Coroner rejects calls for death of Offaly farmer to be forensically investigated by gardaí
The dramatic application was made at the conclusion of a three-day inquest into the death of Joe Grogan (75) who died at his home in Screggan, Tullamore, Co Offaly on 15 April, 2023 just 24 hours after he got married to to his part-time carer, Lisa Flaherty, in a registry office unknown to any of his relatives who were unaware the couple were even in a relationship.
Mr Grogan was a well-known figure in Irish farming circles for hosting the National Ploughing Championships between 2016 and 2018, while the farm will also stage this year's event in September.
The inquest at Offaly Coroner's Court in Tullamore heard that Ms Flaherty – a special needs assistant and mother of three who was 26 years junior to her husband– stands to inherit the 220-acre farm which is valued at €5.5 million as his widow.
It had previously heard that the cause of the farmer's death could not be determined because it was embalmed before a postmortem could be carried out which restricted the tests that could be conducted by a pathologist.
The farmer had been diagnosed with Stage IV Non-Hodgkin lymphoma (a form of blood cancer) in January 2023 and had responded well to treatment, although Ms Flaherty gave evidence that he believed he was dying.
On Tuesday, counsel for three cousins of the deceased – Alo, Margaret and Seán Grogan – Damien Tansey SC, called on the coroner, Raymond Mahon, not to return a verdict and to refer the matter to the DPP for a forensic examination of Mr Grogan's death by gardaí.
Mr Tansey said it would be most unfair to the farmer's memory and to his family if the request was declined.
'Unanswered questions'
Separately, Peter Jones, a solicitor for an aunt of the deceased, Teresa Mooney, also asked the coroner to refer the death to gardaí and to return an open verdict.
Mr Jones claimed the inquest had left 'an awful lot of unanswered questions' and the circumstances of Mr Grogan's death could only be challenged by trained personnel used to investigating 'suspicious deaths.'
However, Mr Mahon returned a narrative verdict based on extensive evidence and claimed the farmer's death was probably due to an infection on the balance of probabilities.
He noted the deceased was a person with a Stage IV high grade cancer who was receiving chemotherapy treatment with a compromised immune system who had also suffered 'significant weight loss.'
Mr Grogan's weight went from 79kg in June 2022 to 67.6kg at the time he was diagnosed with cancer and to 51kg at the time of his death.
The coroner said evidence from witnesses of Mr Grogan's 'slow, elongated decline' lent support to his view that Mr Grogan's death was caused by an infection.
He rejected the suggestion of Mr Tansey that a verdict of unlawful killing could be considered as the evidence was not 'anywhere near the level of proof' required to support such a finding.
Referring to a claim by Mr Jones that the farmer had been 'left to die,' Mr Mahon said there was valid criticism about the way Mr Grogan's care was managed following his last session of chemotherapy.
However, Mr Mahon, who retired as coroner following the case, noted that the deceased had repeatedly told people he did not want to go to hospital and a relative had stated that it was obvious he was dying.
Disquiet in the area
In a submission, Mr Tansey said there was disquiet in the area where Mr Grogan lived over the circumstances of his death which had been significantly added to by the evidence heard at the inquest.
He claimed that the coroner also appeared 'sufficiently troubled' to repossess the body after it had been embalmed to allow an examination to be carried out to try and establish the cause of death.
Mr Tansey said the pathologist Charles D'Adhemar, was working in impossible circumstances due to the 'irreparable damage' caused by the embalming process.
However, he noted that Dr D'Adhemar had been able to detect the presence of three drugs in the body of the deceased which if used in a combination of large quantities could cause respiratory depression.
Mr Tansey accused Ms Flaherty of telling 'porkies' by putting out a false narrative that the farmer was at the end stage of life and requiring palliative care.
He observed that Ms Flaherty had not tried to explain that she was in an 'on-off relationship' with Mr Grogan when she gave evidence that their relationship had been over 16 years but later having to admit that she had another partner up to 2020.
'Secret marriage'
Mr Tansey said another troubling issue was the secrecy surrounding the couple's marriage about which even Ms Flaherty's sister and best friend were unaware.
Advertisement
He also observed she had not called any doctor to see Mr Grogan for the ten days he had been at home before his death after being discharged from hospital after chemotherapy.
The barrister claimed Ms Flaherty had also called an undertaker with 'indecent haste' and had tried to 'ensnare' a doctor in her scheme for getting the body released.
There was a gasped reaction among the large crowd attending the inquest when Mr Tansey reminded the coroner that a verdict of unlawful killing was open to him.
He pointed out that Mr Grogan was clearly ill in the days before his death and there was going to be 'a dreadful end' if there was no appropriate medical intervention.
However, he said the only time the farmer was taken from his house during that period was to go to a registry office 'to hurriedly and secretly arrange a marriage.'
In his submission, Mr Jones said the most solid evidence at the inquest came from doctors who had never given a direction that Mr Grogan required palliative care as suggested by Ms Flaherty.
He noted an oncologist had stated the farmer's death was not inevitable and Mr Jones said it would be a travesty to suggest otherwise.
The solicitor remarked that a 'reign of secrecy' had prevailed over Mr Grogan's final days, while adding that his death was not due to cancer, heart failure or any infection.
However, he claimed the inquest, despite the coroner's best efforts, had not come any nearer to establishing the cause of death.
Mr Jones also noted the 'cruelty' of members of the Grogan family being excluded and only being told of the farmer's death by a friend.
He argued the only people who could 'get to the bottom of this' would be An Garda Síochána and a further investigation would 'satisfy public disquiet.'
The solicitor said Mr Grogan wanted to live and had 'everything to live for.'
However, counsel for Mr Flaherty, Stephen Byrne BL, claimed the inquest had been used to attack Ms Flaherty's good name and reputation.
Mr Byrne said one submission had just stopped short of accusing her of causing Mr Grogan's death.
He claimed the fact that gardaí had not taken any further steps to date 'must carry some weight.'
Mr Byrne reminded the coroner that one of Mr Grogan's own relatives, Enta Conroy, had given evidence that he was fading and approaching the end of his life.
He pointed out that no member of the Grogan family had contacted any doctor if they were so concerned about his health.
The barrister said he struggled to find the relevance of the marriage to the inquest, while the coroner had directed that its validity was not open for discussion.
He also sharply criticised the approach adopted by the Grogan family to the inquest and how they thought it fit and appropriate that Ms Flaherty should have been asked if her marriage had ever been consummated.
The previous two days of evidence of the inquest had also been dominated by bad-tempered exchanges between the legal representatives after the validity of the marriage was questioned, despite a marriage certificate being produced at the hearing.
There were further heated exchanges on Tuesday after Mr Tansey claimed previous evidence of Ms Flaherty which stated her relationship with the deceased started when she was 16 'puts it in the realm of being a paedophile.'
Ms Flaherty was heard to call the barrister a 'scumbag' in response.
Offering his commiserations to all parties at the conclusion of the inquest, the coroner said it had been 'a very difficult case for everyone.'
Speaking afterwards, Seán Grogan said his family had just wanted to find that 'our cousin was treated properly in his dying days' after concerns were first raised when his funeral arrangements had been 'chopped and changed.'
Mr Tansey said the Grogans had been surprised and concerned to find out that no medical personnel had been contacted by Ms Flaherty in the 10 days before his death when it was clear he was suffering some infection from his last session of chemotherapy.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Irish Examiner
15 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
Cork teen accused of falling asleep in bed during burglary
A teenager who is accused of trying to burgle a neighbour's house in Mahon to steal a television and Playstation from a bedroom and then lying down and falling asleep asked the judge by video link from prison: 'Could you not make it peremptory?' Judge Mary Dorgan said to 19-year-old Michael Harrington of Ravensdale Rd, Mahon, Cork: 'Good try, but no'. The judge explained that the case only dated back to May 31. Sergeant John Dineen said directions were still awaited from the Director of Public Prosecutions. Eddie Burke solicitor represented the teenager at Cork District Court as the case was adjourned for DPP directions until July 31. A peremptory adjournment could have resulted in the case being struck out if there was no progress by the next date. Det Sgt Niall Hayes objected to bail previously saying: 'It is alleged that on May 31, 2025, Michael Harrington entered a house at Ravensdale Rd without permission of the home owner. 'He proceeded to ransack a bedroom in the house and place a Playstation and Playstation games and a television in a bag by the bedroom door. 'He then fell asleep on the bed and was found there by neighbours who are related to the owner. 'He admitted attempting to steal, before falling asleep in the bed. 'At the time of his arrest he was found hiding in the attic of his home. 'He is addicted to prescribed tablets and has a substantial drug debt from cocaine and cannabis use. 'It is the garda belief that if given bail, Michael (Mikey) Harrington will continue to commit serious offences to pay for his drug addiction.' Mr Burke said the teenager really wanted to rehabilitate. Judge Dorgan said that for now the safest place for him to be was in prison and to get help on his release.


Sunday World
34 minutes ago
- Sunday World
Man accused of assaulting retired judge remains in custody after being refused bail
At Ennis District Court, Jamie O'Connor was making his fourth appearance in court concerning the charge that he assaulted retired district court judge, Joseph Mangan The County Clare man charged in connection with the alleged street assault of a retired district court judge remains on remand in custody after being refused bail in the High Court, a court has heard. At Ennis District Court, Jamie O'Connor was making his fourth appearance in court concerning the charge that he assaulted retired district court judge, Joseph Mangan on Saturday, June 14th. Mr O'Connor (44) of Laurel Lodge, Clare Rd, Ennis has been in custody since June 18th after Judge Alec Gabbett refused an application for bail. Mr O'Connor subsequently made an application for bail to the High Court and Sgt John Burke at Ennis District Court has told Judge Gabbett that the application was refused. Sgt Burke said that there is progress in the investigation. He said that the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) directions are not yet available but that the file in the case is ready to be submitted with the DPP. He said that Gardai have also obtained a medical report on the alleged injured party. In connection with the alleged assault, it is alleged that Mr O'Connor - who was appearing via video link from Limerick prison - told the former judge 'you put in jail for nothing' before allegedly punching him outside an Ennis cafe. The retired judge - now in his early 80s - served as a judge for 27 years and was the assigned district court judge for Clare from 2001 to October 2011 when he retired at the age of 67. In the case, Mr O'Connor is charged with the assault causing harm of Joseph Mangan at Barrack Court, Ennis contrary to Section 3 of the Non Fatal Offences Against the Person Act on June 14th. At a contested bail hearing on June 18th, Judge Gabbett said: 'This is an extremely serious alleged offence where a retired district court judge now into his 80s was allegedly assaulted for carrying out a public duty when he was a judge.' Sgt John Burke told the bail hearing that at 2.25pm on June 14th, Mr Mangan was sitting outside the Gourmet Store on Barrack Court in Ennis having a coffee. Sgt Burke said that it will be alleged that Mr O'Connor approached Mr Mangan 'and told him aggressively 'you put me in jail for nothing'. Sgt Burke said: 'Following a brief interaction it is alleged that Mr O'Connor stood up and punched Mr Mangan.' Sgt Burke said that Mr O'Connor then fled the scene in the direction of O'Connell Street. He said that Mr Mangan went to the local injuries unit in Ennis where he was treated for possible concussion and dizziness. Sgt Burke said that Mr Mangan made a statement to local Gardai. Sgt Burke said that Mr O'Connor was later arrested where he made no admissions 'and blamed alcohol for his memory loss'. Mr O'Connor (44) of Laurel Lodge, Clare Rd, Ennis is also charged with on June 15th stealing three X cans of beer valued at €11.40 from Dunnes Stores, O'Connell Street, Ennis. The alleged theft occurred one day after Mr O'Connor is alleged to have assaulted Mr Mangan. The High Court. Stock image/Getty News in 90 Seconds - July 24th


The Irish Sun
3 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Irish bank issue urgent warning as thousands at risk amid 150% rise in scam texts to ‘steal your money' this month
AN URGENT warning has been issued for thousands of Irish banking customers over a 'significant rise' in scam text messages. AIB, the spike in the number of customers receiving fraudulent text messages claiming to be from the bank this week. 3 Mary McHale wants bankers to be on alert over the increase in scam texts Credit: Shane O'Neill, Coalesce 3 The scam texts are designed to instil a sense of urgency to react Credit: AIB The messages have contributed to a 150 per cent increase in July compared to the amount of The scam texts can be delivered in AIB's genuine thread, but following the recent changes by Comreg, they are now predominantly coming from unregistered phone numbers. Mary McHale, Head of Financial Crime warned: "AIB is outlining a common fraud type that criminals are using to steal your money on foot of a large increase in text message scams we detected this week. "We want customers and non-customers to be alert, check the advice on our AIB security centre, and to take a moment to ask yourself, 'could this be a scam?'. READ MORE ON SCAMS "That's why you should wait a sec and double check, and never move your money to another account after receiving a call or text claiming to be us. Where customers are scammed, AIB deals sympathetically with them on a case-by-case basis. "We are continuously investing to enhance our fraud monitoring systems in response to new and existing fraud trends. "While other institutions don't offer around the clock support to keep money safe, our fraud helpline is open 24/7, seven days a week to support our customers when they need us. "We also work closely with industry stakeholders including telecommunications companies, the Banking and Payments Federation of Ireland (BPFI), and the Gardai to detect and report fraud trends, as it's only by communicating and coordinating across the whole of society that together we can be effective in combating these criminals." Most read in Money For more information on protecting yourself from fraud, customers can visit the security centre on The My mum's being scammed by an AI deepfake of 'Owen Wilson' who paid her £7 to 'prove' his identity - would you fall for it? Customers are tricked into thinking their accounts are compromised and asked to move their money to another financial institution for safekeeping. One example falsely claimed the transaction was from Foley's Plumbing Limited, a legitimate business. Foley's Plumbing has a notice on its website warning customers about the scam. The scam texts are designed to instil a sense of urgency to react, instructing people to call a provided Eventually, they'll be connected to an individual posing as a member of the fraud team, who falsely claims that the customer's AIB account has been compromised. They will be advised to transfer their HOW TO IDENTIFY AND AVOID SCAMS? Unfortunately, scam messages of any kind can be difficult to identify. It is important to be prudent by following these tips. Always be extra vigilant when you receive messages from unknown numbers, especially those that send links, ask for personal information, or require you to input any bank or card information. DO'S : Hang up immediately if a caller pressures you, claims urgent action is needed, or threatens negative consequences. If a call or text message claims to be from a bank, government agency or a company you know do not engage directly. Look up their official contact details to verify the number. Check messages for spelling errors or incorrect details. Block a number if they persistently call you or engage in suspicious behaviour. If you have friends or relatives abroad. Store their numbers in your phone (including the country prefix). If you are getting persistent scam calls from a number, contact your service provider, and request the number be blocked. DON'TS : NEVER provide any personal information, (bank details/PPS number/credit card details/name and address/passport numbers, passwords, etc.) Do not follow instructions from a recorded message. Be wary of receiving multiple calls or missed calls from the same unfamiliar number, especially if it is like your own number. Do not call back any number that you do not recognise or where no voicemail message was left. If you click on a link in a scam text, close the web page and message immediately. Do not download any unrecognised software or programs. The fraudster then provides the customer with what appears to be a 'new' account number, and customers are instructed to move their funds again to this account. Unfortunately, this so-called new account is controlled by scammers, resulting in victims losing all transferred funds. The scammers are highly skilled at tricking customers into believing they will stop fraudulent transactions from their accounts. They may even ask some questions, pretending to investigate how your account was compromised. Sometimes, they don't ask for security codes or login information to make the scam seem more legitimate. Customers are urged to remain vigilant and to verify any suspicious communications directly with the bank, the AIB's genuine contact details are listed on their official website. They are urged to never transfer money to any account after receiving a text or call purporting to be from AIB. 3 The AIB is urging customers to be aware of the scam texts Credit: Reuters