
Power, perception, precision: notes from covering a plane crash
On the afternoon of June 12, when the Air India flight bound for London crashed into a medical college shortly after take off in Ahmedabad, I was assigned to cover the incident. In this age of technology, where reporters are expected to provide updates in real time, our most vital organ is not the pen and notepad, but the mobile phone. Whether we are covering political rallies, protests, natural disasters, or accidents, we are perpetually tethered to our devices. We use them to mail stories, shoot videos, click photographs, make dozens of calls, and coordinate with the newsroom. As our biggest fear is that our phone battery will die, every one of us has a power bank. This has become as essential as a press card. Many journalists carry multiple backups and some even lug around the monstrous 50,000 mAh power bricks that resemble mini-inverters. Our phones are our lifelines.
I went to the accident site prepared, with a bag full of devices. Yet during the long hours at the crash site and at Ahmedabad Civil Hospital, where bodies were brought in for identification and autopsy, I didn't use my power bank.
This wasn't because there wasn't work. My phone battery dwindled in sync with my energy reserves. Yet somehow, I managed. This is because help came from an unexpected source: the extension boards scattered across the hospital premises. They were not there specifically for journalists, but for everyone gathered there: grieving family members, tireless volunteers, and reporters. The extension boards gave everyone a moment to recharge literally and figuratively.
There were people everywhere offering help in different ways. Volunteers from various Hindu organisations, including the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, the Vishva Hindu Parishad, and local NGOs, along with a few Muslim groups, ensured that food, buttermilk, cold drinks, and glucose-infused water were being supplied at the hospital round the clock. One scorching afternoon, while I was outside the morgue, a man tapped my shoulder and insisted that I drink glucose water. That small gesture and many others like it revealed the depth of the coordinated relief effort.
The premises were always kept clean. Every time someone drank buttermilk or water and leaned to place the empty bottle aside, or looked around for a trash can, housekeeping staff would appear out of nowhere to clear it. Within minutes, every piece of waste was disposed of, no matter how crowded or chaotic the space and the situation.
In short, the worst aviation tragedy in recent times in India was being handled on the ground with precision and thought. In retrospect, I realised that this was not surprising. The crash had made international headlines. Dozens of reporters from national and foreign media had flown into the politically significant State of Gujarat, which has been governed by the Bharatiya Janata Party for decades and is the home turf of both Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Union Home Minister Amit Shah. Any photograph or short video clip of a stray bottle or pile of trash left unattended in one of Asia's largest public hospitals could have easily gone viral. Apparently, even a stray bottle risked becoming a political statement. And that, it seemed, was not a risk anyone was willing to take.
What stayed with me was not just the sorrow of the families, but also the manner in which the tragedy was handled. Even amid the grief, the quiet control being exercised was unmistakable.
deshpande.abhinay@thehindu.co.in

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Indian Express
5 hours ago
- Indian Express
Is there an Indian psychoanalysis? Understanding Sudhir Kakar's cultural turn
Born on this day in 1938, Sudhir Kakar, the 'father of Indian psychoanalysis', is celebrated for bringing a distinct 'Indianness' to the field. Psychoanalysis is a theory of mind and a clinical practice developed by Sigmund Freud. It primarily focuses on the relationship between 'conscious' thoughts, feelings, and behaviours, and the 'unconscious' mind. Notably, Freud and others after him emphasised upon the discipline's universality. By interpreting the Indian psyche through myths and societal norms, Kakar infused psychoanalysis with an Indian cultural richness, and redefined how the discipline could engage with non-Western minds. His ideas continue to reshape how India thinks about the mind, culture, and identity today. Kakar passed away last year. Kakar believed that Freud's theories, while revolutionary, were embedded in European culture, meaning they often failed to resonate with Indian psychological realities. He argued that Indian culture views reality differently from the post-Enlightenment West. 'In the traditional Indian view, which still exerts a powerful influence on how even most modern Indians view marriage and family, parent-sons and filial bonds among the sons living in an extended family override the importance of the couple as the foundation of the family,' he said in an address to the Indian Psychoanalytic Society in 2022. But rather than rejecting psychoanalysis, Kakar expanded it by interpreting the unconscious through the lens of Indian myths, familial structures, and spiritual traditions. He introduced concepts such as the 'Ganesha Complex' as an Indian-alternative to Freud's influential Oedipus Complex, which borrowed from Greek mythology to explain a son's sexual attitude to his mother and hostility towards the father. 'My main argument is that the ''hegemonic narrative'' of Hindu culture as far as male development is concerned is neither that of Freud's Oedipus nor that of Christianity's Adam,' he wrote in 'Hindu Myth and Psychoanalytic Concepts: The Ganesha Complex' published in Asian Culture and Psychotherapy: Implications for East and West (2005). Kakar used the myth of Skanda (also known as Kartikeya) and Ganesha to explain India's culturally sanctioned dependence on the maternal figure. Unlike Skanda, Ganesha in the myth chooses maternal closeness over heroic independence. 'By remaining an infant… Ganesha will never know the pangs of separation from the mother… That Ganesha's lot is considered superior to Skanda's is perhaps an indication of the Indian man's cultural preference in the dilemma of separation-individuation,' Kakar wrote. Kakar drew heavily from Indian epics, folklore, and even popular cinema to reveal how collective fantasies shape the unconscious. 'The self,' he said 'is a system of reverberating representational worlds — representations of culture, primary family relationships and bodily life.' While Kakar's work itself was rooted in Hindu culture, he envisioned an Indian psychoanalysis that would engage critically with Western theories. 'The wish is that a future generation of Indian analysts realises that a critical stance is now needed after a long, much too long phase of idealisation of Western analytic gurus,' he said. Psychoanalysts in India today draw deeply from Kakar's reimagining of psychoanalysis, integrating his culturally rooted insights into clinical practice, specifically acknowledging the imprint of collective histories, myths, and identities on the unconscious. As Amrita Narayanan, a clinical psychologist and psychoanalyst, wrote in 'An Elastic Indianness: In Memory of Sudhir Kakar' (2024), Kakar believed that the Indian 'ego', formed through the blurring of self and other, was fundamentally different than the Western, autonomous conception. 'The 'I am' and 'we are' are birthed simultaneously for Indians,' she wrote, suggesting that for many, social expectations are internalised as personal desires. This deep enmeshment of self and community has major implications for how therapists understand emotional conflict, sexuality, and even violence. 'Much like Freud, Kakar's quest for clues in folk tales, fables, and epics holds the reimagination of Indianness, in which the self yearns for spirituality,' said Pulkit Sharma, a clinical psychologist and psychotherapist. For many clinicians, Kakar's recognition of India's spiritual imagination, through epics, rituals, and mythology, reshaped what counts as healing. Myths of Ganesha and Ram, used by Kakar to illustrate the nurturing and sacrificial Indian son, challenged Western tropes like Oedipus and offered a new vocabulary for male development. Similarly, fantasies of femininity, coded as nurturing, maternal, and emotionally sensitive, are central rather than deviant. 'In the clinical room, sensitivity is given to caste, religion, gender, family, generational myths, and traditions that shape the subjectivity of the client. All of it informs the therapist about indigenous narratives and themes that help in learning the unconscious script. This accessibility serves as a guide to meaningful therapeutic growth,' Sharma said. 'The psychotherapist must know that it's not merely a defence, but a well-meaning psychological structure that fosters healing. The psychopathology is not intrapsychic but extrapsychic in Kakar's works. It further carries the ruptures of colonialism, modernity, and globalisation,' he added.


Scroll.in
7 hours ago
- Scroll.in
Prajwal Hegde
Stories written by Why US court rejected Hindu group's claims that caste discrimination cases violate religious freedom A federal judge rejected a claim by a Hindu advocacy group that California's anti-caste enforcement violated their religious freedom. Prajwal Hegde · 5 minutes ago Romance fiction: Will two warring journalists bury the ghosts of the past to rekindle their love? An excerpt from 'The Way We Were', by Prajwal Hegde. Prajwal Hegde · Sep 22, 2023 · 05:30 pm


NDTV
8 hours ago
- NDTV
When Is Naag Panchami 2025? Recipes You Can Make For Bhog At Home
The month of Sawan is considered sacred by devotees of Lord Shiva, who observe special rituals and fasting throughout this time. Along with Sawan Shivaratri and Hariyali Teej, the festival of Naag Panchami is also celebrated during this period. It falls on the Panchami Tithi of the Shukla Paksha in the month of Sawan, typically two days after Hariyali Teej. Naag Panchami is dedicated to the worship of Lord Shiva and Nag Devta. Devotees believe that offering prayers to snakes brings peace and protection. This festival is also observed in Nepal. Mansa Mata, regarded as the mother of serpents, is also worshipped on this day. When Is Naag Panchami 2025? Full Puja Timings And Panchami Tithi Naag Panchami Date: Tuesday, 29 July 2025 Naag Panchami Puja Muhurat: 5:41 AM to 8:23 AM Duration: 2 Hours 43 Minutes Naag Pancham in Gujarat: Wednesday, 13 August 2025 Panchami Tithi Begins: 11:24 PM on 28 July 2025 Panchami Tithi Ends: 12:46 AM on 30 July 2025 (Source: Drik Panchang) Why Do People Celebrate Naag Panchami? In Hindu mythology, it is believed that Lord Krishna once fell into the Yamuna river, where he encountered a dangerous serpent named Kalia. As Kalia attacked, he soon realised Krishna's divine power and pleaded for mercy. Lord Krishna agreed not to harm him, on the condition that Kalia would never hurt anyone again. Naag Panchami marks this symbolic moment of protection and divine strength. What Is The Religious Significance Of Worshipping Snakes? Snakes have deep symbolism in Hindu tradition. They are associated with rebirth, fertility, and protection. Naag Devta is believed to be a guardian of the netherworld and a close associate of Lord Shiva, who is often shown wearing a snake around his neck. Worshipping serpents during Naag Panchami is believed to remove fear, illness and negative energy from one's life. Many families also worship Mansa Mata on this day, believed to be the mother of all snakes, for protection from snake bites and for the well-being of their families. Rituals Performed On Naag Panchami Drawing snake images outside homes using rice paste or turmeric Offering milk and white flowers at anthills or temples Chanting and performing puja to Lord Shiva Fasting for the day or eating only saatvik food Preparing milk-based sweets as part of the bhog In some regions, clay idols or live snakes are worshipped by priests. Feeding Brahmins and giving charity is also common. 5 Traditional Bhog Recipes For Naag Panchami Puja: Plain Milk Milk is the most basic and traditional offering to snakes during Naag Panchami puja. Though simple, it is considered sacred and essential for this ritual. Chawal Ki Kheer (Rice Kheer) A classic Indian dessert made with rice, milk, raisins and cardamom, garnished with almonds. It is easy to prepare and makes for a comforting, sweet bhog dish. [ Click here for the recipe ] Nariyal Ki Barfi (Coconut Barfi) Prepared with grated coconut, khoya, ghee and sugar, this soft sweet is full of flavour. It is a popular traditional sweet often made with just five ingredients. [ Click here for recipe ] Samak Rice Kheer This vrat-friendly kheer is made using samak rice, milk, almonds and sugar. It is light, mildly sweet and perfect for festive days. [ Click here for recipe ] Kalakand Kalakand is a soft barfi made by simmering milk and cottage cheese with cardamom and rose water. Originally from Rajasthan, it is an excellent option for bhog. [ Click here for recipe ] Prepare these sweet dishes at home and offer them with devotion. Wishing you and your family a peaceful Naag Panchami 2025.