When do direct flights boost economic output (and venture capital deals)?
Research does show startups gain measurable innovation advantages (more patents and citations) when direct flights link them to VC centers — with effects far stronger on international routes than domestic ones.
So yes, ecosystem leaders should invite investors and host meet-and-greets, but not universally fixate on capital, because entrepreneurs need many resources, including quality of life.
→ Read on for details and join Chris Wink's weekly newsletter for more
Pressed to choose between being a home for investors and entrepreneurs, choose the entrepreneurs every time. Venture capitalists are bankers with better branding.
So forgive me for raising my eyebrows whenever I hear an economic development leader tell me they're working on attracting more capital to their region — or that an entrepreneur thinks her hometown just 'needs more capital.' Everybody says this everywhere. The United States has more liquid capital markets than any other country on the planet. We also have more airports than anywhere else. Stop complaining.
Still, I admit research shows there are cases where that is sound economic development strategy. So when is it smart for regional economic development groups to chase venture capitalists? And what does it have to do with direct flights?
'Venture capitalists monitor their investments closely,' said Brian Brackeen, the Lightship Capital general partner whose Black Tech Week event series in Cincinnati matches startups directly with VC investors and corporate clients. 'Founders think constantly about capital. They prefer not to, but they have to.'
Brackeen was my foil on this topic in the last Technical.ly Builders Live podcast alongside our cohosts Victor Hwang of Right to Start and Maria Underwood, an ecosystem builder turned startup COO from Birmingham, Alabama.
Our conversation veered into the role of local events to bring in outside investors — the topic of a separate future Technical.ly story — but our original debate centered on when local ecosystems chasing outside capital made sense.
Brackeen assured me that no 'sensible' local economic leader is expecting to attract a top-tier investment firm to open an office in their city or state on a whim.
Most US regions are without much institutional capital. Local rich grandees might be angel investors, but can often be unsavvy, or at least limited in their checkbooks. Many economic leaders want to create ties to bigger pools of money to accelerate homegrown inventors — and limit departures for bigger investment hubs.
Air travel is often regarded as an economic salve for such far-flung places.
One signature initiative from Jobs Ohio, the liquor-tax funded, state economic development powerhouse, is its ' air service restoration program,' in which it effectively subsidizes direct flights from its airports to major financial centers at up to $10 million annually. Northwest Arkansas's entrepreneur support organization is organizing a VC immersion program, in which it flies in investors for 1:1 meetings with inventors. Ecosystem organizer Serafina Lalany posted a video of her team happily distributing posters of the campaign.
'Bringing investors to your city works,' said Underwood, who led efforts to integrate investor pitches into Birmingham's upcoming Sloss Tech event. 'We bring VCs who've never been to Birmingham to meet our founders. It's economical and effective.'
Research backs her up, to a point. Startups gain measurable innovation advantages when connected by direct flights to venture capitalists, according to a 2016 MIT paper, with a 3.1% increase in patent filings and a 5.8% increase in patent citations.
Interestingly, US communities don't benefit from new direct flights anywhere near as much as international cities do, at least according to a 2018 paper. Foreign cities with new direct flights to Silicon Valley saw an additional $23 million in VC funding over the next year.
Any connection between big enough domestic and foreign hubs did the trick. With each newly introduced direct route between a U.S. and Chinese city increased annual M&A transaction volumes by approximately $50 million, according to a 2021 paper. Domestic cities didn't see the same boost.
'For companies farther away, particularly internationally, direct flights matter immensely,' wrote Waters. This advantage is magnified by geographical distance and cultural barriers.
Selling bits of an early-stage private company for infusions of cash is always tricky, especially for first-time founders and in untested markets. Network effect is real, and local organizers can change that. Invite investors to your annual events and organize meet-and-greets, but ecosystem leaders ought not universally fixate on venture capital. Entrepreneurs need many resources.
As Hwang put it: 'Making connections for entrepreneurs will make good things happen in lots of unexpected ways.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Technical.ly
2 days ago
- Technical.ly
Pittsburgh weekly roundup: Skild opens San Francisco office; Ansys acquisition complete; Forge AI Pitch Challenge
This week in Pittsburgh, the data center gold rush, advice from angel investors on raising capital and more. Read on for weekly roundup of top news in the region. 📰 News Incubator: What else to know • What happens when a data center comes to town? PA's Dorrance Township doesn't want to find out. With real estate developers sniffing around for potential, this rural community is setting up protections before applications start rolling in. [ ] • Skild AI is expanding to San Francisco, a controversial move in the Pittsburgh startup scene. When Abridge announced its intention for a similar move in March, it sparked a debate about why the local talent scene isn't enough for these hypergrowth firms. [ Pittsburgh Biz Times / ] • Synopsys finally completed its $35 billion acquisition of Cannonsburg-based Ansys, after more than a year checking all the legal boxes. [ Synopsys / ] • Protestors surrounded the Energy and Innovation Summit, as Pittsburghers spoke up against Carnegie Mellon University's decision to host President Donald Trump and the impact of AI development on climate change. [ / Pittsburgh City Paper / WESA] • Apply by Aug. 8 for a chance to be recognized as one of the region's top AI startups — and win $50,000 — at the Forge AI Pitch Challenge. [ AI Horizons ] • People aren't moving for jobs, but instead to places they want to live and then finding jobs there, Chris Wink writes in his latest column. In Pittsburgh, telling its unique stories of relative cost of living and quirky culture can be the thing that pulls talent in. [ ] • It just got easier for union workers to report employer violations. Allegheny County launched the confidential Right to Organize Incident Report Form to document the errs, but you should still file a formal complaint, too. [ Allegheny County ] • ICYMI: Catch up on the top takeaways from local startup CEOs Shiv Rao, John Thornton, Jake Loosararian and more at the AI Horizons kickoff event earlier this week. [ Pittsburgh Slack channel ] • If your startup exit strategies rely on M&A, start by finding the right advisor to guide you through it. Here are 10 tips to sift through the candidates. [ ] 🗓️ On the Calendar • Fix your gaming keyboard and get back to gameplay at a $25 electronics repair class hosted by Hackers Guild PGH on July 19. [ Sign up ] • Get access to 3D printers at Prototype PGH at a training session for beginners on July 19. The event costs $10 to attend, but no one will be turned away due to lack of funds. [ Register ] • Level up your woodworking skills at HackPGH's picture frame design class. The July 20 event costs $185 and is recommended for folks with beginner woodworking knowledge. [ Attend ] • Head to the University of Pittsburgh for JuliaCon from July 22 to 25. Prices vary, but for an additional fee, you can attend a Pirates game with fellow enthusiasts of the coding language. [ Get tickets ] • Learn how to access your Bitcoin on the Solana blockchain, followed by a Federal Galley hangout, with BitDevs Pittsburgh on July 23. [ More info ] • Brush up on your sketching skills and meet new people at Ascender's Pictionary Happy Hour on July 24. [ Details here ] • Procrastinate on your latest project by catching up with friends or finally make time for that deadline you've been putting off at Avenu: Meyran's coworking summer Fridays on July 25. [ Learn more ]
Technical.ly
2 days ago
- Technical.ly
DC accrues $514.6M of VC in Q2 — a drop from the start of 2025
Venture capital investment in the DC region slowed in the second quarter of the year, and the White House's lack of clarity on regulation and policy could be to blame. Companies nabbed $514.6 million across 64 deals in the DMV, according to the latest Venture Monitor report released quarterly by PitchBook and the National Venture Capital Association. That's a sharp decline from the first quarter of the year, with its reported $1.3 billion across 60 deals — meaning this most recent quarter saw lower deal values. The region isn't alone in venture capitalists writing smaller checks, per the Venture Monitor report. This is part of a broader, 'more cautious investment climate' across the nation, said Tahira Dosani, cofounder and managing partner at ResilienceVC. 'We're no longer in this 'growth at all cost' mentality,' Dosani, who announced a new $56 million fund earlier this year, told 'We're in an era where there's a focus on capital efficiency, on sustainable pathways to profitability and the broader tightening of fewer companies successfully raising rounds because investors are being more selective.' This has been the mindset for the last couple of years, per Dosani. DC has had a handful of blowout quarters, but they're often led by major raises from established companies. Rockville nuclear power company X Energy nabbed about half of the funds at the beginning of the year, as did the e-cigarette giant Juul to close 2024. This is why looking at data quarter-to-quarter can be difficult, explained Les Alexander, a professor at the University of Virginia Darden School of Business. In 2024, companies in the DMV collectively raised $4.3 billion — the highest amount since 2021. 'I often find that in some markets like the DMV, quarter to quarter activity can be impacted by a few larger deals,' Alexander wrote in a statement to 'so you need to be careful to not draw broad conclusions without longer data trends.' Unstable regulations could lead to lower activity ResilienceVC's Dosani noted that uncertainty around policies like tariffs are making investors more cautious. There's generally a tendency toward deregulation under the Trump administration, which can benefit business, but there needs to be clarity, she said. 'Regulatory uncertainty always makes it harder to make decisions,' she said. Because of this precariousness, it's more difficult for investors to vet startups adequately, said Elena Loutskina, a professor at the Darden School of Business. 'The global economic uncertainty, including one about tariffs, hampers VCs' ability to properly evaluate the prospects of given startups,' Loutskina wrote to in an email. 'This makes investments exceptionally risky and unattractive.' Alexander agrees. Inconsistent trade policy is causing investors to be wary, he said. The economic picture also depends on industry, he noted. He's already seen climate technology companies nab less funding because of policy changes. 'On the other hand, defense tech and cybersecurity, which are attractive investment areas for companies and investors in the DMV region, is seeing increased deal activity with the favorable support from policymakers,' he said. What startups — and investors — should know Securing investments will continue to be challenging for startups, especially for those in early stages, Alexander said. But AI companies will likely continue to see funding, he said. Fundraising for the capital to invest is slowing, too, Alexander said. That's because limited partners aren't getting liquidity back from prior funds they've invested in and a lack of exits, ResilienceVC's Dosani explained. Because of all of this, founders need to be capital-efficient, she said. They also need to demonstrate clear traction to investors and show profitability. 'It's not necessarily a bad thing,' Dosani said. 'It just is the reality of this market, and I think what it will translate into is that … the best founders are the ones getting the cap[ital].' This constriction also requires investors to be more supportive of founders outside the money, she said. That means being more hands-on in business strategies, for example. 'Founders have to think about how they tell their story, how they execute and operate their businesses,' Dosani said, 'and I think investors have to do the same.'
Technical.ly
5 days ago
- Technical.ly
What Philly can gain from a closer look at Chicago's tech growth
I can't tell if it's confirmation bias or the algorithms at work, but lately I've been seeing a ton of Philly friends post pics from Chicago. That's unusual. Chicago and Philadelphia have a kind of weird relationship. They show up in the same breath as examples of 'other big US cities,' but have never really had a deep kinship or persistent rivalry. It feels kind of like siblings that don't speak, or influencers at a brand event trying to avoid one another in their shots. But maybe that's changing. My Philly artist friend was in Chicago to create a new installation. My Philly chef friend was there to host a collab dinner with a local restaurant. These cross-metro connections are multiplying, at least in my world. Truth is these two American metros have a lot in common, and a lot to learn from one another. Figuring out how they can better share wins is why I'm visiting this fall. I'll be in Chicago because of GPLEX, the long-running Philly-based leadership conference, which in September brings a couple hundred mid-Atlantic leaders to the Midwest. (Applications to join are open through July 21; financial assistance is available.) One of the themes of the conference is public perception, and how to turn it into a driving factor for regional economic growth — instead of the opposite. Anyone involved in thinking about either city's future knows that's an uphill battle. In the late 1800s, Chicago and Philadelphia were trying to outdo one another by hosting the best world's fair or gaining enough population to be known as America's ' second city.' But modern similarities include surges in gun violence, persistent racial wealth gaps and disinvestment/gentrification in formerly redlined neighborhoods. Yet each has made strides in these and other areas. And each has a booming tech economy. But if you don't live or work in either place, you might not know it. That's where public perception — and journalism and storytelling in general — come in. 'Stories about places aren't just passive reflections, they're active drivers of economic and social decisions,' my colleague Chris Wink recently noted, citing new research out of Germany. Philadelphia just earned its highest-ever spot on the Startup Genome global rankings. Led by biotech, medtech and a maturing founder base, the Philly region is now considered the world's 13th best place to launch a startup. Chicago, meanwhile, has a more established scene. It's home to 1871, one of the top startup incubators globally. Google is working to build a sustainable office campus downtown. A growing quantum cluster is taking root. And civic organizations like P33 — led by serial entrepreneur Chris Gladwin, who'll speak GPLEX — are pushing hard on inclusive growth, combining frontier tech with workforce programs in historically disinvested neighborhoods. Yet Chicago's calculated ' ecosystem value ' is $55 billion compared to the Philly region's $76 billion. It clocks in at No. 16 in the Startup Genome rankings this year, three spots below Philadelphia. It's not like things are dragging. Projects on Chicago's West and South Sides are especially worth watching. GPLEX will take Philly leaders on a tour of The Hatchery, a food entrepreneurship hub built with community financing that's pledging to create hundreds of jobs. We'll also visit The Polsky Center, which operates the Inclusive Innovation Fund to give local founders commercialization support and free coworking. So why doesn't Chicago get more cred? Back to the public perception thing. Civic leaders in Chicago are trying to shift the narrative by aligning their messaging across tourism, tech and government. It's the kind of cross-sector storytelling Philadelphia has been working on. Enter GPLEX. This year brings the 20th anniversary of the Economy League of Greater Philadelphia's escapades to other cities, which are useful for gaining knowledge of what else is out there, but also for connecting with engaged people back home. The conference goes down Sept. 25-28. The investment in time and funds isn't trivial, but if you're interested in being part of this changemaking crew, the commitment could be worth your while. Stay tuned for my turn to be that Philly friend making people curious with all my Chicago pics.
