victims and local fire community has poured in, said Ricky Walsh, vice president of the International Association of Fire Fighters District 7. 'We are our sisters' and brothers' keepers, and we are going to lean on each other and get through this event,' he said. Tracy Rohr, 52, of Coeur d'Alene, said watching the community come together has been 'heartwarming but tragically sad.' 'For me personally, I feel an overwhelming sense of pride for the way our community has come together,' she said. 'But also, I definitely feel like we're all at a loss. It's tragic.'
