&w=3840&q=100)
Krishna Janmabhoomi: HC junks plea to rename mosque as 'disputed structure'
Responding to the High Court's decision, Advocate Saurabh Tiwari told ANI, "The High Court has rejected the application of considering it as the disputed structure... The court has said that it is a normal application and not a shock to the Hindu community..."
The order was passed by Justice Ram Manohar Narayan Mishra, who stated that the application was being dismissed 'at this stage'. A total of 18 cases are currently pending in the High Court. These petitions largely seek the removal of what are described as illegal encroachments on the premises of the Shri Krishna Janmabhoomi temple, which includes the Shahi Idgah Mosque.
Krishna Janmabhoomi case: Background
The legal conflict revolves around claims that the Shahi Idgah Mosque was built on the site believed to be the birthplace of Lord Krishna. Hindu petitioners allege that the mosque, situated next to the Krishna Janmabhoomi temple, was constructed during Mughal emperor Aurangzeb's rule after demolishing a pre-existing Hindu temple.
In 1968, a compromise was signed between the Shri Krishna Janmasthan Seva Sansthan — the temple's management body — and the Trust Shahi Masjid Eidgah. This agreement allowed both religious places to function side by side on the same premises.
However, several fresh petitions have questioned the legality of this agreement. The pleas argue that the 1968 compromise was made fraudulently and is not valid under the law. Claiming the right to worship at the site, many petitioners have demanded the removal of the Shahi Idgah Mosque.
Brief timeline of legal proceedings
In May 2023, the Allahabad High Court transferred all pending cases related to the Krishna Janmabhoomi–Shahi Idgah dispute from the Mathura court to itself. However, this order was challenged in the Supreme Court by the mosque committee, and later also by the Uttar Pradesh Sunni Central Waqf Board, LiveLaw reported.
Later in December 2023, the High Court allowed a plea for the appointment of a court commissioner to inspect the Shahi Idgah Mosque premises. In January 2024, the Supreme Court stayed the implementation of that inspection order. The stay has since been extended.
Plea to include Radha Rani as a party rejected
In May 2024, the Allahabad High Court rejected a plea seeking to include goddess Radha as a party to one of the 18 suits related to the title dispute. The application argued that Shriji Radha Rani should be made a joint holder of the disputed 13.37-acre land along with the plaintiff deity, Sri Bhagwan Krishna Lala Virajman.
The plea, filed by Advocate Reena N Singh, claimed that Radha Rani is 'the legal wife and the feminine form of the plaintiff in suit — Sri Bhagwan Krishna Lala Virajman — and that together, they both are worshipped as deities since time immemorial.'
However, the court turned down the request. Justice Ram Manohar Narayan Mishra remarked, 'Puranic illustrations are considered hearsay evidence.' The court further said, 'The claim of the applicant as a joint holder of property in dispute together with plaintiff is based on some reference in various Puranas and Sanhitas wherein Shriji Radha Rani is considered as the soul of Lord Krishna.'
During the hearing on May 23, the court noted that the Pauranic depictions 'are usually based on narrative and not on direct observation or testimony'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
40 minutes ago
- Hans India
Suggest ways to overcome booth-wise vote margin deficit: Bengal BJP chief to affiliated organisations
Kolkata: Bengal BJP chief Samik Bhattacharya has directed its affiliated organisations to suggest strategies to overcome or minimise the booth-wise vote margin deficit with Trinamool Congress in the crucial Assembly elections scheduled next year. According to the BJP state committee, Bhattacharya is of the view that the role of the affiliated organisations will be equally crucial to that of the state party unit in overcoming or minimising the booth-wise vote margin deficit with Trinamool Congress. "Precisely that is why he had meetings with the representatives of the affiliated organisations on Friday evening. The party's central observers, Sunil Bansal and Mangal Pandey, were also present at the meeting. In that meeting, Bhattacharya directed the representatives of the different mass organisations to immediately start the process for calculating the booth-wise vote margin deficits and suggest strategies to overcome them," said the state committee member on Saturday. As of the 2024 Lok Sabha elections, the votes secured by the BJP were 23,327,349 against Trinamool Congress' 27,564,561, which meant the vote margin deficit was 42,37,212. Percentage-wise, the BJP secured 40.7 per cent as against Trinamool Congress's figure of 43.3 per cent. On the other hand, in 2024, the Congress-Left Front alliance secured 62,35,669 popular votes. "As per a rough internal calculation, considering that Muslim votes went to Trinamool Congress' kitty in 2024, the majority of 62 lakh votes that went in favour of the Congress-Left Front alliance were Hindu votes or votes from non-Muslim other religions. Now, if we can turn around and consolidate a large portion of these Hindu votes in our favour in 2026, the vote margin deficit of around 42 lakhs could be minimised to a great extent," said the state committee member. At the same time, efforts will be made to consolidate Hindu votes from non-Muslim other religions, which went to Trinamool Congress till the 2024 polls, into the BJP's fold, he said. Bhattacharya also admitted that the vote consolidation process, as aimed by the BJP, will be comparatively easier in the metro and urban pockets than in the rural belts.
Mint
an hour ago
- Mint
Raj Thackeray's blunt advice to MNS workers after Marathi 'slapgate' case: 'Slap, but don't make video'
Raj Thackeray, who patched up with cousin Uddhav Thackeray nearly two decades, issued a blunt directive to his party workers just days after his party, the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS), landed in controversy for assaulting a restaurant owner for not speaking in Marathi. In a starkly blunt message to his party workers, Raj Thackeray said, 'Beat, but don't film it.' Speaking in Marathi, Raj Thackeray said, 'Be it a Gujarati or anyone else here, must know Marathi, but there is no need to beat people for that if they don't speak Marathi. Yet, if someone does some drama, you must hit them below their eardrums.' 'If you beat someone, don't make a video of the incident. Let the person beaten up tell that he has been beaten up; you don't need to tell everyone," Raj Thackeray added. The MNS chief was apparently addressing criticism after his men slapped and intimidated people, including street vendors, over their not speaking in Marathi. The much discussed Thackeray reunion unfolded against the backdrop of 'Marathi pride' sparked by the BJP-led Maharashtra government's move to introduce Hindi as a third language in schools – a decision that was later rolled back following intense backlash. Initially announced as a protest against the original move, Raj and Uddhav Thackeray's rally in Mumbai was converted to a celebration of the rollback. Raj Thackeray's assertion of 'Marathi pride' was followed by Uddhav Thackeray's speech, echoing the same sentiments. The Shiv Sena (UBT) chief also spoke in Marathi, stating: 'Yes, we are goons; if we have to be goons to get justice, we will do goondagiri.' At the much-hyped Mumbai rally, MNS Chief Raj Thackeray delivered a sharp, ironic jab — praising Maharashtra CM Devendra Fadnavis. Raj claimed Fadnavis managed to do what even Shiv Sena patriarch Bal Thackeray could not. "Uddhav and I are coming together after 20 years… What Balasaheb Thackeray could not do that Devendra Fadnavis managed to do," Raj Thackeray claimed at the massive event in Worli. Uddhav Thackeray's split with Raj Thackeray happened when Bal Thackeray was alive, as he preferred son Uddhav over nephew Raj to hand over the Shiv Sena reins. Uddhav also criticised the BJP - in power in Maharashtra and the Centre - for allegedly imposing the agenda of 'Hindi, Hindu, Hindustan' on India. 'We will protect the ideology of Hindutva, in Marathi language,' he further said. Following the Thackeray brothers' cousins at the reunion rally, senior Congress leader Prithviraj Chavan stated that the introduction of Hindi as a third language from class 1 evoked statewide opposition. "It's fine if Raj Thackeray and Uddhav Thackeray claim credit for the withdrawal of the GRs. If they come together politically, our best wishes," Chavan told PTI.
Indian Express
2 hours ago
- Indian Express
Amit Shah in Anand: ‘One cannot deny the contribution of Dr Verghese Kurien, but the cooperative university has been aptly named after Tribhuvandas Patel'
Stating that the upcoming Tribhuvan Sahkari University (TSU) in Anand district in Gujarat would end the 'bhai-bhatija vaad' (nepotism) in the cooperative sector, Union Home and Cooperation Minister Amit Shah on Saturday addressed the controversy around naming the university after Tribhuvandas Patel. Shah said that the value system of Gujarat 'did not permit' sidelining the contributions of Dr Verghese Kurien, but naming the University after Tribhuvandas Patel was 'apt' and a 'fitting tribute' to the legacy of the father of the cooperative sector. Speaking from the dais at the Anand Agricultural University after laying the foundation stone of TSU, Shah said he had been told that Congress leaders had arrived to protest against the naming of the university as 'Tribhuvan'. Shah said, 'I want to tell the Congress leaders from this stage that the university is not named Tribhuvan after any (Hindu) god, but it is named after Tribhuvandas Kashidas Patel. I have no hesitation in saying that since the university has transparency, accountability, expertise, and discipline along with the values of cooperatives in its foundation, no one else, except Tribhuvandas, represents these better. The Congress leaders did not even know that Tribhuvandas Patel was not a leader of my party (BJP), but he belonged to the Congress party of that time. My party (BJP) was not even formed at that time… 'त्रिभुवन सहकारी यूनिवर्सिटी' सहकारिता के प्रति मोदी जी के समर्पण और दृढ संकल्प का प्रतीक है। गुजरात के आणंद में देश के पहले राष्ट्रीय सहकारी विश्वविद्यालय 'त्रिभुवन सहकारी यूनिवर्सिटी' के भूमि पूजन समारोह से लाइव… — Amit Shah (@AmitShah) July 5, 2025 'He is the same Tribhuvandas, who, under the guidance of Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel, sowed the seeds of a new thought (of cooperatives) on this very soil in order to take on the autocratic Polson Dairy. A small milk collection unit became the base of a massive movement. In 1946, Kheda District… was born, and today the seed sown by Tribhuvandas has turned into a massive banyan tree that encompasses 36 lakh women running a business of over Rs 80 crores, without investing more than Rs 100 into it… It was Tribhuvandasji who took on the task of creating a strong cooperative unit to challenge Polson Dairy's exploitative means. Today, the Amul brand is among the most valuable brands in the world's FMCG sector.' The Union home minister said that Tribhuvandas's vision has ensured that the cooperative sector is competing with private brands globally. Shah further said, 'He burned like a lamp to strengthen the cooperative sector, and when he resigned on his own as the director of Amul, the six lakh women who were attached to the cooperative contributed Re 1 to gift him the sum. He used the money to create the Tribhuvan Foundation. 'It was his vision that has ensured that our cooperative dairy is standing tall against the several private dairies of the world. The cooperative model has emerged as a winner among the world's MNCs. It was the vision of Tribhuvandasji that prompted (then prime minister) Lal Bahadur Shastri to turn it into NDDB (National Dairy Development Board)…' Addressing allegations of downplaying the legacy of Dr Kurien, Shah said, 'They say that there is a big contribution of Kurien sahab. The contribution of Kurien sahab is well known; no one can deny it. The value system of Gujarat does not permit us to forget the contributions of Kurien sahab. Those who are speaking about it are the ones who did nothing for his centenary celebrations. It is Amul that is celebrating the centenary year of Dr Verghese Kurien. It was Tribhuvandas Patel who had sent Kurien sahab to the Netherlands to study and backed him in the progress of the cooperative… 'Tribhuvandas Patel presented an example of what effect it can have on nation-building if a cooperative leader, who thinks about the progress of all, works towards the goal. He did it on this land, and this is where the university is being established. The decision to name the university after Tribhuvandasji is definitely an apt one… (Narendra) Modiji has truly paid a tribute to the legacy of Tribhuvan Kaka.' Shah added that the Ministry of Cooperation, which completes four years on Sunday, has undertaken 60 new initiatives since its inception on July 6, 2021. Stating that the TSU would ensure the end of nepotism and help 'fill the vacuum' that had compressed the potential of cooperatives, Shah said, 'TSU is the much-needed initiative to overcome the shortcomings that exist in the movement of cooperation… The cooperative movement is growing at a fast pace, with over 30 crore members – which means every fourth person in the country is attached to it. But the backbone of the development of this movement is the employees and the members of the cooperative committees, who need to be trained and updated… I want to remind that initially people were employed in cooperatives and then trained, but now this university will ensure and is preparing for times when only those people will be employed in the cooperative sector, who have studied and trained in the field… 'Now, you will not like what I say next, but this (university) will ensure that the bhai-bhatija vaad in the cooperative sector will end. Only those who graduate from the cooperative university will get jobs in the cooperative sector, which will increase transparency. Different technically advanced courses will be introduced – this will include accounting and scientific methods as well as marketing strategies, but, most importantly, the graduates will learn the values of cooperation. This is a movement for the poor man of the country, for the Dalits and the tribals.' TSU will be built on a 125-acre plot at a cost of Rs 500 crore, Shah said. From the dais, Shah also urged the Gujarat government to adopt the lessons of the cooperative sector in the state board syllabus, like the CBSE has done.
