Amazon asks court to scrap EU tech label, arguing it poses no systemic risks
The Digital Services Act, which came into force in 2022, requires Big Tech companies to do more to tackle illegal and harmful content on their platforms.
The U.S. online retail giant took its grievance to the Luxembourg-based General Court after the European Commission classified it as a very large online platform (VLOP) under the DSA.
A VLOP designation requires companies to do more to tackle illegal online content, undertake risk management, conduct external and independent auditing and share data with authorities and researchers.
"Online marketplaces like the Amazon Store do not pose systemic risks. Second, the VLOP rules do not and cannot rationally assist in preventing the dissemination of illegal or counterfeit goods," Amazon's lawyer Robert Spano told the court.
"The VLOP rules therefore make no sense when applied to online marketplaces," he said.
Amazon said any risks are limited to individual customers, not the totality of its users and that even if problematic products exist, widespread exposure is minimal and already dealt with by a number of product safety and compliance laws.
"When it comes to marketplaces like the Amazon Store, size does not multiply risk. It is an arbitrary, disproportionate and discriminatory metric," Spano said.
The court will rule in the coming months.
Meta Platforms, Chinese social media app TikTok and German online retailer Zalando have also challenged the DSA on various grounds.
The case is T-367/23 - Amazon EU v Commission.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
4 hours ago
- Straits Times
How Larry Ellison became the world's second-richest person
Oracle CEO Larry Ellison owns more than 40 per cent of Oracle, as well as a stake in Tesla. TEXAS - Mr Larry Ellison dropped out of college before co-founding what eventually grew into one of the world's biggest tech companies. The fortune he amassed propelled him to the ranks of the uber-rich, and in July he eclipsed Mr Mark Zuckerberg to become the world's second-wealthiest person. His success has been accompanied by a well-documented history of lavish living. That lifestyle – which includes megayachts, private planes, trophy properties and the purchase of a Hawaiian island – sometimes brings about controversies. Here's what you need to know about Mr Ellison's life and career. Who is Larry Ellison and how much is he worth? Mr Ellison is the co-founder and largest shareholder of Oracle, a software giant that became famous for its namesake database which underpins many of the world's largest corporate operations. More recently, the company has found success in the competitive market for cloud computing infrastructure, which is dominated by rivals such as Amazon. Mr Ellison, 80, owns more than 40 per cent of Austin, Texas-based Oracle, as well as a stake in Tesla; a sailing team; the Indian Wells tennis event; and real estate, including Hawaii's Lanai island. The tech founder was worth US$251.2 billion (S$322.5 billion) as of July 15, according to the Bloomberg Billionaires Index, putting him behind only Mr Elon Musk. The majority of Mr Ellison's fortune is derived from the stake in Oracle. How did Ellison make his fortune on Oracle? Raised on the south side of Chicago after being adopted by his mother's aunt and uncle when he was 9 months old, Mr Ellison dropped out of both the University of Illinois and the University of Chicago and moved to Berkeley, California, taking a computer programming job at Ampex, where he worked on a database called Oracle for the Central Intelligence Agency. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Business Singapore key exports surprise with 13% rebound in June Business Market versus mission: What will Income Insurance choose? Singapore Over 600 Telegram groups in Singapore selling, advertising vapes removed by HSA Singapore 2 weeks' jail for man caught smuggling over 1,800 vapes and pods into Singapore Life First look at the new Singapore Oceanarium at Resorts World Sentosa Opinion AI and education: We need to know where this sudden marriage is heading Singapore Coffee Meets Bagel's Singpass check: Why I'll swipe right on that Singapore Jail for man who fatally hit his daughter, 2, while driving van without licence With two partners, Mr Ellison founded what eventually became Oracle in 1977. The company sold shares in an initial public offering on March 12, 1986. He stepped down as Oracle's chief executive officer in September 2014, taking on the titles of chairman and chief technology officer. Why is Oracle having a moment right now? Oracle has invested billions of dollars over the past few years to become a provider of cloud infrastructure – offering computing power and storage over the internet. That has made the company a beneficiary of the market's enthusiasm for artificial intelligence as startups and other AI firms seek more capacity. Oracle's share price has nearly tripled since ChatGPT's public release in November 2022. The stock jumped 5.7 per cent on July 15 after the US government eased some Biden-era restrictions, allowing chipmakers such as Nvidia and Advanced Micro Devices to export certain semiconductors to China. The decision was expected to ease tensions in the global chip supply chain, which bodes well for Oracle, a massive buyer of AI chips for its data centers. The latest gain came during a period of explosive growth for the company, which has seen its shares surge more than 90% since late April due to strong revenues and key AI partnerships. Bloomberg reported earlier this month that OpenAI has agreed to rent an unprecedented sum of computing power from Oracle as it builds increasingly powerful AI tools. Mr Ellison also has benefited from a close relationship with President Donald Trump. Mr Ellison has been a Trump supporter and Republican donor for years, and since retaking office in January, Mr Trump has rewarded Mr Ellison by elevating Oracle on multiple occasions. Mr Ellison and Oracle are part of a US$500 billion AI infrastructure project called Stargate that Mr Trump first touted in January. Mr Trump has also expressed support for Oracle to acquire a partial stake in TikTok's US business, which would give Oracle a share of one of the world's most popular consumer products. Oracle's bid for the popular video app owned by China's ByteDance, which includes several other potential investors, has been endorsed by Mr Trump, but it hasn't been approved by leaders in Beijing. What other businesses does Ellison own? He has spent hundreds of millions of dollars on luxury real estate in the past decade, including properties in Malibu and Rancho Mirage, California; the Beechwood Mansion in Newport, Rhode Island; and an estate in the San Francisco Bay Area modeled on 16th century Japanese feudal architecture. Mr Ellison has been a major shareholder of Tesla and owned about 1.5 per cent of the company as of the carmaker's 2022 proxy statement. He stepped down from Tesla's board of directors in June 2022 and his stake hasn't been disclosed in subsequent proxies. He also was one of the largest outside backers of Mr Musk's bid to purchase Twitter. What are Ellison's interests outside of tech? The software mogul has a history of lavish living. In a 2002 email to the tech founder, an accountant suggested that Mr Ellison 'budget and plan' because his spending habits were becoming difficult to sustain, according to a January 2006 San Francisco Chronicle article. Mr Ellison finances his lifestyle using debt and the proceeds from Oracle stock sales and dividends, which have amounted to more than US$12 billion since 2003, according to an analysis of data compiled by Bloomberg. The avid sailor partially financed the BMW Oracle Racing team, which won the America's Cup in February 2010. He sold his stake in Rising Sun, a 138m megayacht, to billionaire David Geffen later that year. His Oracle Team USA defended the America's Cup in October 2013, defeating a team from New Zealand. He signed the Giving Pledge in 2010, promising to give away at least 95 per cent of his wealth to charitable causes. How has Ellison been involved in Hawaii? Mr Ellison's love for Hawaii, which began in his childhood, led to his US$300 million purchase of 98 per cent of the island of Lanai in 2012. There, he has partnered with Mr David Agus – a doctor who treated Mr Ellison's late best friend, Mr Steve Jobs – to create Sensei, a chain of luxury wellness resorts focused on longevity. His personal connections have brought high-profile visitors including Mr Musk, Tom Cruise and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to the once-sleepy island. Mr Ellison's supporters have said his investments have helped revitalise Lanai but there have been complaints that the island has become more hospitable to the super-rich while squeezing out families that have lived there for generations. BLOOMBERG
CNA
8 hours ago
- CNA
Amazon.com defeats lawsuit by Prime Video subscribers over commercials
A federal judge on Wednesday dismissed a proposed class action over decision to begin showing commercials on its Prime Video service unless subscribers paid a $2.99 monthly opt-out fee. Subscribers who paid $139 a year for Prime Video said Amazon had led them to believe the service would remain ad-free. They said the ads amounted to a price increase that breached their subscriber agreements and violated Washington state consumer protection laws. U.S. District Judge Barbara Jacobs Rothstein in Seattle concluded, however, that the ads were a "benefit modification" specifically contemplated and authorized by Amazon and the subscribers. The change went into effect in January 2024.
CNA
11 hours ago
- CNA
EU unveils €2-trillion budget plan amid defence, Ukraine and farming tensions
BRUSSELS: The European Commission on Wednesday (Jul 16) unveiled a blueprint for its most ambitious long-term budget yet, a €2 trillion (US$2.3 trillion) package for 2028 to 2034 aimed at strengthening Europe's security, competitiveness and climate transition while supporting Ukraine. Commission President Ursula von der Leyen said the new framework would be 'more strategic, more flexible, more transparent' as the bloc faces rising trade tensions with the United States, geopolitical threats from Russia and internal pressure over farming and debt. MASSIVE BOOST FOR DEFENCE, UKRAINE AND INDUSTRY A €451-billion competitiveness fund was proposed to drive investment in clean tech, digitalisation, defence, food security and innovation. Defence and space spending would jump fivefold to €131 billion, reflecting Europe's ramp-up in military readiness. The plan also earmarks up to €100 billion to help rebuild Ukraine. 'This is a long-term commitment to Ukraine's recovery and reconstruction,' EU budget chief Piotr Serafin said. But Hungary, Russia's closest ally in the bloc, slammed the allocation. 'Ukraine would get a massive funding boost, while European farmers lose out,' said Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban. FARMERS FEAR CUTS DESPITE €300B PROMISE The budget proposes €300 billion to support farmers under the common agricultural policy (CAP), sparking concerns of a drop from the current allocation of €387 billion. Of that amount, €270 billion is directly paid to farmers. Serafin defended the plan, saying farming remained a priority. But that did not appease protesters. Hundreds of farmers gathered outside EU headquarters in Brussels during the announcement, waving banners and demanding fairer treatment. 'This proposal is a provocation,' said Arnaud Rousseau, head of France's main farmers' union, FNSEA. 'If (our) message is not heard, we will return.' FRAUGHT TALKS AHEAD The announcement kicks off what is expected to be two years of difficult negotiations between the European Parliament and the EU's 27 member states. The wealthier countries are reluctant to contribute more. Adding pressure is the need to repay joint EU debts incurred during the COVID-19 pandemic. The bloc borrowed €800 billion to fund recovery and now faces annual repayments of €25 to €30 billion starting in 2028. Under the proposal, member states' contributions would rise modestly from 1.13% to 1.15% of gross national income, plus an extra 0.11% for loan repayments. The EU also hopes to generate €58 billion annually through new revenue streams such as a carbon border tax and an electronic waste levy. LAWMAKERS CRITICISE STATUS QUO Despite its size, the budget drew criticism from key members of the European Parliament. 'However you try to package this, what we have is a real-terms investment and spending freeze,' said lawmakers including Siegfried Muresan of the EPP, von der Leyen's own political group. 'It is the status quo, which the commission has always insisted is not an option,' they added.
