Rural Tipperary home gets green light despite neighbour's objections
However, Mr O'Brien's proposed neighbour, Ben O'Brien submitted a third-party appeal to the grant of planning permission to An Coimisiún Pleanála, stating that the applicant should not be allowed to build his home on this site, questioning his eligibility under the council's rural housing need policies.
The appellant lives across the road from the proposed new house and stated that 'once the applicant reached 18 years of age he moved out of the area.
"If the housing needs policy and requirements can be satisfied by a child residing in the area for a continuous period of 10 years then effectively there is no rural housing need policy because every child that grew up in their local area and finished secondary school, is eligible for a rural house.'
Under Tipperary County Council's rural housing policy, applicants typically must demonstrate a strong local connection or 'rural-generated housing need'.
The appellant also raised concerns about the height of the proposed new-build.
In response, the applicant, Michael O'Brien rejected the appellant's claims and questioned his own connection to the area.
"He is from a different parish, Hollyford, which is 20 minutes form his home. To say that he has a less right to build a house on the road than the applicant is ridiculous,' the planning files said.
The applicant said that he and his family welcomed the appellant into the area when they built their house some years ago, and they did not lodge any objections to his planning application.
The applicant criticised the neighbour's own large home, describing it as 'enormous' and contrasting it with his proposed build.
ADVERTISEMENT
"The third-party appellant has failed to mention his own dwelling house which is appropriately named 'The Height' which is 3-4 times bigger than the proposed development. His house is enormous and does not blend into the landscape.'
Mr O'Brien was granted permission to build his home on the site, despite his neighbour's objections, subject to eight conditions.
Among the conditions are that the applicant or his family live in the home for at least seven years after the house is built, that the site be landscaped with only indigenous deciduous trees and hedging species, and that any surface water run-off from the site be disposed of within the site.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
6 days ago
- Irish Independent
Striking new artwork unveiled in Tipperary to celebrate town's legacy
Beelines, a new sculpture, has been unveiled on the main road into Clonmel, and is inspired by Clonmel's association with bees and honey making. The Tipperary town is known as the Vale of Honey, and the new artwork marking this has been installed on the N24 Cahir Road Roundabout, Ballingarrane, Clonmel. Designed by artist Kevin Killen, the artwork uses cold rolled metal steel tubes to arrange a distinctive pattern that symbolises the energetic flight patterns of bees to create a contemporary flower-like form on a silver stem. Funded by Tipperary County Council and the Office of Public Works (OPW), the sculpture will act as a permanent gateway to the town of Clonmel, changing colours throughout the seasons as the light changes, and will be complemented with wildflowers that are planted by the Clonmel Borough District. Based in Belfast, artist Kevin Killen obtained a BA (Hons) in Fine Art from the Surrey Institute of Art and Design University College, and completed specialist training in neon making in Dallas, Texas in 2009. His current practice focusses on capturing moments in time, representing life and people's journeys as snapshots of moments, which are often site-specific.
Irish Times
7 days ago
- Irish Times
Galway farmer granted permission to challenge Greenway purchase decision ‘splitting' his farm
A Galway farmer has been granted permission to challenge a compulsory purchase order (CPO) made by An Coimisiún Pleanála (ACP) to construct a cycleway that he says would run across his land and 'split' his farm. He has claimed the route built under the Connemara Greenway Project would make his farmlands – in his family since the 1940s – 'unmanageable and landlocked'. At the High Court, lawyers for Oliver Joyce, of Emloughmore, Clifden, Co Galway, successfully applied to Ms Justice Emily Farrell to challenge the ACP's decision to grant a May 2025 compulsory purchase order (CPO) to Galway County Council relating to lands he owns at Doireliagh, Doireclunlaigh, Clifden, in Co Galway. The project aims to install a cycle and walkway going from Galway city to Clifden over 76km (47 miles) that would go through 'the backbone' of Mr Joyce's property along the old Galway-to-Clifden railway line, he claimed. READ MORE Mr Oliver has taken the challenge against ACP's decision to approve the compulsory acquisition, with Galway County Council named as a notice party. In court papers, Mr Oliver said he was conscious that his farmlands were located in a 'highly sensitive environment', which includes marshland and hilled areas that form part of the Connemara Bog Complex SAC, a conservation area. The plaintiff submitted the practice of farming the lands through generations of his family was done 'in perfect symmetry with the environment' and that he is 'very passionate and concerned about this'. Mr Oliver claimed that when the project was first proposed by the council, it was to be carried out on a permissive basis such that the council would be facilitated in accessing the lands, but the lands would remain in his ownership and open so stock could travel across both sides of the farm. He submitted that his lands have a mix of soil types and this variety was essential, in that each part is integrated and grazed with the marshy area providing water during dry periods and the hilly areas providing respite during inclement weather conditions. Mr Oliver said the project, as approved by the granting, was different from the original, in that it now envisages a wider walk and cycleway. He submitted that he was assured by the council that the lands would remain open for stock to travel and that any fencing would only be constructed when they were required by the landowner and that the application to ACP was one based on his permission. Mr Oliver claimed he understood the project to initially comprise of a 2.5m-wide (8.2ft) 'informal track of a type that one would see in the countryside', but that the more recent, larger scheme now involved a 3.5m-wide (11.5ft) asphalt track with full fencing involving 'sheep wire and barbed wire'. The plaintiff said he was 'shocked' that after an initial agreement on the scheme, Galway County Council then said they would 'accept nothing less than full ownership' and sought the CPO. Mr Oliver argued that the 'fundamental basis of the scheme has been turned on its head' by the CPO and that the decision to do so was 'taken without cause or justification'. He further claimed that environmental assessments carried out and submitted to ACP related to the original scheme and that the new elements that arose in the CPO scheme were not previously considered for environmental impact. Ms Justice Farrell granted leave for the judicial review to Michael O'Donnell BL, instructed by Harrington & Co solicitors – for Mr Oliver – and adjourned the matter to September.
Irish Independent
21-07-2025
- Irish Independent
Plans for Wicklow solar farm refused over visual impact
Located in the townland of Ballymoney, just off the M11, the proposed development – which had a 40-year lifespan - was the second planned by BNRG in the area after receiving consent for a solar farm on a neighbouring 19-hectare site in 2019. The latest application proposed to construct PV panels mounted on metal support structures along with a battery energy storage system (BESS), with access provided via the neighbouring, approved solar farm. The solar farm, battery energy storage system BESS and main infrastructure, including inverter stations, MV stations, new access tracks, underground cabling, a temporary construction compound and a substation, would occupy five fields of agricultural land currently being used for arable farming, with perimeter fencing surrounding it, 16 CCTV cameras and access gates. Refusing the application, a senior executive Wicklow County Council planner noted three reasons for the decision, including the overall scale of the proposed development within a designated Coastal Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty, its visibility from the surrounding road network and the 'cumulative effect of a number of permitted solar farms within the immediate area'. 'It is considered that the proposed solar farm would be contrary to the objectives of the County Development Plan, would result in a significant visual impact due to the local landscape appearing industrialised and would negatively impact on this scenic coastal rural area,' the planner wrote. Noting the potential detrimental impacts on the amenities of residential property in the area, the loss of established agricultural land and the lack of supporting information, the planner commented that the local authority is 'not satisfied that the proposed development would not seriously injure the amenities of the area'. Commenting on how it was 'not possible to fully assess the potential impact on the amenities of the area', the planner highlighted the lack of sufficient information submitted, including a fieldwork-based archaeological impact assessment, decommissioning costs, plans outlining appropriate riparian buffer zones and a report on the potential impacts of a cumulative loss of agricultural land in the area'. BNRG has four weeks from the decision date (July 9) to appeal the decision to An Coimisiún Pleanála.
