&w=3840&q=100)
Bet value doesn't qualify as income under I-T Act: Egaming firms to SC
As per the Income Tax Act, a consideration is defined by law as any sum or value that is either received or recoverable from a user or a client in return for a service that has either been provided or will be provided. Since online RMGs do not accrue or receive the monies deposited by users for themselves, it cannot be considered taxable income, the counsel for the companies told the Court.
He further explained that when people play against the casinos, they settle with the winners and losers and then take whatever is left as surplus.
"We are not valuing the bet but the right to win. It's a different concept from bet value....As far as the face value of the bet is concerned, it belongs to the winner," he said. The court will continue hearing online RMGs' arguments until Friday.
In the last hearing, the companies had argued that the GST provisions before October 2023 were inadequate to impose a 28 per cent tax on online gaming operators in the manner attempted by the authorities. The government's reliance on Rule 31A of the GST Rules (value of supply in case of lottery, betting, gambling, and horse racing), introduced in 2018, was challenged because it lacked statutory authority under the Central GST (CGST) Act, the companies had said.
On Tuesday, online RMGs also contended that attempts to tax actionable claims like betting and gambling as 'goods' by amending the Goods Rate Notification were flawed. Until October 1, 2023, there was no entry for actionable claims in the Customs Tariff Schedule, making their classification as goods unsustainable under GST.
The petitioners (online gaming companies) explained to the court the distinction between platform fees, on which GST is already paid, and prize pool contributions made by players, which are held in trust and returned to winners. They claimed that prize pool contributions do not constitute consideration and thus cannot be taxed under GST.
In the case of online games, they argued that these games are played against each player, with the online gaming operator merely providing platform services, and that the platform operator, as the supplier of platform services, has discharged GST during the relevant period at the specified rate.
The division bench of Justices J B Pardiwala and R Mahadevan is hearing the case, which deals with the absence of clear taxing provisions to enforce tax collection before the October 2023 overhaul. The case, with an estimated financial impact of Rs 2.5 trillion, is one of the biggest tax battles in India's history. The matter will continue on Wednesday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
2 hours ago
- Hans India
FM Sitharaman clarifies GST issue related to apartment associations
New Delhi: Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman clarified in Parliament on Monday that apartment associations are required to register under GST if their aggregate turnover exceeds Rs 20 lakh (Rs 10 lakh in special category states) in a financial year and the associations are required to pay GST only where the maintenance charged is more than Rs 7,500 per month per member. The Finance Minister further stated that apartment associations having maintenance charges up to Rs 7,500 per month per member or having aggregate turnover of goods and services below the threshold need not be registered under GST. The residents staying in the apartments do not have to pay GST. It is only the apartment associations that have to pay as they are the supplier of services, the Finance Minister said in a written reply in the Lok Sabha. "No GST compliance requirements have been placed upon the residents of apartments, irrespective of the monthly maintenance amount paid," she added. Initially, services by an apartment association to its resident members against maintenance charges up to Rs. 5,000 per month were exempt. However, the exemption limit was enhanced to Rs. 7,500 per month per member in accordance with the recommendations of the GST Council in its 25th meeting held on January 18, 2018, the Finance Minister said. The services by an apartment association to its own resident members, where the maintenance charges are greater than Rs 7,500, are taxed at the rate of 18 per cent on the recommendations of the GST Council. The limit of Rs 7,500 was also prescribed on the recommendations of the GST Council in its 25th meeting, in which a decision was taken to increase the limit from the previous level of Rs 5,000 per person per member. Sitharaman also said that if any due tax has not been paid under the GST Act, the taxpayers are provided with an option to pay either no penalty or reduced penalty, provided they are ready to pay the due tax within a specified time period. She also said that events like Taxpayer Samvad, workshops, and awareness programs are regularly being organised for information dissemination and awareness through GST facilitation centres. These initiatives are designed to help taxpayers accurately assess their tax liability. Further, there is no requirement under CGST law to obtain any official letter from the resident or apartment associations regarding their apartment's GST status.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Net FDI has fallen steeply, domestic investors gripped by 'fear': Congress slams govt
The Congress on Monday claimed that the net foreign direct investment has fallen steeply while domestic investors are gripped by "fear and uncertainty", as it asked the government to support incomes, end its "crony capitalist and tax terrorism" policies, fix the GST, and protect Indian industries from Chinese dumping. The opposition party's assertion came after Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman's reported remarks that India's private sector investment has not kept pace with the growing public expenditure. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Please select course: Select a Course Category Cybersecurity Degree Healthcare Project Management Data Science Finance MBA PGDM Data Science Others Management others Leadership Public Policy Operations Management CXO Artificial Intelligence Data Analytics healthcare Technology Design Thinking MCA Product Management Digital Marketing Skills you'll gain: Duration: 10 Months MIT xPRO CERT-MIT xPRO PGC in Cybersecurity Starts on undefined Get Details In a post on X, Congress general secretary in-charge communications Jairam Ramesh said, "The Finance Minister has finally acknowledged what the INC had been saying for a long time: that private investment continues to be sluggish and is not growing at the pace desired and also expected." by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like These Are The Most Beautiful Women In The World Undo "This is even after the significant corporate tax cuts of September 2019, undertaken just before the Howdy Modi event that was held in Houston in support of President Trump's re-election," Ramesh said. He further said that net FDI has fallen steeply while domestic investors are gripped by "fear and uncertainty" -- thanks in large measure to "tax terrorism and policies that only favour a couple of business groups". Live Events The growth of mass markets for consumption goods is being hampered by a decade-long stagnant wages crisis and a flawed GST which awaits fundamental reform, Ramesh argued. Finally, the "dumping" of cheap imports from China -- which is taking place despite the loss of Indian territory in Ladakh -- has also led to the closure of domestic manufacturing units, foreclosing the possibility of new investments, he said. "Acknowledgment is the first step. Now comes the hard part -- the government needs to take action to support incomes, put an end to its crony capitalist and tax terrorism policies, fix the GST, and protect our industries from Chinese dumping," Ramesh said. The Congress has been attacking the government over its handling of the economy, claiming the issues of rising prices, decreasing private investment and stagnating wages were hitting the common people hard.
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
3 hours ago
- Business Standard
Influencers to F&O traders: here's what ITR utility update means for you
As India's digital economy evolves and more taxpayers report income from non-traditional sources like content creation and speculative trading, the Income Tax department has overhauled its ITR utility to introduce a revised list of 'Nature of Business/Profession' codes. This change, effective from assessment year (AY) 2025–26, is designed to bring more clarity, compliance and alignment with sector-specific practices. Why did the Income Tax department make this change? The update is a response to the changing economic landscape. 'The revised codes aim to better capture emerging income sources, like social media influencing or F&O trading, while reducing ambiguity in disclosures,' said Parag Jain, chartered accountant & tax head at 1 Finance. The older codes were too generic, leading to inconsistent classification and potential compliance gaps. The change also boosts the department's analytics and cross-platform matching. 'It is a strategic move to enhance digital governance, improve compliance, and match data with GST and MCA systems,' said Deepak Kumar Jain, founder & chief executive officer of Vivek Jalan, Partner at Tax Connect Advisory Services LLP, noted that the classification will also help the department compare profitability within sectors using AI tools, which may affect how returns are scrutinised. What changes for small businesses, freelancers, and professionals? The new codes help taxpayers report income more accurately. For example: A freelance graphic designer must now use code 14010 instead of the generic 0607 A mobile retailer should now choose code 09019 instead of selecting 'Others' F&O traders must now use code 21010, replacing older catch-all financial activity codes YouTubers and influencers have a new code: 16021 'These help align disclosures with actual income and reduce mismatches,' Parag Jain said. Sonu Jain, chief risk officer at 9Point Capital, added that better classification can also ensure eligibility for presumptive schemes under Sections 44AD/44ADA. What if the wrong code is selected? While there's no explicit penalty, the risks are real. 'Wrong codes can trigger AI-based scrutiny, mismatches, or even notices,' Parag Jain noted. 'This is especially critical if the data doesn't match with GST or MSME/Udyam records,' Deepak Kumar Jain added. Jalan pointed out that if declared profits diverge significantly from industry norms, for instance, an influencer showing just 20 per cent profitability where the average is 50 per cent, they may need to furnish expense justifications. What should taxpayers and CAs do now? Experts agree there's no need to revise past filings. 'This is a forward-looking change,' Sonu Jain said. However, accuracy this year is essential. 'Use the latest ITR utility, match codes with GST/MSME records, and verify presumptive scheme eligibility,' Deepak Kumar Jain advised. In short, the ITR utility's new codes aren't just a formality. They are a signal that the tax system is adapting to modern income sources and taxpayers must adapt too.
