Top cabinet ministers at risk of losing seats even after Starmer recognises Palestinian state, pollsters warn
Health secretary Wes Streeting and justice secretary Shabana Mahmood are among those who could be ousted from parliament at the next general election, the UK's top pollster Sir John Curtice warned, in the face of major challenges from pro-Gaza candidates.
Sir Keir lost a key member of his top team, Jonathan Ashworth, to a pro-Palestine independent candidate at the last election.
Mr Streeting was among those who held his seat, but saw his majority in his Ilford constituency slashed from 5,198 in 2019 to just 528.
But pollsters now warn anger over the issue of Palestine, which Jeremy Corbyn's newly announced political party will attempt to capitalise on, could see Mr Streeting and other high-profile casualties from the cabinet.
Labour pledged to recognise a Palestinian state in its manifesto before the last general election, and Sir Keir this week bowed to growing pressure from his own MPs – and some high-profile members of the cabinet – to lay out a plan to recognise the state of Palestine.
Asked if the move on Palestinian statehood could help save Mr Streeting and Ms Mahmood next time around, Sir John told the Independent that it 'may not be sufficient given the current condition of the Labour Party'. Luke Tryl, from pollsters More in Common, was more blunt. 'No,' he said.
Sir John added that it was clear that Starmer had also 'lost out' on votes in his own constituency last year because of the issue, although the PM's majority is significantly larger than some of his cabinet colleagues.
After promising to tackle Labour's antisemitism crisis when he came to power, Sir John summed up the PM's problem: 'Here is somebody who spent a great deal of time and effort trying to reconnect with the Jewish community, and now he's finding himself having to spend a great deal of effort trying to reconnect with the Muslim community. It is very difficult to keep himself on board with both groups at the moment.'
Mr Tryl said the war in Gaza had uncovered 'deeper' problems for Labour.
'When we have done focus groups with voters in Muslim areas, particularly some of those who backed or were thinking about backing pro-Gaza independent candidates, I compared it to speaking to voters in the red wall after Brexit,' he said.
'In the sense that Brexit was the thing which caused the split, but it actually brought to the fore much deeper resentments - that they have been taken from granted, ignored, left behind by Labour … I think we're going to see exactly the same thing with Muslim voters.'
Mr Corbyn confirmed his party would campaign heavily on Palestine when he launched it last week.
Sir John said that the polling suggested that the new party would take the most votes from the Greens, followed by Labour. But he added, when it came to a new party run by their ex-leader: 'Given that Labour, even without Corbyn being put onto the hypothetical ballot, are behind Reform, they don't really want this.'
Sir John said the Palestine announcement could be seen, in one way, as an example of Labour's problem connecting with the wider electorate.
Asked what the party could do to win back voters across the board, he said: 'Explain to people what you are about. It's the point that everybody's making now. This is a government that has no known direction. And of course, some people are painting (the Palestine move) as yet another example of policy change.
'In terms of substance, (Labour should) turn around the economy and make sure that the health service doesn't have long waiting lists. It's not complicated, just very, very difficult to do.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
6 minutes ago
- The Independent
Reform UK gets first police and crime commissioner after Tory defection
Reform UK has announced its first police and crime commissioner after a defection from the Conservative Party was unveiled at a press conference. Rupert Matthews, who holds the post in Leicestershire and Rutland, was introduced on Monday as having joined the party from the Conservatives. Before being elected in 2021, he served two years as as a European Parliament member for the Tories. He told the event at the Reform UK headquarters in Westminster he had been a Conservative member for more than 40 years. Mr Matthews was quick to turn his fire on modern crime policy, where he said police officers were all too often working with 'one hand tied behind their back'. He said: 'I daily face a fight against crime. I see ordinary, hard-working people burgled, robbed and mugged. Shoplifting is getting out of control. Anti-social behaviour is turning too many of our town centres into an apocalyptic wasteland of lawless Britain.' Mr Matthews said the 'dark heart of wokeness' needed to be removed from the criminal justice system. He said politicians in Britain had taken inspiration from 'Lebanon and Libya' for their policies. He said: 'It's almost as if they've looked at countries like Lebanon and Libya, the policies that have led to them becoming failed states and thought 'that looks good, let's try that here in Britain'.' He continued: 'The self-serving, self-entitled liberal elite who have let our country down time after time after time, are now on notice. Their day is almost done. Be they Conservative or Labour governments, everyone knows our politicians have failed us all. 'They have let this country down. They have let the British people down. Enough. Now is time for Reform.' Mr Matthews, who has previously written books about UFOs and aliens, was mocked by political opponents. The Prime Minister's political spokeswoman said: 'Their big defection is very interesting, the fantastical and the unexplained. 'It's no surprise he's added Reform's fiscal plans to that list.' A Liberal Democrat source said: 'Elected Conservatives are becoming more and more like UFOs themselves – they're rarely if ever seen, and most people don't believe in them. 'Never mind life on Mars, it's unclear if there's life in the Conservative Party.' The party also announced retired prison governor of Wormwood Scrubs, Vanessa Frake-Harris MBE, had joined the party and would be contributing to its law and order taskforce. Ms Frake-Harris, who joined the prison service in 1986, detailed increases in escapes, attacks on prison officers and increases of drugs, weapons and mobile phone finds in the last year. She said: 'Successive governments, Conservative and Labour, have driven the prison service to its knees. Through lack of investment, support and an unwillingness to allow people who know what they are doing to get the job done.' She continued: 'Our prisons are in a crisis caused by Labour and the Conservatives. What have their solutions been? They have let out 10,000 prisoners out of jail early. To let criminals out of jail before they even serve their full sentence is a disgrace.' A Labour spokesperson said: 'It's farcical that Farage can't say what his policies are, how much they would cost, or how they would even work. Reform aren't serious and don't have a clue as to how they would address the challenges facing working people.' The Conservative Party has been approached for comment.
Daily Mail
7 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Moment asylum seeker gives the finger to protesters outside migrant hotel before being ushered away by police
An asylum seeker was filmed giving the finger to protesters outside a migrant hotel before being ushered away by police. The young man was headed towards the The Chine Hotel in Boscombe, Bournemouth, which was surrounded by a group of 40 anti-migrant protesters. The late 19th century hotel is known for its stunning sea views and was a favourite of celebrities including Stan Laurel, Oliver Hardy and Dame Vera Lynn. As he approached the building with an officer, one protester asked the man out loud, 'where are you from mate?' The migrant then flicked a cigarette towards the group before shouting back at them. The policeman ushered him towards the entrance while the crowd jeered and another protester asked him, 'were you running from a war?' This stopped the migrant in his tracks and he turned to give the crowd the middle finger. More cat-calls and chants could be heard from protesters, before the man entered the hotel. The migrant flicked a cigarette towards the group before shouting back at them Most of the 88 rooms at The Chine have views of the sea or the landscaped gardens. The hotel also has an indoor swimming pool and spa facilities, as well as a £200 a night honeymoon suite. It is now one of three hotels in Bournemouth that has been closed to the public for the exclusive use of asylum seekers. The anti-immigration protesters arrived en-masse there last Friday evening to protest against its use to house migrants. They waved Union Jack flags and played patriotic songs including 'Three Lions' and 'Rule Britannia' on a loudspeaker. A 40-person counter-protest organised by Stand Up To Racism then showed up with placards stating 'Refugees Welcome, Stop The Far Right'. Dozens of police officers formed a barrier between the two groups in a bid to keep the peace. One anti-immigration protester squared up to a police officer as tensions flared but no arrests were made during the three hour protest. The Daily Mail has contacted Dorset Police for comment. The protest was just one of the recent anti-migrant demonstrations to take place outside hotels housing asylum seekers in recent weeks. Yesterday, a peaceful protest by mothers wearing pink turned to violence in London as masked thugs hijacked the demonstration outside a migrant hotel. The group of women and children gathered outside the four-star Britannia International hotel in Canary Wharf, where they sat and chanted 'stop the boats'. The group held up England flags and wore pink clothing to raise awareness of how women and young people are being 'let down' by the migrant crisis. But the peaceful protest, which is ongoing, quickly turned to chaos as a group of up to 30 balaclava-clad men - all with their faces covered - swarmed the crowd. The thugs caused a huge bang as they set off smoke bombs and chanted 'Keir Starmer is a w*****'. After trying to charge the fence surrounding the hotel, the group ran back in the direction they came from - but were caught by police.
Daily Mail
7 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Opinion: Starmer is signing his political death warrant
Why are Sir Keir Starmer and Labour unable to reduce the number of migrants crossing the English Channel in small boats? Last week, as Vice-President J.D. Vance accused Europe of 'engaging in civilisational suicide', our Government established a bleak record. More than 25,000 migrants have come across the Channel so far this year, a 50 per cent increase on 2024. It seems certain that 2025 will be the worst year ever. Starmer vowed to stop the boats, though of course has been completely ineffectual. The Government has introduced a multitude of measures, all to no effect. In July last year, a few weeks after the election, the PM promised in a newspaper article that he would 'smash the vile criminal gangs' organising the small boats. With breathtaking arrogance he wrote: 'As leader of the Crown Prosecution Service I worked on operations that took down terrorist networks across Europe. I will never accept the same approach cannot be applied to the people smugglers.' He used similar language many times. A year has passed, and 'the same approach' manifestly hasn't worked. There are daily protests outside hotels housing migrants (average nightly bill £119, admittedly down from £162 in March 2023) which could spiral into something nasty. Following last month's disturbances near a hotel in Epping housing migrants, anti-racism activists clashed with police and anti-migrant protesters on Saturday in Islington, north London , outside a hotel where asylum seekers are being accommodated. Over the weekend, anti-immigrant protests also took place outside a hotel in Newcastle. The group was met by demonstrators carrying placards proclaiming 'refugees welcome'. Some of them reportedly waved Palestinian flags. None of us can know whether these so far relatively isolated protests will become more widespread, as happened last August in the wake of the Southport attack. But the mood of the country does seem febrile. All this illuminates the enormity of Starmer's failure over the small boats. So I repeat my question. Why, despite his undertaking to smash the gangs and his evident realisation that unless he fulfills his promise he and Labour are political toast, have things only got worse? It's simple. Sir Keir has been chasing the wrong people. Yes, the leaders of the gangs are ruthless, mercenary, heartless criminals who don't give a fig for the lives of the migrants whom they load into often defective boats. At least 18 people have died so far this year. But smashing the gangs is an operational impossibility. Arrest one leader and another will emerge. The trade is so lucrative. All the new intelligence of which Starmer boasts plus the extra boats and the enhanced powers of Border Security Command are likely to be of marginal benefit. The Government's latest feeble policy is to outlaw social media adverts promoting journeys on small boats. Perpetrators – if caught – could be sentenced for up to five years in prison and receive a hefty fine. How gang leaders must be quaking. Instead of trying and failing to smash the gangs , the Government should be turning its attention to the people who enable the Channel crossings and make the whole thing possible. I mean the migrants themselves. In Labour's misguided conception, the gang leaders are vile but the migrants are innocent victims. The first proposition is true, the second is false. Those crossing the Channel are trying to break into this country without having been invited . Some are the victims of persecution but most are simply in search of a better life. The majority are young men, among whom there are bound to be a few whose values and standards are at odds with people who live here. The latest example is that of two Afghan asylum seekers who have been charged over the alleged rape of a 12-year-old girl in Nuneaton . Sources told The Mail on Sunday that Warwickshire Police advised local councillors and officials not to reveal the background of the two suspects for fear of 'inflaming community tensions'. As migrants look at the white cliffs of Dover , they know that once they have been picked up by a Border Force boat they'll be fed and housed and given a small allowance. Most important of all, they are well aware that, although they came to this country uninvited, they will very likely be permitted to stay. In the year to March 2025, 99 per cent of migrants from Sudan were granted asylum. The figure for Syria was 98 per cent, and 86 per cent from Eritrea. At the other end of the scale, only 30 per cent of migrants from Iraq were allowed to remain and 19 per cent from Vietnam. Even those refused asylum may well appeal, and will have to be looked after by the taxpayer as their cases wend their way through a costly and overstretched system of tribunals. Home Secretary Yvette Cooper said yesterday that she intends to speed up the process. She'll have her work cut out as battalions of human rights lawyers looking for briefs succeed in clogging up the works. In March there were nearly 51,000 outstanding appeals, almost seven times the number in 2023. The Government is tinkering at the edges when it should be focused on how best to deter migrants from arriving in the first place. That is the only way Sir Keir Starmer can solve this problem – and save his party from electoral annihilation. In its dying days the last Tory Government finally grasped the importance of deterrence. Migrants who crossed the Channel were not permitted to claim asylum and in theory could be removed to a third country such as Rwanda . Unfortunately, the Rwanda plan never got off the ground because it was subject to repeated legal challenges on the basis that the African nation is authoritarian, and migrants might not be safe there. But at least the Tories tried. Not so Sir Keir Starmer, who in his pig-headed way recklessly binned the Rwanda scheme, and permitted those crossing the Channel once again to claim asylum. Unless the Government comes up with some way of discouraging cross-Channel immigration, the numbers will continue to increase. Starmer won't eat humble pie and revive the Rwanda plan, but he could do something similar. Or he could locate a windswept British island and send migrants there. That would certainly act as a deterrent. It's hard to see how the Government will be able to act effectively as long as lawyers can challenge it in the European Court of Human Rights. Withdrawing from it would be a bridge too far for Starmer, while the very idea would cause palpitations in Attorney General (and ex-human rights lawyer) Lord Hermer. But unless Starmer finds a way – and quickly – of deterring illegal migration, he might as well sign his own political death warrant, and that of his party. More worrying for me is the prospect that, without action, there will be more civil unrest. People have had enough. There is a general weariness about uncontrolled legal mass migration but an even greater resistance to large groups of young men from alien cultures being housed unsupervised in our midst. Smashing the gangs is a futile policy. Deterring migrants is the only solution – and Starmer had better get on with it while he still has time.
