Concerns raised over R1. 8 million payment for incomplete stadium project in Durban
The management of the eThekwini municipality came under scrutiny for an allocation of R1.8 million for the rehabilitation of the Rotary Stadium in KwaMashu despite non-performance issues by the service provider.
Councillors approved the urgent reprioritisation of a budget to cater for the stadium rehabilitation. According to the municipality, the R1.8 million is sourced from various projects including R585,000 from a library project.
In a report before eThekwini council on Monday, the Parks Recreation and Culture (PRC) Unit stated that the mandate is to build new and to rehabilitate existing facilities.
In 2024 and 2025, the PRC unit was allocated R185 million for capital projects to build new facilities and develop the existing facilities within the city. There were no figures provided on how much was already spent on the stadium. The municipality stated that the cancellation was due to circumstances beyond their control and that the project was halted due to non-performance issues by the service provider.
The municipality stated that the final account for closing this project has been concluded and the invoice has been received for the payment. The municipality stated that the project line item currently has a budget shortfall, and the unit has identified savings within the unit's capital budget to be reprioritised for the payment of the final account for the project.
Following an in-depth consideration of the item, the DA and Truly Alliance (TA) expressed reservations regarding the approval of this item and proposed that an oversight visit be conducted prior to the approval, as they were of the view that they needed to have all information regarding the work done and the work still outstanding.
This submission therefore seeks authority to pay for part of work already undertaken under this project, with attention drawn to the urgency of the matter in view of threats being levelled against the municipal officials as a result of non-payment.
Daniel Mea, DA Councillor, said the project had come before council again, this time not for progress, but for payment to a contractor who failed to complete the job. Mea said the DA will not endorse rewarding failure and because the facts placed before the council remain deeply concerning and unresolved.
'We were told that the contractor ran out of money and could not complete the contract. This raises critical red flags. Was there a proper project cash flow monitoring and did this not have a fixed scope or fixed budget contract? How did the contractor reach a point where the budget was exhausted but the work remained incomplete? And perhaps most alarmingly despite this failure the municipality now proposes to pay him more," Mea said.
Mea said this sets a dangerous precedent and 'one cannot and must not create a culture where underperformance is rewarded and failure is f ollowed by financial rescue'.
'To date, council has not been provided with a comprehensive audit of the actual work delivered, nor the timeline of expenditure. If the council continues to rubber stamp such proposals then it is complicit in the erosion of accountability. Oversight committees must not be passive observers,' Mea said.
Councillor Musa Khubeka, of ActionSA, expressed serious reservations, stating that one could not approve millions of rands when the report showed that other parties' views, concerns and suggestions of doing oversight were not addressed during a committee meeting.
'We demand transparency and accountability is very important, oversight must be done,' Khubeka said.
[email protected]
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
23 minutes ago
- IOL News
‘Diamond' gift to wife haunts deputy president Paul Mashatile
Deputy President Paul Mashatile. Image: Siyabulela Duda/ GCIS THE DA is gunning for Deputy President Paul Mashatile to provide answers over his failure to declare a diamond gift from businessman Louis Liebenberg to his wife, resulting in Parliament's Ethics Committee recommending that he be fined R10,000. The committee, through the Office of the Registrar, received a formal complaint against Mashatile on March 5, 2025, for an alleged breach of the Code of Ethical Conduct and Members' Interests. The code requires Members of Parliament to disclose gifts received by their immediate family in the confidential part of the register. Following consideration of the complaint and perusal of the confidential part of the Deputy President's disclosed interests, the committee noted that the gift in question - a diamond from Louis Liebenberg - was not disclosed. The committee said it acknowledged Mashatile's response, which included his claim that he was awaiting the diamond's appraisal to determine its value before making a declaration, and that he has since surrendered the gift to the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA), the committee maintained that ethical behaviour necessitates declaring the gift, with its value to be disclosed at a later stage. Liebenberg and his wife were arrested at a Gauteng restaurant on the night of October 22 last year after a five-year probe over allegations that Liebenberg operated a diamond syndicate that was involved in dealing with and luring unsuspecting investors to invest in unpolished diamonds through social media platforms. As such, he has been accused of fleecing his investors of more than R4 billion since 2019. In a parliamentary statement, the committee found that Mashatile breached two sections of the code. 'As a result, the committee will recommend to the National Assembly to impose a reprimand in the House and a fine of R10,000 for a first offence of a breach of the code. 'The committee remained steadfast in its quest to ensure accountability of all Members of Parliament as demanded by the code. The disclosure process not only facilitates public trust in Parliament but also enhances its credibility,' the statement read. Earlier this week it was reported that Mashatile declared in the register two luxury properties with a combined value of R65 million, despite earning just over R3 million annually. Mashatile listed the properties, one in Constantia, Cape Town, and another in Waterfall, Midrand, Gauteng, in the latest Parliamentary Register of Members' Interests. He had previously said the Constantia estate was owned by his son-in-law's company. DA chief whip George Michalakis said the ethics report raises more questions than answers, and the DA will submit Parliamentary questions in this regard. 'What other gifts has the Deputy President and/or his wife received from Mr Liebenberg? What did the Deputy President gift Mr Liebenberg in return for this goodwill? What is the value of the diamond? In this instance, the Deputy President did indicate that his office was in the process of establishing the value, and we look forward to receiving their findings in this regard. There are also questions around the legality of this diamond, its nature, source and certification.' Liebenberg and his co-accused recently appeared again in the Bronkhorstspruit Magistrate's Court where his case was once again delayed when his lawyer, Jaco du Plessis, indicated that while he is withdrawing at this stage, he may return if the financial arrangement can be sorted out. Cape Times
IOL News
an hour ago
- IOL News
Treasury sets the stage for infrastructure overhaul with R1. 8bn credit guarantee vehicle
Deputy Minister of Finance David Masondo said on Thursday that the government has committed to injecting an initial R1.8 billion into a newly established Credit Guarantee Vehicle, with plans to escalate the total investment to R9bn if needed. Image: Supplied The National Treasury has taken a step towards addressing South Africa's staggering infrastructure gap, which is projected to reach around R3.5 trillion to R4trln by 2025. Deputy Minister of Finance David Masondo said on Thursday that the government has committed to injecting an initial R1.8 billion into a newly established Credit Guarantee Vehicle, with plans to escalate the total investment to R9bn if needed. Speaking at the launch of the pre-qualification process for Independent Transmission Projects (ITP), Masondo highlighted the urgency of the situation. He noted that at least 32 development partners have expressed interest in investing in the new scheme, which aims to rally private capital to bridge the nation's infrastructure financing gap. "Formal engagements with participating partners are continuing and will lead to the delivery of conditional equity participation commitment letters in the third quarter of 2025," Masondo said. "This will enable the Credit Guarantee Vehicle to be operationalized by July 2026 to align with the first phase of ITP projects." He said the infrastructure gap called for scaling up of public financing as well as crowding in private capital through public-private partnerships (PPP). "The objective of the Credit Guarantee Vehicle is to mobilize and leverage private capital to address South Africa's infrastructure financing gap by mitigating offtake risk for private investors," Masondo said. "This vehicle will also support the efficient deployment of development partner funding under the Just Energy Transition Partnership (JETP) and the achievement of the country's decarbonisation commitments." Masondo said while the Credit Guarantee Vehicle will focus on the initial phase of enabling investments in transmission infrastructure, it will be expanded into other areas such as logistics and water over time. "The vehicle will be incorporated as a private company in South Africa, regulated by the Prudential Authority. It will operate as a standalone entity with an independent balance sheet and will target a minimum credit rating of AAA," he said. "A professional executive management team and board of directors with relevant experience and expertise will be appointed to operate and manage the fund. The Credit Guarantee Vehicle will issue a combination of payment and termination guarantees to a Special Purpose Vehicle established for the project." Speaking at the same occasion, Electricity and Energy Minister Kgosientso Ramokgopa said the proposed amendments to the Integrated Resource Plan (IRP) 2019 anticipate the onboarding of more than 30GW of renewable energy by 2030 and approximately 56GW of new connections by 2035. "That's an aggressive programme. For that to happen you really need the transmission infrastructure to be in place," he said. "Major players in the renewable space will tell you 53GW of private sector sponsored projects that are waiting for this connection are at various stages, but its just an indicator of the insatiable appetite that exists in the private sector." In this context, he discussed the initial phase, which encompasses 1 164 kilometers with a capacity of about 2 600 MVA, projecting that unlocked renewables could produce an impressive 3 322 megawatts. He acknowledged that Eskom had historically delivered around 350km per annum, but stressed the necessity to scale up infrastructure development. "It's about the maturity and readiness of local industry because we have not done a significant build programme over a continuous uninterrupted period. We have undermined the capacity of industry to respond to opportunities of this scale," Ramokgopa said. "That is an immediate risk that's facing us that's why we will be engaging with the industry to see how best they are ready and of course build up that capacity over time." BUSINESS REPORT
Eyewitness News
2 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
Paul Mashatile to face R10k fine for not declaring diamond gift to his wife from Louis Liebenberg
CAPE TOWN - Deputy President Paul Mashatile is set to face a R10,000 fine for failing to declare to Parliament a diamond gifted to his wife by diamond dealer, Louis Liebenberg. Liebenberg is currently facing a raft of corruption charges related to diamond dealing. Parliament's ethics committee has rejected Mashatile's excuses for why he did not declare the diamond after the Democratic Alliance (DA) laid a complaint in March, questioning the omission. This week, the ethics committee lauded MPs for submitting their latest financial disclosures before the deadline. ALSO READ: Parly's ethics committee co-chair says she trusts that MPs were honest about disclosing financial interests But in the confidential section of last year's register, the deputy president was found wanting for not declaring the diamond highlighted in a court affidavit as part of the Liebenberg matter. In his defence, Mashatile said he was waiting for the diamond to be appraised to determine its value before declaring it and that he'd since surrendered the stone to the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA). But the ethics committee was of the view that he should have declared it first and submitted a value later. Co-chairperson of the ethics committee, Lusizo Makhubela, said that MPs are required to disclose the financial interests of their immediate family in the confidential section of the register. "Members of Parliament would put those financial interests of their immediate family members which we believe should not be consumed by the public in a manner that would expose them or prejudice them." After refuting reports about owning a property in Cape Town, this year, Mashatile has added the disputed Constantia property in his public disclosures.
