Therese Coffey: Civil servants told me to break the law
Lady Coffey, who held several other cabinet positions, including work and pensions secretary, health secretary and environment secretary, became a Conservative peer earlier this year.
She told the House of Lords on Friday: 'There were several occasions when I was advised by civil servants to knowingly break the law.
'Now, they may have only been minor infringements, but I challenge about how is that possible, under the Civil Service code, that in your advice and in your inaction, you are advising me to knowingly break the law? And I wasn't prepared to do it.'
Lady Coffey recalled another situation when she felt the code was not adhered to.
She said: 'I learned that my shadow secretary of state had written to me on Twitter, and I knew it because he also published my response to him on Twitter.
'I'd never seen the letter from the shadow secretary of state. I had never seen the letter written in my name, but there it was: my response and my signature.
'And these sorts of things, unfortunately, in the Civil Service code should be more serious than it was.'
The Tory peer added: 'Sometimes people try and suggest it's just politicians trying to do this, that and the other.
'I'm not accusing the civil service, but their job is to try and manage and, ultimately, I could go on about another legal case where I was named as the defendant.
'I didn't know until a ruling had come against me, formally. These things, I'm afraid, do happen.'
Her comments came as peers debated a report from the constitution select committee.
So-called deep state sabotage
Lady Coffey was the deputy prime minister in the Liz Truss administration in September and October of 2022.
After her brief premiership, Ms Truss took swipes at the civil service and blamed the so-called deep state for 'sabotaging' her.
Speaking at a conference in the US in 2024, the former prime minister said: 'I wanted to cut taxes, reduce the administrative state, take back control as people talked about in the Brexit referendum.
'What I did face was a huge establishment backlash and a lot of it actually came from the state itself.
'Now, people are joining the civil service who are essentially activists.
'They might be trans activists, they might be environmental extremists, but they are now having a voice within the civil service in a way I don't think was true 30 or 40 years ago.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South Wales Argus
10 minutes ago
- South Wales Argus
Reeves says welfare fallout ‘damaging' and declines to rule out tax hikes
The Chancellor warned there would be 'costs to what happened', as she faced questions about how she would cover a shortfall left by the Downing Street climbdown on planned cuts to disability benefits. The Government saw off the threat of a major Commons defeat over the legislation on Tuesday, after shelving plans to restrict eligibility for the personal independence payment (Pip) in the face of a backbench revolt. Rachel Reeves said she had never considered resigning as Chancellor (Jack Hill/The Times/PA) The original welfare proposals had been part of a package that ministers expected would save up to £5 billion a year, with economists warning that tax rises are now likely to plug a gap left by the concessions to rebels. The fallout threatens to cause lasting damage to morale in Labour ranks, with some MPs calling for a reset in relations between the parliamentary party and the leadership before fractures widen. Images of the Chancellor crying in the Commons on Wednesday also spooked the financial markets and led to questions about her future, though a Treasury spokesman said the tears were the result of a personal matter and Downing Street said she would remain in post. In an interview with the Guardian newspaper, Ms Reeves said she had never considered resigning, adding: 'I didn't work that hard to then quit.' She said she had gone to Prime Minister's Questions because she 'thought that was the right thing to do' but that 'in retrospect, I probably wished I hadn't gone in… (on) a tough day in the office'. Ms Reeves added: 'It's been damaging. 'I'm not going to deny that, but I think where we are now, with a review led by (disability minister) Stephen Timms, who is obviously incredibly respected and has a huge amount of experience, that's the route we're taking now.' Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer has said the Government is still committed to welfare reform, but ministers will now wait for the conclusions of the Timms review before implementing changes to Pip.
Scottish Sun
13 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Top Scots civil servant now paid £180,000 moaned about long work days & joked about video game distraction
Newly unearthed texts sent during the pandemic also show the Scottish Government's new Permanent Secretary calling Boris Johnson 'irresponsible' MOAN-DARIN Top Scots civil servant now paid £180,000 moaned about long work days & joked about video game distraction Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A TOP civil servant now on a £180,000 salary was last night blasted for moaning about his long working days. Joe Griffin also joked to a colleague about being distracted from playing the video game Tetris. Sign up for the Politics newsletter Sign up 2 Joe Griffin with First Minister John Swinney 2 Griffin joked to a colleague about being distracted playing the classic video game Tetris Credit: Alamy Newly unearthed texts sent during the pandemic also show the Scottish Government's new Permanent Secretary calling Boris Johnson 'irresponsible'. The WhatApp messages were sent while Mr Griffin was £100,000-a-year Director of Safer Communities. They emerged a week after Scotland's highest-ranked mandarin provoked anger by ruling home-working staff should not automatically be disciplined if they refuse to return to offices at least two days a week. Scottish Tory MSP Murdo Fraser hit out: 'Scots who lost loved ones or saw their business go to the wall during the pandemic will have little sympathy for this senior official moaning about long days. 'Mr Griffin also has a duty to steer clear of criticising politicians or his neutrality will be called into question.' Chats from December 2020 obtained under freedom of information show his reply to an official who asked if a winter planning meeting was 'really needed'. He said cancellation 'probably wouldn't go down well', then added: 'We should be prepared to do that in future — not just sleepwalk into even longer days becoming standard. 'Today started with pre-cabinet call for Humza (Yousaf) at 8.30am, in part to brief on a paper 87 pages long issued at 10.30pm.' In a discussion about a meeting with John Swinney on November 17, 2020, another staffer was told by Mr Griffin they'd 'rudely interrupted my Tetris'. By January 2021, then Prime Minister Mr Johnson was 'optimistic' Covid restrictions would be loosened. Anas Sarwar promises to tackle Scotland's 'unfair' tax system Mr Griffin hit out that this 'shows you how irresponsible the PM's promises are'. Mr Griffin was appointed as Permanent Secretary formally on April 7. In 2021, he was appointed as Director General for Education and Justice before becoming the head of the External Affairs Division. A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'Throughout the pandemic, the focus and intention of ministers, clinicians and officials was to protect people of Scotland from the harms of Covid-19, including providing advice and information about how to stay safe.'
Telegraph
14 minutes ago
- Telegraph
I shouldn't have gone to PMQs, says Reeves
Rachel Reeves has admitted she regrets attending prime minister's questions after she was seen in tears on the Government front bench. The Chancellor said she had been dealing with a 'personal issue' when her bottom lip shook and tears ran down her face during a moment of distress in Parliament on Wednesday. Ms Reeves was speaking after she made a surprise appearance alongside Sir Keir Starmer to unveil the Government's 10-year plan for the NHS. In an interview with The Guardian, Ms Reeves said she regretted going into PMQs after a 'tough day at the office', but hoped people 'could relate' to her distress. She said: 'In retrospect, I probably wished I hadn't gone in... But you know, it is what it is.' The Leeds West and Pudsey MP said she never thought about resigning despite backbench anger over the way she had handled the economy, adding: 'I didn't work that hard to then quit.' A backbench rebellion saw the government forced to drop key welfare cuts, which has left the Chancellor with a £5 billion black hole to fill. She has insisted she is 'totally' up for the job of Chancellor and asserted that she and the Prime Minister remain united. Ms Reeves said: 'People can see that Keir and me are a team.' Sir Keir stood by his Chancellor in the aftermath, telling BBC Radio 4 Today's Nick Robinson: 'She is going to be Chancellor into the next election and for many years afterwards.' He was quick to deny any political link to her tears, insisting it was a personal matter, saying: 'I'm not going to go into the personal matter of a colleague.' Labour insiders have claimed that the Chancellor has made herself 'unsackable' after the public tears. A government source said that Sir Keir 'seems to have tied himself to her' after her tears, which triggered a £3 billion market sell-off and crash in the pound's value. 'I thought at the beginning of Wednesday she would go, then thought it was confirmed when I saw her crying at PMQs but then she didn't,' said the source. Another source said Ms Reeves had enjoyed an 'outpouring of sympathy' over an incident that was still 'inescapably linked to the political facts' of the welfare rebellion. A third added that being pictured distraught on television had 'shored up her position'. In a turbulent week for the government, Ms Reeves refused to rule out tax rises in the autumn budget, saying: 'I'm not going to, because it would be irresponsible to do that. 'We took the decisions last year to draw a line under unfunded commitments and economic mismanagement. 'So we'll never have to do something like that again. But there are costs to what happened.'
