Paramilitaries 'won't be paid to leave'
But the move has been heavily criticised by Justice Minister Naomi Long who said it was "flawed" and would only serve to give paramilitaries "legitimacy in some communities".
'Nursemaid for paramilitaries'
TUV leader Jim Allister also criticised the plan in the House of Commons on Wednesday describing the independent expert as the "nursemaid for paramilitaries".He claimed such groups had "taken successive governments for a ride" over talk of transitioning and "pocketed millions along the way"."When is this pandering going to come to an end?" he asked.SDLP leader Claire Hanna also questioned the move and warned against a "pay day for paramilitaries".But Hilary Benn ruled out any potential payoff for paramilitary groups.He told MPs: "There is no question of paying anybody any money to disband."He also defended the decision to appoint an independent expert to carry out a "scoping exercise" to find out if it was worth having a formal engagement process."The fact is that 26 years after paramilitaries should have left the stage they are still here and are still causing harm to communities," he said."The proposal from the IRC is to go and inquire are there some who do want to leave the stage and if there is merits in having a process."
Justice Minister Naomi Long has said that formal engagement has been tried before and "has not worked".Speaking on the BBC's Talkback programme, the Alliance Party leader said the situation now is "a number of organised groups who have transitioned themselves into organised crime"."Our response has to take account of that," she said.She added that the suggestion that the government might enter formal engagement with these groups would "give them a form of legitimacy that they would not offer for example to a burglar, to a drug dealer, to an extortionist, to a racketeer, to a fraudster".
Mitchell Reiss, a former US Special Envoy to Northern Ireland and a commissioner on the panel of the IRC, said that paramilitarism has "proved more persistent and pernicious" than people imagined at the time of the Good Friday Agreement.Describing paramilitarism as a "blight on certain communities", he said that it has continued to impact economic growth and a "sense of a shared community" in Northern Ireland.He said that "transition has not worked in its current configuration".Reiss said that the direct engagement would enable an "[assessment] of these group's willingness to disband", adding that it would be a "scoping exercise".He said the IRC's hope was that this process of engagement "will come back with a recommendation to the governments as to whether or not they want to set up a formal negotiating process that can move these people off the pitch"."It's more complicated than them just going away, as wonderful as that would be."Reiss said the IRC has been "consistently clear that we're not talking about paying people to go away".
SDLP leader Claire Hanna said there was a sense among the public that "we have soft soaped these guys for years". She said that what "most people see" from paramilitaries is "the racism [and] the sectarianism"."We cannot legitimatise and elevate and pretend that these are conquering armies that we have to help reintegrate into society," she said.
Ulster Unionist Party MLA Doug Beattie said that paramilitaries "shouldn't exist".However, he said that the people in these groups are "people who want to do something positive for their community", people who are "inactive" and "those who want to line their pockets with money and criminality". "The reality then... is there has to be different ways of dealing with these groups."Beatie said that the government's approach should involve "policing and justice" alongside "community transition".
BBC News NI have contacted Sinn Féin to ask them for a comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
5 hours ago
- The Independent
Reform UK gets first police and crime commissioner after Tory defection
Reform UK has announced its first police and crime commissioner after a defection from the Conservative Party was unveiled at a press conference. Rupert Matthews, who holds the post in Leicestershire and Rutland, was introduced on Monday as having joined the party from the Conservatives. Before being elected in 2021, he served two years as as a European Parliament member for the Tories. He told the event at the Reform UK headquarters in Westminster he had been a Conservative member for more than 40 years. Mr Matthews was quick to turn his fire on modern crime policy, where he said police officers were all too often working with 'one hand tied behind their back'. He said: 'I daily face a fight against crime. I see ordinary, hard-working people burgled, robbed and mugged. Shoplifting is getting out of control. Anti-social behaviour is turning too many of our town centres into an apocalyptic wasteland of lawless Britain.' Mr Matthews said the 'dark heart of wokeness' needed to be removed from the criminal justice system. He said politicians in Britain had taken inspiration from 'Lebanon and Libya' for their policies. He said: 'It's almost as if they've looked at countries like Lebanon and Libya, the policies that have led to them becoming failed states and thought 'that looks good, let's try that here in Britain'.' He continued: 'The self-serving, self-entitled liberal elite who have let our country down time after time after time, are now on notice. Their day is almost done. Be they Conservative or Labour governments, everyone knows our politicians have failed us all. 'They have let this country down. They have let the British people down. Enough. Now is time for Reform.' Mr Matthews, who has previously written books about UFOs and aliens, was mocked by political opponents. The Prime Minister's political spokeswoman said: 'Their big defection is very interesting, the fantastical and the unexplained. 'It's no surprise he's added Reform's fiscal plans to that list.' A Liberal Democrat source said: 'Elected Conservatives are becoming more and more like UFOs themselves – they're rarely if ever seen, and most people don't believe in them. 'Never mind life on Mars, it's unclear if there's life in the Conservative Party.' The party also announced retired prison governor of Wormwood Scrubs, Vanessa Frake-Harris MBE, had joined the party and would be contributing to its law and order taskforce. Ms Frake-Harris, who joined the prison service in 1986, detailed increases in escapes, attacks on prison officers and increases of drugs, weapons and mobile phone finds in the last year. She said: 'Successive governments, Conservative and Labour, have driven the prison service to its knees. Through lack of investment, support and an unwillingness to allow people who know what they are doing to get the job done.' She continued: 'Our prisons are in a crisis caused by Labour and the Conservatives. What have their solutions been? They have let out 10,000 prisoners out of jail early. To let criminals out of jail before they even serve their full sentence is a disgrace.' A Labour spokesperson said: 'It's farcical that Farage can't say what his policies are, how much they would cost, or how they would even work. Reform aren't serious and don't have a clue as to how they would address the challenges facing working people.' The Conservative Party has been approached for comment.
Telegraph
7 hours ago
- Telegraph
Reform prison tsar: Trans women can be put in female jails
Transgender women should not be automatically barred from women's prisons, Reform UK's new justice adviser previously said. Vanessa Frake, a former prison governor who oversaw the detention of Rose West and Myra Hindley, has joined Nigel Farage's party. She has previously criticised the Conservatives, arguing that the prison service is now 'on its knees' and that justice in Britain has become a 'laughing stock'. In an interview to mark her appointment as an adviser, she said that trans women should not automatically be barred from women's prisons. Ms Frake called for cases to be assessed 'on an individual basis' and said that sexual offenders may need to be held in a male facility. She told The Times: 'There are equally vile women as there possibly are trans women. So it's all about the risk assessments for me, and each has to be done on an individual basis.' The former governor, who also served as head of security at HMP Wormwood Scrubs, said trans prisoners she had overseen were 'accepted' by other inmates. 'People who want to just say a blanket ban clearly have never stepped foot in a prison and seen how prison runs and how see how risk assessments on individuals happen,' she added. It is unclear whether her view will now become Reform UK's policy. Ms Frake's decision to join the party was announced at a press conference in Westminster on Monday. In February, Mr Farage attacked 'transgender indoctrination' in Britain, but he has previously defended his record on trans rights, pointing to some trans people who had served as elected representatives in Ukip, his former party. Asked if he agreed with Ms Frake's stance, Mr Farage said on Monday: 'I personally never worked in a prison, so I can't answer [that]. 'But I think you'll find that the answer that you'll get from somebody who has worked in prisons at the highest possible level is, I think basically it's about risk assessment.' Most trans women in male prisons The Supreme Court ruled earlier this year that trans women can be excluded from women-only spaces because equality law protecting women refers to biological sex. This means that trans women can be excluded from women's prisons. Labour has said it will update its policy on transgender inmates 'in due course' after the Supreme Court ruling. The party has inherited the previous government's policy of not placing trans women prisoners convicted of violent or sexual crimes on the female estate. Figures published last year show that two thirds of trans women prisoners are sex offenders. Shabana Mahmood, the Justice Secretary, said earlier this year that the majority of trans women were already held in male prisons. Prison service data for 2023-24 show there were 295 transgender prisoners in England and Wales. Of those, 51 were held in female prisons and 244 in male prisons. Ms Mahmood told MPs: 'No trans women convicted of a rape or serious violence offence who retains birth genitalia would ever be considered for being placed in the women's estate.'
Telegraph
8 hours ago
- Telegraph
Farage to make ‘significant' announcement at press conference
Nigel Farage is set to hold a press conference in Westminster as Reform UK further outlines its plan to tackle crime. The Reform leader said today would be the 'most significant event of our crime campaign so far'. It has also been reported that Mr Farage will be unveiling another defector to his party. There has been a steady stream of ex-Tory politicians joining Reform in recent months, with the most recent being the former MP Adam Holloway who announced last week that he had switched allegiances. Mr Farage is also due to be joined at the press conference by Vanessa Frake, a former prison governor, who has been appointed as Reform's new justice adviser. Reform has previously declared that 'Britain is lawless' as it seeks to gain ground on Labour by campaigning on the issues of crime and punishment.
