Levy court battle far from over
The fight over the City of Tshwane's cleaning levy is far from over after the city announced it would appeal the ruling.
AfriForum's advisor for local government affairs, Deidré Steffens, hailed as a major victory for residents the High Court in Pretoria's ruling on the city's implementation of the cleaning levy as illegal and invalid.
'The levy was also set aside with immediate effect,' said Steffens.
Court ruled the cleaning levy illegal
'The civil rights organisation approached the court to set aside the metro's decision to impose a new mandatory monthly levy of R194.37 (excluding VAT) on approximately 260 000 households and businesses within the metro.
'AfriForum argued the levy amounted to illegal and unfair double taxation, especially in cases where residents do not benefit from the metro's refuse removal service and are forced to use private service providers,' she said.
ALSO READ: Court rules against City of Tshwane's cleaning levy
Steffens said during last week's court proceedings the city attempted to defend the levy, arguing it was justifiable considering the metro's 2016 tariff policy.
'However, the city's legal team was unable to present this policy to the court and even admitted that it was unable to locate the document. The court considered this administrative shortcoming to be serious,' she said.
AfriForum district coordinator for Greater Pretoria South Arno Roodt said the implementation of the levy was nothing more than a fundraising ploy aimed at covering up for years of poor planning and mismanagement.
Tshwane says it will appeal
'The court's decision sends a clear message that municipalities must also obey the law and that communities are ready to fight injustice,' he said.
City of Tshwane MMC for environment and agriculture management Obakeng Ramabodu said the city would appeal the judgment, 'as we remain steadfast in our belief that a cleaning levy aimed at improving the maintenance of our landfills is a step in the right direction and necessary to ensure a safe and clean city for all'.
ALSO READ: Proposed cleaning levy sparks legal challenge in Tshwane
'A cleaning levy was introduced in Tshwane between 2016 and 2021 by the erstwhile government, which now claims to take exception to it,' he said.
DA Tshwane spokesperson for finance Jacqui Uys in February called on the ANC coalition not to introduce any new taxes.
'Regardless of widespread public outcry, the ANC, EFF and ActionSA pushed forward and adopted a 'funded' budget that relied on the introduction of a city cleaning levy. Tshwane imposed this new levy on all properties that are using private waste contractors to remove their waste,' she said.
DA Tshwane call on coalition not to introduce new taxes
Uys said that meant properties where there was no service being rendered were being charged extra in Tshwane's efforts to raise over R500 million in new revenue.
'Charging a fee for rendering no services to people who receive private services is daylight robbery,' she said.
ALSO READ: Tshwane cleansing levy 'unfair double tax on residents', AfriForum says
Republican Conference of Tshwane councillor Lex Middelberg said: 'We'll know soon enough just how much they budgeted for this. At least R500 million by my calculation.'
He described the fourth-quarter financial report tabled in council last week as 'utter rubbish'.
'When you dig into it, you find most end-of-year invoices are not captured. But importantly, ratepayers in default are about 25% of the billing. This just serves to underscore the fact that we are on the wrong side of the Laffer curve,' he said.
Revenue remained at R40bn for the third year
Middelberg said the city's revenue remained at R40 billion for the third year in a row despite a 10% increases in rates and tariffs.
'That means that every year the growing number in default is equal to that 10% increase plus inflation. Something big must change – and soon,' he said.
NOW READ: Tshwane cleaning tariff may be challenged in court
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
2 hours ago
- The Citizen
Local government has become graft warzone
The GNU has awakened the ANC to the fact that it can halt wasteful spending without external pressure. One of former minister Dr Zweli Mkhize's trending videos on social media is that of him questioning a mayor at Matjhabeng district municipality in the Free State on an item that appears in their budget. The flustered official and the municipality's chief financial officer have no idea why there's an R18 million item titled 'Bonuses' on the budget. It turns out that some stipends that are meant to be R3 100 for officials on the Expanded Public Works Programme (EPWP) turned into 10 times that, R31 000 per month in the pockets of corrupt officials. The minister in charge of the public works and infrastructure, the DA's Dean Macpherson, promptly suspended funds for the EPWP for the municipality to allow investigations to root out the corruption. The sad part about the decision is that it is a programme meant to provide employment for mainly unemployed youth and, as a result, the suspension means some deserving individuals will suffer because of the decision aimed at rooting out corruption. While praise should be heaped on Mkhize as cooperative governance and traditional affairs (Cogta) parliamentary committee chair that went to the Free State municipality on an oversight visit, it must be pointed out that this is primarily what was lacking in government for the past 30 years. The country can celebrate that corruption is being stopped to prevent further waste of funds, but the ANC should not only take this as democracy in action, but as an indication of what has led to its demise at national level. ALSO READ: Matjhabeng municipality's appeal rejected amid financial challenges, service delivery collapse This is the kind of oversight that should have been standard in government. That is what parliament is there for, to provide oversight, daily. Instead of doing this, parliament became a battleground to protect errant and delinquent leaders who have been exposed as lacking. It seems the local government elections next year carry more significance than last year's general election that ushered in the era of coalition politics at national level. So, the likes of the Matjhabeng district municipality should be shaking in their boots at the prospect of being booted out for mismanagement of funds and corruption. But history has shown that voters are duped into electing leaders who pay themselves first at the expense of providing much-needed work for communities. Local municipalities all over the country are becoming that which the constitution meant for them to be: the face of government for the man on the street. ALSO READ: Macpherson suspends all EPWP funds to municipality That is what Mkhize and Cogta were aiming for in exposing the rot in Matjhabeng. Sadly, because the advent of the government of national unity (GNU) at national level has closed off a lot of taps that were previously available and unmonitored for tenderpreneurs to loot at will, they have now turned their cunning ways and corrupt practices to loot state funds at local government. It is no surprise that forensic auditors like Mpho Mafole in the Ekurhuleni municipality and countless others were assassinated in a brazen and alarming manner to cover up the corrupt acts of the political heads of departments. The coalface of service delivery has become a warzone that is threatening the bedrock of service delivery: honesty in dealing with public funds. The threat issued by Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana to Joburg mayor Dada Morero is further proof that the GNU has awakened even those within the ANC to the fact that wasteful expenditure and unauthorised spending do not require an outside party to be stopped. It can be stopped by civil servants doing the jobs they were employed to do in the first place. NOW READ: Almost 40 municipalities facing sanctions from Treasury over mismanagement
The Citizen
3 hours ago
- The Citizen
BEE left out of US trade talks
Lamola distances political issues from trade talks, saying empowerment policies are not being discussed with US officials. Ongoing negotiations on a trade deal with the US have not included any discussion about political issues, including broad-based black economic empowerment (B-BBEE) or affirmative action, says International Relations and Cooperation Minister Ronald Lamola. At a media briefing yesterday, Lamola emphasised on a number of occasions that those issues had 'not been brought to the negotiating table'. He said despite some 'speculations' by those who had visited Washington, that these matters were critical, 'those issues were not in the feedback' the US negotiators had given their South African counterparts. Nor were they in the framework being discussed. B-BBEE not brought to trade talks table He added: 'We prefer to deal with what is in front of us… 'So, we separate facts and other things that we hear.' Lamola appeared to criticise some groups within South Africa that may have hurt the country's relationship with the US. ALSO READ: US tariffs: Here's why talks over trade deal have been 'complex' 'It is unfortunate that this government's efforts in resetting the relationship with the US have been undermined by some actors within South African society.' Representatives from the DA, AfriForum, the Solidarity Movement and Freedom Front Plus travelled to the US this year to voice concerns over South African policies such as B-BBEE and the Expropriation Act. This coincided with Trump's executive order granting refugee status to Afrikaners, citing claims of persecution, while also cutting US financial aid to South Africa in response to the International Court of Justice case brought by President Cyril Ramaphosa's administration against Israel. Govt accused groups of sowing division As a result, the SA government has repeatedly accused the groups of sowing division in the country. Lamola has assured the public that support programmes will help offset the US 30% tariff on SA exports. He highlighted that the US is South Africa's third-largest trading partner, accounting for 7.5% of total exports. ALSO READ: Government must actively manage fallout from US tariffs with trade crisis committee – BLSA 'South African exports do not compete with US producers and do not pose a threat to US industry. 'On the contrary, our exports are crucial inputs that support America's own industrial base. 'Our agriculture exports are even counter-seasonal, meaning that they fill gaps in the US market, not replace domestic products.' Tariffs could reduce economic growth by 0.2% Economists estimate that the new tariffs could reduce South Africa's economic growth by 0.2%. However, Lamola pointed out that 35% of South African exports will remain exempt. These include products like copper, pharmaceuticals, semiconductors, critical minerals, stainless steel scrap and energyrelated products. ALSO READ: SA's efforts to repair US ties undermined internally, says Lamola amid tariff fallout He also said South African companies had already adapted to steel and aluminium tariffs that were introduced under Section 232 of the US Trade Expansion Act back in 2018. Government will roll out several key support measures. These include an export support desk that will act as a single point of contact for companies affected by the US tariff hike. Support desk The desk will provide ongoing updates, assist with exploring new international markets and connect exporters with South African embassies and high commissions abroad. An economic relief package is also being prepared to help companies cope with short-term financial pressures and develop longer-term plans to protect jobs and production.
The Citizen
3 hours ago
- The Citizen
Tshwane and Joburg squeeze residents for cash
Joburg and Tshwane are resorting to desperate revenue tactics that punish residents instead of fixing mismanagement. Nothing our dysfunctional metros do surprises us. But the latest moves by the City of Tshwane and the City of Joburg smack of a desperation which bodes ill, not only for the metros, but for their residents too. As Tshwane vows to appeal against a court decision that its proposed 'cleaning levy' is unconstitutional, the DA in Joburg claims that the city is in such a financial mess – and desperate for income – that it has instructed its traffic cops that they must collect at least R7 000 each per day in fines. Not only that, but officers have allegedly also been told that they can claim overtime if they need to meet their target. DA MPL Michael Sun said the municipality is pushing its rate collection responsibilities to the JMPD. 'This effectively turns law enforcement into a revenue-generating system rather than a public safety service,' he said. ALSO READ: Motorists could become targets of aggressive revenue collection operations by JMPD, says DA Both the Tshwane and Joburg actions show absolute contempt for their residents and ratepayers – but, at the same time, remind us that two of the biggest cities in the country have been mismanaged into the garbage dump. Desperate revenue raising devices are in operation everywhere you look –increases in rates and utility bills – but, clearly, there is still room for more milking. In much the same way as e-tolls tried to force motorists to pay for a service – highways – already paid for through our taxes, Tshwane's unconstitutional levy is another double tax. The reason the metros are short of cash is, as we have said repeatedly, that they have been mismanaged and looted, mainly by the ANC's deployed cadres… and that hundreds of thousands of freeloaders are allowed to get power and water without paying for it. Again we say: put these cities under administration because those running them are clearly unfit for the job. NOW READ: Court rules against City of Tshwane's cleaning levy
