Scientists Say Earth May Be Trapped Inside a Huge, Strange Void
Their study, which was just presented at the Royal Astronomical Society's National Astronomy Meeting in the UK, could solve one of cosmology's greatest mysteries: the Hubble tension, or why the older universe appears to be expanding more slowly than younger regions.
"The Hubble tension is largely a local phenomenon, with little evidence that the expansion rate disagrees with expectations in the standard cosmology further back in time," Indranil Banik, a cosmologist from the University of Portsmouth who led the research, said in a statement about the work. "So a local solution like a local void is a promising way to go about solving the problem."
Our universe is expanding at an accelerated rate, but precisely what rate is a matter of intense debate. When astronomers analyze the cosmic microwave background, the light leftover from the Big Bang and the oldest light in the universe, the rate is slower compared to that derived from observations in the nearby universe of Type Ia supernovas and luminous, pulsing stars known as Cepheids.
The discrepancy has become undeniable, and its implications are so profound that it's been dubbed a "crisis in cosmology." Is our understanding of the universe wrong? Is there some new physics we are yet unaware of?
But this latest research could pump the brakes a little. If the Earth happens to be near the center of a low density "void" in space, approximately a billion light years in radius and roughly 20 percent below the universe's average density, that could neatly explain the discrepancy.
Banik explains that such a region "would cause matter to be pulled by gravity toward the higher-density exterior of the void, leading to the void becoming emptier with time."
"As the void is emptying out," he continues, "the velocity of objects away from us would be larger than if the void were not there. This therefore gives the appearance of a faster local expansion rate."
The idea of a local void has been floated before. But this latest work adds credence to the theory by analyzing baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO), or as the researchers call it, the "sound of the Big Bang" — emanations produced as the uniform sea of hot matter that formed from the Big Bang repeatedly contracted and then expanded in a tug of war with gravity, before eventually cooling.
"These sound waves traveled for only a short while before becoming frozen in place once the universe cooled enough for neutral atoms to form," Banik said, allowing astronomers to use them as a "standard ruler" to measure cosmos.
If this void exists, Banik argues, then it would distort the BAO in a way that we could measure. After analyzing all BAO measurements taken over the last 20 years, that's exactly what Banik says he's found.
The biggest problem that this theory runs into, however, is that it defies our understanding of the universe's structure: at the largest scales, it should appear uniform and evenly distributed. A region billions of light years across that's somehow less dense than everything around it is quite clearly in violation of that.
Nonetheless, Banik plans to test his local void model with other methods of estimating the universe's expansion.
More on space: Mysterious Object Headed Into Our Solar System Is Coming From the Center of the Galaxy
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Forbes
3 hours ago
- Forbes
Why Bizarre Sub-Neptune Exoplanets Are So Crucial To Astrobiology
Artist's impression of a sub-Neptune planet. Most exoplanet hunters chase biosignatures the way bird dogs chase the scent of a quail. But in a talk at the European Astrobiology Institute's recent BEACON 25 conference in Reykjavik, astrophysicist Kevin Heng espouses the newfound notion of Geoastronomy. The idea is that the long road to finding signatures of life (biosignatures) on a planet beyond our solar system runs throughan epoch dominated by an interdisciplinary merger of Geology and Astronomy. The aim is to make sure that we first spectroscopically identify geological false positives in the atmospheres of extrasolar planets that are totally unlike those in our own solar system. These so-called sub-Neptunes are neither planetary fish nor fowl. They're neither terrestrial nor gaseous and range in size from about four to ten Earth masses. If we don't understand how these sub-Neptunes' chemical species are abiotically generated by the planet's geology, then when we detect them in an exoplanetary atmosphere, we could have a false positive, Kevin Heng, professor of astrophysics at the Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich, tells me in Iceland. This is a problem that's not likely to abate anytime soon. That's because, as yet, there's no reliable formula for detecting extrasolar signatures of life (or biosignatures). Some 40 of these bizarre, geochemically-active sub-Neptunes are currently being studied observationally. But without a firm understanding of the geochemical underpinnings of a rocky planet, we cannot possibly begin to understand whether some purported disequilibrium chemistry can be attributable to a biological process, Stephen Mojzsis, a geologist at the University of Bayreuth in Germany, tells me via email. Both Heng and Mojzsis are leaders in a 10-million-euro, six-year European Research Council-funded project dubbed 'Geoastronomy.' The aim is to unite the disciplines of astrophysics and the geosciences in an effort to comprehend both the chemistry and physics of rocky exoplanets. Fear Of False Positives In his recent Iceland presentation abstract, Heng challenges his colleagues by asking: If we cannot understand hot, geologically active exoplanets without life, what chances do we have of understanding a full-blown planetary biosphere from far away? Again, this clearly is an area of astrobiology that needs attention. There are potentially hundreds of such sub-Neptunes in the local galaxy, some of which orbit their parent stars in only a few days. And even though they have puffy hydrogen-rich atmospheric envelopes, these envelopes make up just 1% of their mass. Their cores, however, are thought to be rocky and molten, which probably means that they are geochemically active. High Pressure Their cores are basically molten rock with temperatures of a few thousand degrees and with pressures 10,000 times that of Earth's surface. At these pressures, there's probably no life, and matter behaves in an unfamiliar way, so that the distinction between gases and liquids are not so distinct and matter is in this strange, exotic mix, says Heng. Too Much Gas? At some point you add so much hydrogen to this core that its hydrogen doubles the size of the core which means that the real extent of the core is the same as the real extent of the atmosphere, Heng notes in his conference talk. Arguably, the most famous sub-Neptune is K2-18b, an exoplanet which recently made global headlines due to the claim that dimethyl sulfide had been detected in its atmosphere. But Heng doesn't buy that explanation. I find K2-18b utterly uninteresting because it's a red herring; we're going from physics to biology when there's so much geology we can learn, says Heng. The sample of exoplanets from which we can learn geology is vastly bigger than the sample of so-called habitable exoplanets, he says. Science can also be impatient. Most people want to make the leap from physics to biology, but let's take what nature is teaching us, says Heng. False positives come from geology because rocks use the same gases that metabolism uses, he says. A Habitability Skeptic Because we have yet to detect any real Earth analogs; we have a sample size of one for life, says Heng. All of the so-called habitable zone planets we have found are based on the assumption that they have the same atmosphere as Earth, and we do not know that they do, he says.
Medscape
5 hours ago
- Medscape
5 Fast Facts: Plant Extracts Relieve Hand Osteoarthritis
If you have patients with hand osteoarthritis (OA) who want extra relief and don't mind trying a plant-based supplement, this combo looks promising. Researchers in Belgium found that a daily combination of plant extracts significantly reduced hand OA pain over time. 1. Patients had real pain relief. People with hand OA who took Curcuma longa (turmeric) and Boswellia serrata had noticeably better pain reduction over 3 months than those on placebo, about 8-9 points better on the pain scale. 2. Quality of life received a boost, too. Patients didn't just feel less pain; they also reported feeling better overall and rated their quality of life higher than the placebo group. 3. Safe and easy to stick with. Patients took the supplement consistently (over 90% adhered to it), and side effects were comparable to those of the placebo. 4. Well-done study — but with a few limits. This solid randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial focused on patient-reported outcomes rather than structural improvements or radiographic findings. 5. Another option for the toolbox. These extracts aren't a replacement for standard care, but they may be a safe adjunct for patients wanting complementary therapies for hand OA pain, especially those who prefer more 'natural' options. Bottom line: Current evidence indicates that plant extracts provide symptomatic relief for hand OA; however, they do not address the underlying joint pathology. Counsel patients on these limitations.
7 hours ago
100 undiscovered galaxies could be orbiting the Milky Way, according to new research
There could be many more satellite galaxies orbiting the Milky Way than previously thought or observed, according to astronomers. As many as 100 undiscovered galaxies that are too faint to be seen could be surrounding the galaxy that houses Earth and the solar system, new research has found. Cosmologists at Durham University in England made the discovery using a new technique that combines the highest-resolution supercomputer simulations in existence with mathematical modeling, they announced at the Royal Astronomical Society's National Astronomy Meeting in Durham on Friday. The supercomputer predicted the existence of missing "orphan" galaxies -- suggesting that up to 100 or more satellite galaxies are orbiting the Milky Way at close distances. "We know the Milky Way has some 60 confirmed companion satellite galaxies, but we think there should be dozens more of these faint galaxies orbiting around the Milky Way at close distances," said Isabel Santos-Santos, the lead researcher at Durham University's Institute for Computational Cosmology, in a statement. If the galaxies are seen by telescopes, it could provide strong support for the theory on Lambda Cold Dark Matter -- the standard model of cosmology that explains the large-scale structure how galaxies form, the researchers said. The model suggests that galaxies form in the center of "gigantic" clumps of dark matter called halos and hypothesizes that ordinary matter in the form of atoms represents only 5% of the Universe's total content, while 25% is cold dark matter, and the remaining 70% is dark energy. Most of the galaxies in the Universe are satellite low-mass dwarf galaxies that orbit around a more massive galaxy, such as the Milky Way, according to astronomers. The existence of these galaxies poses challenges to LCDM because the model suggests the presence of many more companion galaxies than previous simulations have produced, the researchers said. But the new technique allowed the scientists to track the abundance, distribution and properties of the orphan galaxies. The model provides "clear illustration" of the power of physics and mathematics, Carlos Frenk, a co-researcher at the Institute for Computational Cosmology, said in a statement. "Using the laws of physics, solved using a large supercomputer, and mathematical modelling we can make precise predictions that astronomers, equipped with new, powerful telescopes, can test," Frenk said. "It doesn't get much better than this." Existing cosmological simulations do not have the resolution needed to study the faint satellite galaxies, the experts said. They also lack the precision needed to study the evolution of the small dark matter halos that host the dwarf galaxies, which leads to the artificial disruption of some halos, according to the researchers. "If our predictions are right, it adds more weight to the Lambda Cold Dark Matter theory of the formation and evolution of structure in the Universe," Santos-Santos said. New advances in telescopes and instruments could eventually give astronomers the ability to detect the faint objects through viewing. "One day soon we may be able to see these 'missing' galaxies, which would be hugely exciting and could tell us more about how the Universe came to be as we see it today," Santos-Santos said.
