Bid to silence a blogger's running reviews on the Two Oceans Marathon failed in court
Image: Ian Landsberg/ Independent Media
THE Gauteng High Court dismissed the urgent application aimed at silencing a runner and blogger who has raised concerns about irregularities in major races, specifically the Two Oceans Marathon.
The ruling underscored the tensions between race management and public accountability in South Africa's running community.
Antoinette Cavanagh, chairperson of the Two Oceans Marathon, who approached the court for relief, and directed her application at Stuart Mann, the author behind the blog The Running Mann, who has drawn attention to what he describes as "irregularities" in various running events, including the Two Oceans and the renowned Comrades Marathon.
In court, Cavanagh claimed that Mann's online commentary contained defamatory statements, particularly focusing on four posts he shared on social media.
Among them was a December article questioning her suitability to chair the board of the Two Oceans, which highlighted discrepancies between the credentials she publicly presented and those Mann verified.
In his December 2025 "expose", Mann queries whether Cavanagh is an appropriate person to chair the board of the Two Oceans. He set out apparent inconsistencies between her professional and running credentials as set out in a press release announcing her election on the one hand, and those details of her credentials which Mann was able to verify on the other hand.
In April this year he dealt with certain controversies that emerged during the 2025 iteration of the Two Oceans, including a shortage of bronze medals, which Mann contends was due to Two Oceans accepting more entries than it had a permit for.
He also insinuated that she has the board completely under her thumb, as well as publishing her CV which served before the board when she was elected chair. Cavanagh, in claiming the publications are defamatory and unlawful, wanted Mann to remove them and publish an apology. She also wanted an order preventing future publication of similar content.
Mann disputed the urgency of the application and denied that the content of the posts is defamatory or otherwise unlawful.
Judge Seena Yacoob commented that the 'chaotic' and 'vague' manner in which the application is pleaded does not commend itself to determination on an urgent basis, but she agreed to hear it on an urgent basis. She said both Cavanagh and the Two Oceans Marathon (cited as the second applicant) fail to set out a clear factual background.
In addition, the judge said, the applicant's papers contain neither the dates of the publications, nor the specific statements or utterances complained of. Cavanagh, however, said that she considers each publication defamatory in its entirety.
Judge Yacoob further noted that the publications consist of much material which is either not obviously defamatory, or not defamatory at all.
'Neither of the applicants have made out a case that the esteem in which they are held is of a particular type. Cavanagh does not favour the court with her own full history nor does she demonstrate that she is viewed with any particular esteem or that she has a reputation for integrity and good leadership.'
The judge added that the Two Oceans does not contend that it has run its events in a manner reasonably beyond criticism and above board. It does not even contend, let alone attempt to demonstrate that it has conducted its events lawfully and in a manner compliant with its permits from the City of Cape Town.
'There is no attempt to demonstrate that any of the factual claims made in the publications is untrue, although there is a bald allegation that they are all false,' Judge Yacoob said in turning down the application.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
8 hours ago
- IOL News
Tshwane's Boshielo dismisses DA's claims of increased power outages as electioneering tactics
City of Tshwane MMC for Utility Services, Frans Boshielo, responds to DA accusations about increased power outages in Tshwane, citing scheduled maintenance and neglect by previous administrations as the cause. Image: Oupa Mokoena / Independent Media Frans Boshielo, Tshwane's Member of the Mayoral Committee for Utility Services, has dismissed the DA's claims that the city is experiencing more power outages than during load shedding as nothing more than electioneering tactics. This follows DA finance spokesperson Jacqui Uys' statement that her party met with Tshwane officials amid widespread and ongoing power outages across the city. She said: 'Ineptitude and poor workmanship have caused continuous power outages across the City of Tshwane, with the city now seeing more power outages than during load shedding.' Uys said the coalition government's decision to prohibit officials from working on emergency power outages after hours has exacerbated the situation. She was referring to the new overtime policy, which restricts after-hours work and aims to cut excessive overtime payments while supposedly maintaining critical services. The city has previously denied that the policy, which took effect on April 1, would harm service delivery or lead to prolonged power outages due to limited staff availability outside regular hours. Uys said: 'While the administration cites cost control as the reason, a report presented to the city's finance committee revealed that R130 million in electricity revenue was lost in April alone, primarily due to power outages.' She cited an example of planned maintenance over the weekend, which was scheduled for four hours and affected most of eastern Pretoria. She claimed that the project was a failure, had to be rescheduled, and still left residents without power for up to 24 hours due to poor workmanship and problematic overtime rules. 'The DA supports the responsible management of overtime, and that work that needs to get done in office hours is done in office hours. It cannot be business as usual in case of emergencies where entire communities are left in the dark at a cost to both residents and the city,' Uys said. Reacting to the claims, Boshielo said: 'That statement by the DA is electioneering, they know for a fact that the City of Tshwane has published scheduled maintenance that needed to be done for the electrical network.' According to him, outages are not comparable to load shedding, and the issue stems from the outages needed to connect the Njala/N4 power lines, which affected the eastern part, as the network had to be switched off upstream to allow energisation. 'The fact of the matter is that this current administration communicated through official portals which the DA councillors are part of and instead of preparing the affected ward, they want to score cheap political points,' he said. He explained that before the current administration took office, the substations had been plagued by vandalism, theft, and inadequate maintenance budget allocation. In contrast, he said, the current administration has increased the maintenance budget, enabling scheduled maintenance, unlike under the previous DA administration led by former mayor Cilliers Brink. 'The withdrawal of static security personnel by the DA administration exposed the city's infrastructure to vandalism and theft. Illegal connections of electricity are also contributing to electrical network overload and tripping, but the current outages, as I have said, do not surpass load shedding, as the DA alleged,' Boshielo said. [email protected]
TimesLIVE
a day ago
- TimesLIVE
Trump tells Fox News he has group of wealthy people to buy TikTok
Image: REUTERS/Dado Ruvic/Illustration/File Photo US President Donald Trump said in a Fox News interview broadcast on Sunday he had found a buyer for the TikTok short-video app, which he described as a group of 'very wealthy people' whose identities he will reveal in about two weeks. Trump made the remarks in an interview on Fox News' Sunday Morning Futures with Maria Bartiromo programme. He said the deal he is developing would probably need China's approval to move forward and he predicted Chinese President Xi Jinping would likely approve it. The US president earlier this month had extended to September 17 a deadline for China-based ByteDance to divest the US assets of TikTok despite a law that mandated a sale or shutdown without significant progress. A deal had been in the works this year that would have spun off TikTok's US operations into a new US-based firm, majority-owned and operated by US investors, but it was put on hold after China indicated it would not approve it after Trump's announcements of steep tariffs on Chinese goods. A 2024 US law required TikTok to stop operating by January 19 unless ByteDance had completed divesting the app's US assets or demonstrated significant progress towards a sale. Trump, who credits the app with boosting his support among young voters in last November's presidential election, has extended the deadline three times.
The South African
2 days ago
- The South African
Fezile Mkhize crowns Lavigne Swann as successor
In a momentous event, Fezile Mkhize of South Africa officially crowned Lavigne Swann of France as his successor. The ceremony marked the end of an era and the beginning of a promising new chapter. The event drew a diverse crowd of dignitaries, supporters, and media from across the globe. Fezile Mkhize, known for his dynamic leadership and commitment to progress, handed over the mantle with great pride, according to Conan Daily. 'It is with immense honour that I pass this responsibility to Lavigne,' Mkhize said. 'His vision and dedication will undoubtedly steer us towards a brighter future.' Lavigne Swann, who has made significant strides in his career, expressed deep gratitude and determination. The speeches highlighted the importance of international collaboration and showcased South Africa's growing influence on the global stage. For the South African audience, this transition signals a continued commitment to innovation and unity. Fezile Mkhize's tenure saw numerous initiatives that boosted local economies and enhanced social development. His successor promises to uphold these values while bringing fresh ideas to the table. The event also featured a fundraising segment, where attendees contributed generously. The total amount raised reached approximately R3.5 million (South African Rand), aimed at supporting community projects and youth empowerment programmes. As the evening concluded, the atmosphere was charged with optimism. Many attendees expressed confidence in Swann's leadership. This historic handover honours South Africa's legacy but also strengthens its ties with France and the wider international community. It is a moment that South Africans will remember with pride and hope for years to come. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1. Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
