Hockey Canada sex assault defence lawyers respond to verdict: 'Public narrative was one-sided'
David Humphrey, lawyer for Michael McLeod
Mr. McLeod will not be speaking to the media, and I understand the other players will not be speaking to the media. I will not be taking questions and other counsel who come to address you, they will not be taking any questions.
Mr. McLeod had confidence in the Justice process, and he welcomes Justice Carrocia's decision, confirming that he and his co defendants are not guilty of sexual assault. Justice Carrocia's carefully reasoned decision represents a resounding vindication for Mr. McLeod and for his co defendants. Justice Carrocia's found that the complainant's testimony was incredible and was unreliable.
For years, public perception was shaped by a one-sided narrative from a civil lawsuit that went unchallenged. In large part because hockey Canada settled the claim without first informing or consulting the players. The decision was made unilaterally, and the players were only told of the lawsuit and the settlement after the fact. Had they been consulted, they would have refused to settle, and they would have vigorously contested EM's allegations.
That version of events dominated headlines and created a lasting and, a false, a false impression of guilt. It was only through this criminal trial that the allegations were fully and finally tested. The court compared the complainant's 2018 statements to the police, which rightly resulted in no charges with the later conflicting civil claim. Key elements of EM's story were contradicted by the evidence, exposing serious falsehood and leading to today's clear and just verdict of not guilty. Justice Carrocia rejected EM's claims of fear and her claims of non consent. That should be the takeaway from today's judgment.
The damage to Mr. McLeod's reputation and his career has been significant. But today's decision begins to restore what was very unfairly taken away from him. Mr. McLeod is deeply grateful to his family, friends, his agent, and everybody who stood by him.
Megan Savard, defence lawyer for Carter Hart
It is both gratifying and unsurprising to hear an impartial and fully informed decision maker, except Mr. Hart's testimony about what happened on June 19, 2018, as unshaken, credible and truth.
The public narrative of this event was, until this trial, one sided and untested. Now, the criminal process has shown it to be false. To anyone who is surprised or angered by today's outcome, it is the direct result of the media's ongoing failure to publicize the weaknesses in the prosecution's case as it unfolded.
The office of the Crown attorney knew what today's verdict was likely to be. And the evidence at trial came as no surprise to them or anyone with full knowledge of the investigation. Almost every single feature of the evidence that Justice Carrocia identified today as fatal flaws for the Crown was known to prosecutors and to police from 2018. Today's outcome was not just predictable, it was predicted. The Crown attorney did not have to take this case to trial.
Mr. Hart, in particular, was willing to engage in a restorative justice process. He was willing to be publicly named and prepared to use his public platform to teach other athletes about how to ensure that their sexual encounters are responsible and thoughtful. Instead of pursuing restorative justice, the Crown forced a distressing and unnecessary trial to the detriment of Mr. Hart, his co defendants, the complainant, and the Canadian public.
Mr. Hart regrets that it took a criminal trial for the truth to come out, but he has learned from the experience, and he is committing to sharing what he has learned with others in his personal circle and in his professional life. He will be taking time today to process today's outcome, and is grateful to his family, his friends, and his supporters for standing by him during this profoundly challenging time. Thank you.
Julianna Greenspan, lawyer for Cal Foote
I promise I'm the last one. We are the last ones. Juliana Greenspan and this is Lauren Crawford, and we were counsel for Mr. Foote. Just have some brief comments that I want to say at this time. At the start of this trial, Cal Foote walked into this courthouse, an innocent man, and he walks out today exactly that.
Cal never lost faith that justice would be done, despite the clamor of external pressures, and agendas, outside the courthouse doors. Criminal investigations and the trial process must always be free from these influences. On behalf of Cal and his family, we appreciate the court's careful and thorough consideration and for the just verdict delivered today.
Seven years ago, Cal was 19. He is now 26. That is a significant part of a young man's life. He is still young. He has a wonderful future ahead of him, and he is eager to embark on his next chapter. Thank you. He's not answering any questions, but thank you.
Daniel Brown, lawyer for Alex Formenton
After what was meant to be a night of celebration with coaches and teammates. For the last seven years, he's lived under a dark cloud. The public now knows what Alex has always maintained, that he is completely innocent of this false allegation. But only after his case has erupted into a massively publicized social cause, Alex's face has appeared on millions of screens and newspaper pages, and there could be little doubt that an untold number of people out there believed he was guilty, simply because he was accused of a crime, long before any evidence was presented in court.
This rush to judgment to believe the worst of people is one of the most regrettable of human traits. So, too, is our reluctance to change that opinion, even when it's proven wrong, after a full and fair trial. Notwithstanding Justice Carrocia's unequivocal exoneration of Alex today, there will inevitably be those who will still believe he committed a crime.
Nobody in Room 209 that night has emerged unscarred from these events. The criminal court process is a bruising experience for everyone, but never more than when a case is high profile incorporates such high stakes. In Alex's case, he was condemned and felt banished from society. This experience for him has been crushing. Nonetheless, the impact of this case has changed Alex as a person, and he's matured well beyond his years.
It is inevitable that some people will not forgive Alex for what he was accused of doing. Others, however, will understand that this tragic matter, rightly comes to an end today. Alex has never minimized his role in the sexual encounter or denied engaging in consensual sexual activity with the complainants. He fully cooperated with the police investigation and provided investigators with a complete account of his behaviour back in 2018.
Alex's narrative isn't conjecture. His police statement was corroborated at trial by several crown witnesses, by video evidence, and was even supported in large measure by the complainant's evidence herself. Even Justice Carrocia said today that she accepted that Alex told the truth in that police statement. And while no police investigation is perfect, the London police got it right seven years ago when they decided it would be a mistake to charge Alex. The evidence always demonstrated that he didn't commit sexual assaults. However, political and media pressure brought this allegation back into the spotlight in 2022, and the Crown attorney knowingly forged ahead with a hopeless prosecution.
Besides the human toll of everyone involved, this lengthy legal process exhausted valuable resources that could have been deployed elsewhere in the justice system, but were lost here. Alex, his family, and his defense team are grateful to Justice Carrocia for our careful consideration of all the evidence that was presented to this trial. She's reached a just and correct verdict that must be respected.
Nobody disputes that sexual assault is a terrible societal plague, and Alex sincerely hopes that this prosecution doesn't stop the quest to combat sexual violence and to bring genuine offenders to justice. However, an accusation is just that, an accusation. This case stands to the fact that we must never lose sight of the fundamental right to be presumed innocent. Now, more than ever before, a fair response to sexual assault claims requires a balanced perspective and public trust and the decision making of the courts. Anything less, only harms the justice system and the cause of eliminating sexual violence. Thank you.
Julie Santarossa, lawyer for Dillon Dubé
For Mr. Dubé, this has been a long and difficult process. He is relieved by the outcome, and he is grateful that Justice Carrocia decided what she did and did so fairly and efficiently. Throughout this trial, Mr. Dube was impressed by the fairness and impartiality demonstrated by her honor. This decision comes as a result of careful deliberation by her honor.
She engaged with the evidence in a thoughtful, methodical, and principled manner. Her reasons reflect not only a command of the legal principles at stake, but also a deep sense of responsibility in assessing the evidence, applying the law, and demonstrating a strong commitment to justice.
Mr. Dubé has always maintained his innocence. He is thankful for all of the unwavering support from his friends and family who have also believed in him. For all of you that have been by his side throughout this period of time, you know who you are, we thank you. Mr. Dubé is hopeful that everyone can move forward from this in a positive manner. He is requesting privacy during this period of time. In view of the court's decision, Mr. Dubé will not be making any further statements at this time. Thank you.
Read the full statement from the complainant's lawyer
Gasps in court as all five players acquitted in Hockey Canada sexual assault trial
Hockey Canada sex assault complainant 'very disappointed' with judge's assessment of her honesty, lawyer says
Our website is the place for the latest breaking news, exclusive scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark nationalpost.com and sign up for our daily newsletter, Posted, here.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Los Angeles Times
42 minutes ago
- Los Angeles Times
ICE raid at major pot operation clouds picture for legal cannabis in California
Camarillo — Ever since federal immigration agents raided one of the largest licensed cannabis operators in the state this month, the phones of cannabis industry insiders have been blazing with messages of fear, sadness and confusion. 'It sent shock waves through the community,' said Hirsh Jain, the founder of Ananda Strategy, which advises cannabis businesses. 'Everyone is on text threads.' Glass House Brands, whose cannabis operations have helped make Santa Barbara and Ventura counties the new cannabis capitals of California, has long been among the most prominent companies in the state's wild frontier of legal cannabis. Some call it the 'Walmart of Weed' for its streamlined, low-cost production methods, its gargantuan market share and its phalanx of wealthy investors and powerful lobbyists. But federal immigration agents stormed onto company property in Camarillo and Carpinteria on July 10 in a cloud of tear gas, as if they were busting a criminal enterprise. Agents in masks and riot gear marched for hours through the company's vast greenhouses as workers fled and hid in panic. One worker, Jaime Alanís Garcia, died after he fell three stories while trying to evade capture. For Glass House, the aftermath has been devastating. Its stock, which is traded on the Canadian stock exchange, dropped from more than $7.75 a share the day before the raid to $5.27 on Thursday. Some workers disappeared into Immigration and Customs Enforcement detention or bolted, too fearful to return. Others were so traumatized that Glass House brought in grief counselors, according to a source close to the company. Across the wider world of legal California cannabis — where many growers and entrepreneurs have hoped the Trump administration would legalize the drug — people were also shaken. Did the action against Glass House signal an end to federal law enforcement's ceasefire against legal cannabis in California and dozens of other states? And what did it mean for Glass House itself, among the largest cannabis companies in the world? How could this slick corporate entity, founded by an ex-cop and special education teacher and a former tech entrepreneur, be in a position in which federal agents claimed to have apprehended more than a dozen undocumented minors on site? 'This could not come at a worse time,' said Jain, the cannabis consultant, adding that the images and rhetoric that have whipped across social media in the wake of the raid 'impedes our ability to legitimize this industry in the eyes of California and the American public.' He added that 'a failure to legitimize a legal cannabis industry enables the proliferation of an illicit industry that is not accountable and engages in far more nefarious practices.' Working conditions in the cannabis industry are notoriously grim, as documented in a 2022 Times investigation that revealed workers who had their wages stolen, were forced to live in squalid and dangerous conditions and sometimes even died on the job. Glass House had no such reports of injuries or deaths before the raid and has long touted its working conditions. A source close to the company said it pays workers more than minimum wage, and internet job postings reflect that. Still, as with almost all farmwork in California, some of those who labored there were undocumented. The company employs some people directly and relies on farm labor contractors to supply the rest of its workforce. A source close to the company said labor contractors certify that the workers satisfy all laws and regulations, including being 21 or older as required to work in cannabis in California. In the days after the raid, federal officials announced they had detained 361 people, including 14 minors, who by California law cannot work in cannabis. It wasn't clear how many of those detained were undocumented or how many were even working at the operation or were just nearby. At least two American citizens were caught up in the dragnet — a security guard headed to work at Glass House and a philosophy professor at Cal State Channel Islands who was protesting the raid. Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem said this month that Glass House had been targeted because 'we knew, specifically from casework we had built for weeks and weeks and weeks, that there was children there that could be trafficked, being exploited, that there was individuals there involved in criminal activity.' Glass House officials declined to comment for this article, but in an earlier statement on X, the company said that it had never employed minors and that it followed all applicable employment laws. A source close to the company said the search warrant federal officials presented to Glass House the day of the raid alleged it was suspected of harboring and unlawfully employing undocumented immigrants — but did not mention child labor. In the last few years, the company — along with labor contractors — was named in lawsuits by workers alleging they had been sexually harassed, suffered discrimination, and been shorted overtime pay and required meal and rest breaks. One worker at Glass House — who asked not to be identified because he is undocumented and hid from immigration agents during the raid before escaping — said he was employed to work in Glass House's cannabis operation through one of its labor contractors and valued the job because it is year round, not seasonal like many agricultural jobs. But he complained that the contractor had repeatedly paid him late, forcing him to borrow money to make his rent. He also said supervisors put intense pressure on employees to work faster, screaming expletives at workers, refusing to allow breaks, or yelling at them to eat quickly and return to work before their rest periods were done. A source close to the company said the complaints involved people employed by labor contractors, regarding actions by those contractors and not Glass House directly. Many of the suits are pending, with Glass House named as a co-defendant. Company officials declined to comment publicly. A source close to the company said Glass House takes seriously its responsibilities under California labor law and is committed to ensuring that all labor practices within its operations meet the highest standards. The source added that the raid has shaken a company that has always tried to operate by the book and that, despite its exponential growth in recent years, has sought to maintain a close-knit feel. 'It's very sad,' the source said. In the wake of the raids at Glass House, the United Farm Workers union issued a bulletin in English and Spanish warning anyone who is not a U.S. citizen to 'avoid working in the cannabis industry, even at state-licensed operations.' The union noted that 'because cannabis remains criminalized under federal law, any contact with federal agencies could have serious consequences even for people with legal status.' TODEC Legal Center, a Coachella Valley-based group that supports immigrants and farmworkers, issued a similar message. TODEC warned noncitizens to avoid working in the marijuana industry and avoid discussing any marijuana use or possession — even if it is legal in California — with federal agents, because it could hurt their status. About half the farmworkers in California are undocumented, according to UC Merced researchers. Cannabis industry experts said it is too soon to know whether the raid on Glass House will affect the larger cannabis workforce — or whether more licensed cannabis operations will be raided. 'My best guest would be that this is going to be happening to a lot more cultivation farms,' said Meilad Rafiei, chief executive of the cannabis consulting group We Cann. Among the undocumented workers at Glass House on the day of the raids was Alanís, 56, who had been a farmworker in California for three decades. Over the last 10 years, Alanís worked in the Ventura area, first in a flower nursery and then, once Glass House converted the massive greenhouse complex there, in cannabis. On Monday night, his family held an emotional wake for him in Oxnard, where he lived. The Camino del Sol Funeral Home was filled, as many family members held one another tightly and cried. They remembered him as a hardworking, joyful man, who danced at parties and enjoyed every meal he shared with family. State Sen. Monique Limón (D-Goleta), who led the Senate in adjourning in Alanís' memory last week, told the chamber how he had climbed onto the roof of a greenhouse to escape federal officers. From 30 feet up, she said, he called his family to tell them what was happening, and to report 'how scared he was.' 'Jaime's life was dedicated to our lands, our crops, and to providing for his family,' Limón said, adding that he 'had had no criminal record, he was who our country and our state depended on to provide food on all of our tables.' She added that 'his last moments on Earth were filled with terror.'
Washington Post
43 minutes ago
- Washington Post
Katie Ledecky and Summer McIntosh, a year after Paris, set to duel at worlds
One is the most decorated, most celebrated, most everything female swimmer ever to dive into an Olympic-size pool. Her name is known worldwide, and somehow, at 28, Katie Ledecky is showing no signs of slowing down. The other is a full decade younger and somehow making the kind of splash the sport hasn't seen since, well, Ledecky. Canada's Summer McIntosh already has scrawled her name across the record books, and most around the pool deck agree her fastest races are still ahead of her.
New York Times
43 minutes ago
- New York Times
A Grim Anniversary in Canada's Fight Against Guns
Veteran police in Canada still remember the days when officers, stunned that a colleague had taken a gun off the street, would gather to have a look at the firearm. 'It would fly through the station,' said Paul Krawczyk, an inspector with the integrated guns and gangs task force of the Toronto Police Service, Canada's largest metropolitan police force. Seizing firearms is now a routine, and growing, part of the job for Canadian police, especially in Toronto. This week marked the grim anniversary of a mass shooting in 2018 in a bustling east Toronto neighborhood called Danforth. Two people — a teenager, Reese Fallon, 18, and a child, Julianna Kozis, 10 — were killed and 13 others were injured. The gunman killed himself after the attack, which police said was carried out with a Smith & Wesson handgun that had been legally imported into Canada from the United States, then stolen from its owner. Families of the victims filed a class-action lawsuit against Smith & Wesson in 2019, arguing that the gun manufacturer had been negligent in not installing 'smart-gun' technology, like fingerprint recognition, that could have prevented the unauthorized use of their firearms. The lawsuit was certified by a judge in June after an appeal. 'We're very relieved because we recognize the novel nature of the case,' said Ken Price, whose daughter, Samantha, was shot in the hip when she was 18. 'The gun manufacturers and the industry itself needs to be more concerned about how their guns are used,' Mr. Price told me. Canada in recent years has tightened its gun laws. It banned most assault rifles in 2020, after the country's deadliest mass shooting rampage in Nova Scotia. In 2022, the government introduced sweeping legislation to crack down on gun trafficking and put a freeze on the sale, purchase and transfer of handguns, of which about 1.1 million are registered in the country. Further restrictions on certain firearm models have come into effect over the last eight months as the government rolled out its gun buyback program for assault-style rifles. The program is currently open to business owners of gun stores, and will be available to individual firearm owners later this year. [Canadian reader call-out: Are you a gun owner? Do you operate a firearms business? Are you participating in the buyback? I'd like to hear from you. You can reach me at While the government moves to expand firearm restrictions domestically, some officials are calling attention to gun smuggling across the border. Aggregated data in a 2022 Canadian government report shows that about 32 percent of guns seized in crimes were smuggled from the United States, but the figures are much higher in urban parts of Ontario and Quebec. For example, in Peel Region, an area covering the populous suburbs west of Toronto, 90 percent of the 205 guns seized in 2024 came from across the United States border. Police forces have seen a steady rise in the number of illicit firearms traced to states with less stringent gun laws along the so-called Iron Pipeline along the Southern United States. In 2024, more than half of the illegal firearms seized in Quebec came from Ohio, Florida, Texas and Georgia, according to the provincial police. In his ongoing trade dispute with Canada, President Trump has renewed his focus on border security, but blamed Canada for trafficking 'massive' amounts of fentanyl south, a statement that has been disproved by American border data. 'My first thought was, what about all the guns coming north?' said Nando Iannicca, chair of the police service board in Peel Region, a civilian group governing police operations. Mr. Trump's bellicose tone on the border issue and tariffs, and his repeated threats of annexing Canada, has ruptured the relationship between the two countries. 'Canadian officials are perhaps understandably reluctant to provide these counterarguments in fear that they're somehow going to rattle or anger President Trump,' said Scot Wortley, a criminology professor at the University of Toronto who is studying the use of guns among inner-city youth. Toronto Police began tracking the origins of firearms in 2005, which came to be called the 'summer of the gun' after a spate of shooting homicides. 'If we're going to stop this crime, we have to stop these guns coming into the city,' said Inspector Krawczyk of the Toronto Police. 'We owe it to the citizens of Toronto,' he said. Trans Canada Canada's premiers gathered in Huntsville, Ontario, this week to discuss plans to fortify the country's economy in the ongoing trade war against the United States. 'Their patriotic unity swiftly dissipated into the regional rifts that have long divided the country,' writes Ian Austen. Prime Minister Mark Carney said Canada would not accept a trade deal with the U.S. at 'any cost.' From The Athletic: The five players from Canada's 2018 world junior hockey team who were accused of sexually assaulting a woman were found not guilty. Serge Schmemann, an Opinion writer at The Times, reflects on deteriorating Canada-U.S. relations while on vacation in Labelle, Quebec. Here's the latest on wildfires in Western Canada. A new study has found that climate change is making fire weather worse. A small Canadian company called Central European Petroleum claims to have discovered large oil reserves in Poland. The car company Stellantis, which paused production at Canadian plants for several weeks because of Mr. Trump's tariff measures, said it had lost $2.7 billion in the first half of this year. Rescuers freed three workers trapped in a mine in British Columbia. A cat owner in British Columbia has been flooded by calls from people reporting that they've seen her cat — who has never been lost — because of a T-shirt. Vjosa Isai is a reporter at The Times based in Toronto. How are we doing?We're eager to have your thoughts about this newsletter and events in Canada in general. Please send them to nytcanada@ Like this email?Forward it to your friends, and let them know they can sign up here.
