Doctors write to health minister over 'deeply damaging' decision on northwest surgical hub
Plans to build surgical hubs nationally were first announced in December 2022, with an 18-month turnaround time predicted. However, so far only one of the six has opened, with funding allocated for hubs in Cork, Waterford, and Limerick.
A location for the northwest hub has not yet been named, but it has recently emerged this is likely set for Sligo and not Donegal.
Now, GPs and hospital doctors have called on health minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill to meet with them and hear the arguments against that decision.
Dr Padraig McGuinness said the decision ignores the reality of local geography.
'Donegal has a larger population than the combined areas of Sligo, Leitrim, South Donegal, and Cavan,' he said.
Many of our patients would face round trips of five hours or more to access elective surgical care in Sligo. That's unacceptable and dangerous.
He added: "This isn't just about a building or a budget line. It's about whether Donegal patients are treated as equals in our health system. Right now, they're not.'
Pressures on Letterkenny hospital are a key reason why they need the hub, argued Dr Louise Moran, consultant in intensive care and anaesthetics.
"Patients in Donegal already face some of the worst cancer survival rates in the country due to late presentation and access issues,' she warned.
'To bypass Letterkenny again is not only medically indefensible, it's a direct hit on patient safety and regional equality.'
Letterkenny is often among the most overcrowded hospitals in the country as recorded by the Irish Nurses and Midwives Organisation.
The hubs are seen as a central part of plans to tackle overcrowding.
Each is expected to deliver 10,000 day case surgeries and minor procedures, and 18,500 outpatient consultations every year.
Plans by the HSE to instead offer Letterkenny an ambulatory care centre for outpatients are seen by this group of doctors as 'an inadequate substitute lacking ring-fenced funding, staffing plans, or timelines.'
Consultant general surgeon Michael Sugrue said: 'We need real surgical infrastructure, not vague promises'.
He warned of the long-term impact for recruitment at Letterkenny University Hospital.
Without adequate surgical resources, we simply cannot attract or retain the consultants we need.
"This decision risks the future of general surgery in Donegal and the long-term viability of LUH as a Model 3 hospital,' he said.
They called for an evidence-based review of the HSE's plans to locate the hub in Sligo.
In April HSE regional executive officer Tony Canavan said a proposal to build a surgical hub linked to Sligo hospital has been submitted.
"We've identified a site for it that will be considered by the HSE senior leadership team in mid-May and then to the board of the HSE at the end of May,' he told RTÉ News.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
'Young people and rural areas let down by lack of drug treatment and prevention services'
Concerns have been raised around access to drug treatment services and prevention efforts, according to an independent evaluation of the Government's drug strategy. Rural areas, young people, and marginalised groups are reported as being 'disproportionately affected' by service discrepancies. Meanwhile, the review found that annual funding arrangements and restrictive hiring policies have contributed to staff shortages and disruptions in service delivery. The national drug strategy (NDS) is set out as a national framework for addressing substance use through a 'whole-of-Government, person-centred, and health-led' approach that primarily frames substance use as a public health issue. An independent review of the strategy, published on Monday, has found that several stakeholders also believe prevention efforts are underdeveloped, inconsistent, and lacking national ownership. The report, compiled by Grant Thornton, notes some progress and achievements, but makes 10 recommendations for the future direction of the strategy. The 10 strategic recommendations Improve the right to health for people who use drugs, providing culturally-sensitive and appropriate services for all groups. Increase community engagement and involvement from people who use these services, ensuring that they are central to policy-making and service design. Align service delivery with regional priorities, working with Health Regions to ensure that the implementation of a future drugs strategy and allocation of resources are appropriate to the local population needs. Maintain and strengthen coordination and communication between the oversight structures of the National Drugs Strategy. Establish mechanisms for interdepartmental collaboration, reflecting the need for systemic alignment across housing, justice and health sectors. Continue to strengthen alternatives to coercive sanctions for those found in possession of drugs for personal use, such as the Health Diversion Scheme and community liaison roles. Ensure equitable access to peer-led recovery services and develop national standards for recovery pathways. Strengthen prevention and early intervention initiatives across sectors. Strengthen the integration of alcohol within the national drugs strategy, rolling out integrated treatment services to enhance service delivery. Invest in monitoring, evaluation and research systems to support evidence-based policy and accountability. The authors consulted with the HSE, the health research board, members of the national oversight committee and strategic implementation groups for the NDS, as well as service users and family members with experience of drug use. Based on those engagements, it found that equity of access continues to be a concern, particularly for marginalised groups. Prevention and early intervention efforts were found to be fragmented and inconsistently delivered, while recovery and service-user involvement requires further formalisation and resourcing. Additionally, the limited integration of alcohol policy and the 'gradual implementation of legal reforms', such as alternative sanctions, were identified as requiring strategic refinement. Governance structures Meanwhile, governance structures were found to lack clearly defined roles, mandates, and accountability mechanisms. Stakeholders highlighted the need for strong national leadership, enhanced co-ordination across departments, and more inclusive decision-making processes that incorporate lived experience of service users. There were also calls for enhanced data integration and the establishment of a national research and evaluation centre. The report also details claims of inconsistent reporting from all treatment providers, which is further constraining the ability to assess the strategy's effectiveness. Stakeholders reported that high attrition rates have been observed in different regions due to factors that include limited funding. Multi-annual funding There were repeated calls by some stakeholders for multi-annual funding commitments and targeted workforce investment to support more consistent and sustainable service provision. Prevention efforts were widely viewed as 'under-resourced and lacking strategic focus'. There was an emphasis on the need for early, community-based interventions that address root causes such as trauma, poverty, and social disadvantage. Evidence shows that early-life experiences significantly influence later substance use. The social, personal, and health education programme in schools was repeatedly cited for its inconsistent delivery. Alcohol addiction Many stakeholders also felt that the NDS lacked clarity and strategic direction regarding alcohol addiction. Health minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill said it is 'essential' to assess how the more than €300 million in annual public expenditure on drugs delivers impact. She said: The establishment of new HSE health regions presents a valuable opportunity to tailor drug treatment services to population needs and to ensure that both existing and new funding is allocated effectively and transparently. Meanwhile, the minister of State with responsibility for the National Drugs Strategy, Jennifer Murnane O'Connor, said: 'We have made significant progress in implementing the national drugs strategy, and I'm pleased that the independent evaluation documents the many achievements over the last eight years.' She added: 'The recommendations from the independent evaluation will inform the development of the successor National Drugs Strategy. "We need to move forward with new policies and better services to address the ever-changing drugs situation.'
The Irish Sun
3 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Ireland's cancer care postcode lottery laid bare as lives put at risk with new person diagnosed with disease every 3mins
A POSTCODE lottery exists for patients accessing cancer care, it has emerged. New data shows huge variations in tests and treatment across Ireland, meaning where you live can significantly impact how quickly you're diagnosed, and start treatment. 3 The postcode lottery is putting cancer patients at risk Credit: Getty Nationally, only 74.2 per cent of men got their prostate rapid access clinic appointment within 20 working days – below the 90 per cent target. This dropped as low as 12.7 per cent in Major regional variance was also seen in breast and lung Some 96.6 per cent of But this was down to just 62 per cent for Irish Cancer Society chief Averil Power warns there is no question these delays are causing avoidable deaths and that this postcode EVERY three minutes someone in Ireland learns they have cancer. One in two of us are now expected to get the disease in our lifetime. When you, or someone you love, receives that devastating news, you deserve the best possible chance of surviving the disease. Sadly, right now in Ireland, many people are not getting that chance. The major symptoms of 'common cancer' as HSE say 'know the signs' In cancer care, time can be everything. For many cancers, your chances of survival at stage one are 80 per cent or more. TIME MATTERS But by stage four, that can drop to less than 20 per cent. So early detection and treatment can literally be the difference between life and death. That is why target waiting times for cancer tests and treatment are set out in the National Cancer Strategy. However, WAITING FOR TESTS Many patients are waiting much longer than they should to access tests for breast and prostate cancer. Imagine being told by your This was the experience of one woman referred for an urgent breast assessment at the Mater Hospital in Dublin. Nationally, almost one in four women referred for urgent testing at Breast Rapid Access Clinics were not seen within the 10-day target. At the Mater, seven out of ten patients were not seen on time. Three other hospitals dropped below five in ten for at least four months last year. One in four patients nationally waited longer than they should have for their first appointment at a Prostate Rapid Access Clinic. At Galway University Hospital, only 13 per cent of patients accessed the prostate clinic on time. Access to cancer care and diagnostics should not be a postcode lottery. In Ireland, it is. CHEMOTHERAPY DELAYS If you are in the west or north-west of the country, you are far more likely to wait longer than you should for access to chemotherapy. The longest waiting times were in Letterkenny University Hospital, where on average only 20 per cent of patients started their treatment on time. In some months, nobody did. The situation has improved, but it is not acceptable that it became this bad. RADIOTHERAPY DELAYS The longest waiting times for radiotherapy were in the east of the country. Ninety per cent of patients should start radiation oncology treatment within 15 working days. In public hospitals across Ireland, just 66 per cent of patients did. In St Luke's in Dublin, only 62 per cent started on time. PUTTING LIVES AT RISK These waiting times are not only causing enormous anxiety for patients and In fact, the INADEQUATE STAFFING, EQUIPMENT AND SPACE For cancer services to function effectively, they need three things – staff, equipment and physical space. Most cancer centres are struggling with at least one of those. Our hospitals are staffed with incredible doctors, nurses, and other healthcare professionals. They are working hard to deliver the best care they can. However, there are simply not enough of them. Equipment is a problem too. There is no PET scanner in our public hospitals in Galway, Limerick or Waterford. Some of the radiotherapy machines in Dublin are seven years past their useful life and are often out of service. While many welcome extensions have been added at some hospitals, others are half the size they need to be. INVESTMENT It must also deliver increased investment in cancer staffing in the next year's If the current coalition runs its full term, almost a quarter of a million people will hear the words 'you have cancer' under its watch. They must invest to ensure that more of us receive the words the Irish Cancer Society believes that everyone should hear: 'You will survive.' 3 One person learns they have cancer every three minutes in Ireland Credit: Getty 3 Irish Cancer Society chief Averil Power said delays are causing avoidable deaths Credit: Fennell Photography
Irish Examiner
13 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Endometriosis education programme to be expanded across secondary schools
A new endometriosis education programme offered by a teacher and medical scientist has already been used by 14 schools with plans for more from September. An estimated 10% of girls and women worldwide have endometriosis. It is known as the missed disease as worldwide it can take up to 10 years to diagnose. There is no cure but symptoms can be eased with treatment. Cate O' Connor, a primary school teacher in Limerick, said the reaction from girls in secondary schools has been great. 'We go through the basics of the menstrual cycle, and then we go into endometriosis,' she said. 'The other big message we're trying to get across to them is about what's normal and not normal, so the difference between discomfort and distress.' They aim to present the science in an accessible way. 'The students see an awful lot of information on TikTok,' she said. 'There's a lot of information recently about contraception and taking the pill with adverse effects but then they go to the doctor (with period pains) and that's the solution that's offered so there's conflicting information.' She added: 'They're getting information from TikTok which is not medically based and then they're getting information from their doctor and they're not sure what to do.' Ms O' Connor and co-founder Kathleen King, a HSE medical scientist, have endometriosis but do not discuss this with the students. 'Some schools have said to us that with these kinds of topics sometimes having an outside person come in can help the girls open up more,' she said. 'They see us, ask us questions and it's not embarrassing because they're probably not going to see us again.' She added the pair would also like to see interested teachers trained up. It is usually SPHE teachers inviting them in and they also worked with a PE teacher worried about girls dropping out of sport. 'That is one way the Department of Education could get involved,' she said. The programme is inspired by New Zealand's 'what about me' menstrual education programme. The Irish programme is called 'MISE' which means 'me' in Irish and here stands for Menstrual Information Specialising in Endometriosis. They run it as volunteers, taking annual leave to deliver the courses. Schools pay €1 per student who attends. 'It's a lot to do, you hear a lot of stories. It makes it worth your while when they come up and ask you the questions,' she said. 'I think the hardest part for us is knowing you are sending them more empowered to their doctor to follow up and more empowered to talk about it at home, but they are going to get caught in the system (with delays).' A new national endometriosis service is rolling out, but the HSE has acknowledged recruitment challenges.
