Cape Town father challenges R172,000 maintenance order, citing financial strain despite over R1 million bonus
Image: Pexels
A Cape Town father who reportedly receives over R1 million in annual bonuses, has challenged the mother of his children and refused to produce his proof of income.
The parents, who divorced in August 2010, have been at odds over financial responsibilities, as the mother continues to care for their children, aged 15 and 19.
In February 2025, the maintenance court ordered the father to pay R172,188.63, which, amongst other things, will go towards the tuition cost of their older child. The money had to be paid before the end of March 2025.
He was further ordered to pay over R20,000 towards the annual school fees of their second child. The total amount he had to pay was over R222,000.
However, following the court's ruling, the father swiftly filed an urgent application in the Western Cape High Court to suspend the maintenance order. He argued that the amount was nearly double his net salary, asserting his financial inability to honour such payments.
The high court granted a temporary suspension of the order, while simultaneously requiring the mother to demonstrate why this suspension should not become permanent pending the appeal hearing.
The mother took further legal action, serving both the father and his employer with a subpoena duces tecum. A subpoena duces tecum is a court order requiring a person to appear in court and produce specific documents or other physical evidence relevant to a legal case.
According to the mother, the father misled the court in his application to suspend the maintenance order. She argued that the maintenance court granted the order in line with what was provided by the father in terms of his monthly salary as well as his annual bonus which amounts to over R1 million.
She further argued that the father did not provide proof to support his claim that he cannot afford to pay maintenance. He also didn't provide any evidence to support that his financial position had changed for the worse since the order was made.
Furthermore, she said the father lied in his affidavit as his IRP5 showed that he had received more than R1 million in March 2025. With this information, she sought to have the interim order suspending the maintenance order to be dismissed.
Furthermore, the mother highlighted discrepancies in the father's affidavit, alleging that his IRP5 tax document, which revealed earnings exceeding R1 million as of March 2025, illustrates his capacity to pay the mandated maintenance while still maintaining a comfortable lifestyle.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Ad loading
In response, the father approached the high court again, seeking to have the subpoena set aside. He claimed the documents requested by the mother were irrelevant and warned that such disclosures would cause irreparable harm.
Presiding over the matter, Judge James Lekhuleni said the previous maintenance court order revealed that the mother battled to coerce the father to honour his maintenance obligations. He only provided financial support to the children when it suited him.
He commented on the mother's diligent efforts, recognising that she was an unrepresented litigant trying to safeguard her children's welfare. The judge made it clear that the mother's attempts to compel the father to meet his obligations should not be viewed as an abuse of the legal system.
Moreover, judge Lekhuleni emphasised that denying the subpoena would unduly harm the mother and the children, while the father would not suffer significant prejudice from its continuation.
"As I see it, there is no prejudice that the applicant (father) will suffer if the subpoena is not set aside. While on the other hand, setting aside the subpoena will have deleterious effects on the first respondent (mother) and the children," he said.
The father's application was dismissed.
sinenhlanhla.masilela@iol.co.za
IOL News
Get your news on the go, click here to join the IOL News WhatsApp channel.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

IOL News
an hour ago
- IOL News
Leaked affidavit exposing Landiwe Ntlokwana's involvement in a multi-million rand scheme
According to the affidavit, Ntlokwana managed investor data, tracked payments, and even used her company's bank account — GTT Wealth (Pty) Ltd — to receive millions of rands from individuals drawn into Bushiri's now-notorious commodities investment platform. Image: Supplied A leaked affidavit has exposed Landiwe Ntlokwana, a former auditor and financial coordinator for Prophet Shepherd Bushiri, as a key figure in a multi-million rand investment scheme — and strongly suggests she is using her testimony under Section 204 of the Criminal Procedure Act in a strategic bid to escape prosecution. According to the affidavit, Ntlokwana managed investor data, tracked payments, and even used her company's bank account — GTT Wealth (Pty) Ltd — to receive millions of rands from individuals drawn into Bushiri's now-notorious commodities investment platform. Her phone, she claims, was used by multiple committee members as the central point of contact for investor communication. 'The committee and I continued our administrative duties as described previously. My phone continued being passed around for whoever wanted to focus on that function,' she said. With a strong background in Microsoft Excel, Ntlokwana took responsibility for consolidating all investor information into a single master file, which she says was used by the IT team for internal reporting and to generate investor statements. The affidavit details the rapid expansion of the scheme and growing unrest within the church community. Ntlokwana describes how popularity surged beyond South Africa's borders, leading to complaints from international followers of Bushiri's Enlightened Christian Gathering Church who felt excluded from the opportunity. 'They started saying what was the point of belonging to a community where only a select few can participate in empowerment initiatives,' she said. These concerns, she claims, were taken directly to response, Ntlokwana says Bushiri called a closed-door meeting with her and five other women in his inner circle — Gladness, Rosemary, Shirley, Jumoke, and Memory. During the meeting, Bushiri announced the launch of a new investment round: Commodities Trade Cycle 3. This phase, however, was exclusive to high-net-worth individuals, with a minimum investment of R1 million. Despite her corporate background at firms like Grant Thornton and Allan Gray, Ntlokwana admits there were no formal contracts governing her role. Legal experts find this highly questionable. 'She's not an amateur. She knows how finance works,' said a senior investigator. 'The absence of contracts and the use of her company account are not rookie mistakes — they point to direct involvement.'Under Section 204, an accused may be granted immunity in exchange for full and truthful testimony. ''But such a deal hinges on credibility — something that could be Ntlokwana's biggest hurdle.'She handled the money, the records, and the investor lists,' the investigator continued. 'Now she's trying to claim she was just assisting — but this affidavit proves she was in control.' With Bushiri still in Malawi and his extradition proceedings stalled, Ntlokwana's testimony could close the case but she if found to be self-serving or unreliable, the prosecution could be left with little to stand on

IOL News
6 hours ago
- IOL News
Public Works Minister takes action against alleged political abuse in Matjhabeng's EPWP
EPWP payments frozen in Matjhabeng amid claims of councillors receiving over R31,000 monthly; Minister vows to root out corruption and restore the programme's core purpose. Minister of Public Works and Infrastructure Dean Macpherson has halted all Expanded Public Works Programme (EPWP) fund transfers to the Matjhabeng Local Municipality. This comes after a City Press investigation revealed that the municipality's EPWP payroll is allegedly being used to pay inflated salaries, over R31,000 per month , to former councillors and current political office bearers, more than ten times the average EPWP stipend. Macpherson said the EPWP was never meant to serve as a vehicle for political patronage, but rather to provide short-term, skills-based work opportunities to unemployed South Africans. He has now instructed the Department of Public Works and Infrastructure to suspend all transfers to the municipality until a formal investigation is completed.

IOL News
8 hours ago
- IOL News
First-Time Buyer in SA? Why a 10% deposit can save you over R160K
It pays to conduct a detailed analysis of your spending habits as a starting point. Image: RON AI Simon* was no stranger to second-guessing himself, and at times, he really wondered if he was making progress in life. As a junior account manager at a marketing agency, he was making a reasonably good salary for a 28-year-old. Not thriving, not rolling in it, but theoretically skirting within the boundaries of middle-class life. But often it just didn't feel like it. He lived in shared accommodation with two other people. When his girlfriend slept over on weekends, she complained about having to share a bathroom with other housemates. She also wasn't a fan of his silver 12-year-old Toyota Yaris with a massive gash across the back bumper. Many of his friends rented their own townhouses, often impeccably furnished, and with the obligatory big screen TV for Saturday's rugby game. One of his friends, at a similar earning level, bought himself a brand new Polo GTI, right out the box. But when Simon looked at his investment account balance, a gentle smile lit up his face. Living below his means, and strictly managing his cash flow, was allowing him to save between 30% and 40% of his net income, depending on each month's unexpected expenses. He'd been saving at a significant level since the age of 26, and not too long after his 30th birthday, Simon bought his first house. He did this with a 30% deposit, drastically reducing his interest rate and setting himself up to be debt-free sooner than expected. He also traded up to a partner who didn't judge his trusty old ride. There are numerous examples of South Africans who made the necessary sacrifices to save up for their home loan deposit. Although many first-time home owners opt for a zero deposit option, this will lead to significantly higher interest rate payments over the long term. Let's look at a simple example. If you buy a R1 million home with a 100% deposit, at 11.75% interest over 20 years, your monthly instalment will be R10,837, and the total interest paid over the term will amount to R1,6 million, according to FNB. But put down a 10% deposit of R100,000 and you're looking at a lower monthly payment of R9,753, and the total interest amount is reduced to R1.44 million. That's a saving of around R160,000 in interest over the 20-year period, and you stand to save far more than that by putting down a 20% or 30% deposit. 'Putting down a deposit signals that you're financially ready. It reduces the loan amount you need, lowers your monthly repayments, and increases your chance of approval. It also shows that you've built the habits needed to manage your long-term financial commitments,' says Sfiso Mahlangu, structured lending product manager at FNB Home. But how do you save for that all-important deposit? Farzana Botha, senior communications manager at Sanlam Risk and Savings, said she and her husband made several sacrifices while saving for their first home deposit. These included downsizing their car to reduce repayments and selling household items that were no longer needed, while her husband also took on side jobs to generate additional income. 'These sacrifices were tough but worthwhile – having a deposit gave us access to better finance options and made our dream of homeownership possible,' Botha enthused. She says living below your means is one of the smartest ways to reach your dream of owning a home faster. 'It starts with being intentional about how you spend and save. Work out how much you'll need for a deposit and set a monthly savings target. Automate that amount as soon as you're paid so it becomes a priority rather than an afterthought.' She recommends tracking every cent of your income and expenses, and making lifestyle tweaks where possible. This could mean cutting back on things like entertainment, takeaways and subscriptions. Even small changes like cooking at home and sharing streaming services can free up hundreds each month, she adds. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ It's well worth saving up for a bigger deposit if you can. Image: RON AI Luke Davis-Ferguson, financial planner at Fiscal Private Client Services, advises South Africans to resist the urge to upgrade their lifestyle after receiving a raise or bonus. 'Consider moving in with family, getting a roommate or relocating to a more affordable area temporarily. Selling unused items can also give your savings a quick boost.' His firm recently helped a couple create a monthly surplus of nearly R5,000, simply by reducing discretionary spending on eating out, subscriptions, and impulse purchases. Be aggressive with your savings strategy Luke Davis-Ferguson says the first step is understanding exactly where your money is going. He recommends downloading bank statements from the past three to six months and reviewing every line item. Tools such as Discovery Bank's Vitality Money Financial Analyser or FNB's Money Savings Goals can be used to create a detailed and customised monthly budget. Davis-Ferguson says the 50/30/20 rule is generally used as a starting point for budgeting. This means 50% for needs such as rent, groceries, transport and medical aid, 30% for wants like entertainment and eating out and 20% for savings and debt repayment. However, if your goal is to save for a deposit, this ratio needs adjusting. Consider trimming wants to 10% and boosting savings to 40%. Ester Ochse, product head at FNB Integrated Advice, recommends a 'pay yourself first' approach to savings, in which you automate your banking and move a set percentage of your income into a separate savings account. Ester Ochse, product head at FNB Integrated Advice. Image: Supplied 'This removes the guesswork and the temptation to use what's meant for your future on short-term wants,' Ochse said. She recommends the 80:20 rule, with at least 20% of one's income being directed to savings, or more if possible. Furthermore, it's vital that you set a clear savings goal with a clear timeline, says Tando Ngibe, senior manager at Budget Insurance. 'Break it down monthly so it feels achievable. Then automate your savings through your bank so it becomes a habit, not a decision. 'Remember, living below your means isn't about depriving yourself. It's about being intentional with your money so you can build the future you want,' Ngibe added. Tackle your debt first Before ramping up your savings, it's crucial to tackle any high-interest debt, especially from credit cards, clothing accounts or personal loans, Davis-Ferguson says. 'These debts often carry interest rates that far exceed what you could earn in a savings account, meaning they erode your financial progress,' he adds. 'Start by listing all your debts, including balances, minimum payments, and interest rates. Focus on paying off the highest-interest debts first (the avalanche method), or if you need quick wins to stay motivated, start with the smallest balances (the snowball method). 'Once you have cleared your high-interest debt, redirect those monthly repayments into your savings,' Davis-Ferguson concludes. It's important to estimate what your monthly costs will be after purchasing your first home, Discovery Bank's head of technical marketing, David Leibowitz advises. This means adding up the estimates of your monthly home loan, as well as municipal rates, utilities, levies (if you're in a complex), home insurance and future property repairs and maintenance. Bond registration and property transfer costs also need to be budgeted for in advance. Why you should put extra money into your bond If you've budgeted correctly and there is still a bit of money left over at the end of each month, it makes a great deal of sense to put this into your bond. Simon, who we mentioned earlier, is already looking forward to paying off his bond sooner and saving a great deal on interest by employing this trick. But how much can realistically be saved? According to FNB, paying an additional R500 into your 20-year bond on a R1 million property, using the aforementioned example, will save you R335,000 in interest and shorten your loan period by three years. Whichever strategy you follow, it is important to approach your savings with a goals-based approach, says Nicola Langridge, wealth manager at Private Client Holdings. 'Starting a new exercise regime has always been hard for me when I am not clear on what the goal is. I am far more committed when I have entered a 21km race or booked a hiking trip that requires preparation and has a clear deadline. Saving for your financial future follows the same principle,' Langridge says. But life does not happen in a straight line, so regular reviews and adjustments are essential as circumstances evolve, she adds. IOL