China suppresses coverage of deadly attacks - some are complaining online
A four-sentence police statement said a 35-year-old male driver hit pedestrians due to 'improper operation' of the car.
It didn't mention the school or that the victims included children.
Photos of the aftermath, which showed a half-dozen people lying in the street, were scrubbed from China's closely controlled internet.
'We need the truth,' said one post on Weibo, a leading social media platform similar to X.
ADVERTISEMENT
The ruling Communist Party has expanded information control since leader Xi Jinping came to power in 2012, seeing it as a way to prevent unrest.
The morning's headlines in 90 seconds, including wintry blast on the way, Gloriavale leader in court, and Liam Lawson picks up points. (Source: Breakfast)
More and more topics, from negative news about the economy to LGBTQ+ identity, have become subject to some form of censorship.
In the past half year, mass attacks — in which a person kills or injures multiple people with a vehicle or knife — appear to have been added to the list.
Some people in China are pushing back, complaining online in at least two cases in recent months after drivers hit pedestrians.
The government may be trying to prevent copycat crimes, experts have said. Another motivation could be local authorities wanting to cover up when they fail to do so.
A deadly case in November sparked a government reaction
ADVERTISEMENT
There was a spate of attacks last fall, but it's difficult to gauge whether they are increasing, given the dearth of information.
The attacks weren't always a taboo topic.
In the past, authorities released the basic details. Typically, the assailant was described as taking out their anger on society, often over financial losses.
That appears to have changed following a particularly horrific case in November that killed 35 people in Zhuhai in southern China.
Authorities said the driver was upset about a divorce settlement. Orders came from the very top — from Xi — to take steps to prevent similar attacks.
Eight days later, an SUV hit students arriving at an elementary school in Hunan province.
The number of injured — 30 children and adults — wasn't made public until nearly a month later when the driver was sentenced.
ADVERTISEMENT
The clampdown on information has tightened further since.
In April, reports circulated online that a car had run into people outside a primary school in Jinhua city. At least three provincial state media outlets posted stories — but they were quickly taken down. To date, authorities haven't released any information.
Censorship makes some people hungry for information
Twelve days later, a fast-moving car veered off a street and into people at a bus stop in the city of Tengzhou in eastern China.
Authorities said nothing. Videos of the May 4 crash were taken down from social media. The next day, online criticism of the silence began to appear. People said the police should release basic information such as the driver's identity and the number of casualties. A few defended the police, saying it happened on a holiday.
'If a few such precedents are set, and more local governments follow this way in the future, the rules of information disclosure may not be upheld and may be compromised,' Hu Xijin, the former editor of a state-owned newspaper, warned in a social media post.
Local governments want to cover up news that reflects badly on them or their polices, said Jennifer Pan, a Stanford University professor who researches how political censorship and information manipulation work in the digital age.
ADVERTISEMENT
The central government sometimes has other priorities.
'When the issue gains attention despite local censorship efforts, the centre has an incentive to preserve the legitimacy of the overall system through responsiveness and acknowledgement of the event and underlying issues,' she said in an email response.
The details came out 48 hours after the crash. Six people had died, and it had not been an intentional attack: The driver was drunk, a state media report said.
Police respond with quick statements that are short on details
Since then, local authorities, at least in two cases in Beijing, seem to be taking a new approach: Issue a report quickly but with scant details.
Eleven days after the drunk driving case, a car hit people outside an elementary school in Beijing on May 15.
The Beijing Traffic Police issued a report within a few hours but left out that the location was near a school. It said only that four people had been injured when a car sideswiped pedestrians on Jian'an West Road, and that the driver had been detained.
ADVERTISEMENT
Authorities appeared to impose an information shutdown that evening. Police were stationed along the stretch of road and a person who appeared to be a neighbourhood watch volunteer cautioned people in a nearby residential compound not to speak to strangers.
Six weeks later, posts appeared online on June 26 saying a car had hit children in Miyun, about 60 kilometres northwest of central Beijing.
One well-reputed media outlet, Caixin, reached area shop owners who said that children had been hit, and a hospital that confirmed it was treating some child victims.
Whether it was an intentional act remains unclear.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
6 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Head of China's Shaolin Temple removed over embezzlement claims
The head of the Chinese temple known as the birthplace of kung fu will be disrobed for 'extremely' bad behaviour. Beijing's top Buddhist authority made the announcement on Monday, after allegations of embezzlement saw Abbot Shi Yongxin placed under investigation. The Shaolin Temple said on Sunday that Shi, known as
NZ Herald
7 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Round three - United States and China hold economic talks as trade truce nears end
The Trump Administration has been trying to win concessions from many countries before an August 1 deadline for reimposing tariffs announced in April. Those levies were suspended in order to reach trade deals. Over the last week, the Trump Administration has announced deals with some of America's biggest trading partners in quick succession. Last week the US and Japan finally agreed to a deal that included a 15% tariff on Japanese imports and a pledge from Japan to invest US$550 billion in the US. Today, Trump announced that he had also reached a deal with the European Union, whose economies rely on exports to the US. The deal would put a 15% tariff on many European exports, including cars. One of the biggest unknowns is what will happen with China, which remains one of America's largest source of imports. After a tit-for-tat period of tariffs and retaliation, the two nations have come to something of an uneasy truce after talks in Geneva in May, and in London in June. Today, before he met with European officials, Trump implied that some kind of trade arrangement with China might be close at hand. 'We just struck a deal with Japan as you know, and we're very close to a deal with China,' he said. This will be the first meeting between the countries without an imminent crisis, like the tariff standoff or China's economically crippling ban on rare earth exports this year. Trade experts said the list of potential topics for discussion was long, ranging from Trump's push to get China to stop the flow of fentanyl to the US, to America's concerns about its purchases of Russian and Iranian oil, and recent exit bans that have prevented US citizens from leaving China. US officials appear to be looking forward to more ambitious trade talks in the months to come. Those could include Chinese purchases of American products, steps to open the Chinese market and, potentially, Chinese investment in the US. They are also likely seeking to lay the groundwork for a potential meeting between Trump and Xi Jinping, the Chinese leader, this year. Administration officials are considering a trip to Beijing before a meeting of Asian and Pacific countries in South Korea in October or potentially connecting Trump and Xi on the sidelines of an international meeting. Michael Pillsbury, a former government official who has advised the Trump Administration on China, said this would be Trump's sixth summit meeting with Xi. Each of those summits had a minimum of two hours of dialogue, and Trump went prepared with specific dealmaking requests, he said. 'The President feels it's better to deal face to face,' he said. Trade experts are also wondering whether US technology controls or an agreement to transfer ownership of TikTok may be on the negotiating table. On CNBC last week, Howard Lutnick, the Secretary of Commerce, said that the US had submitted a proposal to China for transferring ownership of TikTok to American companies, and that the Administration was waiting for the Chinese response. The topic was 'not officially' part of the trade talks, he said, 'but unofficially, of course'. Tensions between the US and China started to spiral after Trump announced his 'Liberation Day' tariffs in early April. China was the only country to immediately retaliate, matching Trump's tariffs of 34% with 34% tariffs on American products. Beijing also set up a licensing system to restrict exports of seven rare earth elements that are processed almost exclusively in China and used in electric cars, smart bombs and other high-tech devices. Trump then responded by ratcheting up tariffs on Chinese products to a minimum of 145%, which brought much of the trade between the countries to a halt. The previous rounds of negotiations secured a temporary truce that included China's relaxing its restrictions on shipments of valuable rare earth minerals and magnets needed by US manufacturers. In return, US officials agreed to roll back limits on exports of US products and technology, including ethane and airplane parts, as well as the proposed visa restrictions. US tariffs on Chinese imports were scaled back to 30%, while China has 10% tariffs on American products. The truce is scheduled to expire on August 12, after which tariffs would rise by 10%. However, Bessent has been optimistic that the truce could be extended. In an interview on the Fox Business Network last week, Bessent said that 'trade is in a good place' with China. He added that he hoped to begin having broader discussions with his counterparts about rebalancing the Chinese economy and encouraging China to curb purchases of Russian and Iranian oil. Bessent said China was in a manufacturing slump and faced a residential real estate market crisis. He argued Beijing must focus on building a consumer economy. 'They can't export their economic problems to the rest of the world; they need to solve them,' Bessent said. US companies continue to have a rash of criticisms about doing business in China, including the country's newly established rare earth licensing system. The processing time for licences is long, American firms say, and China requests proprietary and sensitive business information as part of the applications. In a survey released this month, members of the US-China Business Council said strained relations and tariffs between the two countries remained their biggest concerns. But they also said Chinese policies favouring domestic companies were eroding confidence in doing business in the country. This article originally appeared in The New York Times. Written by: Alan Rappeport and Ana Swanson ©2025 THE NEW YORK TIMES
RNZ News
8 hours ago
- RNZ News
Gloriavale abuse trial: Victims too afraid to speak out, court told
Howard Temple in court today. Photo: The Press/Kai Schwoerer A climate of fear in Gloriavale prevented a victim from reporting sexual abuse suffered at the hands of the community's 85-year-old leader, a court has heard. Howard Temple - Gloriavale's Overseeing Shepherd - is on trial at the Greymouth District Court on two dozen charges of sexual offending against girls and young women over more than two decades. He has pleaded not guilty to all charges. The first of nine complainants gave evidence this morning. The former Gloriavale member, who has name suppression, told the court she was too scared to tell anyone of the repeated indecent touching she suffered. Temple had the power to change the trajectory of her life within the community, she said. Defence lawyer Michael Vesty told the court the 85-year-old accepted some of the incidents could have occurred, but he denied they were indecent. They were gestures of gratitude and support that were acceptable conduct in the day-to-day life of the community, Vesty said. Temple would often acknowledge the young women's work in the dining hall or kitchen with an "affectionate hug", he said. The court watched a video of the woman's police interview before she took the stand. She told police she had not told anyone of the alleged touching, groping, hugging and harassment because she feared being blamed. The woman, who was born at Gloriavale and left in her 20s, said women were always considered to be at fault in similar situations. "The man's wife would be at fault because she wasn't doing the right things to keep her husband's eyes only on her and the girl who had been abused was also at fault because she had obviously tempted the man in a way that made him feel like he could do those things to her," she said. Not tying the belt on the uniform in the correct type of bow, pulling up your sleeves, wearing ankle socks or showing too much hair under a headscarf could all be considered attempts to attract a man. Telling anyone about the assaults risked being branded a flirt or worse, she said. Leadership and the rest of the community could shame the girls or they could be isolated, which "happened to a lot of girls", the woman said. "Ultimately maybe if the offences were grave enough, I would never get married, and at Gloriavale that's a pretty severe punishment." She recounted Temple grabbing her, rubbing her legs or pulling her to him in the dining room while she was serving food or drinks. She said she was sure others had noticed but had not intervened. "In addition to being scared to say anything, I thought something was maybe wrong with me for not liking it," the woman said. Vesty cross-examined the complainant this afternoon. He focused on letters Temple sent to the woman when she was a teenager, during periods the community's leader spent in India setting up a Christian community and orphanage, which he said reflected well-meaning interest in the young woman from a pastoral perspective. Vesty accused the woman of embellishing a comment Temple was alleged to have made to her weeks after her marriage asking about her sex life. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
