Doubts Remain Over Proposed Joint Water Entity
This was the advice former Masterton mayor Lyn Patterson gave councillors at this week's Local Water Done Well hearing, held at Waiata House.
Although 58% of Masterton submissions were in favour of a Wairarapa-Tararua water services model, some stipulated their support was conditional on there being no standardisation of prices between districts.
About 39% supported a Masterton-only enhanced status quo approach, and about 3% did not support either option.
Patterson, who was one of several submitters who presented to council on Wednesday, said the council should not have limited people's choices to only two options and was concerned there was no guarantee of non-standardisation once a Wairarapa-Tararua water entity was established.
'Given you have to act in the best interests of present and future Masterton generations, you really don't have a choice,' she said.
'Please err on the side of caution as there is too much at stake.
'Be bold, be courageous, and if in doubt opt out now and support standalone, unless there is a legal watertight guarantee to no standardisation.'
Amber Craig, who submitted on behalf of Rangitāne o Wairarapa Incorporated, supported the Masterton-only option and said joining with other councils watered down the voice of whānau, hāpu, marae, and iwi.
Meanwhile, Rangitāne Tū Mai Rā Trust, the post-settlement governance entity for Rangitāne o Wairarapa and Rangitāne o Tamaki nui-ā-Rua, made a submission supporting the Wairarapa-Tararua option.
Masterton Ratepayers and Residents Association president Lyn Riley said there was too much uncertainty in choosing the Wairarapa-Tararua option.
The group's biggest concerns were financial fairness, lack of detail, and loss of local control, she said.
There were 'way too many unanswered questions' about governance, cost-sharing, ringfencing, shareholder agreements, and asset control.
'The devil is always in the detail, or in this case, the lack of detail,' Riley said.
Submitter Chris Blunden supported the Wairarapa-Tararua option and said pooling together resources across the districts into one organisation would increase resilience and safeguard resources and staff expertise.
Erica Jar from Sustainable Wairarapa said her organisation supported the Wairarapa-Tararua model in principle but had concerns about the level of uncertainty that came with the option.
Submitter Robbie Hullena supported the Masterton-only option and said standardisation would be a constant threat for Masterton shareholders.
Because of this, and other unknowns, he said a 'safe vote' would be for the Masterton-only option.
Submitter Peter Debney said the Wairarapa-Tararua option was the 'only affordable option' but also said he wanted to believe standardisation was 'not a possibility'.
Submitter Jamie Falloon said the biggest risk in the Wairarapa-Tararua option was standardisation and that the process that had been prescribed by the government and followed by councils was 'distinctly average'.
He was uncomfortable with the council agreeing on an idea, binding ratepayers to it, and then negotiating to 'see what happens'.
Masterton councillors would deliberate on all submissions on May 21.
The proposal Masterton District Council consulted on was the Wairarapa-Tararua option.
Its consultation document said each council would have different investment requirements and costs of service and that there was no requirement for water charges to be standardised across the districts.
The proposal's projected costs were based on water charges not being standardised and were an average of $2305 per Masterton connection by Year 10.
The council also included information on pricing over time in its consultation document to show what a standardised cost could look like 'compared to the cost under the Proposal without standardised costs'.
This standardised price was $3620 per connection by Year 10.
– LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
3 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Mayor's vote seals decision to go with CCO
Queenstown mayor Glyn Lewers. PHOTO: ODT FILES A mayoral casting vote was needed to decide how Three Waters services will be delivered in the Queenstown Lakes district. After nearly three hours' debate at a full council meeting yesterday, Mayor Glyn Lewers used his vote to ensure council staff's recommended option of a council-controlled organisation (CCO) won the day. Councillors were evenly split on the issue, despite 77% of the 118 submissions received during community consultation favouring the retention of Three Waters services in house. In her report for councillors, strategy and reform manager Pennie Pearce said submitters' main concerns about a CCO had either already been addressed by her original analysis, or would be dealt with by amendments to the government's "Local Water Done Well" reforms. Since submissions had opened in June, amendments had been made to the Local Government (Water Services) Bill that strengthened the case for a CCO, Ms Pearce said. Asked by Cr Esther Whitehead whether the council's recommendation showed a disregard for the consultation process, chief executive Mike Theelen said it was not a "game of numbers". He urged councillors to make their decisions "based on the information and evidence before you". The decision means the council will transfer the district's drinking water, wastewater and stormwater assets — and associated liabilities — to a CCO, but will be its sole shareholder. Ms Pearce's analysis projects average annual water charges for households to be 10% lower under a CCO in the long term, compared with the in-house model. The CCO will operate independently from the council, with its own specialist board and management, although amendments to the Bill will require CCOs to consult with the community on matters of significance. The council's debt is expected to significantly decrease, giving it more headroom for other capital spending. Property and infrastructure general manager Tony Avery told councillors a CCO would be "singular in its purpose", faster to respond to changing circumstances and better placed to secure debt and expertise. Cr Lisa Guy said the small number of submissions — about 100 from a population of more than 50,000 — did not represent a mandate for keeping the status quo. Many submitters had opposed a CCO, but also criticised the existing model for its delivery of Three Waters services. "If we're in agreement the status quo isn't delivering, how can we not be open to a model that might provide us with hope of doing it better?" Cr Niki Gladding said they were making their decision in a "fear and pressure environment" arising from repeated staff warnings of how central government might react if they chose the in-house model. "Neither option is the status quo. Both are an improvement. "I don't see why we can't achieve the benefits of a CCO — bar losing the debt — with an excellent in-house model." Cr Matt Wong said he was wary of basing his decision on cost, because he was sceptical about the accuracy of financial projections over such a long time period. They were under pressure from the government to make a decision based on highly complex information and a great deal of uncertainty, and he joked he would "need a coin" to make his. "I hope the public listening today is not going to judge any one of us on which way we vote."
Otago Daily Times
3 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Major rates increase forecast for district
It was a case of more bad news for Waitaki ratepayers this week, with suggestions big rates rises could be coming sooner and more often than first thought, as the district tries to fund a financially sustainable in-house water services unit. There was also bad news for those who might be elected to Waitaki District Council in the October elections. As part of the government's Local Water Done Well reforms, councils throughout New Zealand must submit a Water Services Delivery Plan (WSDP) to the Department of Internal Affairs by September 3. The Waitaki District Council last month voted that would be done through an in-house business unit, rejecting three other options including a joint council-controlled organisation (CCO) with the Central Otago, Clutha and Gore district councils. On Tuesday, it held a second weekly workshop to refine a draft plan to be put to Internal Affairs for initial feedback this week. Following the first workshop, councillors heard a rates rise of 25.61% in the 2028 LTP year would be needed to fund the in-house plan (it might also rise to about 30% if depreciation of water assets was included in the WSDP). This week, the council's chief financial officer Amanda Nicholls told the meeting if depreciation was included the 2028 rates rise would need to be 42.55%, with another "significant" increase needed in 2035. However, Mayor Gary Kircher suggested including the depreciation earlier than 2028. Doing so would ease the needed rates rise but bring it forward, Ms Nicholls said. Mr Kircher said he did not think there was a choice. It would mean a 25% rates increase for next year, followed by a 30% hike the following year. He recognised that also meant leaving it to the new council (following the local body elections in October) to redo the long-term plan and try to reduce the rates rise by cutting capital projects. "There's a lot of stuff that council has to do between now and agreeing on that annual plan to cut costs elsewhere," Mr Kircher said. The existing long-term plan was put together under the understanding that the council would adopt a joint CCO water services model, as it had previously said that was its preferred choice of model.
NZ Herald
4 days ago
- NZ Herald
Kaipara councillor warns Northlanders face $4000-plus water rates
Affordability for users was the big elephant in the room, Paniora said. She said financial metrics for the new CCO meant user charges within 2.5%-3.5% of household income. Paniora said that meant Northlanders paying between $2888 to $4430, based on Infometrics' average $115,536 annual household income. Drinking water and wastewater assets, debts and services for about 100,000 Northlanders will shift from the three councils to the CCO. KDC yesterday voted to become part of the region's Local Water Done Well (LWDW) plan at a meeting in Mangawhai. WDC kick-started the councils' move toward the regional three-council CCO on July 24. FNDC councillors will decide on whether to step into the plan today. Whangārei's strong drinking water and wastewater asset position has become a hot potato amidst the changes. KDC chief executive Jason Marris said his council had won the inclusion of cross-subsidisation in the new CCO. This had meant concession from Northland's two other district councils. The new CCO's agreement says cross-subsidisation, which it calls harmonisation, will be considered within three years of the company's 2027 establishment. But KDC will be pushing for it to happen as soon as possible within that timeframe. KDC general manager corporate services Sue Davidson said the CCO's initial principles required ring-fencing of debt and pricing, with a pathway to harmonisation to be considered within three years of establishment. 'However, KDC will work towards including harmonisation as early as possible in the implementation phase,' Davidson said in meeting agenda papers. This means Whangārei ratepayers will likely be subsidising those in Kaipara. If KDC didn't move on to the regional CCO, it faced a potential Local Water Done Well financial crisis, she said. KDC could not achieve financial sustainability delivering water services, if it adopted an in-house business unit to do so. The council is still carrying debt from the controversial Mangawhai sewerage scheme and has little financial room to move for required drinking water and wastewater services fixes to meet tougher new water reform requirements, which are monitored through regulator Taumata Arowai. KDC initially wanted to shift its council water services into Auckland's Watercare instead of joining with a Northland CCO. But Auckland Council turned that move down, before the September 3 deadline for regions to get their water services plan to the Government. Financial contributions to KDC from developers operating in Kaipara's Mangawhai, New Zealand's fastest-growing coastal settlement, have been significantly factored into the new Northland CCO meeting LWDW financial sustainability requirements. Davidson said there was significant risk around the amount of development contribution money factored into the new model's financials. 'The initial calculations were considered too aggressive and were moderated on request of elected members. The numbers remain ambitious and continue to carry significant risk of being achieved,' Davidson said. Paniora said the new arrangements did not regard water as a taonga as had already been established by the Treaty of Waitangi. She said Māori as tangata whenua had been left out of the conversation regarding the new plan. Paniora said the only hope for consideration of this aspect lay with FNDC. She said she couldn't vote in favour of today's KDC decision and wanted to wait for the outcome of tomorrow's FNDC decision. The new three-council CCO plan for Northland allows an off-ramp for FNDC not to sign up. In that case there would be a two-council CCO. Kaipara Mayor Craig Jepson, Deputy Mayor Jonathan Larsen and councillors Mike Howard, Gordon Lambeth, Ash Nayyar, Mark Vincent and Rachael Williams voted to be part of the Northland plan. Paniora and councillor Eryn Wilson-Collins voted not to be. ■ LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
