IND vs ENG, 2nd Test: ‘Kuldeep Yadav should bat at No. 3' - Bold advice from cricket expert
from the playing XI for the second Test against England at Edgbaston has drawn sharp criticism, with former India pacer Dodda Ganesh delivering one of the most scathing reactions.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
Taking to X, Ganesh remarked,
'
Kuldeep should bat in top 3 for Uttar Pradesh in the #RanjiTrophy and get some runs, to be picked to play for India in the tests. I don't see any other way he can force his way back into this setup where one's secondary skill dictates the team selection
.'
The comment, dripping with sarcasm, reflected the widespread frustration over India's growing reliance on all-rounders at the expense of pure specialists.
Kuldeep, who last played a Test in 2024 against New Zealand, has featured in just 13 Tests since his 2017 debut despite consistently impressive returns whenever selected. His omission has puzzled fans and experts alike, especially after the left-arm wrist-spinner picked up key wickets in recent matches and showed signs of being in red-hot form.
EXCLUSIVE | David Gower on Shubman Gill, Bumrah & India's England Tour
Former Australia captain Aaron Finch also joined the chorus of criticism, writing:
'
If Bumrah was fit to play then surely you need to pick the best bowler in the world? At the very least Kuldeep has to be in the XI if you're worried about taking 20 wickets. Yes, he might be more expensive but he's the next best attacking option!'
Captain Shubman Gill defended the decision, citing a need to bolster the batting after lower-order collapses in the previous Test.
'
We were very tempted to play him... but we wanted to add a bit of depth in the batting,
'
Gill told Michael Atherton at the toss.
Poll
Do you think India is over-relying on all-rounders in their Test squad?
Definitely, it's a concerning trend Not really, it's a balanced approach
But with India needing to take 20 wickets to stay alive in the series, leaving Kuldeep out has only intensified the heat on the team's selection strategy.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
21 minutes ago
- India Today
ENG vs IND: Shubman Gill slots into No. 4 like he has always belonged
It was a day when, for the first three hours, all the talk was about Jasprit Bumrah and the Indian management's decision to rest him. The second Test was a game where India needed to counter-punch, according to Ravi Shastri, and the choice to bench their best bowler was, at the very least, baffling in the eyes of the former Indian day, however, began with Indian batters stepping up once again. Yashasvi Jaiswal scored a fluent 87 to give India early momentum, and Karun Nair showed flashes of brilliance. India needed a big day to silence the Bumrah chatter—and it was skipper Shubman Gill who rose to the vs IND, 2nd Test, Day 1: HIGHLIGHTS The 25-year-old was under scrutiny when he was named captain and handed the No. 4 role, especially after a poor run in Australia that had put his place in the squad under question. But Gill responded with a century in the Headingley Test and followed it up with another strong performance on Day 1 at Edgbaston. The No. 4 spot has historically been reserved for India's finest—legends like Sachin Tendulkar and Virat Kohli—and Gill seems determined to continue that legacy, as pointed out by Mohammed Tendulkar, Virat Kohli and now Shubman Gill... India is always blessed to have a solid world class batsman at No. 4. Maybe this continue forever. Gill continuing a great tradition," said Kaif in his the run-scoring looking easy at times, India did find themselves in tough situations, with England applying consistent pressure. Gill came in after a well-set Karun Nair was dismissed and saw India lose key wickets at crucial Gill adjusted and tempered his stroke-makingThe flat Edgbaston surface promised free-flowing runs—or at least, Indian fans hoped so-after being put into bat. But Gill showed that the key was resilience, and the runs would eventually the 199 balls he faced to bring up his seventh Test hundred, there was only one moment where fortune played a part. In the 34th over, Brydon Carse produced a sharp delivery that struck Gill on the pads. However, a faint inside edge saved him. That was the only slice of luck he needed. From that point onward, Gill took complete control, showing immense resolve and not offering even half-chances to the the heart of his innings was an improved and compact defence—something Ravi Shastri believes Gill has worked heavily on. Speaking to Sky Sports, the former coach said that Gill used to play with hard hands on his previous England tour, much like Kohli, but has since refined his Gill has worked hard on his defence. When he last came to England, he played with hard hands, pushed at the ball, a bit like Virat Kohli. But now, the top hand is in much more control.""He allows the ball to come to him, trusts in his defence and has all the shots in the book when he goes on the attack," said the captaincy hat aside while battingOver the years, we've seen many players struggle with the burden of captaincy. Some lose sight of their primary role—whether as batters or bowlers—and try to overcompensate. But this is where Gill has stood out with maturity on this hasn't allowed the pressures of captaincy to cloud his role as a batter—something Cheteshwar Pujara also praised."He understands that this is a big responsibility on him as a batter. It's not just captaincy. When you are batting, you need to put captainship aside. He's just going out there and batting with a lot of responsibility because he knows that he has to score. He's batting at No. 4."advertisement"So someone from top 6 has to score a hundred in these conditions where things are slightly in favour of the batters. He played a captain's knock, but when he's going out there, he's not carrying any baggage of captainship.""He's just going out there playing his natural game, playing his innings, which is expected from a top order batter, and he's doing it again and again, which shows great signs going ahead," said signs are indeed promising for Gill, who is proving himself to be the right fit at No. 4. While the Bumrah debate is sure to resurface once India take the field with the ball, the skipper has done his part for now—ensuring that his side has the upper hand at the end of Day 1. And that, for the moment, is what matters most.- Ends
Hindustan Times
39 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Shubman Gill reminds David Lloyd of ex-IND skipper and it's not Rohit, Kohli or Dhoni: ‘Relaxed mannerisms looked like…'
Jul 03, 2025 11:12 AM IST Shubman Gill received praises from all corners after producing another stellar knock against England and registering back-to-back centuries in the Test series. The Indian skipper led from the front again and slammed a brilliant century at Edgbaston to pull India out of trouble. The 25-year-old has flourished as a batter since taking over charge as Test skipper; he has shown great composure with the bat in both matches. With back-to-back centuries, the transition from Virat Kohli to him also looks steady at the moment. Shubman Gill scored a majestic century at Edgbaston, Birmingham.(HT_PRINT) On Day 1 of the Edgbaston Test, Gill batted with remarkable poise, barely making a mistake as he blunted England's attack with assured strokeplay and patient temperament. Bringing up his seventh Test century off 199 balls — the slowest of his career — Gill showcased maturity and control in testing conditions. His unbeaten 114 formed the backbone of India's innings on Day 1, with Ravindra Jadeja (41*) offering solid support at the other end as the visitors reached stumps at 310/5. Former England cricketer David Lloyd was highly impressed with Gill's batting and compared his playing style to legendary India batter Mohammad Azharuddin. "Shubman Gill has slotted in seamlessly at number four, with a century at Headingley and another hundred here. Batting looks effortless to him and he is wonderful to watch. He reminds me of Mohammad Azharuddin, who with his languid stroke play and relaxed mannerisms looked like nothing fazed him," Lloyd wrote in his column for Daily Mail. Also Read | Tendulkar shares classy message for Jaiswal, Gill; Yuvraj grabs Smith's attention after India captain achieves rare feat However, Lloyd is still not very convinced about Shubman Gill, the captain. He stated he was confused in the first Test and now has the opportunity to avoid repeating the same mistakes in Edgbaston. "At just 25, Gill's next challenge is to get comfortable with the captaincy because he looked a little confused at Leeds," he added. Also Read | Jaiswal launches firm defence of Shubman Gill after Shastri, Gavaskar's attack over Bumrah call: 'He's very clear' Meanwhile, India made three changes for the second Test, with the headline decision being Jasprit Bumrah's exclusion as part of a pre-determined workload management plan that limited him to three matches in the five-Test series. Shardul Thakur and Sai Sudharsan also missed out on the playing XI. However, Bumrah's omission—especially with India trailing 0-1—sparked widespread criticism. Former cricketers like Ravi Shastri and Sunil Gavaskar questioned the logic behind resting the team's premier pacer, particularly with a five-day gap between the two Tests. The move left many surprised, given the importance of bouncing back in the series.
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
an hour ago
- Business Standard
Ravi Shastri among 11 honoured with SJAM Lifetime Achievement Award
Former India cricketer and head coach Ravi Shastri was among 11 sportspersons who were honoured with the Lifetime Achievement Award by the Sports Journalists Association of Mumbai here on Wednesday. The others included former India women's cricketer Shubhangi Kulkarni, three-time Amateur World Champion in English billiards Michael Ferreira, Niraj Bajaj (table tennis), GM Pravin Thipsay (chess), shooters Anjali Bhagwat, Suma Shirur and Deepali Deshpande. Hockey Olympians Mervyn Fernandes and Joaquim Carvalho as well as former national badminton champion and national team captain Sanjay Sharma were also honoured with the award. While Shastri was not present at the event ceremony here at the Bombay Gymkhana, his mother Lakshmi shared the memories of his playing days including the feat of hitting six sixes in an over in a domestic match. Shastri had emulated the feat of West Indies legend Gary Sobers in hitting six sixes in an over off Tilak Raj, during a Ranji Trophy match against Baroda in the 1984-85 season. "There are many treasured memories which Ravi has given us. But I would say that the one which stands out is when he scored six sixes in an over. I was blissfully unaware of the fact that he was doing it at Wankhede Stadium," she told the audience. "I was told by my bhelpuri wala who was present there and witnessed this." "When Ravi came home, he had to immediately leave for somewhere else. I asked him what happened today. You know his style, he never wanted to say the truth to me. So he said, you want to know what I did? Then tune in to today's All India Radio for the 7:0'clock news'." She continued, "Since the bhelpuri wala was talking about it, this was running in my mind. (I was thinking) why has he (Ravi) asked me to do this? So I went, informed my husband, who was sitting in his clinic, that you better come and hear the 7:O'clock, 7.30 I think, the Maharashtrian news." Shastri's mother said her son had "Sobered Sobers". "He (her husband) said, 'why?' I said, this is what everybody is saying. So I came home, and there to my great surprise, it was being announced that he had 'Sobered Sobers' and I am quoting the banner that was put on the Marine Drive the next day." Lakshmi said 1985 was a "glorious year" for her son. "These are precious memories that I carry with me. 1985, for instance, was a glorious year for him," she said. "He started with these six sixes, then he ended up at the Benson Hedges World Championship of Cricket, where he was awarded this title, 'champion of champions', and the famous Audi car, which nobody, at least me, I didn't even know how to pronounce the name of that car." "And I'm sure many in India have not seen that, and that memory of the entire team taking a round in the Melbourne Ground," she added.
