Serious concern over Finance Bill 2025 amendments expressed
ISLAMABAD: All Pakistan Fruit & Vegetable Exporters Importers and Merchants Association has expressed serious concern over Finance Bill 2025 amendments, empowering Officer of Inland Revenue to arrest any person including Chief Executive Officer, Directors, or Chief Finance Officer for alleged involvement in tax fraud.
According to a letter of the association to Finance Minister, the tax officer may believe that delay in arrest may enable the accused to evade the process of law or circumstance exist in which obtain prior approval of the Commissioner Inland Revenue is not practicable, involved in tax fraud, surfaced during an investigation and supported by evidence.
This provision is deeply troubling as it allows arbitrary and unchecked arrest powers, without any judicial oversight, due process of law or defined evidentiary standards. The members of our association also stressed the need for increasing momentum of confidence level and facilities to be availed in easy way for onward boost the exports and bring the foreign exchange as well achieve the revenue target.
The taxpayers/members of our association raised grave legal and practical concerns regarding implementing this proposed provision of law due to the following reasons: The power to arrest without prior approval, based on subjective belief, undermines due process. It opens the door to potential misuse or abuse of power. Granting arrest powers without checks can create fear among corporate leadership, including CEOs, CFOs, and directors. This may discourage investment and negatively impact economic activity.
The threshold of 'supported by evidence' is vague—what qualifies as sufficient evidence? No clear procedural safeguards to prevent arbitrary detention or ensure judicial oversight. This may conflict with fundamental rights such as the right to liberty, fair trial, and protection from arbitrary arrest. It also violates the due process of law standards under national and international law.
It is submitted that the Courts of Pakistan have also consistently ruled out in favour of safeguarding the liberty of citizens, including taxpayers, and ensuring that tax authorities do not overstep their legal mandate.
It is further emphasized that the Constitution of Islamic Republic of Pakistan also provide that any attempt to arrest a taxpayer without observing due course of law— is a violation of Article 4 and Article 10-A of the Constitution of Pakistan. Such actions are legally untenable and liable to be struck down by the courts.
In light of the above said, it is strongly urged that the proposed Section37AA be deleted entirely, without further argument or justification. The inclusion of such a provision is not only excessive but unnecessary, given that adequate legal mechanisms already exist to deal with tax fraud under due process. We sincerely hope that this concern will be given due consideration in the interest of fairness, justice, and economic stability, it added.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
a day ago
- Express Tribune
PSX climbs to historic high at 124k
Shares of 333 companies were traded. At the end of the day, 135 stocks closed higher. PHOTO: FILE Listen to article Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX) closed at another all-time high on Friday, with the benchmark KSE-100 index surging over 2,300 points, or 1.91%, and closing just shy of 124,400, marking a weekly gain of 3.6%. The rally was fueled by aggressive institutional buying ahead of FY26 portfolio allocations, strong foreign inflows and improved investor sentiment. Key gainers included Fauji Fertiliser Company (FFC), Lucky Cement and Meezan Bank, while Pakistan Services, National Foods and International Steels weighed on the index. Fresh hydrocarbon discoveries by Pakistan Oilfields and MOL in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa lifted energy sector confidence. On the diplomatic front, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif and US Secretary of State Marco Rubio reaffirmed their commitment to deepening trade ties. Meanwhile, Pakistan secured $3.1 billion in commercial loans and over $500 million in multilateral funding, expected to be reflected in reserves late Friday. Trading volumes remained robust at 773.4 million shares while traded value stood at Rs37.6 billion. The market is expected to find support around 122,000 with potential upside towards 127,000 in the coming week. "Stocks closed at an all-time high after the National Assembly passed Finance Bill 2025 amid political consensus. Investors eye State Bank's policy easing amid falling government bond yields in the recent auction," said Arif Habib Corp Managing Director Ahsan Mehanti. Surging global equities on a stable Iran-Israel ceasefire and rising global crude oil prices drove the PSX to a record close, he added. At the end of trading, the benchmark KSE-100 index posted a surge of 2,332.60 points, or 1.91%, and settled at 124,379.07. Arif Habib Limited (AHL) wrote in its daily review that on Friday, the index rose by 1.91%, led by strong performances from FFC (+2.23%), Lucky Cement (+4.28%) and Meezan Bank (+2.98%). On the flip side, Pakistan Services (-8.3%), National Foods (-1.76%) and International Steels (-0.8%) were the key drags on the index. In a positive development, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif and US Secretary of State Marco Rubio agreed to deepen bilateral ties, especially through enhanced trade. Meanwhile, the government of Pakistan secured $3.1 billion in commercial loans and over $500 million in multilateral funding, which would be reflected in the reserves update. In the energy sector, Pakistan Oilfields (+6.06%) and MOL announced new hydrocarbon discoveries in K-P's Makori Deep-03 well, expected to yield 22 mmcfd of gas and 2,112 barrels of oil per day, AHL mentioned. For the coming week, technical support is expected at around 122,000, with resistance seen near 127,000. It was a strong week for Pakistan's equity market, with the KSE-100 index gaining 3.6% week-on-week to close above the 124,000 mark, it added. Topline Securities, in its review, wrote that bulls dominated trading on aggressive buying by local institutions as the KSE-100 index increased 1.9% to close at its highest-ever level of 124,379. "This buying by local institutions can be attributed to fresh liquidity due to new fiscal year allocations towards equity funds," it said. Top positive contribution to the index came from FFC, Lucky Cement, Meezan Bank, Pakistan Oilfields, Engro Holdings, Engro Fertilisers and OGDC as they cumulatively contributed 1,044 points. Traded value-wise, Lucky Cement (Rs2.27 billion), OGDC (Rs2.11 billion), PSO (Rs1.97 billion), Pakistan Petroleum (Rs1.94 billion), Maple Leaf Cement (Rs1.09 billion), Hubco (Rs1.03 billion) and UBL (Rs1.02 billion) dominated the trading activity, Topline added. Mubashir Anis Naviwala of JS Global said bulls took charge on the trading floor, with the KSE-100 index climbing 2,332 points. Strong price action was seen across the board, reflecting renewed investor confidence. Broad-based buying interest lifted major sectors, boosting the overall market sentiment, he said. The rally was supported by robust demand for cement, banking and fertiliser stocks. The near-term outlook remains positive, with dips offering attractive entry opportunities, the analyst said. Overall, shares of 484 companies were traded. Of these, 334 stocks closed higher, 116 fell and 34 remained unchanged. Bank Makramah was the volume leader with trading in 79.7 million shares, gaining Rs0.56 to close at Rs5.07. It was followed by Ghani Global Holdings with 27.7 million shares, gaining Rs1.60 to close at Rs17.99 and Pervez Ahmed Consultancy with 24.9 million shares, losing Rs0.02 to close at Rs3.27. Foreign investors sold shares worth Rs1.2 billion, the National Clearing Company reported.
Business Recorder
a day ago
- Business Recorder
Tax fraud via bank account to land holder in jail
ISLAMABAD: The person, whose bank account has been used to commit tax fraud, would be considered as 'abettor' and would be subjected to prosecution including punishment/ imprisonment. Thus, the person operating business bank account to facilitate tax fraud would be considered as 'abettor'. The amended Finance Bill (2025-26) has revised the definition of 'abettor'. Key amendments made to Finance Bill: Tax fraud arrests only post-inquiry According to the amended Bill, the 'abettor' means a person who intentionally abets or connives in tax fraud as defined in clause (37) of section 2 or in the commission of any offence warranting prosecution under Sales Tax Act, and includes a person who, prepares, or causes to be prepared with or without authorization of the registered person, invoices for false claim of input tax adjustment. The 'abettor' also included a person who allows use of bank account held or operated by him for abetting tax fraud or other offence warranting prosecution under this Act or unauthorisedly or illegally maintains or operates business bank account in other registered person's name, amended Finance Bill 2025-26 added. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
a day ago
- Business Recorder
FBR deploys taxmen on leading solar cos' premises
KARACHI: The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has tightened the noose around solar energy sector, deploying tax officials in the premises of country's leading solar energy companies to monitor sales record and plug revenue leakage under section 40-B of the Sales Tax Act 1990. As an intensified effort to ensure compliance in country's growing renewable energy sector, the FBR has given a go-ahead to the Chief Commissioner Inland Revenue, Corporate Tax Office Karachi to station its officers at the premises of top solar energy companies for a period of 30 days, the letter said. The monitoring exercise, under section 40-B of the Sales Tax Act 1990, has initially commenced against four prominent solar companies operating in Karachi. Sales Tax cut on solar panels import: Rs20bn revenue hit expected Sources claimed that these companies have reportedly been engaging in sales suppression to evade sales tax obligations. Therefore, the deployment is part of a targeted effort to verify it and ensure proper tax compliance, they said. 'The officers will monitor the sales of taxable goods and stock positions of these solar companies under section 40B of the Sales Tax Act 1990, which empowers the tax office to post officials at business premises to ensure compliance with tax regulations and prevent revenue leakage,' source said. The solar energy sector has experienced remarkable growth in Pakistan in recent years as the country is pursuing energy diversification strategies to reduce costly energy imports and address persistent power related issues, sources said. However, this rapid expansion has also raised concerns about potential revenue losses from non-compliance, they added. Furthermore, they said the 30-day monitoring period would allow FBR officials to conduct real-time oversight of business operations, sales transactions, and inventory management, adding that the monitoring exercise against these companies, which is expected to conclude within 30-day timeframe, may be expanded to other high-growth sectors to meet revenue targets. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
