logo
The centre bounce has become a relic. It's time for the AFL to bring back the chaos or scrap it

The centre bounce has become a relic. It's time for the AFL to bring back the chaos or scrap it

The Age11-07-2025
'What can you tell me about the centre bounce of the ball? It goes anywhere, so it's really, really hard for the players ... if the ball bounces sideways, they're going to move,' Suns coach Damien Hardwick said.
Geelong skipper Patrick Dangerfield described it as not a 'valuable enough part of the game to protect', while Brisbane Lions coach Chris Fagan said, 'I'm not a fan of the bounce ... it contributes to umpire contact. It bounces, goes all over the place.'
Removing the bounce is a decision the AFL Commission can make as it was not enshrined in the 2014 Laws of the Game Charter. Under the fundamental element category of the game, it says : 'At the start of each quarter and after each goal, play is resumed by a ruck contest at a centre bounce or ball-up.'
Removing the bounce to help reduce umpire-player contact (a counter-argument is that the certainty a ball-up provides crowds players around the umpire, making them more vulnerable) is not the only reason it has been in the gun.
Those arguing for its elimination want to keep good decision makers in the game, even if they were ordinary bouncers. Let's face it, in what other sport – apart from perhaps skating in ice hockey – are umpires required to execute a physical skill?
The ball is now thrown up at all centre bounces in the AFLW. In the AFL, it has been thrown up around the ground since 2013 and umpires can be exempted from bouncing the ball due to the risk of injury.
The bounce must go up within a circle 10 metres in diameter and only the rucks can contest it. If the ball goes too far from the mark, it is called back, as the game attempts to balance unpredictability with fairness.
It means umpires have to execute the skill even more perfectly than in the past when no recalls were required, ruckmen weren't nominated and any player could contest the ball where it landed.
Just look below at some of the bounces from the past, from the 1975 and 1986 grand finals.
Tradition? What tradition?
Apart from all the rule changes, it's also worth noting that the tradition so fiercely protected to start a grand final has not occurred in two of the past 38 deciders.
In 1987, a free kick was paid to Carlton's Wayne Johnston before umpire Ian Robinson even had a chance to bounce the ball as five Hawthorn players stood in the square.
It's not clear why Johnston, rather than the Carlton ruckman, was awarded the kick, but no one blinked an eye.
In 2023, an errant bounce was recalled, taking two seconds off the clock in the Collingwood v Brisbane Lions decider before umpire Simon Meredith threw it up for Mason Cox and Oscar McInerney. When a bounce is recalled, the clock does not reset, losing the time taken.
That famous grand final that Collingwood won by four points was defined by a centre clearance goal in which Magpies star Jordan De Goey kicked to regain the lead with less than six minutes remaining. The ball was thrown up because of a 6-6-6 position warning.
That moment of uncertainty was removed in a climactic end to a great grand final and could be again if a bounce was recalled. Yet, the sky didn't fall in.es remaining. The ball was thrown up because of a 6-6-6 position warning.
Three of the final four centre bounce situations were ball-ups in the final six minutes, two due to 6-6-6 warnings and one due to a recall (which took two seconds off in the final five minutes).
The AFL changed the rule at the start of this season so that umpires bounce the ball after issuing a 6-6-6 warning (as happened just before three-quarter-time time on Thursday night).
It's time for a decision on the bounce
The rule changes around the centre bounces make you wonder what is being protected. In 2025, it has degenerated into a wrestling match between ruckmen, since the AFL last year enabled straight-arm blocks providing the ruck involved was contesting the ball. It is no longer exciting to watch.
Lawmakers were trying to avoid such wrestling when they introduced the centre circle across the line in 1980, following the ugly rucking spectacle that marred the 1979 preliminary final when Collingwood's Peter Moore and North Melbourne's Gary Dempsey wrestled like two pythons throughout the match.
For half a century the game achieved that objective until a 2024 rule change was introduced for reasons unknown.
'It's gone back to Dempsey-Moore,' Madden said, adding he would remove the line across the centre, and debate the size of the circle, to reconfigure the contest. 'Everyone would have to move to the ball.'
He doesn't think anyone would notice if the bounce was scrapped.
Although the reason for the next major change was sound, the rot set in when the AFL limited the ruckman's run-up to 10m in 2005 to protect them against posterior cruciate ligament injuries which occurred when knee hit knee.
Four years later, the chaotic element was minimised again when umpires were empowered to recall an errant bounce at a stoppage and replace it with a throw-up. It followed controversy when North Melbourne midfielder Adam Simpson was gifted a centre clearance in 2008 that led to a vital goal against Collingwood in round seven that season.
That decision started the decline of the centre bounce into the relic it is now.
A senior club official argued that the game should be wary of yielding to coaches' need for certainty in an era when fans crave the uncertainty sport provides. The bounce, he argued, should be retained on that basis.
Loading
But what we have is a facade of the centre bounce.
Another real debate is needed.
Scrap it forever in the interests of fairness, protecting umpires' backs and Hardwick and his ilk, or return it to the wonderful random tradition it once was by removing the recall.
Incoming football operations boss Greg Swann needs to convince the AFL Commission to back the bounce or sack it. If they sacked what we have now, in less than a season, no one would miss it.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

A footy text put our friendship on the brink. She should know there are rules
A footy text put our friendship on the brink. She should know there are rules

Sydney Morning Herald

time2 hours ago

  • Sydney Morning Herald

A footy text put our friendship on the brink. She should know there are rules

It's a weekend, I've time on my hands and it strikes me that I haven't checked in with a few friends for a while. But before I text, I need to look up the footy fixture. I'll work through a mental checklist. Has their team played yet? Did they win? Did they get thrashed? Where are they on the ladder? Are they out of finals' contention? Does it fit with pre-season predictions? Whether they're Carlton supporters with the blues, Saints mates having a hellish season or Bomber besties nosediving, footy fandom comes with great highs and the lowest of lows. If they're hardcore card carrying, scarf waving, form-following fans their moods are delicately connected to the win/loss ratio of their teams. If there's a game coming up, I'll usually put off my text for another day. If their team has been thrashed, I will give it a miss. Don't poke the bear. If they've had a win I might text a congratulatory message. My sporting fix is AFL, but it could apply to any other code. The season starts with great promise, and before long teams and the hopes and dreams of their supporters are cruelled by injuries, long-awaited premiership windows vanish and suddenly September is looking free. Anyone for a weekend away? Others are on tenterhooks, madly calculating if their team can make the cut, and praying for unlikely upsets in hope that other teams will make way for them. A friend and I bristled after a Collingwood-barracking friend texted us to gloat as we stood, stunned and disappointed in the MCG stands after the siren, as Richmond's 2018 campaign for back-to-back premierships came to a sudden end.

Inside Richmond's flag blueprint: the hunt for the next Riewoldt and Rance
Inside Richmond's flag blueprint: the hunt for the next Riewoldt and Rance

Sydney Morning Herald

time2 hours ago

  • Sydney Morning Herald

Inside Richmond's flag blueprint: the hunt for the next Riewoldt and Rance

Richmond have proven most critics wrong by winning five games with five rounds to go in a season doomsayers predicted last year's wooden-spooners may not win once. The Tigers have also blooded the second-most debutants (nine), behind only injury ravaged Essendon (13). Losing top-tier talent The bulk player exits in Yze's first season at the helm, after celebrating only two victories, could have been daunting – but the coach insisted this week there was never any panic. 'You go through what we went through, and the toughest part of it was injury. Players leaving and retiring [is] part of footy,' Yze said. 'You're constantly regenerating your list, and guys are finishing and starting.' Injuries were a genuine excuse: only Carlton lost more games last year to first-choice players (167) than Richmond (155). As soon as Tigers list boss Blair Hartley knew Rioli, Bolton and Baker were leaving, he resolved to maximise the trade return and use it to make a major investment in a loaded 2024 draft that they recognised years earlier as a standout crop. Richmond's actions the previous year showed how much they loved that draft class. They made several trades, including sending Ivan Soldo to Port Adelaide and twice moving down in the 2023 draft, which resulted in them gathering future assets. Hartley then secured picks six, 10, 11, 18 and 23 for Rioli, Bolton and Baker, and engineered a separate deal with Brisbane – who were looking to stack draft selections to match father-son and academy bids – to also receive the Lions' No.20 for some of those future picks that were acquired 12 months earlier. The strategy The Tigers came no higher than ninth, and averaged a 13th-placed finish, during a difficult 11-year period between 2002 and 2012. In the early years under Hardwick, Richmond eventually played finals in each of the next three seasons before tumbling again, only for club officials to famously stick by the man who went on to lead them to three flags. That fateful decision paved the way for one of the Tigers' greatest periods – but as important were their drafting calls years earlier. After far too many recruiting missteps, and watching Hawthorn swoop on twin towers Jarryd Roughead and Lance Franklin either side of Brett Deledio and Richard Tambling in 2004, Richmond began identifying building blocks – big ones – who became an enormous part of the future success. Loading Francis Jackson's first draft as national recruiting manager in 2006 saw him select Jack Riewoldt (pick 13) and Shane Edwards (26). The next year, it was Trent Cotchin (two) and Alex Rance (18). In 2009, the Tigers snared Dustin Martin (three) and David Astbury (35) before using a pre-season draft pick on a kid from the Northern Knights, Dylan Grimes. Six of the seven played integral roles in Richmond's 2017, 2019 and 2020 premierships. Five-time All-Australian key defender Rance played in the first, but an ACL rupture cost him from featuring in the second, before his shock retirement. Four of them were important bookends. In between, they also used a top-10 pick on forward-ruck Ty Vickery, who left for the Hawks at the end of 2016 – but assembling key-position talent was a priority. Loading That strategy was front-of-mind when current list boss Blair Hartley presided over a haul of seven first-round draft picks last year. Jackson is still at the Tigers, working in the 'futures' talent market. Richmond used six of those selections, on midfielders Sam Lalor (one), Josh Smillie (seven) and Taj Hotton (12), plus key forwards Jonty Faull (14) and Harry Armstrong (23), and tall defender Luke Trainor (21). They savvily traded the seventh in a package for North Melbourne's 2025 first-rounder, which currently projects to be the No.2 pick. The Roos drafted swingman Matt Whitlock. On day two of the draft, the Tigers resisted the temptation of rival clubs' offers to pick 199-centimetre forward-ruck Tom Sims with the opening selection of the second round. Sims was their fourth draftee who stood at least 195 centimetres tall. 'We're trying to pick a premiership team, not a team to win potentially next year,' Hartley said in November. 'You look at the basis of a lot of the premiership sides, even [going] back in time with Richmond, and it was Riewoldt and Rance in '06 and '07. Building that base of talls allows them to develop as we continue to build our side over the next few years.' Differing approaches By contrast, North Melbourne opted to build from the midfield out. It is too simplistic to just compare the Roos and Tigers in this way, but their respective recruiting blueprints were at odds. Richmond entered round 20 above North on the ladder, despite the latter launching their rebuild with a massive cleanout at the end of 2020. The Kangaroos, for various reasons, have not won more than four games in any season since, whereas the Tigers are already up to five this year. 'I recall being asked before the season, 'How are you going to cope when you're not winning, or you're getting 100-point losses?' – but we can't live in that headspace,' Livingstone told The Age. 'We understand there are going to be bumps in the road with players developing their game, but we want to teach them winning habits. We want them to be able to learn how to fight through games, and how to be down by a lot against Geelong [in round 17], down at GMHBA, and then fight through and have a competitive second half. Loading 'They're the sorts of things that will set you up for long-term success.' An opposition recruiter, who spoke to this masthead on the condition of anonymity to discuss another club more freely, described the Tigers' early rebuilding efforts as 'unbelievable' – and forecast they could contend for finals again as soon as 2027, ahead of Tasmania's entry into the league. 'It's a credit to them for being brave enough to let all those guys go, then to make all those picks in one year,' the recruiter said. 'They would have known it was an average draft this year, particularly with how compromised it is, and that last year's draft was the one to do it [invest heavily]. But it's also a big credit to the coach for playing them all, and Blair's done a great job.' Richmond's ex-chief executive Brendon Gale famously made a bold but stunningly accurate prediction in 2010 that they would win three premierships by 2020. Yze and Livingstone were unwilling this week to do any such crystal-ball gazing, beyond saying they wanted to 'bounce back as quickly as we can'. 'We're not going to say, 'We should be here in two years' or three years' time',' Livingstone said. 'Our player development team is doing a wonderful job at trying to fast-track their careers and help teach these guys the winning habits that are going to take us forward sooner than we think. But putting time frames on it is not for us to worry about right now.'

Inside Richmond's flag blueprint: the hunt for the next Riewoldt and Rance
Inside Richmond's flag blueprint: the hunt for the next Riewoldt and Rance

The Age

time2 hours ago

  • The Age

Inside Richmond's flag blueprint: the hunt for the next Riewoldt and Rance

Richmond have proven most critics wrong by winning five games with five rounds to go in a season doomsayers predicted last year's wooden-spooners may not win once. The Tigers have also blooded the second-most debutants (nine), behind only injury ravaged Essendon (13). Losing top-tier talent The bulk player exits in Yze's first season at the helm, after celebrating only two victories, could have been daunting – but the coach insisted this week there was never any panic. 'You go through what we went through, and the toughest part of it was injury. Players leaving and retiring [is] part of footy,' Yze said. 'You're constantly regenerating your list, and guys are finishing and starting.' Injuries were a genuine excuse: only Carlton lost more games last year to first-choice players (167) than Richmond (155). As soon as Tigers list boss Blair Hartley knew Rioli, Bolton and Baker were leaving, he resolved to maximise the trade return and use it to make a major investment in a loaded 2024 draft that they recognised years earlier as a standout crop. Richmond's actions the previous year showed how much they loved that draft class. They made several trades, including sending Ivan Soldo to Port Adelaide and twice moving down in the 2023 draft, which resulted in them gathering future assets. Hartley then secured picks six, 10, 11, 18 and 23 for Rioli, Bolton and Baker, and engineered a separate deal with Brisbane – who were looking to stack draft selections to match father-son and academy bids – to also receive the Lions' No.20 for some of those future picks that were acquired 12 months earlier. The strategy The Tigers came no higher than ninth, and averaged a 13th-placed finish, during a difficult 11-year period between 2002 and 2012. In the early years under Hardwick, Richmond eventually played finals in each of the next three seasons before tumbling again, only for club officials to famously stick by the man who went on to lead them to three flags. That fateful decision paved the way for one of the Tigers' greatest periods – but as important were their drafting calls years earlier. After far too many recruiting missteps, and watching Hawthorn swoop on twin towers Jarryd Roughead and Lance Franklin either side of Brett Deledio and Richard Tambling in 2004, Richmond began identifying building blocks – big ones – who became an enormous part of the future success. Loading Francis Jackson's first draft as national recruiting manager in 2006 saw him select Jack Riewoldt (pick 13) and Shane Edwards (26). The next year, it was Trent Cotchin (two) and Alex Rance (18). In 2009, the Tigers snared Dustin Martin (three) and David Astbury (35) before using a pre-season draft pick on a kid from the Northern Knights, Dylan Grimes. Six of the seven played integral roles in Richmond's 2017, 2019 and 2020 premierships. Five-time All-Australian key defender Rance played in the first, but an ACL rupture cost him from featuring in the second, before his shock retirement. Four of them were important bookends. In between, they also used a top-10 pick on forward-ruck Ty Vickery, who left for the Hawks at the end of 2016 – but assembling key-position talent was a priority. Loading That strategy was front-of-mind when current list boss Blair Hartley presided over a haul of seven first-round draft picks last year. Jackson is still at the Tigers, working in the 'futures' talent market. Richmond used six of those selections, on midfielders Sam Lalor (one), Josh Smillie (seven) and Taj Hotton (12), plus key forwards Jonty Faull (14) and Harry Armstrong (23), and tall defender Luke Trainor (21). They savvily traded the seventh in a package for North Melbourne's 2025 first-rounder, which currently projects to be the No.2 pick. The Roos drafted swingman Matt Whitlock. On day two of the draft, the Tigers resisted the temptation of rival clubs' offers to pick 199-centimetre forward-ruck Tom Sims with the opening selection of the second round. Sims was their fourth draftee who stood at least 195 centimetres tall. 'We're trying to pick a premiership team, not a team to win potentially next year,' Hartley said in November. 'You look at the basis of a lot of the premiership sides, even [going] back in time with Richmond, and it was Riewoldt and Rance in '06 and '07. Building that base of talls allows them to develop as we continue to build our side over the next few years.' Differing approaches By contrast, North Melbourne opted to build from the midfield out. It is too simplistic to just compare the Roos and Tigers in this way, but their respective recruiting blueprints were at odds. Richmond entered round 20 above North on the ladder, despite the latter launching their rebuild with a massive cleanout at the end of 2020. The Kangaroos, for various reasons, have not won more than four games in any season since, whereas the Tigers are already up to five this year. 'I recall being asked before the season, 'How are you going to cope when you're not winning, or you're getting 100-point losses?' – but we can't live in that headspace,' Livingstone told The Age. 'We understand there are going to be bumps in the road with players developing their game, but we want to teach them winning habits. We want them to be able to learn how to fight through games, and how to be down by a lot against Geelong [in round 17], down at GMHBA, and then fight through and have a competitive second half. Loading 'They're the sorts of things that will set you up for long-term success.' An opposition recruiter, who spoke to this masthead on the condition of anonymity to discuss another club more freely, described the Tigers' early rebuilding efforts as 'unbelievable' – and forecast they could contend for finals again as soon as 2027, ahead of Tasmania's entry into the league. 'It's a credit to them for being brave enough to let all those guys go, then to make all those picks in one year,' the recruiter said. 'They would have known it was an average draft this year, particularly with how compromised it is, and that last year's draft was the one to do it [invest heavily]. But it's also a big credit to the coach for playing them all, and Blair's done a great job.' Richmond's ex-chief executive Brendon Gale famously made a bold but stunningly accurate prediction in 2010 that they would win three premierships by 2020. Yze and Livingstone were unwilling this week to do any such crystal-ball gazing, beyond saying they wanted to 'bounce back as quickly as we can'. 'We're not going to say, 'We should be here in two years' or three years' time',' Livingstone said. 'Our player development team is doing a wonderful job at trying to fast-track their careers and help teach these guys the winning habits that are going to take us forward sooner than we think. But putting time frames on it is not for us to worry about right now.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store