
Two MV Matthew crew were 'completely expendable', court told
Det Superintendent Keith Halley told the three-judge court that Englishman Jamie Harbron was on the "lowest rung" in the criminal enterprise to transport the massive drugs haul across the Atlantic, into Europe.
Harbron was hired as a deck hand on board the Castlemore, an Irish ship which was supposed to meet the MV Matthew and take the drugs to the UK, the detective said.
Under cross-examination, Det Halley told Harbron's defence counsel, Michael O'Higgins SC, that Harbron's jobs appeared to include "greasing things up" or tidying the ship. He did not appear to be a "competent or good deck hand," Supt Halley said.
He could not operate the radio, find the life vests or secure a tow rope thrown from a coastguard boat in an attempt to rescue the vessel.
Having been on rough seas from Friday afternoon until Sunday evening, Harbron was "very sick" and told gardaí he believed he was going to die.
Harbron was finally winched to safety by a coastguard helicopter and was "very, very grateful" to his rescuers, the superintendent said.
When the Dubai-based organisers of the criminal enterprise realised the Castlemore had run aground, they initially told the ship's captain, Vitaliy Lapa, not to call the coastguard.
They then removed the Castlemore from the virtual chat room used to communicate with the vessels and told the MV Matthew they would find another boat to make the rendezvous.
Supt Halley agreed that this indicated Harbron and Lapa were "completely expendable".
Harbron appeared to have become involved in the plot at the last minute and had told gardaí that he was promised €10,000 would be wiped off a €20,000 drug debt.
Lapa, the detective said, speaks no English and the two men communicated using Google Translate.
The Dubai-based leadership had an "erroneous belief" that the messages they had sent to the Castlemore would automatically delete after one hour, Supt Halley said.
However, gardaí retrieved the messages, which were used as part of the evidence in the case.
Eight men have pleaded guilty to offences arising from the seizure of €157 million worth of drugs on board the MV Matthew.
Members of the Irish Army Rangers wing of the Defence Forces boarded the ship on 26 September 2023 in a daring mission in rough seas as the MV Matthew manoeuvred to try to evade capture.
The ship had departed from Curacao, off the Venezuelan coast and sailed across the Atlantic before arriving in Irish territorial waters.
Ukrainians Mykhailo Gavryk, 32, and Vitaliy Vlasoi, 33, Iranians Soheil Jelveh, 52, and Saeid Hassani, 40, Filipino Harold Estoesta, 31, and Dutch national Cumali Ozgen, 50, pleaded guilty that between 24 and 26 September 2023, both dates inclusive, at locations outside the State, on board the vessel MV Matthew, they possessed cocaine for sale or supply, in contravention of the Misuse of Drugs Regulations.
Ukrainian national Vitaliy Lapa, 62, with an address at Rudenka, Repina Str in Berdyansk, and Jamie Harbron, 31, of South Avenue, Billingham in the UK pleaded guilty that on dates between 21 and 25 September 2023 they attempted to possess cocaine for sale or supply, in contravention of the Misuse of Drugs Act.
Lawyers for all eight today asked the court to be as lenient as possible in sentencing.
For mitigation, they rely on their guilty pleas and the fact that their time in prison will be spent in a foreign country away from their families.
None of those before the court were the leaders of the criminal organisation involved in transporting the drugs but were hired to perform specific roles on the two ships, lawyers said.
The only defendant with a record of offending is Jamie Harbron, whose convictions include cannabis and cocaine possession in the UK.
Lawyers for the others submitted that their clients were of good character before this offence, but they "succumbed" to temptation, hoping to resolve various financial difficulties.
Brendan Grehan SC, for Kumali Ozgen, said his client's job on board the MV Matthew was to "mind the cargo".
He was, counsel said, the "eyes and ears" of those directing the operation from Dubai and had no seafaring experience.
Ozgen admitted to gardaí that he loaded crates of drugs onto the ship and used paint thinners to try to burn the drugs when the Irish Navy began its pursuit.
He also said he was to be paid €50,000 to €100,000 if successful, but has received nothing.
Mr Grehan said Ozgen took the job in a "misguided attempt" to provide for his family, in particular his son, who suffers from poor health.
Hugh Hartnett SC, for Gavryk, said his client was of excellent character before this offence.
Michael Hourigan SC, for Estoesta, said his client had provided gardai with valuable information, including that when the drugs were loaded onto the MV Matthew, ordinary crew members were plied with alcohol to distract them.
Mark Lynam SC for Hassani said this was the first time his client was involved in "anything of this kind".
He had been a sailor of good character all his life but "succumbed to temptation", believing the money from this job would allow him to spend more time with his wife and family.
Colman Cody SC, for Lapa, said his client was a hard-working, law-abiding citizen and a loving husband and father.
Following the Russian invasion of Ukraine in 2022, Lapa found himself in a "vulnerable financial position".
Despite having retired as a fishing captain, he was compelled to go abroad to provide for his family. "He was vulnerable to certain pressures, and that ought to be taken into account," counsel said.
Paul O'Higgins SC, for Vlasoi, said his client was the first officer on the boat but had led a blameless life before.
He had limited knowledge of the operation, counsel said.
Keivon Sotoodeh BL, for Jelveh, said his client was the captain of the MV Matthew but was acting on orders from Dubai.
The court previously heard that Jelveh became frustrated with the instructions he was receiving and called the coastguard for an emergency medical evacuation.
A coastguard helicopter lifted Jelveh from the MV Matthew before the ship was engaged by Irish Naval vessel the LE William Butler Yeats.
Ms Justice Melanie Greally, sitting with Judge Sarah Berkeley and Judge Gráinne Malone, will deliver the sentences on 4 July.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Irish Examiner
8 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
Jim Power: Budget countdown begins with big promises
The publication of the summer economic statement has set the budgetary process in motion, and the destination will be reached in early October. The two relevant ministers have outlined a budget package of €9.4bn, with a net tax package of €1.5bn, and an expenditure package of €7.9bn. This expenditure package will be comprised of current expenditure increases of €5.9bn or almost 75% of the total; and capital spending of €2bn or just over 25% of the total. Proposed Vat cut On the tax side, the Government has given a commitment to reduce the Vat rate for part of the hospitality sector — the food element — to 9% and this would cost around €580m in foregone taxes. If this is delivered and applies from January 1 next, it means that effectively less than €1bn would be available for personal tax changes. To put this in context, it is estimated that a 1% indexation of the employee tax credit would cost around €230m in a full year, so to index for projected inflation in 2026 would cost somewhere in the region of €460m; or a 1% decrease in the 40% tax rate would cost around €540m. If the government delivers the Vat cut from the beginning of 2026, which it has committed to, the tax package will be small. So not surprisingly, there are suggestions that the cut might be delayed until July, thereby significantly reducing the cost in 2026. If this transpires, the hospitality sector would have every right to be aggrieved. Restaurants and food businesses are the most crucial element of our tourism product, and many businesses are struggling to stay afloat. Inflation Data released by the CSO last week show that in 2024, Irish food prices are the third highest in the EU-27 and are 12% above the EU average. In the year to May, agricultural output prices increased by 20.7%, with cattle prices up by 48%. These prices obviously feed into restaurant input costs, but the pressures are compounded by labour costs, insurance, water charges, commercial rates etc. I am a supporter of the reduced Vat rate, and I think it is now more appropriate to provide some limited support to a key employer of people all over the country, and a vital part of the tourism offering, rather than to pump money through excessive expenditure into an economy that is still doing quite well. Does the Irish economic cycle need a continuation of out-of-control current expenditure now? I think not. Even if the Vat cut is pushed out, the extent of the easing of the personal tax burden will be miniscule. We should have learned from the past We should have learned our lessons from the pro-cyclical policies of the past. The summer economic statement projects planned expenditure of €108.7bn this year, which is €3.3bn higher than planned in Budget 2025, and it is likely to turn out even higher than this latest projection. Not surprisingly, the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council is not happy and has justifiably accused the Government of 'poor planning and budgeting.' Obviously, the ability of the two ministers to deliver the proposed budgetary package, and indeed to deliver the ambitious, but detail lacking, revised National Development Plan, will be heavily contingent on the future performance of the economy, and especially the actions of Donald Trump. Downward creep in projections There is not a lot of detail in relation to economic assumptions in the summer economic statement, but it is interesting to note that for 2025 the Department of Finance is projecting growth of 2% in modified domestic demand (MDD), down from 2.5% in April, and 2.9% in Budget 2025 last October. For 2026, MDD is projected to grow by 1.8%, down from 2.8% in April, and 3% in Budget 2025. There is downward creep occurring in Ireland's economic projections, which seems logical in the context of Trump-induced uncertainty. In relation to the National Development Plan, it is quite amazing that we must await detail on the projected spend until close to budget time. What in the name of God has been happening since January? The aspirations outlined in the revised plan — such as energy, water, housing, transport infrastructure, and climate change — are difficult to argue with, but delivery on time and on budget will be essential. One hopes there will be greater control, transparency and accountability in relation to National Development Plan delivery than we have seen with major infrastructure projects such as the children's hospital and the infamous bicycle shed.


The Irish Sun
8 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Hunt for Irish man suspected of brutal murder of wife & 3 kids in Oz as cops ‘still hopeful' for answers decades later
AUSTRALIAN cops are looking for the help of the Irish public in solving a 55-year-old quadruple murder cold case. On July 2, 1970, the bodies of Therese Crawford and her three children Kathryn, James and Karen were found murdered in their car. Advertisement 4 Elmer Kyle Crawford is suspected of killing his wife and kids in Australia 4 Cops believe he might be hiding out in Ireland Her husband, Elmer Kyle Crawford, is the only suspect He had emigrated to the country in his 20s, after leaving In a bizarre case, the bodies were found after a family of tourists travelling the Great Ocean Road discovered the car 20m over a cliff at Loch Ard Gorge in Port Campbell. Advertisement It hadn't yet dropped to the water but the front of the car was crushed, and a hose running from the exhaust was stuck inside the front window. When emergency services were finally able to access the car, they found the four bodies inside, covered with blankets and a tarpaulin, with random items, including biscuits, strewn around. They later discovered Therese, 35, was also pregnant with her fourth child. Her husband Elmer was missing and it came about in the investigation that two weeks before they were killed, he and his wife had drafted new wills which left a large sum of money to him if his family died. Police said Elmer had created an electrocution device, used a 49ft length of lead and alligator clips, which he attached to his wife's earlobs and fingers as she slept. Advertisement He also electrocuted Kathryn and James and struck them with hammers, while the youngest, Karen, was beaten to death with a hammer, which was placed in the car alongside the bodies. At the time of their deaths, Kathryn was 13, James was eight and Karen was six-years-old. LAST SIGHTING A 1971 inquest into the deaths stated Elmer was responsible for them and it was believed that he hoped to stage the scene as if Therese had murdered the kids and then used the fumes from the hose to take her own life in a murder-suicide. Elmer was last seen at the family home in the afternoon on the day the bodies were discovered. He has reportedly been spotted in Western Australia, New Zealand, Advertisement But despite extensive searches, police have never been able to locate him. In one instance in 1994, a former associate of Elmer was holidaying in Perth and is believed to have spoken to him. Elmer appeared not to recognise the associate and claimed to be on holidays from New Zealand. He was born in Canada to an Irish woman, who left him to grow up with his grandparents in Australian police have issued a digitised photo of what Elmer would look like now, which they are circulating around the globe amid the possibility that he may have fled as far afield as Ireland. If he was still alive, Elmer would be around 95-years-old. Despite whether he is still alive or has passed away, investigators remain keen to find out where Elmer has been since his family's murder. Advertisement 'STILL HOPEFUL' Detective Inspector Dean Thomas from the Victoria Police Homicide Squad told 'The investigation into the deaths of Therese, Kathryn, James and Karen Crawford in July 1970 remains open. 'While nearly 55 years have passed since they were located deceased in the family vehicle at Loch Ard Gorge in Port Campbell, Homicide Squad detectives have not given up hope that the case may be solved one day. "It is likely that he has changed his appearance in order to disguise his identity". 'Police also continue to seek information on the current whereabouts of Elmer Crawford, who is believed to be responsible for the death of his pregnant wife and three children. 'If he were still alive today, Elmer would be aged in his 90s. Advertisement 'Anyone with information in relation to the murders or the disappearance of Elmer Crawford is asked to contact Crime Stoppers by submitting a confidential crime report at 4 The bodies of Therese Crawford and her three children were found murdered in their car Releasing the age enhanced photo of Elmer in 2008, police announced a $100,000 reward for information on his whereabouts. At the time, Detective Sergeant Peter Harrington from the Victoria Police Homicide Squad said: "There have been a number of sightings of Elmer over the years, which leads us to believe that he is still alive and living interstate to avoid detection. "It is likely that he has changed his appearance in order to disguise his identity. He previously worked as an unqualified electrician and even though would now be of retirement age, it is possible he still does a bit of this type of work on the side". Advertisement He added: "This was a particularly horrific incident which effectively erased an entire family. "Therese, Kathryn, James and Karen deserve some answers and we believe somebody out there has information that will bring those people responsible to justice". FAMILY BACKGROUND Therese was from Ipswich in Queensland and came from a large family. She moved to Melbourne to pursue a nursing career and that's where she met Elmer. The pair had a whirlwind romance and wed quickly before building their home. Advertisement Locals told media after the deaths that Elmer was an unusual character and somewhat of a loner. He was an unqualified electrician and a cook on the side, but it's understood he amassed a decent sum of financial savings and some land in Queensland. Author of Almost Perfect: The true story of the Crawford family murders, Greg Fogarty interviewed a number of neighbours and friends of the Crawford family. He said friends of the Crawfords told him that despite being known as a quiet man, Elmer was known to have outbursts of anger, including one time he smashed up his car in a fit of rage when it was causing him trouble. Anybody with information is asked to contact Crime Stoppers on 4 The Loch Ard Gorge, Victoria, Australia, where the family's car was discovered Credit: Getty Images - Getty Advertisement


Sunday World
12 minutes ago
- Sunday World
INLA issue warning to ‘far-right gangsters' and ‘vermin' drug dealers
Table and stares: armed masked men pose in front of starry plough flag associated with socialist republican groups The three masked men posing with weapons An armed republican group are allegedly warning 'far-right gangsters' and drug dealers they will be taking 'direct action' against them. A statement posted and circulated on social media includes a photo of three masked men posing with what appear to be automatic weapons fitted with silencers. A table in front of the armed men is draped with the starry plough flag usually associated with socialist republican groups. The statement suggests the group has already taken action against criminals in the Crumlin area of Dublin. A social media account supportive of the Irish Republican Party and slain Real IRA leader Alan Ryan posted the statement from the group 'reported to be the Dublin brigade of the INLA'. 'Our organisation has taken action in the Crumlin area, dealing with the antisocial behaviour that has plagued our community. 'As seen, we have taken direct action with housebreakers and other people attacking our community. We have the names of the individuals involved in these crimes against our people. We say to them: be warned, you're next.' The statement on Instagram The statement then turns to drug dealers in the area: 'The working-class communities have been hit hard with the rise of heroin, tablets, crack cocaine dealing, and drug intimidation. 'We reject these vermin; we ask the community to reject them.' Action 'We will be taking direct action with these parasites at the time of our choosing.' 'Our movement has continued to grow in numbers, with our community initiatives, rising numbers of youth coming into our ranks due to our sincere commitment to tackling community issues.' It is also suggested that the group are targeting members of the political far-right, accusing them of recruiting young people to carry out hate-crimes. 'Until now, we have been investigating and gathering intelligence on far-right gangsters trying to drag our youth to jail carrying out hate crimes. 'Our targets are far-right criminals hiking up hate within normal concerned Irish citizen protests.' 'We say to the working class: beware of your surroundings. 'Our volunteers are ready to deliver our response to all anti-community parasites. 'These perpetrators are a blight on our communities, and we ask those within the communities to be vigilant. 'We owe our allegiance to the working class. Saoirse go deo.' A spokesperson for Irish Republican Socialist Party said they were aware of the statement but as a legally registered political party said they had no role to speak on behalf of an armed group. Earlier this year another organisation calling itself the Republican Defence Army warned drugs dealers to leave the north-west of the country. The three masked men posing with weapons Today's News in 90 Seconds - July 27th