BSc Environmental Science vs BSc Geography: Which will help you solve climate problem more effectively?
— Sunil Puri
Climate change is no longer a distant threat but a daily reality that impacts the ecosystem, economies, and the lives of millions. Global priorities are being reshaped as the world gears up to address the challenge and many students are asking: which undergraduate path should they pursue, environmental science or geography, if they truly want to contribute to solving climate problems? The answer is not straight-forward as both disciplines are deeply interconnected and essential and today all fields of science are interdependent.
Nevertheless, although both disciplines deal with Earth's systems, their approaches to solving climate issues differ significantly.
Environmental Science is an interdisciplinary subject that integrates biology, chemistry, and earth sciences to study the environment and develop scientific solutions to ecological problems. Students learn about pollution control, environmental impact assessments, climate modeling, and sustainable technologies.
In contrast, Geography blends physical and social sciences. Physical geography provides foundational knowledge about Earth's physical systems, including hydrology, landforms and climate systems, aiding in the assessment of environmental changes. However, human geography focuses on spatial relationships, urban planning, population dynamics, and policy — crucial for climate adaptation and mitigation strategies.
Career prospects in both fields are enormous but vary based on specialisation. Environmental Science graduates often find roles in environmental consultancy firms, pollution control boards, NGOs, research institutions, and sustainability roles in corporations. With further study, they can become environmental analysts, ecologists, or climate scientists.
Geography graduates, especially those who specialise in GIS (Geographic Information Systems), remote sensing, or environmental planning, are in demand in urban planning, disaster management, and public policy. Opportunities also exist in government agencies like NITI Aayog, IMD, ISRO or consulting firms as research analysts.
Placement opportunities depend on institutional reputation, internships and additional skills. Environmental Science programmes linked to labs or research centers often lead to scientific roles. Geography students with strong GIS and spatial analytics skills have higher employability in tech and governance sectors.
With the growing integration of AI in environmental monitoring, disaster forecasting, and spatial data studies, there is a greater demand for graduates of Environmental Science and Geography with data science and AI competencies in new and evolving job markets.
If you are inclined toward lab work, scientific research, and environmental technology, Environmental Science offers a focused path. If you are interested in the intersection of environment, society, and spatial planning — and enjoy working with data and maps — Geography may be a better fit.
Ultimately, solving climate problems needs both scientific insight and spatial reasoning. Whichever path you choose, aligning your academic interests with practical skill-building is key to making a real-world impact.
Prof. (Dr.) Sunil Puri is the dean of academic affairs-cum-registrar and faculty of basic sciences, Shoolini University. He is a Postdoc from Oxford University UK, and PhD in Biological Sciences, NAAS fellow.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
a day ago
- Time of India
Need India AI risk framework, says academic Amlan Mohanty
As new AI tools flood the market, experts are calling for stronger self-regulation to ensure safe and responsible use, supported by risk frameworks, government backing, and industry Mohanty, an associate research fellow at the Centre for Responsible AI (CeRAI), IIT Madras, emphasised that a risk-based classification system is needed. This will determine which AI systems are 'low risk' and 'high risk,' he also a non-resident fellow at Carnegie India and Niti Aayog who previously led public policy for Google in India, added that collecting real-world data on AI-related incidents in India is crucial for developing these his recent paper, 'Making AI Self-Regulation Work – Perspectives from India on Voluntary AI Risk Mitigation', Mohanty outlined a practical policy roadmap for India, arguing that voluntary or self-regulation frameworks can help manage AI risks without stifling innovation.'My suggestion would be to introduce baseline protections for all types of AI applications, while high-risk applications should be subject to additional rules,' he told ET. If an AI application causes harm or injury to an individual's life or livelihood, it should be considered high-risk, the research explained.B Ravindran, head, Wadhwani School of Data Science, said it is important to govern AI risks throughout their life cycles.'Organisations involved in AI development should proactively embrace voluntary self-regulations to lead the AI adoption in India in a safe, ethical, and responsible manner mitigating adverse impacts on humans,' he the government has not formally proposed voluntary AI risk commitments, a draft report prepared by a committee set up by the principal scientific advisor and convened by Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY), 'AI for India-Specific Regulatory Framework,' suggests that voluntary commitments could play a key role in the early phase of AI of the key arguments in the paper is that India needs its own definition of AI-based risk classifications that are influenced by local, social and cultural factors.'Do Indians worry about AI-based surveillance the same way Europeans do? Probably not. That's why one cannot simply transpose the risk classification from the EU's AI Act to Indian law. We need to collect real-world data from local communities,' Mohanty research stressed that reporting AI-related incidents will help identify the reasons behind harms caused and assess the nature of impact, whether physical, emotional, financial, or otherwise. This evidence-led approach will be key to designing a contextual and effective AI risk classification recommend a mix of financial, technical, and regulatory incentives to encourage the adoption of voluntary AI commitments For example, companies seeking grants under the India AI Mission could be required to adopt specific AI commitments as a condition for support. Leveraging the proposed AI Safety Institute in India to shape industry behaviour, develop benchmarks, and promote the use of AI safety tools is also seen as critical. Establishing a Technical Advisory Council could provide valuable expertise to government agencies, facilitate risk assessments, and support compliance efforts, experts India's approach to AI regulation is pro-innovation, each country tailors its strategy to its own priorities. The US uses a decentralized, sector-specific approach; China emphasizes centralized information and content controls. The EU has put in place the AI Act, which imposes risk-based legal obligations.
Indian Express
2 days ago
- Indian Express
Has Chandipura changed its pattern? ICMR teams visit Gujarat as samples of all 14 deceased children test negative for virus
With samples of children, who died of suspected Chandipura virus over the last few weeks, testing negative for the infection, teams of the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) visited Gujarat earlier in July in a bid to study the 'changing pattern' of the viral encephalitis. The teams collected samples of sandflies, domestic animals and residents from villages where suspected Chandipura deaths among children have been reported since June this year. the ICMR teams camped in four districts of the state – Panchmahal, Rajkot, Bhavnagar and Valsad – and studied the pattern of the virus. According to officials in Panchmahal, the ICMR team visited the district last week to gather samples of sandflies, ticks, mosquitoes and other vectors along with the that of domesticated animals and cattle, rats and human beings from the areas where four deaths have been reported. Panchmahal Chief District Health Officer Dr Vipul Gamit told The Indian Express, 'The ICMR team has gathered samples of those in the vicinity of the family that witnessed a death in the last month. They will be studied for antibodies — IgM and IgG — to understand the spread of the virus. There is a changing pattern in the virus… the same case with Japanese encephalitis, which in the recent past, has not been detected positive in laboratory tests.' Dr Gamit said that much like 2024, the Chandipura suspected cases —that later turned out to be negative after tests in Gujarat Biotechnology Research Centre (GBRC) — emerged sporadically from villages that were unrelated to one another. 'In one case, of a five-year-old boy from Panchmahal who died, and later tested negative, the other two children living in the same house — his cousins aged 7 and 8 — did not have any symptoms and are doing well,' Dr Gamit said, adding that the symptoms include high-grade fever, convulsions, followed by diarrhoea with 'little or no time' for medical response. 'Once the respiratory organs are involved, the children cannot be saved,' he added. Teams of ICMR also visited Bhavnagar, Valsad and Rajkot to collect samples of the vectors and other residents in close proximity to the deceased. Officials of the Gujarat government's medical department said that the ICMR will take the samples to its laboratory in Puducherry to check if the pattern of the virus has changed in the current season. An official said, 'The sudden increase in the number of negative cases of acute encephalitis syndrome (AES), which are not showing a positive report, has prompted the ICMR to send across a team this year to study the pattern of the virus. Specific villages in certain areas where the cases have been high have been selected by the ICMR teams for the study.' Vadodara's SSG hospital has recorded 14 deaths out of the 24 cases, including a 1.5 year old infant from Dahod, of suspected Chandipura reported this year. In-charge Medical Superintendent and Dean of Baroda Medical College, Dr Ranjan Aiyer, said, 'Every year, around June, in the month of monsoon, Chandipura cases occur due to vectors and sandflies, especially among people living in mud houses in rural areas… This year, we received unknown virulent cases of around 24 children, who presented similar symptoms, particularly in areas of Panchmahal-Dahod and even Madhya Pradesh. They deteriorated very rapidly despite a paediatric team treating them.. However, all samples have tested negative for Chandipura.' What is Chandipura virus? Chandipura virus belongs to the Rhabdoviridae family, which includes rabies. It is transmitted by sandflies and mosquitoes, including Aedes aegypti, which is also a vector for dengue. The virus resides in the salivary glands of these insects and can be transmitted to humans or domestic animals through bites. The infection can lead to encephalitis and inflammation of the brain's active tissues. The symptoms include high-grade fever, convulsions, followed by diarrhoea with 'little or no time' for medical response, according to Panchmahal Chief District Health Officer Dr Vipul Gamit. The Chandipura virus was discovered in 1965, in the blood of two individuals suffering from febrile sickness, in a hamlet of the same name near Nagpur, Maharashtra.
Mint
3 days ago
- Mint
Forewarned is fore-armed: Adopt AI for better climate forecasting
For much of modern history, weather forecasting has battled public scepticism. In 19th century England, Admiral Robert FitzRoy's early forecasts were mocked as 'guesses dressed up as science" and umbrellas would come out only when sunshine was predicted. Until recently, India's own meteorological service faced similar mistrust, with people joking that IMD stood for 'It Might Drizzle.' However, this is beginning to change. India now boasts of satellite infrastructure for climate and weather monitoring that ranks among the world's most advanced. INSAT-3D, 3DR and newly launched 3DS satellites monitor the atmosphere, land and oceans. These will be complemented by NISAR, an upcoming Nasa-Isro mission, which will track ecosystem shifts, ice melt, sea levels, groundwater and natural hazards. India also has 17 earth observation (EO) satellites, including Resourcesat, Oceansat, Cartosat and Scatsat, which track land use, agriculture, forest cover, water resources and ocean conditions. Megha-Tropiques and SARAL, part of a collaborative mission with France, aim to keep tropical weather systems, sea levels and ocean circulation under watch. The National Information System for Climate and Environment Studies (NICES) is responsible for integrating satellite data to create long-term climate records and generate variables like snow cover, vegetation indices and glacial lake characteristics. These efforts support the forecasting and tracking of critical climate events. Despite such capabilities, India is at the front line of the global climate crisis, grappling with flash floods, droughts, cyclones and heatwaves. Also Read: Time for the Global South to leverage DPI for climate action With a fragile Himalayas range and a long coastline, India's geography amplifies its exposure to climate risks. A 2021 study by Council on Energy, Environment and Water revealed that over 80% of our population resides in districts acutely vulnerable to climate shocks, while much of the country lacks the adaptive capacity to withstand them. India has seen average temperatures rise, with longer and more intense heatwaves. By 2065, these could last up to 25 times longer, posing severe health and agricultural threats. Meanwhile, erratic rainfall and a surge in dry spells have pushed nearly 600 million Indians into water stress. These challenges demand that we re-assess our climate preparedness and explore technologies such as artificial intelligence to prepare better. To achieve our net-zero target for emissions by 2070, climate risks must be assessed across a range of future economic scenarios and their associated carbon footprints. Traditional climate models offer limited simulations but machine learning can vastly enrich our modelling. Also Read: How ISRO's partnership with NASA will boost India's space industry Traditional climate models rely on complex equations to simulate the planet's systems. Globally, AI is now being used in three key ways to enhance climate modelling. First, AI-based emulators like QuickClim and ACE can mimic traditional models by learning patterns of emissions, climate outcomes and their links, enabling faster and cheaper simulations. QuickClim, developed by the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation, used 15 emulators trained in 30 minutes each to make accurate temperature projections. ACE, developed by Allen Institute for AI, outperformed conventional atmospheric models on speed and precision. Second, foundation models like ClimaX go beyond replication to uncover new patterns in climate data, offering deeper insights into global climate dynamics using observations that go back more than a century. Also Read: Space mission Axiom 4: The universe can be a family one day Third, hybrid models blend machine learning with physics-based approaches to improve accuracy in complex areas such as cloud and snow formation. Projects like CLiMA (under Caltech, MIT and Nasa JPL), Nasa and the European Space Agency's Earth system 'digital twins' and the EU's DestinE initiative aim to create simulations to better predict climate events and minimize uncertainty. Similarly, AI is transforming weather forecasting by producing accurate predictions up to 10,000 times faster than traditional models, while reducing energy and computing costs. Trained on decades of weather data, AI models can quickly analyse complex atmospheric patterns and deliver near-real-time forecasts. Notable innovations include Google DeepMind's GraphCast, which uses historical and current data for six-hourly weather forecasts. Huawei's Pangu-Weather delivers accurate weekly forecasts within seconds by processing all weather variables. Nvidia's Earth-2 combines AI and simulation tools, such as FourCastNet, to model extreme weather events such as hurricanes. While these are encouraging developments, a key challenge in AI-based prediction remains AI's 'black box' problem, which makes it difficult to trust or fix AI tools. This has drawn the scepticism of climate scientists, who still lean towards traditional models because of the complexity of Earth's systems and uncertainty over future scenarios. Although AI-based models show promise, their ability to forecast an evolving climate scenario remains uncertain. Also Read: Space race: Is competition among Indian startups ready for lift-off? India has made significant strides in satellite technology and climate data collection, but the threats of climate change demand a more forward-looking approach. Indian research organizations and leading tech companies must step up to the task of improving the speed and accuracy of climate and weather forecasting. This is vital to our long-term climate resilience. The authors are, respectively, associate director at The Convergence Foundation, and an economist.
