logo
Bet value doesn't qualify as income under I-T Act: Egaming firms to SC

Bet value doesn't qualify as income under I-T Act: Egaming firms to SC

The bet money placed by users in online real-money games (RMG) is neither accrued nor received by casinos and, therefore, should not be considered as income under the Income Tax Act, RMG intermediaries told the Supreme Court on Tuesday.
As per the Income Tax Act, a consideration is defined by law as any sum or value that is either received or recoverable from a user or a client in return for a service that has either been provided or will be provided. Since online RMGs do not accrue or receive the monies deposited by users for themselves, it cannot be considered taxable income, the counsel for the companies told the Court.
He further explained that when people play against the casinos, they settle with the winners and losers and then take whatever is left as surplus.
"We are not valuing the bet but the right to win. It's a different concept from bet value....As far as the face value of the bet is concerned, it belongs to the winner," he said. The court will continue hearing online RMGs' arguments until Friday.
In the last hearing, the companies had argued that the GST provisions before October 2023 were inadequate to impose a 28 per cent tax on online gaming operators in the manner attempted by the authorities. The government's reliance on Rule 31A of the GST Rules (value of supply in case of lottery, betting, gambling, and horse racing), introduced in 2018, was challenged because it lacked statutory authority under the Central GST (CGST) Act, the companies had said.
On Tuesday, online RMGs also contended that attempts to tax actionable claims like betting and gambling as 'goods' by amending the Goods Rate Notification were flawed. Until October 1, 2023, there was no entry for actionable claims in the Customs Tariff Schedule, making their classification as goods unsustainable under GST.
The petitioners (online gaming companies) explained to the court the distinction between platform fees, on which GST is already paid, and prize pool contributions made by players, which are held in trust and returned to winners. They claimed that prize pool contributions do not constitute consideration and thus cannot be taxed under GST.
In the case of online games, they argued that these games are played against each player, with the online gaming operator merely providing platform services, and that the platform operator, as the supplier of platform services, has discharged GST during the relevant period at the specified rate.
The division bench of Justices J B Pardiwala and R Mahadevan is hearing the case, which deals with the absence of clear taxing provisions to enforce tax collection before the October 2023 overhaul. The case, with an estimated financial impact of Rs 2.5 trillion, is one of the biggest tax battles in India's history. The matter will continue on Wednesday.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

GST: Small traders call off planned protest
GST: Small traders call off planned protest

The Hindu

timean hour ago

  • The Hindu

GST: Small traders call off planned protest

Traders in Karnataka have decided to withdraw the State-wide protest planned on Friday (July 25) after the government decided to not collect three years of arrears of Goods and Services Tax (GST) from small traders and shopkeepers with Unified Payment Interface (UPI) transactions exceeding an annual turnover of ₹40 lakh. However, traders have been told to mandatorily register under the GST to ensure prompt payment of taxes in the coming days. Traders had planned planned a protest on Friday after they were served notices to pay tax arrears by the State Commercial Tax Department officials. 'I appealed to them to withdraw the protest and they agreed. No action will be taken on notices issued to traders,' the Chief Minister, who holds the Finance portfolio, said.

HC disposes of PIL on land compensation, upholds district judges verdict
HC disposes of PIL on land compensation, upholds district judges verdict

News18

time2 hours ago

  • News18

HC disposes of PIL on land compensation, upholds district judges verdict

Last Updated: Shillong, Jul 23 (PTI) The High Court of Meghalaya has disposed of a long-standing public interest litigation (PIL) relating to alleged excess compensation paid during a land acquisition in Ri Bhoi district, upholding the findings of a Special Judicial Officer. A division bench examined a 2017 direction of the Supreme Court which had sought a probe into whether public money was squandered through inflated land compensation. Under the apex court's order, a district judge-level judicial officer was appointed to examine the compensation paid. The Special Judicial Officer, who is also a district judge, held on June 20, 2025, that the compensation was not excessive and had been computed in accordance with the law. The petitioner had already received 80 per cent of the compensation and sought the remaining 20 per cent through this appeal.. However, respondents opposed the claim, arguing the compensation received exceeded what was due, and questioned the petitioner's entitlement. The high court observed that the reference to the special judicial officer stemmed from a Supreme Court directive in a public interest litigation, and not under any statutory provision. Treating the officer's decision as a final judgment/decree in original jurisdiction, the court stated that any aggrieved party is at liberty to seek appropriate remedies as per law. The remaining 20 per cent of the compensation amount will continue to be withheld for eight weeks from the date of the high court order, after which it will be released to the transferor unless directed otherwise.. The intervening period since June 20 will not be counted towards the limitation period for any legal appeal or proceeding. With this, the HC disposed of the PIL. PTI JOP NN view comments First Published: July 23, 2025, 21:00 IST Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

AAP govt stabilised states declining economy: Punjab FM
AAP govt stabilised states declining economy: Punjab FM

News18

time2 hours ago

  • News18

AAP govt stabilised states declining economy: Punjab FM

Last Updated: Derabassi (Pb), Jul 23 (PTI) Punjab Finance Minister Harpal Singh Cheema on Wednesday said the AAP government has successfully stabilised the state's declining economy during its three-year tenure. He emphasised that consistent efforts are underway to further enhance Punjab's performance in gross state domestic product (GSDP) and other key economic indicators. He was addressing a gathering at an event here. He noted that Punjab now ranks among the top three states in the country for tax compliance. The state is registering remarkable growth in goods and services tax collections, overall revenue and expenditure, he said. Highlighting the government's fiscal achievements, the minister said Punjab has surpassed the total GST compensation cess collected during the previous regime (2017-22). Over the last three years, the state received a total of Rs 63,000 crore in GST compensation cess. He also stated the excise revenue has doubled during the AAP government's tenure, rising from Rs 6,152 crore to around Rs 12,000 crore. Additionally, the government has provided over 55,000 merit-based government jobs, curbing brain drain and boosting admissions in state universities and colleges, he said. The minister credited the government's tax reforms for significantly improving the state's economic health. PTI CHS MR view comments First Published: July 23, 2025, 21:00 IST Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store