B.C. woman sues after father's brain found years after his death, cremation
A Victoria, B.C., woman is taking legal action after her father's brain was found sitting in a hospital fridge over two years after he died.
Mandy Large is suing the B.C. Coroners Service and the Vancouver Island Health Authority for negligence and for breaching their duties of care.
Her father, Philip Peter Billy, was 55 when he died in Nanaimo on Feb. 27, 2022. His brain was removed for examination during an autopsy and was never put back, Large said.
'They were cleaning out a fridge at Royal Jubilee Hospital and they found my dad's brain in a jar,' she told CTV News Vancouver Island.
In an email chain Large shared with CTV News, a coroner confirms her claim.
'When (Billy's brain) was received by Royal Jubilee Hospital it was misplaced in a fridge and not returned to the body. It was found now while the fridge was being cleaned out,' coroner Emily Lefler wrote to Large on Oct. 1, 2024.
The coroner's service and the health authority said they cannot comment while the matter is before the court.
In April 2022, the notice of civil claim says Billy's body was moved from Nanaimo to Victoria, where Large said he was to be cremated. Billy's brain remained at the Nanaimo Regional General Hospital, and Large said she doesn't know why.
A month later, the coroner's service said the brain and body had been reunited, according to the notice of claim.
'But it didn't happen,' Large said, though she didn't know that at the time, so she went ahead with cremating her father.
'My dad being cremated without his brain, it just meant that he was… in the spirit world without a brain,' said Large, who is First Nations.
Her email exchange with Lefler suggests a miscommunication led to the alleged mishandling of the brain.
'Royal Jubilee staff were the ones that misplaced the brain and told us it was with the body when it was not,' the coroner wrote.
Large describes her father as a gentle giant with a soft voice and a good soul, despite enduring residential school and having a hard life.
'I found some peace in my dad passing away – for him – because he no longer had to struggle,' she said.
'My dad didn't get to die with dignity… He was wronged even after his passing by these systems that are put in place.'
She hopes the lawsuit ensures other families don't suffer in the same way.
'What happened to my dad greatly affected me emotionally and mentally and it still affects me today,' she said.
His brain has been cremated and reunited with the rest of his remains, she said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
5 hours ago
- CTV News
Nanaimo, B.C., councillor's motion proposes asking for closure of safe injection site
The City of Nanaimo is seen in this file photo. ( A city councillor in Nanaimo, B.C., is expected to push the city to reach out to a B.C. health authority in a bid to close the overdose prevention site next to city hall. The agenda for Monday's council meeting says Coun. Ian Thorpe will bring forward a motion, asking council to 'formally request' that Island Health close the supervised drug consumption site on Albert Street. Thorpe said during Nanaimo's July 21 council meeting that he planned to put forward a motion that tells the provincial government that the city has 'had enough' of local disorder. The motion comes after council decided at a July 16 committee meeting against building a 1.8-metre-high fence proposed by city staff aimed at protecting those at city hall from what they said was violence and disorder associated with the overdose prevention site. Mayor Leonard Krog said earlier this month that the proposed fence may not have made a 'real difference' to workers subjected to intimidation and harassment while sending a 'really problematic message' about how to deal with disorder in the area. The fence came with an estimated cost of $412,000 before it was rejected at the committee meeting. This report by Chuck Chiang of The Canadian Press was first published July 26, 2025.
CBC
10 hours ago
- CBC
What is swimmer's itch? And how can you treat it?
For many, it's not summer until you've taken a dip in one of B.C.'s glistening lakes, a welcome reprieve from those hot July days. But sometimes, you end up with something not so welcome: itchy red bumps on your skin. Some call it swimmer's itch, some call it duck itch, and for others, it's simply the itch. But what is it, exactly? University of Northern British Columbia zoologist Dezene Huber said that itch — whatever you call it — is caused by a parasitic flatworm. "It's really quite tiny," he told CBC's Daybreak North guest host Bill Fee. "You're not able to really see it very well with your naked eye." That worm begins as an egg in the water, Huber said, and when it hatches, the little larvae swim using little hairs on the sides of their bodies in search of a snail. Once they get into the snail, they reproduce asexually in "vast numbers." From there, the new larvae leave the snail, in search of something larger — any sort of water bird, but usually a duck, Huber said. Once they find a duck, they burrow into the bird's feet and get into its circulatory system en route to its gut. That's where they lay the eggs that are then returned to the water when the duck poops. You may notice humans aren't involved in that life cycle at all. But humans, like ducks, are warm in the water, so sometimes, those little parasites mistake people for ducks. "They're really well adapted to survive in a duck, but they're not well adapted to survive in a human, so as soon as they burrow into the skin of a human, they die just underneath the skin of the human and that causes an allergic reaction," Huber said. "It's basically parasites making mistakes in a fairly complex life cycle." Those itchy red bumps you get are an immune response as your body rejects a parasite trying to get inside you, Huber said. Treatment While these parasites aren't causing long-term harm to humans, that itch can be pretty uncomfortable. According to the province, scratching those bumps can lead to pain and even infection. Fort St. James, B.C., pharmacist Ankur Pipaliya said the best tip for avoiding the itch is to avoid swimming in areas known to be a problem for swimmer's itch.. But, if you do, he said, towel dry or shower immediately after you get out of the water. Showers should be with cold water, Pipaliya said. And then, he said, apply moisturizer. "Dry skin, it promotes that allergic reaction. So if your skin is moist, it kind of helps you from having any irritations." If it's too late and you've already got red, itchy bumps from swimming in the lake, Pipaliya said he usually suggests mild corticosteroid creams to reduce discomfort, along with cold showers and cold compresses on the bumps. He said Epsom salts and baking soda also help, as well as over-the-counter allergy medications like Benadryl. The province also suggests calamine lotion and colloidal oatmeal baths for relief from swimmer's itch. It said symptoms can develop within 12 hours after infection, and can last anywhere from two days to two weeks.
CBC
a day ago
- CBC
Construction trades launch peer-support program to help workers facing mental health challenges
When Shawn Underhill worked as an ironworker, it was his job to check the fit-for-duty box for the crew, a standard part of the daily safety paperwork. "It was a lie," said Underhill, explaining that he and other members of his crew weren't always sober. For decades, Underhill struggled with mental health and addiction, the result of cascading personal tragedies, worksite injuries and painkiller prescriptions. "If I only had someone early on [to] just sit and talk with me … it would have changed things for me," said Underhill, who's now settled in Mission, B.C. That's exactly what he wants to do now for other men and women struggling in the same way he did. Underhill is one of 12 current and former tradespeople across the province, training to be a peer-support worker for a mental-health initiative, led by the Construction Foundation of B.C. (CFBC), called The Forge. It's aimed at the skilled trades, an industry which sees higher-than-average rates of health concerns. On July 31, the CFBC breaks ground on the future headquarters for The Forge in Langford, B.C., just west of Victoria. More than 80 per cent of construction workers report experiencing mental health struggles. Substance abuse rates in the trades are nearly double the national average, according to the CFBC. "If people show up for work who are not OK, it can have catastrophic effects on the job site," said Katherine Davies, VP of operations at Aryze Developments. "You can see mistakes that then lead to safety events, that then lead to massive financial implications for the company." Long shifts, demanding work So why do people in the trades, and particularly tradesmen, struggle more with mental health and addictions? John Oliffe, the Canada Research Chair in men's health promotion at UBC, said long shifts and physically demanding work may contribute to recreational drug use and self-medicating with substances. In an industry where reaching out for help may be seen as a weakness, he said, peer support can be an effective way to normalize conversations about mental health. Trevor Botkin, who is heading up The Forge with CFBC, remembers the culture of toughing it out alone. The former journey carpenter and superintendent said he thought mental-health counselling was "for the birds." Then, his career came into crisis in 2019, when his addiction got out of hand and he narrowly escaped a suicide attempt. Standard mental-health supports are just not resonating with the culture of the construction industry, said Botkin. "We've got all these services… standing outside the construction fence waving in saying, 'Hey, we have help here!'" said Botkin. Peer support, on the other hand, gets past that fence to "put guys with lived experience down there in the dirt … pulling on the rebar and who are actually qualified to have those conversations in a meaningful way." Botkin hopes to launch The Forge by December, by which time peer-support workers will have completed their 40-hour training module, focused on how to listen actively without judging or giving advice. "It's about asking good questions," he said. "We want to keep guys in the driver's seat as much as possible. Those are the decisions that stick."
