Build on this joint statement to try and save Gaza
This is the strongest western criticism yet of Israeli conduct across Palestine, and it has coincided with Israel's offensive on Deir al-Balah, the city which has acted as a refuge for thousands of displaced people. It has the infrastructure, logistical bases and personnel to keep people alive, and its destruction will be catastrophic.
It appears unlikely that this western condemnation will deter Israel. With a few exceptions, western governments have been calling upon their ally, Israel, to stop or moderate its behaviour while also ensuring that Tel Aviv has not suffered serious diplomatic, economic or military costs for acting with impunity across Palestine. Further, neither Germany nor the United States, Israel's most steadfast backers and its largest arms suppliers, have signed that statement. This is a signal that there has been no change in their policies and may be another reason why Israel is unlikely to stop.
But there is still time for the world to act and prevent the Palestinians from being destroyed.
The facts
Is Israel committing genocide? The International Court of Justice (ICJ) may take years to determine this. Several jurists, legal and other scholars argue that what is unfolding in Gaza is in fact a genocide. However, rather than guiding us to facts, this question has become politicised and an end in itself. And the facts are sickening.
Gaza had a population of about 2.3 million people when the war began in October 2023. About 60,000 people are confirmed dead, perhaps half of them women and children, and 90% the population has been displaced multiple times. The United Nations says that Gaza's remaining population has been squeezed into about 46 square kilometres of land where systems of food, health and hygiene have collapsed. That is about 43,478 people per square kilometre, living in conditions that one would not wish upon any form of life.
Tel Aviv's game plan
But these numbers do not capture what is widely suspected to be a systematic destruction of human life and habitat in Gaza through a micromanaged plan of starvation. Israel has curbed aid inflow when the war began. Earlier this year, it imposed a total blockade of 11 weeks and followed it up with a new aid delivery system that, according to the western nations' statement, 'deprives Gazans of human dignity'. Israeli forces have killed about a thousand desperate people seeking limited amounts of food under degrading conditions. And the UN says a third of the population has been living without eating. Exhaustion is endemic. Starvation is widespread. And famine looms. Is this not a genocide?
Israel does not allow foreign journalists to report freely from Gaza. And it discredits the non-Israeli accounts coming out of Gaza. This has allowed it to dispute any assessment of its likely endgame in the territory.
That Israel is carrying out ethnic cleansing is clear. Israeli leaders have publicly stated their plan to control most of Gaza, force the Palestinians into a 'humanitarian city', and let them out only if they choose to leave for another country. Two former Israeli Prime Ministers, Ehud Olmert and Yair Lapid, have called this 'city' a 'concentration camp'. Conditions for a future generation of Palestinians in Gaza are being destroyed. And as Jean Drèze recently noted in this daily, once famine sets in, people will turn against each other, which will put an end to all solidarity and chances of reconstituting. It would then be used as evidence of Palestinian barbarism and sub-humanity — and thus further proof that the Palestinians are not a people.
Stop the hedging
The UN says that the 'last lifelines to keep people alive are collapsing', but the world can still step in. The world has a chance to halt the catastrophe. Governments can review the scale of their diplomatic, economic and military ties with Israel. International peacekeepers can be sent to Gaza. Russia, China and India could join their 'Global South' partners in exerting additional pressure on Israel to stop. The Gulf countries and Türkiye should stop hedging. The western nations' statement has '... urge[d] the international community to unite in a common effort' to end the war. Non-western governments can test western sincerity by offering to evolve a common approach.
There are some of us who know what is going on in Gaza is an act that will end the idea that 'humanity is one and universal'. Therefore, we must do what we can. Governments and corporations have more influence, but individuals can act on their conscience too. The time to act is now. Otherwise, we will be hanging our heads in shame and regret.
Atul Mishra teaches international relations at the Shiv Nadar University, Delhi-NCR
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
10 minutes ago
- Time of India
126 packages, six countries: Israel airdrops aid in Gaza; dismisses 'starving' Palestinians claims
Israel on Friday said that it air-dropped humanitarian aid into the Gaza Strip, in partnership with six countries, including three European nations. The Israel defence forces (IDF) claimed the operation delivered 126 aid packages containing food to residents in both northern and southern Gaza. The joint airdrop involved the United Arab Emirates, Jordan, Egypt, Spain, France, and Germany, according to an IDF statement cited by the Jerusalem Post. This marked the first time the IDF coordinated such a relief effort with the three European countries. The move comes amid increasing global criticism over the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. IDF chief of staff lieutenant general Eyal Zamir rejected global claims that Israel is starving children in Gaza. Responding to the accusations, Zamir said, "The false campaign about starvation these days is a deliberate, coordinated, and deceitful attempt aimed at accusing the IDF—a moral army—of war crimes." "The party responsible for the killing and suffering of Gaza's residents is Hamas. IDF soldiers and commanders act with morality and integrity, in accordance with the IDF's spirit and international law," Zamir added. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Unsold 2021 Cars Now Almost Free - Prices May Surprise You Unsold Cars | Search Ads Learn More Undo Commenting on the ongoing hostage negotiations, Zamir indicated that military operations would continue regardless of diplomatic developments. "I estimate that in the coming days we will know whether we can reach a partial deal for the release of our hostages," he told commanders, according to the Jerusalem Post. "If not, the fighting will continue without pause." Since the nearly three-year war between Hamas and Israel began, over 58,000 Palestinians have been killed, according to Gaza's health ministry. Several ceasefires have been attempted, but none have held. Israel has continued military action in Gaza and the West Bank, with consistent backing from US President Donald Trump. At least 91 people were killed and 600 wounded in Gaza over the past 24 hours while waiting for aid, amid ongoing ceasefire discussions and inspections of food distribution, according to the Guardian.
Scroll.in
35 minutes ago
- Scroll.in
Two visions of Berlin pride: Club music at one event, mourning for Gaza at the other
There were two pride marches in Berlin on July 26. One, organised by CSD Berlin, a registered NGO, was supported by major brands and corporations. Trucks bearing corporate logos rolled through the streets. Brand slogans floated on flags, club-style music blared from sound systems. Behind them, groups of revellers danced, posed, and marched in festive clusters. In keeping with Berlin's character, it is a technicolour procession, heavy on spectacle. 'This is a party,' said Yassi, 24, who works in hospitality. She identifies as lesbian. I was with two other queer friends, Lisa and Charlie. We had taken the S-Bahn from Potsdam to Berlin and reached the Victory Column just as the CSD parade reached its final stop behind the Brandenburg Gate. The mood there was jubilant, and familiar, much like the previous three prides I had attended. But we weren't staying. We turned and left for the second march: the Internationalist Queer Pride. Charlie, our usual route-finder, found us a back way after metro stations nearby were blocked off. On the Telegram channel, IQP had just posted an alert: the police had attacked the demonstration; the march had temporarily stopped. More updates followed, hinting at escalating tensions. Days earlier, the organisers had issued an advisory, not on party etiquette and sunscreen, but on protest safety. 'Carry a lawyer's number; avoid oil-based creams that worsen the effects of pepper spray; stay calm, stay together.' The anticipation of arrest and police action was evident. It was a sober primer for navigating a demonstration under duress, a telling indicator of how Berlin's police treats political dissent. The Internationalist Queer Pride insisted that pride remains a political demonstration, anti-racist, anti-capitalist and internationalist in makeup. There were no trucks or floats. It was attended by blocks from a wide range of marginalised collectives, disability and minority groups and migrant organisations. The speeches were raw and unsparing. They conjured not rainbow euphemisms, but Gaza, hunger, incarceration, and memory. They spoke of 'every child in Gaza crying from hunger… dying from the hunger that wraps itself around every cell'. They spoke of stones, not as metaphors, but as resistance – recalling Faris Odeh, the 14-year-old killed by Israeli forces after hurling rocks at tanks during the Second Intifada. The International Jewish Anti-Zionist Network denounced 'pinkwashing' – the appropriation of queer rights to obscure state violence. 'The Israeli Occupation Forces flies rainbow flags over ruins they have bombed,' one speaker said. 'Zionism has never made Jews safer, only the world more dangerous.' For context: in the West Bank, the Israeli state continues to authorise settlement expansion in violation of international law. Just this week, Awdah Hathaleen, a Palestinian activist from Masafer Yatta, featured in the award-winning documentary No Other Land, was killed near Umm al-Khair. He was 31. He had three children. He was killed by Yinon Levi, a Jewish settler previously sanctioned by the Biden administration, whose sanctions were later reversed under Trump. We reached the scene near Cottbusser Damm. On a canal wall, a banner read: 'No genocide in anti-semitism.' Nearby, three masked figures stood behind an Antifa flag. One held a placard delcaring, 'Against antisemitism and hate of Israel.' I heard a heated exchange. A woman called the IQP march anti-Semitic. A cyclist had paused beside two women in disagreement. 'It's a queer march,' he insisted. 'Not against Jewish people.' One woman scoffed and shifted the argument, 'You know why there's no ceasefire? Hamas pulled the plug last minute,' before clapping her hands and gesturing dismissively. The entire road was swamped with police officers, police surveillance vehicles and dog squads. We continued. The demo approached. There were no corporate trucks. One placard read, 'Queer as in Free Palestine.' Another asked, 'Who were you before you obeyed into silence?' A long black banner stretched across the street: 'Germany you cry 'never again' while funding it again.' On the reverse: 'If Jewish life is safe only in Israel, what does that say about Germany?' I spotted Yassi. 'This is where I belong,' she said. 'Not the other pride. This reminds me why we do this, why we march. It's political, it's for freedom, it's for everyone.' I asked if she was worried about police violence or feared arrest. 'I'm relatively privileged,' she said. 'I'm German-Moroccan and I pass as white. My risk is lower than others who've faced violence.' The march was halted. A line of police blocked the road. A group of officers charged into the crowd. There was panic among people. The police pinned an individual to the ground. The crowd chanted, 'Let them go!' Others tried to protect a demonstrator being dragged. As a photojournalist and immigrant in Germany, I was frightened. I have read about such police violence, watched videos from a safe distance. But being there, seeing it unfold metres from me, hearing people scream, watching someone pinned to the pavement, their shirt pulled over their head, it was something else entirely. It was not televised, but immediate. I stayed. The police dissolved the protest, citing threats to public safety. IQP legal observers contested it, arguing the protest had been peaceful. At the time of writing, their challenge remains unresolved. I met Sandra, a German-American woman. 'We were peaceful,' she said. 'Even when police attacked people without reason. Who are they protecting? Who are we threatening? The people are cheering us from their windows. They are not threatened.' Sandra, who grew up in East Germany, continued, 'The German police today aren't different from Nazi police.' I ask her what she thinks of freedom of assembly, democracy in Germany. Sandra's friend added, 'We're fucked. There is no freedom. They'd never treat a Zionist march like this.' While we spoke, a woman was thrown to the ground. Her shirt ripped up, her bare chest scraped against the street. People shouted, 'At least show respect for the frau.' A woman in a blue vest, perhaps part of the organising team, pleaded with police to let participants leave safely. She moved from one officer to the next, make her request. I took photos, then tried to approach the police vehicle where demonstrators were being taken. A line of officers closed in, shielding the police van. One of the officers pushed me. I stated clearly that I was a journalist and duty bound to record their actions. My camera was brushed aside without acknowledgment. I was pushed further. They moved forward as a wall. I was forced backwards. There are moments when the work of reporting blurs with the impulse to flee, to protect oneself. I was torn between documenting this story and being a part of it – between being a witness and being seen, suspended between being a body in the crowd and the one meant to observe it.
Time of India
35 minutes ago
- Time of India
Hamas Attacks IDF Soldiers With Hidden Bombs In Gaza, Blows Up Convoy Routes
Chilling new footage shows Hamas fighters in Khan Younis burying and detonating three barrel bombs aimed at an Israeli armored vehicle. The video, reportedly filmed Monday, captures the moment of explosion as thick black smoke engulfs the road. Hamas claims IDF casualties, though Israel has not confirmed. This comes amid rising violence across Gaza, with over 80 Palestinians reported killed in Israeli strikes on Friday.
