&w=3840&q=100)
Preliminary report on Air India crash to give peek into jet's final moments
A month after the worst aviation accident in India in decades, authorities are poised to release a preliminary report into the catastrophe, offering the first official clues to what caused the aircraft to plummet back to the ground just 30 seconds after taking off.
Investigators have revealed very few details since the Air India accident, and the report also stands to be basic and factual — if previous initial findings are any guide. Authorities are unlikely to draw definitive conclusions or assign blame, as their work continues in the coming months to piece together a complicated puzzle of what happened on the Boeing Co. 787 Dreamliner on June 12.
What is known is that the aircraft, fully loaded with fuel, quickly lost altitude and slammed into a hostel for medical students, where it exploded, killing all but one of the 242 individuals on board and more than 30 people on the ground. The pilot issued one mayday alert before Flight AI 171 crashed in the western city of Ahmedabad.
Videos that have circulated widely of the plane's takeoff and brief time in the air show that 'everything is normal until they don't put in the (landing) gear, and very shortly after the aircraft is losing thrust,' said Bjorn Fehrm, an aerospace analyst and former fighter pilot.
What's unusual is that the power loss appears to be simultaneous in both engines — there's no puff of smoke that would indicate a bird strike, or yaw by the aircraft that would be typical if one engine failed first. The 787 Dreamliner and other commercial planes have more than enough power to complete a takeoff on a single engine, and pilots are well-prepared for that event.
But as to scenarios where both engines power down simultaneously? 'That's improbable like hell,' Fehrm said.
Some potential key factors have begun to emerge, despite a lack of briefings or updates from the local government or India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau, which is leading the probe. Both the cockpit voice and the flight data recorders were retrieved from the wreckage, and their content was extracted by Indian authorities.
One particular line of inquiry is the movement of fuel control switches that sit in the center console of the cockpit, according to people familiar with the matter who spoke confidentially because the information isn't yet public. The devices are used to turn fuel supply on and off to two engines made by GE Aerospace.
It remains unknown whether the pilots toggled the switches — either inadvertently or intentionally — and when during the flight the movement may have occurred. The detail was first reported by The Air Current, an aviation trade publication.
The Wall Street Journal reported Thursday preliminary findings indicated the fuel switches were turned off, though it's unclear whether that was accidental or intentional and whether any effort was made to turn them back on, according to people familiar with the situation.
A representative for GE Aerospace declined to comment. Boeing referred questions to the AAIB. The National Transportation Safety Board also referred questions to Indian authorities.
India's air accident authority didn't immediately respond to an email seeking comment.
Aviation accidents are usually caused by multiple factors and investigators are exploring a wide range of aspects related to the crash.
So far, investigators also haven't found any evidence that would suggest the crash was caused by a design or mechanical problem with the Boeing aircraft or the GE engines, according to the people familiar with the matter.
They pointed to the fact that neither company, nor the US Federal Aviation Administration, has sent out any notices or safety bulletins to operators, which they said would normally occur quickly if an issue that could impact other 787s in operation was identified.
The people conducting the probe are also looking at the backgrounds and experience of the pilots — a normal step for this kind of investigation. The aircraft was in the command of captain Sumeet Sabharwal and first officer Clive Kunder, who had 8,200 and 1,100 flight hours, respectively, according to a statement from the Directorate General of Civil Aviation.
It's widely assumed that the doomed 787 had a dual engine failure, especially after early evidence indicates that an emergency backup power source, known as the ram air turbine, was deployed.
But restarting the engines at the low altitude and speed at which the 787 found itself just seconds after takeoff wasn't feasible, pilots say, meaning that the cockpit crew simply didn't have enough time to bring the engines back to life.
John Cox, a former airline pilot who's now chief executive officer of consultancy Safety Operating Systems, said that moving a switch to the cutoff position would shut off fuel supply to an engine. A dual failure would occur if the switches for both engines on the 787 were shifted.
'If you move those switches from run to cutoff, those engines will stop running in literally seconds,' Cox said.
A deliberate moving of the switches can't be ruled out, he said. But there are also other possible scenarios, including that one engine failed and the pilot reached down to flip the switch for that engine but instead shifted the switch for the good engine.
It wouldn't be the first time this kind of mishap occurred — a Delta Air Lines Inc. pilot in the 1980s mistakenly cut off fuel to the engines of the Boeing 767 he was flying. But in that case he was able to restart them because the aircraft was higher in the sky, avoiding catastrophe.
Pilots may also move the fuel switches in response to a dual engine failure. An emergency checklist that pilots need to commit to memory instructs aviators to cycle the fuel switches to cutoff and then back to run in the event of such a failure.
Moving the levers to cut off and back on allows the electronic engine control system to reset, according to several pilots who fly the airplane and spoke to Bloomberg.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)

Business Standard
a few seconds ago
- Business Standard
FAA finds no fuel system fault in Air India Dreamliner crash probe
The head of the United States Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) has said there is no conclusive evidence that a mechanical fault in the fuel control system caused last month's fatal crash of an Air India Boeing 787 Dreamliner. The June 12 crash, which took place shortly after take-off from Ahmedabad, killed 260 people and is being described as the deadliest aviation disaster in Air India's recent history. According to a Reuters report, FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford told reporters at an aviation event in Wisconsin on Thursday that investigators had found no signs of malfunction in the fuel control unit or any indication of unintentional manipulation of the aircraft's fuel switches. 'We feel very comfortable that this isn't an issue with inadvertent manipulation of fuel control,' Bedford said, adding that mechanical failure had largely been ruled out. Flight 171 crashed minutes after take-off The accident involved Air India Flight 171, which was en route to London Gatwick with 242 people on board. The plane crashed into a medical college in Ahmedabad's Meghani Nagar area just minutes after take-off, killing 241 passengers and crew, as well as 19 people on the ground. Fuel switches cut off supply, say preliminary findings India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB), which is leading the probe with support from the US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB), found that both fuel control switches—key components that regulate engine fuel flow—moved to the 'cutoff' position seconds after take-off, abruptly cutting off fuel to the engines. Although the switches were moved back to the 'run' position within 10 seconds, the engines did not regain thrust in time. Cockpit recordings inconclusive on switch movement Cockpit voice recordings revealed one pilot asking the other about the fuel switch movement during the critical moment, with the other pilot denying activation. Investigators have so far been unable to determine whether the remarks were made by First Officer Clive Kunder or Captain Sumeet Sabharwal. DGCA orders urgent Boeing switch inspections In response to the crash, India's Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) on July 14 issued an order for immediate inspections of the locking mechanisms on fuel control switches in Boeing 787 and 737 aircraft operated by Indian carriers. The deadline for compliance was set at July 21. Air India has since confirmed completion of the inspections across its widebody and narrowbody fleet, reporting no anomalies. Boeing and the FAA have also said the current systems, including the locking mechanisms, are secure and do not warrant design changes based on available evidence.


Hindustan Times
17 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Indians in US called out for ‘mocking their own, twisted sense of enlightenment'
A Redditor lashed out at Indians living in the USA, accusing them of interrogating fellow desis for gossip, and of tearing each other down for clout. The share has struck a chord with many, prompting a heated discussion about the Indian diaspora in America. A post by a Redditor about Indians in the USA has struck a nerve. (Representational image). (Unsplash/Nirmal Rajendharkumar) Titled 'Indians in the USA — harsh truth,' the post claims that many Indians in the US have a 'twisted sense of entitlement.' 'Privacy? Forget it. When Indians meet other Indians, they turn into interrogators — digging into your personal life, family, job, income, relationships, even your grades. But it's not curiosity — it's data collection for self-gain, gossip, or sabotage,' the post continues. The Redditor further alleges that when in a mixed group, some 'Indian men suddenly develop a superiority complex.' The individual accused the desis of bringing down their own to impress non-Indians. What did social media say? An individual wrote, 'Shouldn't we treat everyone equally in the workplace, regardless of background? While I understand why some Indians might feel a sense of solidarity with each other, especially when working abroad, isn't it also important to integrate and connect with everyone around us, not just those from our own community?' Another expressed, 'Embrace liberty and individuals as individuals. Stop with group identity, I guess.' A third added, 'I agree with this. Being here for a very long time, I have seen this repeatedly. Once, I was in a relationship with an American woman who was much older than me. The amount of stares and judgment I got from Indian men was annoying. I expected this from foreigners, but it came from our own. Some even went to pass on various kinds of comments and to tell how lucky I was to get a white woman who has 'experience' and I should marry her immediately to secure a green card.'


News18
38 minutes ago
- News18
Vastu Tips: 5 Photos You Should Never Keep At Home
Vastu Shastra, an ancient Indian system of architecture, has gained popularity in recent years. Many people now design and decorate their homes based on Vastu principles to attract peace, prosperity, and positivity. But did you know that certain pictures or artworks, whether placed knowingly or unknowingly, can bring negative energy into your home? Sinking Ship or Boat: Never hang a picture of a sinking boat or ship. According to Vastu, such imagery can symbolise failure and instability. It is believed to block career growth and even cause financial losses or business setbacks. (News18 Gujarati) Nataraja Statue or Image: Nataraja, a fierce form of Lord Shiva performing the Tandav dance, represents destruction and struggle. While spiritually significant, displaying this posture at home, especially in living spaces, can invite disruptive energies. It is best avoided for a peaceful domestic environment. (News18 Gujarati) 3/5 Picture of a Rose Plant: Although roses symbolise love, the thorns are associated with negativity. Vastu Shastra discourages placing pictures of thorny plants like rose bushes inside the house. They are believed to cause financial stress, conflicts, and difficulties in both personal and professional life. (News18 Gujarati) 5/5 Crying Child: A picture of a crying child may seem artistic or emotional, but according to Vastu, it should never be kept at home. Such imagery is believed to bring sadness, tension, and poverty. On the other hand, pictures of smiling children are thought to attract joy and positivity. (News18 Gujarati)