‘Eyewitnesses recalled faces after 100 days, how,' ask judges
HC pointed out that two cabbies who claimed to have taken two accused, both alleged planters, to Churchgate station; and four eyewitnesses who claimed to see the accused planting bombs in the trains were silent for over 100 days, which, the court said, was "very abnormal." The court said that with minimum interaction, it was doubtful the the cabbies could identify the accused duo after 100 days, reports Swati Deshpande.
The identification parade of various accused in the 11/7 train blasts case was conducted by two special special executive officers or SEOs, one of whom ceased to hold the post in 2005. The Bombay high court said in its judgment that the prosecution failed to bring any evidence on record to show that he continued to be the SEO when the test identification parade was conducted by him on Nov 7, 2006. Hence, the identification of three accused—all alleged planters—stands vitiated and is discarded, it stated.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
American Investor Warren Buffett Recommends: 5 Books For Turning Your Life Around
Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List
Undo
You Can Also Check:
Mumbai AQI
|
Weather in Mumbai
|
Bank Holidays in Mumbai
|
Public Holidays in Mumbai
However, prosecution witnesses can identify accused in court during the trial, but the high court found such identification lacked the credibility it needed.
The HC said the first of six categories of eyewitnesses produced by the prosecution against the accused were two taxi drivers who took two accused, both alleged planters, to Churchgate station; they identified the accused. A total of eight witnesses identified the accused in test identification parades and also in court.
Apart from the two taxi drivers, four claimed to have seen the accused planting the bombs in the trains.
The seventh one claimed that he saw the accused preparing bombs, and the eighth said he saw the hatching of the conspiracy and identified the accused in court. One witness claimed to have seen the suspects after they alighted from the train. His statement helped in creating two sketches, but he was not asked to identify the accused in court, the HC noted.
The HC underscored the part of the brain that helps with face recognition. It said Mumbai cabbies operate in a "manner distinct" from others in India. A passenger states where he wishes to go, and a taxi driver either agrees or disagrees. There is hardly any chance for any taxi driver to have a long interaction with any passenger and to have sufficient and ample opportunity to notice and observe the passengers and their faces, and to store the same in memory for a long period, unless there is some special reason (to do so).
The court said neither cabbie went to the police for over 100 days. The defence said they are "got up witnesses." The high court said that with minimum interaction, it was doubtful they could identify the accused duo after 100 days.
Accounts of the other four eyewitnesses who claimed to see the accused planting bombs in the trains were discarded by the high court, as three of them were in the test identification parade conducted by the SEO who lacked power. Also, for over 100 days, they too were silent, a fact that the high court said was "very abnormal," and they identified the accused in court after over four years. The high court found no special reason for their ability to recollect the faces after "such a long period.
"
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NDTV
28 minutes ago
- NDTV
FBI Ignored Key Evidence In Hillary Clinton Email Case: Declassified Files
Washington: US former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton is once again under scrutiny in the United States after a report claimed the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) "failed to fully investigate" Clinton's use of a private email server and mishandling of highly classified information during her time working with the Obama administration. The report comes days after US Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard alleged that the Obama administration manufactured the 'hoax' around Donald Trump's Russia link. The FBI received "thumb drives" from a "confidential source" that contained official data acquired via cyber intrusions - including emails from President Barack Obama -- the federal agency "barely glanced" at it, according to a declassified appendix to a June 2018 Justice Department (DOJ) inspector general report. US Senator Chuck Grassley's office released a statement on the DOJ's Clinton annex report, alleging that then-FBI Director Comey, Deputy Director Andrew McCabe, former Agent Peter Strzok, and others failed to perform additional, targeted searches of the drives, even though they contained information relevant to the inquiry. Im making "Clinton annex" public 2day so the American ppl hv all the facts Sen Johnson & I hv requested this document's declassification together since 2020 & Pres Trump/Pam Bondi/Kash Patel + others finally got it done Thx 4 ur dedication to transparency — Chuck Grassley (@ChuckGrassley) July 21, 2025 "This document shows an extreme lack of effort and due diligence in the FBI's investigation of former Secretary Clinton's email usage and mishandling of highly classified information," Grassley said. According to Grassley, the thumb drives contained highly sensitive information exfiltrated from US government agencies, including the Department of State, as well as then-President Barack Obama's emails and, potentially, congressional information. The thumb drives were reportedly never reviewed as part of the Clinton investigation, contrary to the recommendation of a draft FBI memorandum. The report was penned by then-DOJ Inspector General Michael Horowitz, who holds the same position at the Federal Reserve Board and Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. It is not known if the FBI has carried out any other thorough investigations of the said hard drives since the 2018 watchdog report was released. The federal agency's Cyber Division had tried to obtain access to the hard drives during the 2016 campaign cycle to carry out targeted searches for information relevant to the Clinton probe. However, the request was rebuffed, according to a Fox report. Then-FBI Deputy Director Andrew McCabe also asked then-US Deputy Attorney General Sally Yates if he could refer to the drives for the bureau's probe of Russian interference in the 2016 election, but again, the request was shot down. This was reportedly done due to concerns that the FBI's probe parameters were too wide and didn't properly safeguard privileged information.' Hillary Clinton Mailing Controversy Before she was sworn in as Secretary of State in 2009, Clinton set up a private email server at her home in New York. During her four years in office, she relied on this server for official as well as private communications rather than using official State Department email accounts maintained on federal servers. Clinton's mailing system courted controversy after a New York Times 2015 report claimed that the system "may have violated federal requirements" and was "alarming" to current and former government archive officials. However, the FBI later determined that Clinton's server did not contain any information that was clearly marked classified and cleared her of all charges.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Missing girl's dad made chilling ‘white van' claim before 9-year-old's body found as ‘inconsistent' timeline exposes truth
Officials said Monday, July 21, that Luciano Frattolin , a father who reported his daughter missing while on vacation in the United States, was charged with second-degree murder and concealing of a corpse. Luciano, 45, called the police on Saturday to report that 9-year-old Melina may have been kidnapped near Lake George, New York. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Select a Course Category Project Management Cybersecurity Technology MCA Public Policy Finance healthcare Leadership Digital Marketing PGDM MBA Operations Management others Artificial Intelligence Data Analytics Design Thinking Management Degree Data Science Product Management Others Healthcare CXO Data Science Skills you'll gain: Portfolio Management Project Planning & Risk Analysis Strategic Project/Portfolio Selection Adaptive & Agile Project Management Duration: 6 Months IIT Delhi Certificate Programme in Project Management Starts on May 30, 2024 Get Details Skills you'll gain: Project Planning & Governance Agile Software Development Practices Project Management Tools & Software Techniques Scrum Framework Duration: 12 Weeks Indian School of Business Certificate Programme in IT Project Management Starts on Jun 20, 2024 Get Details Also read: Melina Frattolin death: how New York cops found girl's body after father Luciano's account and timeline sh by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Play War Thunder now for free War Thunder Play Now Undo After Melina was discovered dead in a nearby town, inside a pond, an Amber Alert was issued for the girl, however it was cancelled. When she was discovered, Luciano "was suspected of having visited" the location. Live Events Luciano's strained ties with Melina's mom At a press conference Monday morning, Captain Robert A. McConnell of the New York State Police said that Luciano and the girl's mother had been at odds since 2019 and that the mother had full custody of Melina. Melina had called her Montreal-based mother just before she passed away to let her know that the two of them were headed home. According to McConnell, "the child did not appear to be under any duress and appeared to be in good health." "The investigation has found that Mr. Frattolin allegedly murdered Melina and left her body in a remote area, where she was later found by law enforcement, sometime after Melina called her mother and before he called 911." Authorities say the man said he had stopped in a parking lot to urinate and then went back to the car, but Melina was not there. Also read: What happened to Melina Galanis Frattolin? Everything we know so far about the missing 9-year-old found de White van used to coerce child, says 'dad' "Initial reports from Mr. Frattolin of a suspicious white van in the area of the alleged disappearance was proven to be untrue," McConnell stated. Later, the chief disclosed that Luciano had stated that she had been coerced into the van by two unidentified men. "That lead was thoroughly investigated and disproven," he stated. The state police were "working tirelessly to hold those responsible fully accountable," according to a post made by New York Governor Kathy Hochul on Sunday night. NY Gov. Kathy Hochul makes statement about case "Lake George has broken the news. She wrote on X, "We're grieving the loss of 9-year-old Melina Frattolin . "There is no ongoing threat to the public at this time." Timeline of Melina Frattolin's murder Authorities released a detailed timeline following the death of Melina Frattolin. July 19, 5:30 p.m. – Melina is captured on surveillance cameras with her father, Luciano, in Saratoga Springs, New York. July 19, 6:30 p.m. – Melina speaks to her mother and mentions they are heading back home to Canada. July 19, 10:00 p.m. – Luciano contacts 911 to report a possible abduction. July 20, early morning – An Amber Alert is issued for Melina. July 20, 1:50 p.m. – A body is discovered in a shallow section of a pond in Ticonderoga, New York. Source: New York State Police According to authorities, Luciano had no past criminal history, including domestic violence, and the cause of the girl's death will be disclosed after the autopsy is completed. "We were informed that she had passed away while I was in the command post. "It was really emotional and challenging," he added. "At that point though, the best we could do is provide some measure of justice to the family and we are just fortunate we're able to do that in this case." Also read: Who is Luciano Frattolin? The grieving father at the heart of the Melina Frattolin tragedy Since the beginning of their journey on July 11, the two have been touring the United States, stopping in destinations like New York City and Connecticut. According to the police, Melina's mother didn't worry for her when she was with her father. It is anticipated that Luciano would face charges in New York.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Canadian father arrested for murder of 9-year-old daughter found dead near Lake George after reporting her missing
A Canadian man has been arrested for the murder of his 9-year-old daughter, just days after he reported her missing while the two were vacationing in New York's Adirondack region. Luciano Frattolin , 45, is now in custody following the discovery of his daughter, Melina Galanis Frattolin's body in a wooded area near Lake George over the weekend. The chain of events began late Saturday, July 19, when Frattolin called 911 from a rest area near Exit 22 off the I-87 in the popular upstate New York vacation spot of Lake George. He reported that Melina had been kidnapped by two men in a white van, prompting New York State Police to issue an Amber Alert . Explore courses from Top Institutes in Select a Course Category MCA Others Data Science Project Management CXO Operations Management healthcare MBA Management Product Management Technology Data Analytics Data Science Leadership Design Thinking PGDM Digital Marketing Artificial Intelligence Public Policy Cybersecurity others Healthcare Finance Degree Skills you'll gain: Programming Proficiency Data Handling & Analysis Cybersecurity Awareness & Skills Artificial Intelligence & Machine Learning Duration: 24 Months Vellore Institute of Technology VIT Master of Computer Applications Starts on Aug 14, 2024 Get Details The alert described Melina as 5 feet tall, approximately 100 pounds, with brown hair and eyes, last seen wearing a striped shirt and Adidas sneakers. Frattolin claimed the van was heading south on the interstate. Responding to the alert, multiple agencies, including K9 units, aviation support, and forest rangers, launched an intensive search. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Top Most Expensive Luxury Cars - Nobody in Sichon Has One! Undo However, within hours, inconsistencies began to emerge in Frattolin's story. Investigators could find no evidence to support the reported abduction. After analyzing surveillance footage, timelines, and physical evidence, police dismissed the kidnapping theory. On Sunday morning, the Amber Alert was canceled, and the case quickly shifted direction. By Sunday afternoon, authorities had located Melina's body in a wooded area along Route 74 in Ticonderoga, about 15 miles east of Lake George and close to the New York-Vermont border. Her remains were discovered in a shallow, swamp-like pond. She was pronounced dead at the scene. Live Events Frattolin was arrested early the following morning and booked into the Essex County Jail on charges of murder and concealment of a human corpse . At his initial court appearance in Ticonderoga Town Court, a not guilty plea was entered on his behalf, and he remains held without bail. During a press briefing, New York State Police Captain Robert McConnell confirmed that Frattolin had "fabricated the initial report of the abduction" and was now the sole suspect in Melina's death. McConnell stated that investigators believe the child was killed sometime Saturday evening, shortly after speaking with her mother by phone to say she and her father were heading back to Montreal following a 10-day road trip through New York and Connecticut. Melina's mother, who had been estranged from Frattolin since 2019, reportedly had no objections to the trip and was in regular phone contact with her daughter. She told officers that the call Saturday night was typical and raised no red flags. Canadian authorities are closely coordinating with their American counterparts as the investigation continues. Authorities have not released the official cause of death, pending a full autopsy report from the medical examiner. Law enforcement officials emphasized that the incident was isolated and posed no ongoing threat to the public. 'This is a profoundly tragic and disturbing case,' said Captain McConnell. 'Our deepest sympathies are with Melina's family and community. We are committed to ensuring justice is served.' A scheduled press conference was held in Latham, New York Monday morning, where state officials reiterated that all investigative leads now point to Frattolin acting alone. No other suspects are being sought.
